Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Report

“The Gathering 2009”

Wednesday 1 December 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 395 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

395 contributions · showing 1–200
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Item 2 is the section 23 report “The Gathering 2009”. I welcome to the meeting the First Minister, Alex Salmond, and the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning, Michael Russell.Before we open the discussion, I remind members that the potential legal action relating to creditors is still sub judice. Members will have to determine for themselves whether any comments that they want to make may infringe on any issues relating to the legal case.Before we proceed to questions, does the First Minister or the cabinet secretary wish to make any opening comments?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I am content to allow committee members to proceed with questions.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Thank you very much, and thank you for making time for us.Prior to the initial grant being given to The Gathering 2009 Ltd, did either of you have any contact, meetings or discussions in any capacity with Lord Sempill or Jenny Gilmour?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I did not.

The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning Michael Russell
link

I met Jamie Sempill many years ago—before the 1999 election, I think. I think that he was a Tory candidate then. I had no contact with Jenny Gilmour, and I never discussed the gathering with either of them at any time before my first meeting with them.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

The decision to give a grant was not exceptional in itself; that would happen in the normal course of business practice. However, it was a bit unusual to agree to give a grant to a company that was structured in the way that this one was. For example, in the case of the Cairngorm funicular railway, there was joint public sector and private sector exposure. In this case, the company directors’ only exposure when the organisation was set up was £1 each, so the public sector was essentially taking on all the risk. As we now know, some small private companies have clearly suffered as a result. The set-up was unusual. Why did you think that it was acceptable to give a grant to a company that was structured in that way? The directors had very little exposure to liability.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

As I remember, the original grants were from EventScotland, the City of Edinburgh Council and the local enterprise company.

Michael Russell
link

The company limited by guarantee structure is not unusual in itself; there are many companies limited by guarantee. I think that the company was seen as a company within the cultural sector that was doing a public good. I understand that the gathering could have come about only with the involvement of the Standing Council of Scottish Chiefs, of which Jamie Sempill was a prominent member—indeed, I think that he was chair of the council at one stage—and the company was seen to be undertaking a public good to a great extent. The fact that the three public sector funders that the First Minister mentioned each provided a grant during 2007 confirms that it was seen that a public good was being undertaken.The Scottish Government’s further involvement in 2008 was targeted closely on two aspects of the proposal. There was £80,000 for the Highland games element and £20,000 for the education programme. In other words, that money was seen as purchasing certain aspects that fitted in with the Government’s objectives.I do not think that the fact that the company was limited by guarantee was a major issue in itself or that the funders would have seen it as a major issue.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

It might be helpful to say that, across the homecoming programme as a whole, a ratio of return of 8:1 was looked for. I believe that the same ratio, which I assume comes from EventScotland and the tourism industry, has applied to other tourism events for many years. In other words, it is assumed that £1 of public grant will be able to generate £8 of value in the total event.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I accept what you and Mike Russell are saying, but the issue is that, if things had gone badly, as they subsequently did, the company directors were liable for only £1 each. When you decided to give a grant on top of the other public sector grants, you stood to lose considerably more than either of the directors. Is that a factor?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

A grant is not something that we expect to get back; the grant is for the delivery of the event, and that is matched against whether the event is delivered or not. We will come on to discuss the loan that was advanced to The Gathering 2009 Ltd, for which it is obvious that there were different criteria. If the event had been successful in financial as well as in tourism terms, we would not have expected to get the grant back. The loan is a different matter.

Michael Russell
link

It is important to note that, as it says in the heading on page 13 of the Audit Scotland report,“Throughout the organisation of the event financial projections indicated that a small deficit was most likely”.No doubt we will come on to what the projections actually meant and what was taking place with the steering group. The steering group obviously thought that during the period when the organisation was on-going a small deficit was most likely. Had there been an indication that a massive profit was likely, I suspect that it would have discussed the matter closely with the people involved.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Why did you decide that the Government would not be involved in the steering group?

Michael Russell
link

Again, I am dealing with matters that occurred before I became the relevant minister. I think that there was a feeling that the steering group was the appropriate group of organisations that would have a day-to-day involvement with the event as it took place. Remember that, as the Auditor General for Scotland said,“the steering group had a purely advisory role”.The best advisers would have been the people who were delivering on the ground. However, I accept the argument in the Auditor General’s report that the approach should be considered again for future events.Steering groups are not unusual in the sector that we are considering. For example, the MOBO awards, at which Mr McAveety and I were present, and the Ryder cup had steering groups of a similar nature. The question whether the Government should be more closely involved in steering groups for events that perhaps have a national dimension needs more consideration and I am grateful to the Auditor General for suggesting that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Do members have questions about the grant?

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

After the Government signed up to the grant, it had to consider progress on the event. It says in the Audit Scotland report that you received “informal updates” on progress. Will you give a bit of detail about what that means?

Michael Russell
link

The steering group, as we are indicating, met on a regular basis. It started with quarterly meetings, then it met monthly and eventually there was a weekly meeting. The steering group included organisations with a connection with government, which were watching what was taking place.Substantial sums of money are used in smaller or larger degrees to go to arts and cultural organisations of many types. There are processes from the grant-awarding bodies to ensure that that is the case. In this case, we were receiving information via the steering group. Of course, as the Gaelic proverb goes, at the end of the day the fisherman tells of his fishing. We would also have expected the outcomes of the event to be positive because we felt that there was planning with the steering group. That turned out not to be the case.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

Did the informal updates relate to the feedback that you were getting from the steering group?

Michael Russell
link

The steering group was instrumental in ensuring in discussions with the group that it was going in the right direction.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

Do you find it surprising that, in its monitoring of progress, the steering group was not receiving actual and year-to-date financial information on performance?

