1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2708)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 7
- Alex Fergusson 5
- John Swinney SNP 1
The record
20 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2708)
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
The First Minister has a woeful record on building consensus, but yesterday he managed it: he united all the Opposition parties in the chamber in agreement—agreement that his budget is a cynical, short-term stop-gap measure, made in a vain attempt to get re-elected. Everyone knows that he put the short-term interest of his party before the long-term interest of his country. Especially at a time such as this, is that not an abdication of his responsibility as First Minister?
I will refresh Iain Gray’s memory with regard to the idea that this is the first time that Labour has been unified with the Tories and the Liberal Democrats. As I remember, there was unity on the Edinburgh trams project between the Labour Party, the Liberals and the Conservatives. I am surprised that Iain Gray, as the former minister who announced the trams project, cannot remember that.
The budget that was presented yesterday tackled the huge issue that faces this country, which is the thirteen hundred million pound cutback in the public finance that is available to Scotland this coming year. That is the largest decline in public expenditure not just in the history of devolution but in the history of public spending. That is what Mr Swinney faced, and that is what he faced down. That is why we have taken the tough decisions that are required, and that is why this Government will be re-elected next May.
The budget that was presented yesterday tackled the huge issue that faces this country, which is the thirteen hundred million pound cutback in the public finance that is available to Scotland this coming year. That is the largest decline in public expenditure not just in the history of devolution but in the history of public spending. That is what Mr Swinney faced, and that is what he faced down. That is why we have taken the tough decisions that are required, and that is why this Government will be re-elected next May.
Mr Swinney said yesterday that the budget was
“more than a one-year challenge”.—[Official Report, Wednesday 17 November 2010; c 30461.].
However, he then immediately failed his own test. Alex Neil admitted on television—I was standing right beside him—that, if the Scottish National Party gets past the election, it will bring out the three-year budget then. What is the First Minister hiding? What happens in years 2 and 3 of his spending plans that he will not tell us about now?
“more than a one-year challenge”.—[Official Report, Wednesday 17 November 2010; c 30461.].
However, he then immediately failed his own test. Alex Neil admitted on television—I was standing right beside him—that, if the Scottish National Party gets past the election, it will bring out the three-year budget then. What is the First Minister hiding? What happens in years 2 and 3 of his spending plans that he will not tell us about now?
It is quite extraordinary—Andy Kerr used that line yesterday. That point is covered in the budget document. Andy Kerr could argue that he had only an hour or two to read it yesterday, but Iain Gray has had 24 hours to read it. As the budget document says, Campbell Christie and his commission—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
The Christie commission will examine structural change in Scottish public services and will present a report in order to take forward the Government’s plans for Scotland. [Interruption.] I can see members on the Labour benches looking desperately. They have all had 24 hours. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Am I meant to assume that they cannot find the right section in the budget document? Do I need to draw it to their attention?
John Swinney has faced the biggest ever decline in Scottish public spending, and he has taken the decisions that are required to face up to it. Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats are united on something else, too: they have no alternative future for Scotland, except a generation of cutbacks led by the Westminster Government.
Let us remember that, while Labour condemns the Con-Dem coalition, two thirds of the cutbacks were promised by Alistair Darling in a regime that was to be deeper and tougher than under Margaret Thatcher. We are not only facing down the immediate challenge; we are saying to Scotland, “Give us the economic power to grow the economy and take us into a better future.”
John Swinney has faced the biggest ever decline in Scottish public spending, and he has taken the decisions that are required to face up to it. Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats are united on something else, too: they have no alternative future for Scotland, except a generation of cutbacks led by the Westminster Government.
Let us remember that, while Labour condemns the Con-Dem coalition, two thirds of the cutbacks were promised by Alistair Darling in a regime that was to be deeper and tougher than under Margaret Thatcher. We are not only facing down the immediate challenge; we are saying to Scotland, “Give us the economic power to grow the economy and take us into a better future.”
I have indeed read the budget document, and not even it was as tedious as Alex Salmond’s answers. It is full of commissions, reviews, contracts and concordats, but it has no answers in it. All budgets—
link
What about your answers, mate?
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order!
Members: What are your answers?
Members: What are your answers?
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order! Sit down, please, Mr Gray.
I understand the political situation in the chamber, and it is entirely understandable that members are somewhat overexcited. However, I cannot tolerate the Presiding Officer not getting order when he or she asks for it. That situation cannot remain. I ask members that, when I ask for order, it is given.
I understand the political situation in the chamber, and it is entirely understandable that members are somewhat overexcited. However, I cannot tolerate the Presiding Officer not getting order when he or she asks for it. That situation cannot remain. I ask members that, when I ask for order, it is given.
All budgets—especially the one that we have been discussing—are about priorities. Let us look at the First Minister’s priorities. We have obtained the information that, last year, as Scotland tried to recover from recession, he spent £0.5 million on the 16 members of staff in his speech-writing unit. I have heard his speeches. Can we have our money back, please?
It is well known that this Government’s administration costs for special advisers are dramatically lower than they were in the Administration that Iain Gray was a member of and in the previous Administration.
