Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Police Act 1997 (Criminal Records) (Registration) (Scotland) Regulations 2010 (SSI 2010/383)

Wednesday 17 November 2010 Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 24 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

24 contributions
The Convener
link

Item 2 is subordinate legislation. The committee will take evidence from Scottish Government officials on the final batch of subordinate legislation relating to the protection of vulnerable groups scheme. I am pleased to welcome Andrew Mott, who is PVG implementation legislation manager in the Scottish Government’s PVG implementation team, and Ailsa Heine, who is senior principal legal officer in the PVG and schools solicitors division of the Scottish Government. I understand that Mr Mott wants to make an opening statement.

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

Yes. Thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to make an opening statement on the six Scottish statutory instruments. I expect that members will be pleased to hear that this is the last scheduled batch required for PVG implementation. That said, it is inevitable that we will need to come back from time to time to respond to changes in policy and practice, and, in due course, we will need to make provision for retrospective checking.The batch comprises six negative resolution instruments that, broadly speaking, pick up consequential changes that are required in light of the PVG scheme. SSI 2010/380 makes provision for Disclosure Scotland to access information that is held by the Scottish Court Service to assist it with consideration cases. In particular, the order will facilitate the retrieval of information about historical convictions where the information that is held on police systems such as the criminal history system is not sufficient to allow the case to be concluded. The order also amends the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 (Power to Refer) (Information Relevant to Listing Decisions) Order 2010 (SSI 2010/178), which the committee considered in the summer, to correct defects in it. The Subordinate Legislation Committee had highlighted problems with SSI 2010/178, in that it did not identify “relevant functions” of the NHS tribunal. The Scottish Government undertook to correct those defects, which the order does.SSI 2010/381 allows organisations to access PVG disclosure records for individuals whom they are recruiting or retaining to do activities outside the UK that would have been regulated work had they been done in Scotland. That provision is made in response to stakeholder demand and delivers on the policy proposal in the Scottish Government’s response to the consultation on draft SSIs in April 2010. Members should note that provision for work done in England, Wales and Northern Ireland is properly a matter for the UK Government and the other devolved Administrations.SSI 2010/381 also makes provision to allow PVG disclosure records to be obtained in respect of certain positions in the Scottish Social Services Council. In particular, the convener or members of the council or the convener or members of the registration or conduct committees or sub-committees are eligible. Those committees deal with the admission to and removal from the register of social service workers and complaints against such workers.SSI 2010/379 prevents the Scottish ministers from appointing a barred individual as a convener or member of the Scottish Social Services Council. SSI 2010/381 gives ministers the power to access PVG disclosure records in respect of such appointments, and one effect of those regulations is to make such checks a requirement. The SSSC is responsible for appointments to its committees and sub-committees, and will use the PVG scheme to prevent the appointment of barred individuals.SSI 2010/378 places requirements on health boards and ophthalmic medical practitioners, opticians and dentists who seek to do NHS work to make appropriate use of the PVG scheme. Health boards must maintain lists of such practitioners who are authorised to do NHS work in their area. These regulations amend existing regulations that govern the operation of those practitioner lists, primarily to substitute references to enhanced disclosure with appropriate references to the PVG scheme and PVG disclosure records.SSI 2010/382 removes the requirement to include information about cases that are being considered by the Independent Safeguarding Authority on enhanced disclosures with suitability statements. Members will recall that the fact that an individual is under consideration for listing by Disclosure Scotland will be included on PVG disclosure records and enhanced disclosures with suitability statements.The long-standing intention was that those disclosures would include the fact that the ISA was considering an individual for listing. However, that information will not be available to Disclosure Scotland for that purpose at go-live, because the UK Government is not progressing the necessary arrangements, at least while the remodelling of its vetting and barring scheme is on-going. SSI 2010/383 sets out the requirements on organisations that want access to standard and enhanced disclosures and PVG disclosure records. The regulations consolidate and build on existing regulations—the Police Act 1997 (Criminal Records) (Registration) (Scotland) Regulations 2006 (SSI 2006/97)—with the most significant change being the implementation of the new charging regime for registration. That delivers on the policy proposal that was set out in the Scottish Government’s response to the consultation on draft SSIs.Organisations that seek to countersign applications and receive disclosures need to comply with a code of practice as well as the regulations. The code covers the handling of disclosure information and sets out in detail what registered persons need to do. Contrary to what the Executive note states, the code has not yet been laid before the Scottish Parliament, but it will be laid before go-live. There is no parliamentary procedure attached to the code; the requirement is that it be laid before Parliament.Changes to the code will mainly be logical consequences of the introduction of the PVG scheme, and the revised code will be made available to organisations in good time before go-live.That concludes my introduction. I am happy to take any questions.

The Convener
link

Thank you, Mr Mott. Does any member wish to ask a question?

Ken Macintosh
link

I have a couple of questions on SSI 2010/381, SSI 2010/382 and SSI 2010/383.Paragraph 18 on page 4 of the Executive note for SSI 2010/381 relates to the provision for an organisation outside the United Kingdom to apply for information that is held by Disclosure Scotland. It states:“the use of such disclosure records is entirely discretionary”.What are the limits of that discretion? Would it be exercised by Disclosure Scotland?