Michael Russell
link

As the Auditor General said in his report and in evidence to the committee, with hindsight there were questions about the quality of that information. At the time, I think that the group felt that it was getting the information that it needed. As the Auditor General said on page 1,“Throughout the organisation of the event financial projections indicated that a small deficit was most likely”.I think that, during the period up until the event, all the indications that the steering group had were that things were going in a positive direction.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

However, you were receiving informal updates from the steering group. I find it staggering that a group that was monitoring progress was not receiving accurate financial information. Did the Government not pick up on and have concern about that?

Michael Russell
link

Had the group known that it was not receiving accurate financial information, I would find that staggering, too, but all the evidence is—again, it is in the Auditor General’s report—that it is only with the benefit of hindsight that we know that to be the case.Indeed, on the analysis of the figures that the Audit Scotland report gives, there were issues with the income undershoot that would not have been picked up until the event had taken place. That is quite clear. Some of those issues were to do with ticket sales on the day and at the weekend. I think that that explains where we are.09:45

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Remember that a steering group does not replace the board of directors. The board of directors has legal duties and a range of other things. The steering group approach, which, as Michael Russell said, has been applied across a range of supported events, is taken to ensure that the event will be delivered as envisaged—in other words, that the grant from the public will result in the event that was promised. In fact, the tourism impact of the gathering turned out to be much larger than had been envisaged. The issue with the gathering is not the impact on Scottish tourism but the financial difficulties and debts of the company.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

I understand the legal requirements on company directors, but I would have thought that, if a steering group was in place to monitor how the event was progressing, consideration of key financial information would have been part of its role. It is unusual, to say the least, that actual and year-to-date financial information was not being provided. I would have thought that the Government would have looked at the matter in the context of the updates that it was receiving.

Michael Russell
link

I have indicated what the steering group’s role was and what information was being received, and I have said that, in hindsight, some of the projections turned out to be wrong. On the projections about the day and thereafter that were wrong, I do not think that any of the information that the group had beforehand would have told them that.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

It is not surprising that the projections were wrong if it was not using actual financial information—

Michael Russell
link

It was using financial information, Mr Kelly, as I think all the reports show. Of course, there are questions, which you are raising, about some of the information that went to the group. However, it was using financial information.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

What financial information did the Government receive in its informal updates from the steering group?

Michael Russell
link

We received information about whether the event was on schedule, planned and going to take place—in other words, as the First Minister said, on whether the event would be delivered. The information that we had all the time was that it would be delivered, which will be germane when we discuss the events of 28 April 2009 and thereafter. The information that we were receiving was that the event was going to be delivered. That was the most important information that we could have at that stage.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

You were seeking broad-brush, high-level assurances, as opposed to financial information that might give an indication of how things were progressing—

Michael Russell
link

Not “as opposed to” financial information, Mr Kelly. That would be a misrepresentation. However, our view was that we had provided the grants for specific purposes—£80,000 for the Highland games and £20,000 for the education programme—and the indication was that those would be delivered.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

Did you receive no financial information in your informal updates?

Michael Russell
link

If we were to check everything that was going on with every organisation with which we are involved every ten minutes, we would not do anything else. Our job was to ensure that the event would be delivered.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

As I recall, it says in the Audit Scotland report that the steering group was receiving information on central, pessimistic and optimistic assumptions. The financial information that it received turned out to be wrong, but it was receiving financial information.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Mr Kelly is concerned about the Government’s day-to-day involvement in the event. I am not sure what he is looking for and whether he expected you to be down there organising the event on the day. Was your involvement in the gathering different from the involvement that you would have in a similar event? Was your approach radically different from the approach that the previous Government would have taken? My understanding is that it was not. Were you doing anything radically different from the general approach to running events?

Michael Russell
link

I would have said not. We do our best to help and support where we can do, and it was important that we should secure an event that had such strong significance in terms of the multiplier effect, as the First Minister said.I draw your attention to paragraph 36 of the Audit Scotland report, which says:“Steering group minutes and discussions with members indicate that the group paid attention to maximising income and keeping costs down, while ensuring that the event attracted sufficient visitor numbers and made an impact.”I would have thought that that was a reasonable degree of monitoring that provided information that was useful to all of us.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I understand from the timeline and the Audit Scotland report that Lord Sempill and Jenny Gilmour first approached EventScotland in February 2007. That was not when EventScotland, the City of Edinburgh Council and the LEC agreed to make the first grants. Given that the same steering group structure was used for other events, I cannot see why we would have had a different structure in this case. When we came into office, we did not say that we would change the structure of steering groups for delivery of major events. In retrospect, perhaps changes should have been made, but we did not make them.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

On pages 8 and 9 of the Auditor General’s report, it is indicated that, at one stage, The Gathering 2009 Ltd sought £205,000 of additional grant funding but the Scottish Government decided to provide £100,000. That suggests that, throughout the process, the Scottish Government did not have a blank-cheque policy towards The Gathering 2009 Ltd and that its requests were considered in detail and on their respective merits.

Michael Russell
link

Exactly so. The report also confirms—it is entirely clear—that the £100,000 that was awarded towards the end of 2008 was awarded for specific purposes that we wished to see delivered and which were delivered, and in a way that met Scottish Government objectives. That is why the commitment was made. The relationship is entirely clear. Equally, we did not support proposals that did not meet or were not central to our objectives, or which we did not wish to see delivered. That is entirely proper. Others would have taken the same view.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

If I remember correctly, two things were happening at the time. First, the event was shaping up to be much bigger than had been originally anticipated. Secondly, The Gathering 2009 Ltd was seeking funds to support the broadcasting of the event. However, the Government took the view that that should be a commercial matter between The Gathering 2009 Ltd and the broadcasters. To be fair to The Gathering 2009 Ltd, by then we were into the financial crisis. It may have been much more difficult to secure broadcasting at the end of 2008 than it would have been at a different stage. Nonetheless, the Government decided to support specific educational and other initiatives as part of the gathering event but not to support what we viewed as being primarily a commercial activity—the broadcasting of the event.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Paragraph 17 on page 9 is relevant to the points that James Kelly and Anne McLaughlin have explored. It states:“The Scottish Government followed its normal procedures for awarding grants”.I presume that you concur with that conclusion.

