The SDC is owned by the four Governments. It is probably worth highlighting that, at the UK level, the Environmental Audit Committee has just done a sustainable development review as a result of the decision by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to cease funding the SDC’s Whitehall office. One issue that the Environmental Audit Committee raised was how that decision was made and the lack of involvement of the devolved Administrations in it. There is a lot of good work in what that committee has said about the making of that decision and what the UK Government is going to do.The UK Government made an announcement about the SDC in July. It is clear that a change of culture is coming because of the change of Government, but it spoke about its desire to mainstream sustainable development. That has involved taking some of the SDC’s core functions back into DEFRA, particularly to do with engagement and wider sustainable development networks. It also highlighted a role in scrutiny for the Environmental Audit Committee. Therefore, some things have happened.The UK Government has also been considering the governance around that and has explored options around Cabinet sub-committees, supported by the Cabinet Office. It has yet to come to a final decision, but we expect there to be something at the heart of the UK Government that will ensure that mainstreaming can take place. We need to see the details of that, but we are heartened by that commitment. Indeed, the Environmental Audit Committee has recommended that the Cabinet Office should create a minister for sustainable development to drive sustainable development across the Government from a senior level. We have welcomed that committee’s recommendation.15:15
In Wales, the proposal is to set up a new organisation, which tacitly is called a sustainable futures body and would have a commissioner at its head, which would be a public appointment, and a secretariat. It would be set up as a charitable body, but with a public appointment—a hybrid body, if you like. It would continue the advice function and some of the scrutiny work and wider networking with organisations throughout Wales that are interested in sustainable development. In Northern Ireland, the proposal is for a reframed and refocused sustainable development policy unit within the civil service.So, in two of those three areas there will be less than previously existed and in Wales there will broadly be a recreation, with a Wales-only body. However, in Northern Ireland and at the UK level, at least some of the core functions that the SDC has carried out will continue. That is different from Scotland, where all of the SDC Scotland’s core functions will stop.We proposed two options. One was the Welsh model, which is what we would ask for if we could ask for anything. The second was partly about learning from what we had done and partly about learning from different models of sustainable development in Scotland. The previous Administration had a Cabinet sub-committee on sustainable development, which Jan Bebbington attended and for which we provided support. That was a useful way of engaging ministers—and, between meetings, civil servants—in the challenges. We talked about the options of creating a smaller unit in the Scottish Government to do that. The model that we proposed as a comparison was the Scottish Government’s office of the chief scientific adviser. The adviser is a clear expert who has access to wider networks of expertise and who is supported in her job by a small team. We were disappointed that, although that was considered, it was decided not to go with it. That proposal would have been affordable and would have fitted with the proposed terms and moves following the recommendations of the Crerar review.