The next item on the agenda is the consideration of subordinate legislation. I remind members and the public that all mobile phones and pagers should be switched off or set to silent mode.To help our consideration of the Holyrood Park Amendment Regulations 2001 (Draft)—which are subject to the negative procedure—we are joined by Chris Watkins, the south regional director for Historic Scotland, and Gregor Stark, the south regional architect for Historic Scotland. The purpose of the regulations is to amend the Holyrood Park Regulations 1971 (SI 1971/593), which specifically ban commercial vehicles from, and the exhibition of advertising material in, Holyrood park.The amendments would permit commercial vehicles to use a specified route through the park as an alternative route to Holyrood Road, which is scheduled for partial closure, partly because of the building of the new Parliament. They would permit the display of advertising material on such commercial vehicles. The explanatory note and the Executive's note attached to the draft instrument give more details.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Chris Watkins Historic Scotland 11
- Brian Monteith Con 7
- Karen Gillon Lab 3
- Michael Russell SNP 3
The record
27 contributionsHolyrood Park Amendment Regulations 2001 (Draft)
Is there considered to be a difference between commercial and heavy commercial vehicles?
Yes, there is. The difference is to do with the weight and the axle size. The regulations were introduced to limit the number of very heavy vehicles going through that section of the park.
Are commercial vehicles able to go through the park at the moment?
Under the current regulations commercial vehicles are not allowed to go through the park.
Will the regulations have any effect on coaches? I understand that coaches have access to the park on payment of a fee. Will the new regulations make any difference to them?
Coaches will be able to use the section identified as the Holyrood loop without payment.
Will that interfere with the collection of the fee for the remainder of the park?
No, it will have no impact on that at all.
Will there be a time limit on the regulations? Given that the route will be permanent, is it intended that the regulations will remain in force?
Yes. It will be a permanent change to the regulations.
Who will police the change?
Although there are royal parks constables in the park, the policing is the responsibility of Lothian and Borders police. It is their responsibility to police the breaking of any traffic regulations in the park.
I ask that question because I have noticed a number of commercial vehicles displaying advertising driving between Meadowbank and Holyrood and not being apprehended.
That would be more of a matter for the park police than Lothian and Borders police.
Is there any alternative route that could have been considered or was considered?
Along with the Parliament project team and the Edinburgh City Council, we considered other possibilities. The only possibility was one that involved duplicating those roads in the Royal High School playing fields. It was confirmed that that would raise traffic movements in the park and would allocate more of the area to roadways. That was therefore discounted early on.
The presence of the Parliament will affect the traffic flow in that area. Will the presence of the Parliament also increase the traffic in that section of the park covered by the regulations?
Studies have been done on that. The regulations are being accompanied by a number of traffic calming measures in the vicinity of the Parliament, along roads such as Horse Wynd. There will also be improvements to the current road layout. The Holyrood triangle was always a problem for traffic control and resulted in problems for the management of traffic in that area. That is being replaced with a roundabout. The improvements to the traffic layout, plus the traffic calming measures, are likely to have a beneficial effect on traffic in that area of the park.
I was specifically asking about the increase in traffic volume because of the presence of the Parliament. Do you think that traffic volume will increase because of the presence of the Parliament and that therefore there will be an increased use of the roads specified in the regulations?
The Parliament is likely to attract more vehicles to that area. However, the overall impact is difficult to predict. I do not think that any of the surveys have been conclusive. There are balancing measures that are likely to reduce as well as increase the number of vehicles. The exact impact is unclear, but measures have been taken to calm the traffic in that area and consequently reduce the number of vehicles using that route unnecessarily.
Are you confident that the road infrastructure in that section of the park is able to cope with the type of vehicle that will be using it? Obviously those vehicles are not currently using it. If the infrastructure cannot cope in the long term, who has responsibility for repairing and replacing that section of road?
Part of the works that were identified for the roads in Holyrood park included upgrading the underlying sub-structures of areas of the road that we knew to be soft. Improvements have to be made to the existing roundabout and the Holyrood triangle is to be replaced. There has been comprehensive upgrading of those roads so that they are capable of taking the type and expected numbers of vehicles on those sections of road. The roads will remain the responsibility of Historic Scotland. There is no change to that.
I do not have any indication that members wish to oppose the SSI. We will not therefore make any recommendation to Parliament and will allow the SSI to proceed.
Meeting adjourned.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Oct 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Tuesday 23 October 2001 (Afternoon) Committee business · 8
- Item in Private Procedure · 4
- Scottish Qualifications Authority Committee business · 6
- Scottish Media Group Committee business · 8
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 27
- Budget Process 2002-03 Committee business · 31
- School Education (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 48
- Budget Process 2002-03 Committee business · 46
- Regulation of Care (Scotland) Act 2001 Committee business · 4
- Items in Private Procedure · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.