Michael Russell
link

Absolutely.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

On page 8, the Auditor General states:“EventScotland concluded that Red Sky at Night Ltd had ‘good credit worthiness’”.Red Sky at Night Ltd is the company with which the individuals concerned had been involved previously. Presumably, there were no concerns about the history of the business activities of those individuals.

Michael Russell
link

I think not. In addition, we know that, from June 2007, The Gathering 2009 Ltd had been discussing its business plan with EventScotland. In July 2007, the three public sector funders—EventScotland, Scottish Enterprise Edinburgh and Lothian and the City of Edinburgh Council—agreed to provide a grant of £100,000 each. The event was well established and clearly had bona fides at that stage. However, when The Gathering 2009 Ltd came to the Government to request resources, we treated it in exactly the same way as anyone else. A substantial part—half—of its request was turned down.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

I think that I am right in saying that Lord Sempill and Jenny Gilmour have confirmed that they have never previously been involved in a company in liquidation.The Convener indicated agreement.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We move on to the issue of the loan. Cabinet secretary, we are advised that, in April 2009, when you were in your previous role, the directors of the company met you and reported cash-flow problems. Did the suggestion of a loan come from them or from you?

Michael Russell
link

In my recollection, the issue did not arise at that meeting, at which the company was outlining its difficulties.It is important to realise—and I think that this point has been confirmed in previous evidence—that the company came to see me primarily to discuss the broadcasting issue. I think that Paul Bush of EventScotland had suggested that the company come to see me. The broadcasting issue was giving the company great concern: the company had sought resource from us for broadcasting at the end of the previous year but had made no progress from then until April. The company brought its broadcasting consultant to the meeting—Sandy Ross, who I think will be known to the convener, as he was formerly a Labour councillor, among other things. During the meeting, it became obvious that the company was making no progress on the broadcasting issue. I found that surprising, given the importance of the event.Towards the end of the meeting, the company raised the WorldPay issue, said that it was experiencing cash-flow problems, and explained to me what the problems were. At the meeting, all I said was that the issue concerned me and that I would have to consider the information that the company had given me. The question that arose was whether there was any possibility of underwriting the cash flow from that point through until the event itself. A substantial sum of money was being held by WorldPay, which the company expected to rise to £0.25 million. To be fair to the company, the sum did indeed turn out to be £0.25 million, almost exactly. At the end of the meeting, I said that I would consider the matter. However, I do not think either that the company asked for a loan mechanism or that I suggested one. We got on to a discussion of whether there was any way of underwriting the cash flow.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Just to clarify, what the company was talking about was, in effect, a host broadcaster. Dozens of international broadcasters covered the event. However, they were not paying any money to do so but were covering it as news journalists. The Gathering was looking for a company to buy the broadcasting rights for the event. That is what they were struggling with.

Michael Russell
link

That would have given the company additional income, and it would have maximised the potential for international sales of, for example, the DVD and CD that it hoped to issue. The company did, in fact, issue both—but it was not able to market them because, by that stage, it had very bad credit problems.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

When did the issue of the loan first arise?

Michael Russell
link

After 28 April, the company produced further information that I had asked for. It looked at ways in which the Scottish Government might be able to assist it—whether through additional funding, through help for the company to negotiate with WorldPay, or through a loan. Scottish Government officials and I discussed the issue. As Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution at the time, I informed the First Minister of my discussions as part of my normal reporting to him. By round about 7 May, officials sought advice from the finance directorate as to whether a short-term loan would be possible. I know that the committee has been through this evidence with the former permanent secretary, but there was no indication that a short-term loan was anything other than possible. Officials then moved forward to detailed discussion with the organisation as to its plans and its financial projections. Eventually, we concluded that the offer of a loan would be appropriate. That offer was made on 1 June and accepted on 5 June.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So the idea of the loan came from the Government, rather than from the company.

Michael Russell
link

By the time the options paper came out and the discussion took place, a number of possibilities were hardening up. The intention was clear: we wanted to support the company through a short-term difficulty in order to allow it to hold the event—in other words, to allow the outcomes to be secured. Ways in which that could be done formed the discussion that took place Eventually, the subject of the discussion hardened into a short-term loan. I think that that was regarded as the best and most appropriate way of providing assistance.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

The company did not ask you for a loan; your officials decided that a loan was the best way in which to move forward.

Michael Russell
link

As you will know, convener, their evidence indicated that they thought of a number of possibilities, one of which would have been some sort of loan assistance. In examining those possibilities, opinion within the Government eventually hardened up on the question of a loan.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But the idea of a loan came from the Government side rather than from the company.10:00

Michael Russell
link

I think that the evidence shows that that idea was probably current on both sides during the discussion. I do not think that it can be attributed to one side or the other.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Well, except that you said earlier that, when you were looking at the range of options, that was one of the options that you had considered. You said that, in the initial discussions, the question of a loan did not come up, so it is quite clear that the germination of that idea was on the Government side rather than the company side.