Let us talk about the choices that Scotland faces. Yesterday, we announced a difficult policy of pay restraint in the public sector because we believe that it is right to maintain and save jobs in Scotland. That is not easy to do; it is tough. Iain Gray has said that he supports that policy. On 29 October, he said to the BBC:
“We have to have significant pay restraint, probably close to, or at, a pay freeze”.
He added:
“Certainly over a couple of years, maybe two or three years.”
Fine. However, yesterday, I saw him outside the Parliament demonstrating beside a banner that demanded no pay freeze. This morning, I heard him on the radio. He was asked whether he supports pay restraint. He replied that he does: he coughed, he said, “Excuse me,” and he said that he does support it and that he has said that before. If he supports pay restraint to save jobs, what was he doing yesterday? He is the first Opposition leader in history to hold a demonstration against his own policy.
Let us talk about the choices that Scotland faces. Yesterday, we announced a difficult policy of pay restraint in the public sector because we believe that it is right to maintain and save jobs in Scotland. That is not easy to do; it is tough. Iain Gray has said that he supports that policy. On 29 October, he said to the BBC:
“We have to have significant pay restraint, probably close to, or at, a pay freeze”.
He added:
“Certainly over a couple of years, maybe two or three years.”
Fine. However, yesterday, I saw him outside the Parliament demonstrating beside a banner that demanded no pay freeze. This morning, I heard him on the radio. He was asked whether he supports pay restraint. He replied that he does: he coughed, he said, “Excuse me,” and he said that he does support it and that he has said that before. If he supports pay restraint to save jobs, what was he doing yesterday? He is the first Opposition leader in history to hold a demonstration against his own policy.
I will stand alongside workers who are trying to save their jobs any day of the week. [Applause.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
The only job that the First Minister is really trying to save is his own. He should start to do that job. He has no idea about reform of the teaching profession. Someone else can sort that out in June. He has no idea about public service reform. Someone else can sort it out in June. He has no idea about higher education funding. Someone else can sort it out in August. The First Minister has no ideas and no answers, and there is no leadership from him. He used to fancy himself as a Celtic lion. Does not the budget show that he is just a cowardly lion instead?
Iain Gray was not outside demonstrating for jobs yesterday; he was out demonstrating beside a banner that demanded no pay freeze. That is diametrically opposed to his policy. However, we should not be too surprised. Where does he stand on the other choices that Scotland faces? The Government has proposed a social contract that would say to people that we have made valuable gains in freezing the council tax and removing prescription charges in return for pay restraint. Where does Iain Gray stand on that? He has changed his mind about the council tax three times. First, he said that it was to rise. Then, in a BBC interview, he said that it was not to rise. Then, at his conference, he said that it was to rise, but that he was going to cap it. Rather than tell me what we should do over the next four years, why does he not make up his mind about what his policy is for next year?
John Swinney has taken the big decisions and faced up to the biggest decline in public spending in the history of devolution. He has put forward tough but fair policies to maintain jobs and protect workers in Scotland. Above all, like all Scottish National Party members, he has a vision of getting control over Scotland’s economy to grow our way, as opposed to taking the cut, cut, cut approach of Labour, the Tories and the Liberal Democrats.
John Swinney has taken the big decisions and faced up to the biggest decline in public spending in the history of devolution. He has put forward tough but fair policies to maintain jobs and protect workers in Scotland. Above all, like all Scottish National Party members, he has a vision of getting control over Scotland’s economy to grow our way, as opposed to taking the cut, cut, cut approach of Labour, the Tories and the Liberal Democrats.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Nov 2010 →- Care Home Costs Debate · 41
- Prescription Charges Debate · 73
- Hospitals (Free Parking) Questions · 11
- Public Service Design (Disabled Access) Questions · 6
- Flooding (Edinburgh) Questions · 6
- Policing (Budgetary Pressure) Questions · 10
- Carloway Review (Remit) Questions · 4
- Licensed Premises (Oversubscribed Areas) Questions · 6
- Youth Violence Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Asylum Seekers (Accommodation) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Coal-fired Power First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Fishing Quotas 2011 First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Local Government Funding Questions · 10
- Taxation Powers Questions · 11
- Budget (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- High-speed Rail Questions · 6
- Planning Decisions (Impartiality) Questions · 4
- Business Rates (Angus) Questions · 9
- Urban Regeneration Companies Questions · 4
- Renewable Energy (Financial Incentives) Questions · 9
- Business Promotion (Environmental Credentials) Questions · 7
- Youth Unemployment Questions · 4
- Budget (Central Scotland) Questions · 4
- Local Authority Budgets (Impact of United Kingdom Budget) Questions · 6
- Local Authority Budgets (Impact of Scottish Budget) Questions · 4
- National Renewables Infrastructure Fund Questions · 6
- Renewable Energy Enterprises (Fife) Questions · 4
- Alternative Vote Referendum Date Debate · 138
- Decision Time Decision time · 20
- Anticoagulation Therapy Members’ business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.