1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2661)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
11 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2661)
Later today, I will take the opportunity to sign a pledge marking the fifth anniversary of the co-operation agreement between Scotland and Malawi. Thousands of Scots have worked hard to support Malawi’s development and to improve the lives of many of the world’s poorest people. In the past five years, the Scottish Government has supported some 207 projects, involving £13 million. I know that all members will join me in celebrating the contribution that Scotland has made to alleviating poverty and building capacity in Malawian communities. I also extend my thanks to my predecessor Jack McConnell for his support for and continuing commitment to the project. [Applause.]
Yesterday, at the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee, we heard about the proposed cuts in Scotland’s further and higher education sectors. Alastair Sim, director of Universities Scotland, said that cuts of 16 per cent will cause severe damage to the sector. He said that “urgent work” was required now to bring forward a workable scheme for Scotland. The education secretary says that he hopes that a funding solution can be found by next August. Is that the First Minister’s idea of urgent action?
The timescale for bringing forward a Scottish solution on the issue is exactly the same as the timescale south of the border. The dramatic increase in student fees that the coalition Government south of the border is proposing—up to £9,000—will be introduced in the academic year in two years’ time, which will be exactly the same academic year in which the Scottish alternative will be deployed. So the timescale south of the border for what is euphemistically called the new funding stream—the punitive introduction of extraordinary tuition fees—is exactly the same as the timescale for the Scottish alternative, which will seek to find a better answer for Scotland.
On the speculation about what will be able to be done in the coming year in the Scottish budget, I point out that the comprehensive spending review outlined a cut of 40 per cent in university funding south of the border over the CSR period and a cut of 25 per cent for colleges. If we extrapolate the figures for Scotland through the consequentials, we get the sort of figures that are being talked about. I hope that everybody in the Parliament hopes that we can do better than that. However, I should say to Iain Gray that the first cut in university funding did not occur in the current financial year or in the CSR; instead, it was the Mandelson cut of earlier this year, which already put the university and college sector south of the border in a cuts position.
On the speculation about what will be able to be done in the coming year in the Scottish budget, I point out that the comprehensive spending review outlined a cut of 40 per cent in university funding south of the border over the CSR period and a cut of 25 per cent for colleges. If we extrapolate the figures for Scotland through the consequentials, we get the sort of figures that are being talked about. I hope that everybody in the Parliament hopes that we can do better than that. However, I should say to Iain Gray that the first cut in university funding did not occur in the current financial year or in the CSR; instead, it was the Mandelson cut of earlier this year, which already put the university and college sector south of the border in a cuts position.
Linda McTavish of Scotland’s Colleges said:
“there are going to be colleges across Scotland that will fail.”
Tony Axon from the University and College Union said that 4,000 jobs could go. Everyone told the First Minister that the crisis was coming. It is more than two years since we told him that he needed a review of higher education funding. Although he and I might agree that we do not like the answers that are coming forward south of the border, at least answers are being brought forward. That is not the timetable that we are following here. Why is the First Minister just starting to think about a Scottish answer to the problem now?
“there are going to be colleges across Scotland that will fail.”
Tony Axon from the University and College Union said that 4,000 jobs could go. Everyone told the First Minister that the crisis was coming. It is more than two years since we told him that he needed a review of higher education funding. Although he and I might agree that we do not like the answers that are coming forward south of the border, at least answers are being brought forward. That is not the timetable that we are following here. Why is the First Minister just starting to think about a Scottish answer to the problem now?
Iain Gray should have listened to the answer to the previous question. The Scottish alternative will be introduced in exactly the same timescale as that for the proposals south of the border. The difference is that we will find a different Scottish solution to an extraordinarily difficult position that was started by the previous United Kingdom Government and greatly accentuated by the current one. I see Labour members shaking their heads. Who proposed removing the ceiling on the top-up fee south of the border? It was the previous Labour Government. The timescale to which we are working for the Scottish solution is exactly the same timescale as is being proposed south of the border.
At some stage, Iain Gray will have to see that kicking things into the long grass with his commission was not the answer. We will bring forward a solution on exactly the same timescale as the timescale south of the border.
Last week, the Labour Party published a document that proposed £1.7 billion of additional spending commitments, set against a reduction in the Scottish budget for next year, forced by Westminster, of £1.3 billion. No amount of commissions or kicking into the long grass could solve the quandary of the Labour Party spending like there is no tomorrow when next year’s Scottish budget is being cut by London.
At some stage, Iain Gray will have to see that kicking things into the long grass with his commission was not the answer. We will bring forward a solution on exactly the same timescale as the timescale south of the border.
Last week, the Labour Party published a document that proposed £1.7 billion of additional spending commitments, set against a reduction in the Scottish budget for next year, forced by Westminster, of £1.3 billion. No amount of commissions or kicking into the long grass could solve the quandary of the Labour Party spending like there is no tomorrow when next year’s Scottish budget is being cut by London.
The First Minister needs to listen to the questions, too. We suggested a review almost two years ago. If he had held one, we would have a solution now. Tony Axon said yesterday that if we had had a review, we would not be in this situation today.