Michael Russell
link

No, what I indicated was that, between 28 April and 7 May—I will repeat it, convener—a paper was produced, there were discussions about options, which included additional grant funding, helping the company to negotiate with WorldPay and a loan. I do not think that either side would have had a eureka moment. I think that what took place here was a productive discussion about possibilities that hardened up, certainly on the side of the Government, to the effect that this was the best way to do it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Yes, we can go back over the evidence, because my recollection is that the company said that there were other options. It is clear to me, anyway, that much of this discussion started from the Government side. Obviously, both sides would have agreed, ultimately.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Convener, Mr Russell kept me informed of this, but I think that it is pretty clear from the information that the company produced that it would have preferred a further grant to a loan.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That is as may be, but I am just trying to find out where the idea of the loan came from.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

As I think Mr Russell said, he asked for further information and, after that request, the company produced a paper that set out the difficulties and a range of options, one of which was a further grant and one of which was a loan. Mr Russell kept me informed of everything that was happening. He took the decision as a responsible minister. However, given that the very real possibility was that, because of the cash-flow difficulties, the event might not take place, I cannot believe that any other minister faced with that situation would have done anything other than to secure the future of the event. If the choice is between securing the future of the event by further grant or by a loan, then clearly the Government’s preference will be to do it by a loan.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. You have identified a key issue there, First Minister. You say that, if the loan had not been made, there was a real danger that the event would not have happened. Ultimately, then,

what the private sector creditors are saying is right, which is that they would not have been left out of pocket had the loan not been made.

Michael Russell
link

I think that the evidence that you had from Jamie Sempill indicated that there may well have been more private sector creditors before the event at that point than there were afterwards. That is not something that I know or do not know. However, I think that it would be wrong to assign causal inevitability in that way. No, I think that that is probably not right. Yes, I think that the event would not have taken place, but the number of people left in the lurch at that stage might have been greater, and might have included all those who had purchased tickets.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Well, of course, and we can trace back to the evidence of that, but the fact is that the financial commitments made by a lot of the small companies that are now out of pocket were made after the loan was granted, so these small Scottish companies would not be struggling in the way that they are had that loan not been given.

Michael Russell
link

I think that this loan was made with the best intentions in order to secure the outcomes of the event.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Did Audit Scotland not comment directly on the circumstances? This is Michael Russell’s area, so he will be able to help me with this, but Audit Scotland precisely commented on the position that the minister was in and said that it was “not unreasonable” to come to that conclusion. I repeat that I cannot conceive that any Government minister faced with that proposition would not have taken action to secure the future of the event. The second argument is that, at that point, the evidence was produced that this was a cash-flow difficulty and that the funds were frozen in WorldPay. There was no reason to believe that the company would later run into financial difficulties to the extent that it did. What was likely, if the cash-flow position had not been resolved, was that there inevitably would have been financial difficulties with, according to the evidence of the directors, many more creditors affected than has subsequently been the case.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I have two further questions; I will then bring in other members.You knew at that point that the company was starting to face problems, and you were considering how it might be helped. What due diligence did you carry out at that stage before you decided to give a loan?

Michael Russell
link

We had been dealing with the company for some time; that has been made clear in previous evidence. At that stage, the company was working with the steering group on a weekly basis, and we thought that we knew quite enough about it to give it a short-term loan. We also knew that the moneys that were due to it more than matched the short-term loan. There was specifically a cash-flow difficulty—again, I am relying on the Auditor General’s evidence. In those circumstances, we took the not unreasonable decision to provide a loan. The Auditor General said in his evidence that “time was not on”our “side”.—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 26 June 2010; c 1820. I go back to the First Minister’s point about what others might have done in the circumstances. I was grateful to a former senior Labour minister for saying to me after my statement in the Parliament on 30 June that he did not think that any minister in any previous Administration would have made a different decision. I stand by that decision.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Finally, the loan was secret. Why was it kept secret?

Michael Russell
link

It was not a secret loan. EventScotland was aware of it. In the circumstances, I think that it believed that it was best not to spread that information any further. However, it was not a secret loan.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So the steering group knew about it.

Michael Russell
link

It was not a secret loan. EventScotland knew about it. Nobody in EventScotland suggested to us, and we did not suggest to it at any stage, that it should be secret. It was felt that the information had gone as far as it should go in the circumstances.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So the steering group and the City of Edinburgh Council did not know about it.

Michael Russell
link

It was not a secret loan in the terms that you have put it, convener.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Did the City of Edinburgh Council know about it?

Michael Russell
link

It was not a secret loan in the terms that you have put it, convener.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

It is on the record that the City of Edinburgh Council—

Michael Russell
link

It is on the record that it was not, in my opinion, a secret loan in the terms that you have put it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

It is on the record that the City of Edinburgh Council did not know about the loan. Jim Inch said to the committee—

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Convener—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Just let me finish what I am saying, First Minister; I will then bring you in. Jim Inch said to the committee:“I believe that we were not aware of loans being made to the company, The Gathering 2009 Ltd, which meant that our position and our advisory group were compromised.”He said:“we were let down by not having all the information to hand.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 3 November 2010; c 2111.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I was going to say that the Audit Scotland report points to that. In retrospect, I think that Audit Scotland is right. We should have insisted on EventScotland informing the rest of the steering group of the loan. That is a perfectly fair point to make.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Who was involved in the discussions on the loan?

Michael Russell
link

I and my officials, who advised me, were involved, and at one stage the Scottish Government’s finance director was consulted on the propriety or otherwise of the loan. The normal set of advisers was involved.

Michael Russell
link

I think that the former permanent secretary has indicated to the committee that he was not involved and told you at some length why he felt that that was so. He has given evidence on that.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Given the importance of the event and the request for a loan, might it have been appropriate for the former permanent secretary to have been involved?

Michael Russell
link

No. I rest entirely on his view of the matter, which is correct. He has made his view entirely clear.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

I know from his letter that he has reflected on the issues. The word “reflected” is important in modern politics. Given that he had to make the final decision to write off the loan, might it have been best if he had known—

Michael Russell
link

No. He was entirely clear about why he felt that it was not necessary for him to have been told. I lean on that evidence.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

How did you arrive at the sum identified for the loan?

Michael Russell
link

It seemed to meet the difficulty that the company had identified.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

On the discussions about the loan, on reflection—there is a lot of reflection going on—do you agree with the First Minister that it would have been best to have informed the steering group of the loan?

