Members have in front of them a proposal that was put to the conveners liaison group yesterday, seeking permission for the committee to hold an away day. The committee agreed to a draft proposal at a private meeting. We decided that it would be useful for us to take stock of where we had been, to examine how things had worked over the past year and then to consider how to move forward in the final two years of the committee's work in this session.I am happy to report that, after considerable lobbying by the deputy convener, the conveners liaison group has given us permission to have an away day up to a cost of £3,000. I will abuse my position as convener and suggest that the venue for the away day should be New Lanark, given its history in developing forward-looking education and the fact that the school has now been reopened for public use. There is a hotel there with conference facilities. I am sure that, with negotiation, we could get a rate that would allow us to hold the away day there within budget. Holding such an event outside Edinburgh would be useful as we could ensure that we were away from our telephones and staff who might want us to be doing something different elsewhere.If members are agreed, we should invite various people along to assist our discussions. We need to look back at what has happened over the past two years. That will be a fuller process for some of us than it will be for others. The key element of the committee's work over the past two years has been undertaken in reaction to situations as they have developed. Obviously, we will need to have space in our timetable to react to situations, but it is important that the committee is proactive over the next two years. We want to have made some positive contribution to education, culture and sport in Scotland. We must not sideline any aspect of our work.The deputy convener and I had a useful and helpful meeting with Lindsay Paterson and Carol Craig from Edinburgh University. They are currently working with parents, teachers and other people involved in education to develop a vision for education in Scotland. It might be useful to invite them to the away day to outline what they are doing and to consider whether the committee could have a role in initiating the debate on the shape of education in the future. That is one of the big issues facing Scottish education.We might want to invite certain people to provide input on other issues around sport and the cultural strategy. I would like to ask both the ministerial teams with which we work to come along at some point in the day to give us an indication of what they are planning for the next 18 months. It is important that we know what their thoughts are. The Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee had a full and frank discussion with Wendy Alexander, which gave it an insight into the direction in which the ministerial team is moving. The Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee can now plan its work alongside that of the minister's team. It would be helpful if we could do something similar.I welcome comments from members on the proposal and any ideas for the away day.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Karen Gillon only · show everyone- Karen Gillon Lab 6
- Frank McAveety Lab 3
- Ian Jenkins LD 2
- Cathy Peattie Lab 1
- Irene McGugan SNP 1
Karen Gillon’s contributions
6 contributionsIt depends on what we want to do with the away day. It is not the appropriate occasion on which to have detailed discussions about policy development. The intention is that we should use it to form an agenda for the committee so that we can get into a detailed investigation of policy. It would be helpful for people to come to give us an overview of the situation in each of our areas of responsibility rather than discuss the nitty-gritty detail.
The idea behind having a brief session on what we have done is to get an idea of the time scales that we work to, to consider how long things take and to see what we have been able to achieve in the past two years. We have managed to do some good things. Before we start that process, it would be helpful to acknowledge what we have managed to achieve, despite everything. I envisage it being a short, half-hour session. We could have three presentations, one on each of the core areas of our remit. It is for members to decide how we run that.The Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee was away from lunchtime on Tuesday until lunchtime on Wednesday. If we did that it would mean losing a full morning, because members would need to be back in Edinburgh for Wednesday afternoon. It could be argued that the away day should be held on a Monday and Tuesday. Obviously, that would have constituency implications. However, for once it might be worth taking a Monday away from constituency work. We could meet at about 11 o'clock, if that suited members. I know that Irene McGugan would have to travel furthest. We could have three presentation sessions on the Monday and a dinner that night. On the Tuesday morning we could meet the ministerial team and in the afternoon we could have a go at planning for the future, before finishing about Tuesday tea time.
Yes.
I suggested that we invite speakers to give us an overview of the situation in their field. That might involve a 20-minute presentation as part of a two-hour session. The committee would then thrash out what we see as the priorities in the area that is being discussed. The next day we would hear from the ministerial teams, so that they could give us an idea of their position. We would spend the afternoon of the second day pulling things together and drawing up a plan for the committee. The in-depth, detailed discussion of issues would take place later. We could spend the next 20 years discussing some of them. We will need to be strict with ourselves and to identify priorities.We have received a couple of suggestions for speakers on education. I do not have a problem with either of the people who have been mentioned. I suggest that we invite the new chief executive of sportscotland to speak to us about sport. He is a visionary young man. We may also want to hear from Charles Raeburn, who has already appeared before the committee. He has a slightly different perspective on matters and he has considerable expertise across the school sports sector.We might want to ask someone from the Scottish Arts Council—perhaps Tessa Jackson—to give us an overview from the SAC perspective. We could also seek someone who works in that field. Two 15-minute presentations would be enough, and we could then have a one-and-a-half-hour discussion of the issues. We can try to fit in three two-hour sessions on the first day back, followed by a dinner. That will involve a lot of work, but I think that it is worth doing. We are moving along, and I think that we should do things right when we are there. Do members have any preferences about particular days? We initially mentioned October, but I think that it would be more useful were we to hold the away day sooner rather than later. I think that September would be a better time to aim for. I suggest that we e-mail members and ask them for an indication of Mondays and Tuesdays in September when they will be available. If there are any items in members' diaries that they cannot cancel, we will need to work around those. I always hold surgeries in my constituency on a Monday, but I think that I can put them to one side for this purpose. I understand that members include items in their diaries a long way in advance, which they cannot get out of. I would like members to indicate next week their availability. We can then begin negotiations on the venue. Are people happy with New Lanark as a venue? Is that acceptable?Members indicated agreement.
I abuse my position as convener. I promise that I will not talk too much about New Lanark's history. If we e-mail members today, I would like to get a response by the end of next week. We can then try to firm something up.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Jun 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Wednesday 27 June 2001 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- “Assessing our children's educational needs: The Way Forward?” Committee business · 11
- Petition PE342 Petitions · 8
- Work Programme Procedure · 13
- Gaelic Broadcasting Committee business · 14
- Consultative Steering Group Principles Committee business · 5
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.