I have listened to the education secretary talk about his timetable—there is a summit this month, a green paper next month, a leisurely stroll through the ideas and perhaps a solution next year. One would almost think that the First Minister knew that it will be someone else’s problem by then. Does he not understand that higher and further education funding is a problem now? Does he not see that it is he who is kicking the problem into the long grass on the other side of an election?
I have listened to the education secretary talk about his timetable—there is a summit this month, a green paper next month, a leisurely stroll through the ideas and perhaps a solution next year. One would almost think that the First Minister knew that it will be someone else’s problem by then. Does he not understand that higher and further education funding is a problem now? Does he not see that it is he who is kicking the problem into the long grass on the other side of an election?
If Iain Gray had an answer to the problem, he would not be suggesting a review; he would be telling us what his proposal was. He has made bold proposals, in that statesmanlike way that we have come to imagine, to increase the council tax, and then he said that he did not want to increase the council tax—and then he said that he would increase the council tax, but would cap it. It is reasonable to assume that if Iain Gray had a Scottish answer to the alternative that is being suggested south of the border of a 40 per cent cut in university funding and a 25 per cent cut in college funding, he would not come to this chamber with his great idea of a review; he would be telling us what his proposal was. Now he has one more question. It is a question, but perhaps he will give us a wee inkling of what Labour’s policy is in that direction. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
That is right; I have one more question, because this is First Minister’s question time. For as long as the First Minister sits in that seat in the chamber, the question will be, “What is his answer?” Of course, if he had one we would not believe it anyway. It is not just Nick Clegg who has broken his promises to students; Alex Salmond dumped his promise to cancel student debt. He left Scottish students with less to live on than students in the rest of Britain. He abolished the graduate endowment, and last night his MP Pete Wishart said, “Of course we can bring the graduate endowment back.” The First Minister cut university places by 10 per cent and now he does not know what to do.
Presiding Officer, you were at the Scottish reformation reception last night at which the First Minister reminded the audience that our ancient universities were founded by papal bull. Now they are being jeopardised by Alex Salmond’s bull. Will the First Minister show some leadership and introduce his plans for higher education right now?
Presiding Officer, you were at the Scottish reformation reception last night at which the First Minister reminded the audience that our ancient universities were founded by papal bull. Now they are being jeopardised by Alex Salmond’s bull. Will the First Minister show some leadership and introduce his plans for higher education right now?
If Iain Gray is going to become a statesman, he will have to recognise that it is best not to telegraph his jokes so far in advance.
Iain Gray will have to confront the position that, unless we want meekly to go down the road set south of the border—a road started on by the previous Labour Government and Peter Mandelson and now accentuated by the Con-Dem coalition—we will have to find the Scottish answer. It is not the case that university funding has been cut in Scotland; we have record university and college funding in Scotland, and far more than the previous Labour Administration was prepared to spend. When we reintroduced free education—incidentally, I tell Iain Gray that that was the point of my comments last night—we did it in the teeth of Labour opposition in this Parliament.
As we bring forward that solution, we know that the answer is not just to cope with the Con-Dem cuts without finding a way forward for Scotland. We know that the real answer for Scotland is to get control of our economy, so that we can grow revenue and invest in the future of this country, instead of being imprisoned in the Westminster straitjacket in which Iain Gray, for all his bull, is content to let Scotland suffer.
Iain Gray will have to confront the position that, unless we want meekly to go down the road set south of the border—a road started on by the previous Labour Government and Peter Mandelson and now accentuated by the Con-Dem coalition—we will have to find the Scottish answer. It is not the case that university funding has been cut in Scotland; we have record university and college funding in Scotland, and far more than the previous Labour Administration was prepared to spend. When we reintroduced free education—incidentally, I tell Iain Gray that that was the point of my comments last night—we did it in the teeth of Labour opposition in this Parliament.
As we bring forward that solution, we know that the answer is not just to cope with the Con-Dem cuts without finding a way forward for Scotland. We know that the real answer for Scotland is to get control of our economy, so that we can grow revenue and invest in the future of this country, instead of being imprisoned in the Westminster straitjacket in which Iain Gray, for all his bull, is content to let Scotland suffer.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Nov 2010 →- Managing Scotland’s Finances Debate · 127
- Unemployment (Young People) Questions · 6
- Consumer Focus Questions · 4
- Rural Primary Schools (Argyll and Bute) Questions · 8
- Ferries Questions · 4
- School Building Programme Questions · 4
- Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Airports Questions · 4
- Postal Service Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Alcohol (Harm to Society) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Power Stations First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Students (Cross-border Flow) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Health and Wellbeing Questions · 1
- Podiatry Services Questions · 6
- Glasgow Western Infirmary (Patient Care) Questions · 4
- Football Clubs (Supporters Trusts) Questions · 7
- Hospitals (Patient Care) Questions · 4
- Chlamydia (Testing) Questions · 7
- Malignant Melanoma Questions · 4
- Community Empowerment Action Plan Questions · 4
- Armed Forces Personnel (Health Statistics) Questions · 4
- NHS Lanarkshire (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Insulin Pump Therapy Questions · 6
- XMRV (Blood Testing) Questions · 4
- Dentistry (Far North) Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Training) Questions · 4
- Out-of-hours Medical Services Questions · 6
- Historic Environment (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 49
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 15
- Peatlands Members’ business · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.