Michael Russell
link

I think that EventScotland should have informed the steering group with our assistance, but there was no secrecy. Nobody was told not to do things. That is a key distinction.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

If you were a member of the steering group, would you feel a bit out of sorts that no one had informed you of such a loan?

Michael Russell
link

I was not a member of the steering group. I cannot speculate on that.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

If you were a member of any group that was trying to deliver a major project such as this—

Michael Russell
link

Mr McAveety, I am not going to speculate on things that I have no responsibility for.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Do you not think that it would have been appropriate for the people who were asked to deliver one of the major events that the country was putting on for the year of homecoming to have been given some information about the loan?

Michael Russell
link

We have both said—I concur with the First Minister—that it would have been better had EventScotland told the steering committee. However, I have also made the key distinction about the words used, which I put on record earlier.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

You might remember, Frank, that the Government was not on the steering group. However, I have already said that, as Audit Scotland said, we should have insisted that EventScotland inform the other members of the steering group. I have to say that I would have been surprised if the other members of the steering group had not thought the move a good idea, as they were as anxious as we were to secure the future of the event. Nonetheless, it would have been proper of us to instruct EventScotland to inform the rest of the steering group. Incidentally, we did not instruct EventScotland not to inform the steering group. However, although we were not part of the steering group, formally, we should have instructed EventScotland to inform the other members.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

What is the limit before you have to report a loan being made?

Michael Russell
link

I do not think that there was a limit on this occasion. The distinction that the permanent secretary made was that there were differences in terms of the sums of money that were being used by the Government. He said to the committee that he was not looking down his nose at the £180,000, but that it was not the largest sum of money that the Government was involved with. I do not think that there is an absolute limit of any description but, in these circumstances, the advice of the finance directorate was that this was perfectly proper and that there was no need to raise the matter with the permanent secretary. He has not only confirmed that but concurred with it—after reflection, to use that important word.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Did you discuss with the permanent secretary how to handle the issue of the loan under the legal conditions relating to how loans are dealt with? He has discussed issues around the use of section 23 of the National Heritage (Scotland) Act 1985.

Michael Russell
link

Advice was given that the loan could be made under section 23, and that was the circumstance in which it was made. That was discussed with the appropriate officials. The advice was that that was how it should be done, and that is how it was done. Equally, it is clear that the advice of the finance directorate was that that was legitimate and that there was no need to report it elsewhere.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Is it normal for your officials not to inform the permanent secretary of a loan of such a scale?

Michael Russell
link

Yes, quite clearly so. In terms of the proper activities, the permanent secretary has confirmed that there was nothing wrong with his not being informed. The finance directorate has made that clear, and the permanent secretary has concurred with those views, even after reflection.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Are there any examples of similar loans being given without the permanent secretary being informed?

Michael Russell
link

I am unable to give you that answer. As the permanent secretary indicated, loans are not uncommon across a range of Government bodies.

Michael Russell
link

No, this is the only occasion on which that route has been used. However, there are other pieces of legislation that are commonly used to provide loans, and I am sure that the permanent secretary is not informed of many of those loans.

Michael Russell
link

Section 23 has been used for a wide variety of cultural purposes, but not for loan giving, except on this occasion.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

It would have been possible to allocate a further grant to the company, but the question involved a judgment about whether the company’s arguments—which were verifiable—about an amount being effectively frozen in the WorldPay system were true. If the company’s arguments were true, as seemed to be the case—and still seems to be the case—a loan, as opposed to a grant, seemed to be the proper way in which to deal with a cash-flow problem.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am not disputing that a loan was probably a better course of action than a grant—the evidence indicates that it would have been daft to have given a grant, so a loan was a reasonable option. I have been asking about the process of information around that loan.10:15

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Mr Russell, you seem not to like the word, but is it not a simple fact that this loan was kept secret from the partners in the event? They did not know about the loan, and they were not informed of it. Is that not a definition of something being kept secret?

Michael Russell
link

The phrase was not “kept secret”; it was “a secret loan”. I do not want to split hairs with you, Mr Stephen—or is it Lord Stephen these days? I accept the First Minister’s view that it would have been better if EventScotland had told the other members of the steering group of the loan. However, at no time was I or any of my officials involved in an act of secrecy with regard to the loan. That is very important, in terms of how this matter is presented.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So, you do not like the phrase, “secret loan”—

Michael Russell
link

It was not a secret loan.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

But you would accept that the loan was kept secret from those partners. Is that right?

Michael Russell
link

I would accept that the First Minister was entirely right to say that it would have been better had EventScotland communicated the information to the other members of the steering group. That is what I have said, on the record, and that is what I will continue to say.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

EventScotland was not making the loan; the loan was being made by the Scottish Government. That information was given to EventScotland. I have said twice now that I agree with the fair point in the Audit Scotland report that we should have insisted on EventScotland informing the other members of the steering group.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

And you, as the Scottish Government, which gave the loan, had no responsibility to those other partners to tell them directly.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

We should have insisted on EventScotland doing that. We were not on the steering—

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Why go through EventScotland? I am not clear why—

Michael Russell
link

We were not on the steering group.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

EventScotland was part of the steering group. On reflection—to use Mr McAveety’s term—and after reading the Audit Scotland report, I believe that it is reasonable to say that we should have insisted on EventScotland informing the other partners on the steering group.Having conceded that point—which seems to me to be a reasonable one—I must say that I cannot believe that the other partners would have wanted anything other than that the loan should be advanced to meet a cash-flow difficulty and to enable an event in which they had already invested a substantial sum of money to take place. It is also the case that other partners were doing their best, through the steering group, to assist the company in its cash-flow difficulties.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I am coming on to that point, but I just want to be clear that you, as the Scottish Government—the organisation that granted the loan to The Gathering 2009 Ltd—did not feel any obligation to inform the other partners in the event directly, not through EventScotland, that the loan of £180,000 had been given.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

We should have insisted that EventScotland, as a member of the steering group, inform the other partners.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You feel that it should have been done through a third party, EventScotland.