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

Suppose, for example, that a Scottish organisation is recruiting a Scottish individual as a ski instructor to teach children how to ski on the Italian Alps. That activity of teaching and instructing would have been regulated work if it had been done in the Cairngorms but, without the provision in SSI 2010/381, there would be no way of accessing the disclosure records for someone who is doing that work in Italy. The provision allows an organisation that recruits the individual to access a PVG disclosure record, but there is no requirement for it to do so—it is entirely up to the organisation whether it does that. Also, it would have to be for an activity under schedule 2 or 3; the provision could not be used for just any purpose.12:45

Ken Macintosh
link

I suppose that, if the activity was taking place in this country, there would have to be a disclosure anyway. If a foreign company or organisation were in the same situation, employing Scottish people who might or might not need to be checked, would it be able to apply for disclosure, or would the provision apply only to Scottish organisations abroad?

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

There is nothing to specify that it must be a Scottish organisation although, to access the PVG disclosure records, it would need to be a registered body. The organisation would have to register either with Disclosure Scotland or with an umbrella body. An organisation that was based in France, for example, that recruited Scottish individuals to work in the French Alps would be able to access that information as long as it met the registration conditions.

Ken Macintosh
link

I understand that SSI 2010/382 has been introduced because England and Wales are not progressing with the necessary arrangements for disclosure of cases that are under consideration. No progress will be made until after the 2007 act has been implemented. Can you bring us up to date with that? What will happen after the 2007 act goes live? What will happen to cases that are under consideration in England and Wales?

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

It is important to stress that the vast majority of cases that are under consideration will be Scottish cases that Disclosure Scotland is considering. Nevertheless, there is potentially a small gap regarding the cases that are being considered by the Independent Safeguarding Authority. When an application is made for PVG disclosure, Disclosure Scotland will not know that the person is under consideration by the ISA, so that will not be disclosed. The UK Government is reviewing its vetting and barring scheme, and the outcome of the review is due at some point early next year. It is hard to make any prediction until that is published. From our go-live, we will disclose Scottish consideration on disclosure, but we cannot disclose ISA consideration.

Ken Macintosh
link

Why bother repealing the provision? Why not just wait until we know what is happening down south? Surely, you might need to reintroduce it.

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

You are right. The provision was originally inserted into the Police Act 1997 by the PVG act because we believed, at that time, that all the arrangements would be sorted out. The problem is that it places a duty on the Scottish ministers to disclose the information, and that is a duty that the Scottish ministers cannot comply with because they do not have the information. The provision needs to be removed for that reason.Nevertheless, you are right to say that we might eventually come back to insert a similar provision. We would need to make amendments anyway, as the provision in the PVG act dealt only with English and Welsh cases, not with Northern Irish cases. We would need to come back to it in any case.

Ken Macintosh
link

Let us turn finally to SSI 2010/383. This is a new measure, is it not? It introduces a register that did not previously exist.

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

No, that is not the case. There are registration regulations in force at the moment, and organisations that want the higher forms of disclosure must be registered with Disclosure Scotland. An awful lot of the provision in these regulations is taken from existing regulations that are already in force, which have been consolidated with subsequent amendments. The main point of interest in these regulations is the new charging regime, which comes into force on 1 April 2011.

Ken Macintosh
link

I wanted to ask about that. You describe the charge somewhere as minimal, but it is £150 initially and then £75 annually after that.

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

The £150 is the charge under the current regime.

Ken Macintosh
link

Currently, everybody pays £150.

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

Yes. An organisation that wants to register with Disclosure Scotland currently pays £150 plus £10 for every additional countersignatory. That is a one-off payment. The proposal for the future, which applies to registration applications after April 2011, is that organisations will pay a £75 charge every year, and that will include up to four countersignatories, with an additional charge for additional countersignatories. Organisations that are currently registered will move to the new regime over a period of a year. We will be migrating those organisations. That is the change.

Ken Macintosh
link

They have already paid a one-off charge, but they will have subsequent annual charges.

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

Yes.

Ken Macintosh
link

How much of a difference will that make in income? How much money will be brought in?

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

It is a very modest amount. I do not have the exact amount, although I can get it for the committee, but it is modest and much smaller than the amount raised through the disclosure fees.

Ken Macintosh
link

Is it in the tens of thousands of pounds or the hundreds of thousands?

Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate
link

I think that it is in the hundreds of thousands, but I will check that.

The Convener
link

As members have no further questions, I thank Mr Mott for attending.Item 3 is the committee’s formal consideration of the statutory instruments that have just been discussed under item 2. No motion to annul has been lodged in respect of the statutory instruments. When the Subordinate Legislation Committee considered the instruments at its meeting yesterday, it did not highlight any issue for our attention. As members have no comments, do we agree that the committee has no recommendation to make on SSI 2010/378, SSI 2010/379, SSI 2010/380, SSI 2010/381, SSI 2010/382 and SSI 2010/383?Members indicated agreement.Meeting closed at 12:53.

  1. 10:00 Autism (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 161
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 24

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.