We resume the public part of our meeting. I ask members of the public to switch off any mobile phones, if they have not already done so.The purpose of this agenda item is to make public the committee’s findings at stage 3 of the complaints process on a complaint against Mr Kenneth Gibson MSP from Mr Ian Gemmell.Mr Gemmell complained to the Scottish Parliamentary Standards Commissioner that Mr Gibson failed to register in the “Register of Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament” a property that he has owned since 2008. Mr Gemmell complained that by failing to do so, Mr Gibson breached provisions of the Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Act 2006 and of section 2 of volume 2 of the code of conduct for members of the Scottish Parliament.At stage 1 of the complaints process, the commissioner confirmed that the complaint met all three tests of admissibility, including that it was likely that the conduct that was complained about had taken place and that the complaint therefore warranted further investigation. The commissioner also determined that, if proved, the conduct would constitute a criminal offence under section 17 of the 2006 act. Because of the possibility that a criminal offence had been committed, the commissioner reported the matter to the procurator fiscal in December 2009 and suspended investigation of the complaint. In August 2010, the commissioner received a response that advised him that prosecution in the public interest was not necessary. He then resumed his investigation.14:30
At stage 2, the commissioner investigates any complaint that has not been dismissed at stage 1. In this case, the commissioner’s conclusions were as follows.First, Mr Gibson was required to register his interests in the property as owner no later than 1 May 2008 and as lessor no later than 1 August 2008, but he did not do so. He did so on 30 October 2009. Accordingly, by failing to register timeously his interests in the property, he was in breach of the relevant provisions of the 2006 act and the code.Secondly, Mr Gibson, on becoming aware that he had registrable interests in the property that ought to have been registered but had not been, was required to register his interests in the property in the register of interests within seven days, but he did not do so. He registered his interests in the property on 30 October 2009. Accordingly, by failing to register timeously his interests in the property as a late registration, he was in breach of the relevant provisions of the 2006 act and the code.At stage 3, the committee’s first role is to consider whether it agrees with the commissioner’s findings. The committee considered the contents of the commissioner’s report at its meeting on 2 November. The committee notes that the commissioner is duty bound to report his conclusions without detailing or considering mitigating circumstances, and thanks him for his thorough and balanced report.The committee agreed with the findings in fact and the commissioner’s conclusions that Mr Gibson had breached the relevant provisions of the 2006 act and the code of conduct. Having agreed that, the committee is required to consider whether the breaches are sufficiently serious for it to recommend to the Parliament that a sanction be imposed on the member. The committee may take into account any mitigating circumstances surrounding the breaches at this stage of the deliberations.I invite members to comment on whether they consider that sanctions should be imposed on the member.