Michael Russell
link

As it was the body that was running the steering group, I would have thought that that would have been entirely appropriate.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

On your point about the other partners agreeing on the need for loan, I would point out that, of course, they did not have the information that would enable them to make such a decision at that time—benefit of hindsight is a grand thing, is it not? Surely the crucial point is that the loan would have flagged up to the other partners in the event the financial difficulties that the company was facing. It would surely have been of immense benefit to those organisations to have learned about those difficulties at as early a stage as possible. In effect, what happened was that those financial difficulties were kept secret from those partners.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Around the time of the loan, the partners were presented with a financial estimate of the event, with a pessimistic main run and an optimistic scenario. That is in the documents and the Audit Scotland report. They were getting financial information on the course of the gathering.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

They were totally unaware of the cash-flow difficulties that were being faced by The Gathering 2009 Ltd.

Michael Russell
link

They were not. We know that the final pre-event projections in July 2009 showed the company’s indebtedness quite correctly and included a series of projections based on pessimistic, likely and optimistic views of ticket sales, passport sales and other income. The company represented its situation perfectly accurately, and the steering group was involved in detail with the group in helping it to take the issue forward. It is one thing to criticise ministers or others, but a range of people were involved in the steering group and were providing strong practical help to The Gathering 2009 Ltd to ensure that, as the Audit Scotland report says, “the group paid attention to maximising income and keeping costs down, while ensuring that the event attracted sufficient visitor numbers and made an impact”.Other actions were taking place at the same time.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Do you believe that full and accurate financial information was being provided to the steering group members at that time?

Michael Russell
link

I think that all the indications suggest that the steering group was performing its function, which is defined in paragraph 22 of the Audit Scotland report, and the directors of the company were working hard in order to deliver the event. You will know that the post-event analysis indicates where the problems were and that there was a slight overspend and a considerably smaller amount of income than had been anticipated. You will also know that one of the reasons that was given for that was the weather on the weekend and that there were other reasons to do with ticket sales. Those are the reasonable analyses that were done.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

The two pieces of information that belie what you are saying, Nicol, are in the Audit Scotland report. The entry on the timeline for 8 July 2009 says:“Public sector partners agree to explore the possibility of bringing forward remaining grant instalments to aid cash flow.” The entry for 16 July 2009 says:“Final pre-event budget financial projections are provided to the steering group. Anticipates a deficit of £223,000 (pessimistic), a deficit of £49,000 (most likely) and a surplus of £118,000 (optimistic) based on ticket sales”.The steering group was receiving financial information and was being told about the cash-flow issues that the company faced. It is important to emphasise that, when Michael Russell decided to advance the loan, he was given information, which he had no reason to doubt and which was verifiable, that an amount more than covering the loan was held in the WorldPay system. In that sense, it was a genuine cash-flow issue. An amount due to the company was held within that payment system, and the loan was designed to ease cash flow against that company asset.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

If that was the case, why were no protections built into the offer of loan to ensure that the funds that were due to the company from WorldPay were received by the Scottish Government?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

That is an interesting point. The issue of confidence in what the company was telling people is relevant.The issue has been floated elsewhere of whether the Government should have taken, or in some way asked for, preferred creditor status in relation to the loan. I am not sure that that would have been justified, because why would the Government want—

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I am asking about any protection. As far as I can see from the letter of offer of loan, no protection was asked for.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I am going through the sorts of protection that might have been sought. One is preferred creditor status. There are some difficulties with preferred creditor status. If you seek that, it rather implies that you do not accept the information that you have been given, and it would put the Government in a different position from other potential creditors. The question whether it would be impossible to secure the loan against the assets of WorldPay is more interesting. That is one of the lessons that might come out of this affair.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So none of those options was considered at the time. Is that correct?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

When the Auditor General said that giving the loan was not unreasonable, he also said that“time was not on anyone’s side”.—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 23 June 2010; c 1820.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

An unusual letter, dated 1 June 2009, was sent by Carolyn Gardner of the Scottish Government to Lord Sempill regarding the authorisation of the loan. It talks about a grant being made—schedule 1 of the letter is a grant claim form, which reads:“We hereby claim total grant of £180,000”.The first paragraph of the letter makes it clear that the money is intended to be a short-term loan, and the second paragraph discusses the repayment terms, saying:“I am therefore requesting that The Gathering 2009 Ltd repay the £180,000 in full within 14 days of your receiving payment from World Pay”.There seems to have been no effort to ensure that that was followed up on. The other interesting thing is that the letter talks about the state aid de minimis rules. Can you explain those rules to me, with reference to the ceiling of €200,000? Can you also say why the loan seems to have been counted under the state aid rules while other payments from the Government were not? It seems to me that the document has all the signs of being, as you said, thrown together in haste, without clarity and without proper protection of the public purse.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I did not say that it was thrown together in haste. I said that, as the Auditor General said, “time was not on” the Government’s“side”.—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 23 June 2010; c 1820.

Michael Russell
link

I am happy to provide a detailed written briefing on the issue of state aid and de minimis aid. As a former Deputy First Minister, Nicol Stephen knows that it will not be possible for me to go through what is a huge number of regulations and rules in detail between now and lunch time.I entirely refute—

Michael Russell
link

If you will allow me to finish my answer, you will be able to ask another question.I entirely refute the view that the loan was either thrown together or utterly unusual or irregular. I go back to the key point. If Lord Stephen is suggesting in any way that we should not have provided reasonable assistance to allow the event to take place, that is a legitimate point of view, but casting aspersions on Government documents or on information provided is not the way to do that. Lord Stephen clearly disagrees with us. He does not think that the loan should have been provided, and that is a legitimate point of view. If the committee is asking for a briefing on state aid, I can give one, but it will be lengthy.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Why does the document refer to grant aid being given?

Michael Russell
link

Because we had not given a loan under section 23 of the National Heritage (Scotland) Act 1985 before. As the first paragraph of the letter of 1 June refers to a “loan”, I would have thought that people reading the letter would have realised that it was a loan.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So the words“We hereby claim total grant of £180,000 in respect of the above period in accordance with the terms and conditions of the offer of Grant dated 18 May 2009 and the Schedules attached thereto”—

Michael Russell
link

A loan is a loan is a loan. It was clearly a loan. It was known that it was a loan.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So the word “grant” is an error. Is that right?

Michael Russell
link

A loan is a loan is a loan.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I am sure that the letter makes it clear that it is a loan, and I am sure that Nicol Stephen would not want to say anything other than that. The documentation makes it clear that it is a loan, does it not?

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I am clear that it was eventually understood to be a loan, but when the letter was sent out, clarity was not uppermost. The protections that were given to the Government and the taxpayer as a result of the loan offer letter were, it is fair to say, non-existent. The First Minister is smiling, but I regard this as extremely serious. Let us be clear that £180,000 of Scottish Government money—taxpayer’s money—was thrown out of the window as a consequence of that letter.

Michael Russell
link

I am sorry, but that is not so.

Michael Russell
link

Not so.

Michael Russell
link

It is clearly not so.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

We have an Audit Scotland report that considers whether it was wise to offer the loan, and concludes that, in the circumstances that Mr Russell faced, it was not an unreasonable thing to do. Most of the time, when Audit Scotland considers ministers’ actions and concludes that they were not unreasonable, that is regarded as a general indication of a verdict on what the minister did. Nicol Stephen clearly does not regard it as such; fortunately for him, he was not facing the circumstances that Mr Russell faced.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I asked a very simple question. Was the money ever repaid?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Clearly the money has not been repaid, as everyone knows.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Were any protections built into the offer, to secure the WorldPay money?

Michael Russell
link

The offer was for repayment. That was clearly the protection that was felt necessary at the time. The Audit Scotland report and other comments have made us consider whether we should improve things in such circumstances, and I am willing to consider that.The construction that you have put on the events is neither fair nor accurate.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

If the Official Report records laughter when Nicol Stephen was speaking, I hope that it reflects that the laughter was at him and not with him.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Mr Hepburn, we do not need personal insults.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Okay; I withdraw the remark.Mr Stephen suggests that the £180,000 was not well spent. What were the economic effects of the gathering and homecoming to Scotland?10:30

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Convener, can I place it on the record that I have never said that in this committee and that, as far as I can recall, I have not said that at any time? It would be helpful if members did not make personal comments about individual members of the committee or put inaccurate words into committee members’ mouths.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. The point is noted.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Can I suggest that Nicol Stephen alluded to it, convener, if he did not outright state it?

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Can we get on with questioning the First Minister and the cabinet secretary?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

As the committee will know, there was an independent examination of the economic impact of both the gathering and homecoming. The evaluation showed that the economic impact of the gathering to Scotland was rather more than £10 million and to the city of Edinburgh rather more than £8 million. In terms of its economic impact, the gathering was undoubtedly a success. It far exceeded original expectations, including those of the public sector bodies that supported it.The difficulty with the gathering is not the expenditure of public money, because the public money delivered a substantial, huge and beneficial event. The difficulty with the gathering is twofold. First, the financial difficulties of the company have resulted in a substantial number of small private sector creditors not being paid or having very little prospect of being paid. Secondly, the chances of staging another highly successful tourist event in future have been damaged. However, in terms of its economic impact, there is no question but that the gathering, like homecoming, exceeded original expectations—in the case of the gathering, by a very substantial margin.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Would either or both of you agree that defining all things unknown as “secret”, as some members seem to be suggesting, is unhelpful to say the least, if not probably sensational and misleading?

Michael Russell
link

I think that I would be happy to agree with that, but I would add to the First Minister’s remarks with a quotation from the manager of the Holyrood hotel, who had his entire hotel booked during the gathering by members of clan Donald. He stated:“Although we expected there to be increased interest because of the Homecoming, we never thought there would be as much as this.”Both the gathering and homecoming had a direct impact on the hospitality sector and the tourism sector in Scotland. One of the individuals who turned up was quoted in a newspaper saying that she was“truly proud ... The joy and excitement I felt ... filled my heart and soul with happiness.”A whole number of people thought that it was an immensely significant event and a whole number of people benefited financially from it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Jamie Hepburn can have a last question.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

I have two more questions, if that is all right, convener.Mr Russell, you have stated clearly that officials from the finance directorate sought advice on your instruction regarding the provision of a loan. I believe that the Audit Scotland report reflects that and that you were advised “that there was no barrier to offering funds”.I take it that you agree with the findings of the report, and I suggest that that indicates that this was not done on a whim; it was considered in some detail.

Michael Russell
link

It certainly was not done on a whim. The timeline shows that very serious consideration was given to what should take place and what the mechanism should be to take things forward. I think that the Audit Scotland report reflects that. The permanent secretary has given very clear evidence on the considerations that were brought to bear and the solution that was eventually found. I again lean on that evidence.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

On the convener’s point about the subsequent effect on other businesses—the company’s creditors—I presume that the loan was awarded not on the basis that The Gathering 2009 Ltd was going to go into administration or liquidation. I suppose that essentially this is the question: the Scottish Government does not have a crystal ball, does it?

Michael Russell
link

We were dealing with an organisation that had started to deliver the event in 2007 and which was the only organisation that was able to deliver it, because of the involvement of the Standing Council of Scottish Chiefs. It had been working with the steering group since February 2008 and had been funded by the Scottish Government to deliver certain clear objectives in the grant that went to it at the end of 2008.In all those circumstances, we would have felt, and did feel, that we were dealing with an organisation that had run into a short-term difficulty caused not only by the WorldPay issue but by the recession, which was biting very deep. In those circumstances, a short-term measure to assist it through that difficulty was—I am sorry to keep quoting the Auditor General—“not unreasonable”. I stand by that, and I stand by the remark that I referred to from a senior Labour minister. It was not unreasonable and I believe that it was a decision that any minister in my position would have made; it was clearly designed to ensure that the outcomes were achieved.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I have three quick points to make. First, the loan was offered not because it was envisaged that the gathering would fail, but to allow it to succeed; that was the intention. Secondly, the evidence from the directors of The Gathering 2009 Ltd was that there would have been more creditors if the event had not gone ahead. That is their opinion, and it would seem to be a likely outcome, although it is subject to different interpretations.Thirdly, there can be no doubt that if the event had not gone ahead, £10 million less would have been spent in the Scottish economy and £8 million less in the Edinburgh economy. There is no question about that, and there would also have been 280 fewer jobs in Scotland last year.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

To go back to the convener’s point, when it came to making a decision on whether to provide financial assistance as a grant or a loan, you decided to give the loan. In making that decision, did you think about the private creditors and local businesses that were going to participate and had already participated in the run-up to the event? Did you aim to help or hinder them?

Michael Russell
link

I was mindful in the discussions that took place that there would have been a very severe effect on those who were already involved and who were creditors. We are talking about a decision that was made during May, which was roughly two months before the event took place. A large number of people and organisations were already involved and were expending considerable time and money. That would have been a major problem.It was in my mind that if the event did not take place, that would have had a severe financial effect. It would also have had a financial effect on those who had booked to come, the transport companies that were involved and the hotels that had bookings. Given those circumstances, it seemed to me to be—I go back to this point—a “not unreasonable” decision to make.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Obviously I understand that, as did the Auditor General. You said that you do not like to speculate, but perhaps you will speculate on this. Let us say that you decided that you did not want the extra £10 million for the Scottish economy, were not bothered about the extra £8 million for the Edinburgh economy or concerned about the other creditors whom Lord Sempill says probably would not have been paid if the event had not gone ahead—I hate the term “no-brainer”, but that is a bit of a no-brainer. If you had decided to say, “No, we’re not going to support you”, and the event had subsequently collapsed, and therefore nothing happened that weekend and there was no gathering, what do you think the response would have been from the rest of the Parliament?

Michael Russell
link

I hate to speculate, and I think that I should not, having refused Mr McAveety. However, I will just say that I suspect that I might have been in front of this committee for that decision. Perhaps we should reflect on that.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

Mr Russell made the decision, and he informed me about it. He got the information. I note the evidence from Lord Sempill, who was led by Lord Foulkes into saying that my private secretary phoned him to arrange the meeting. We now know that that was Mr Russell’s private secretary—there is no doubt about that.That puts me in the position of saying that I cannot believe that any other minister in any other Government who was faced with the set of circumstances that Mr Russell faced would have made any decision other than to help the company to secure the future of the event, for all the reasons that Anne McLaughlin has cited.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

You said that, without the loan, it is unlikely that the event would have gone ahead and rightly made the point that many creditors have not been paid for the event. What is your view about their expectations, given that the Government was clearly fully in support of the gathering? You have said that you were not formally involved in the steering group, but Government organisations were involved in it. Do you have a view on that? Are you aware of creditors’ views that the Government’s involvement in the steering group—albeit informally, through Government organisations—gave it some kind of responsibility, having kept the gathering going at a point at which it might have collapsed?

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

I am very aware of and sensitive to the creditors’ position. When we come to discuss the efforts in which I was personally involved to secure the event’s future and the creditors’ position, I will be able to demonstrate that awareness. Many of the 400 events for homecoming were supported directly by the Government, but the Government does not take on liability for private companies that pursue events. The Gathering 2009 Ltd is a company limited by guarantee and was established before the Government took office. The fact that an event is supported by the Government and the existence of a steering group, which is the case for many events, do not mean that the Government takes on a company’s liability, which rests with the company’s directors. A steering group does not replace a board of directors, legally or in any other way.As Sarah Boyack must know, if by supporting a company by Government grant the Government took on liability, we would make no Government grants. If the Government took on liability for a company by setting up a steering group, we would set up no steering groups. No Government at any time or in any place could take on commercial risk, which—rightly—falls on the company. No steering group can replace a board of directors, which is liable for the company’s position.I hope that I will be able to demonstrate that I had great concern for the creditors’ position. I hope that we will move on to that issue, so that I can explain what I was trying to do. However, the Government cannot take on liability for a company by virtue of giving it a grant or setting up a steering group. That cannot be done.

Michael Russell
link

As I pointed out earlier when the member was not here, the steering group model is used widely. There were advisory steering groups for the MOBO awards and the Ryder cup. Paragraph 22 of the Audit Scotland report states:“As the event was run by a private sector company, the steering group had a purely advisory role and could not enforce any actions or changes. The company, as the event owner, had the power to make all commercial decisions.”That is not only the reality but the law.

Sarah Boyack Lab Edinburgh Central
link

I was responding to the comment by both of you that, without the loan, it is unlikely that the event would have gone ahead and that people provided services on the basis that they thought the Government supported the event and wanted it to go ahead. I have been left high and dry by what you have just said. Without the decision to go ahead, a number of people would not have spent money and provided resources. As a result of what has happened, those people have not been paid.

The First Minister Alex Salmond
link

The loan was extended with the intention of securing the event. If the event had not gone ahead and income had not been generated from it, many creditors would have been in the position you describe. Our intention in advancing the loan was to secure the future of the event and allow it to proceed successfully. We and the steering group had every indication that there was a good chance that that would happen. The loan was made with the intention of securing the future, not in anticipation of the event’s failure. If we had not extended the loan, the risk of failure and of the event’s not taking place would, at the very least, have been very high.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Report Committee business · 395

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.