Item 3 is the continuation of our review of the enterprise network. We will take evidence from a panel of academic experts—I am sure that they will be delighted to know that that is what they are. Unfortunately, Tony Mackay, from Mackay Consultants Ltd, is unable to attend, as he has been detained on other business overseas. He sends his apologies.I invite the panellists to introduce themselves, after which we will move to questions.
Official Report · Committee
Enterprise Network Inquiry
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John McLaren Centre for Public Policy for Regions 26
- Professor Danson 17
- The Convener 16
- Ms Alexander 8
- Stuart McMillan 8
- Lewis Macdonald 6
- Rob Gibson 4
- Christopher Harvie Mid Scotland and Fife) (SNP 3
- Professor Mike Danson University of the West of Scotland 1
The record
89 contributionsI am an economist. I have worked in the Treasury and the Scottish Government both pre and post-devolution. Currently, I am working for the Centre for Public Policy for Regions, among other things.
I am professor of Scottish and regional economics at the University of the West of Scotland. At one time, I worked in Strathclyde Regional Council. I have been working on regional development agencies since the mid-1970s and have published various books and so forth on the issue.
I will start by asking a fairly general question. Has the review of the enterprise networks that was introduced in 2008 made the enterprise network in Scotland more effective or less effective?
I have a couple of points to make. First, I have very little contact with the front line, so it would be difficult for me to comment on that front. Secondly, it is too early to evaluate whether the process has been successful. I have not seen much in the way of proper evaluation, which would need time, to allow me to give a judgment on that.
I agree. It is quite difficult, if not impossible, to evaluate regional development agencies as such. We usually fall back on evaluating their policies and programmes, many of which, by their very nature, take years to come to fruition. In some ways, it is too early to say.
So your argument would be less about the structures of the organisations and more about the programmes that they are in a position to deliver.
Yes—in general, that is the sort of evaluation that we see.
From your experience and your studies, what type of programmes do you consider that an RDA or an enterprise agency needs to deliver in Scotland at present? Are there things that Highlands and Islands Enterprise and Scottish Enterprise are doing particularly well, things that they are not doing particularly well or things that they are not doing that they should be doing?
It is quite interesting. Twenty years ago, in the 1990s, Scottish Enterprise and its Irish equivalent were seen throughout the world as the models—everybody wanted to have a Scottish Enterprise. By the start of this decade, that had disappeared, because the rest of the world had changed in how it delivered economic development. The first thing to say in response to the question is that we should be looking at what is appropriate and good for Scotland, or parts of it, rather than looking for models elsewhere, because there are not any. However, we can look for best practice elsewhere.What do the agencies do well? As always, foreign direct investment and boosting entrepreneurship and enterprise tend to be things that they do well. With other things, such as work on information and broadband, it is difficult to tell how they are doing, because there is no benchmark.
You have asked the narrow question before we, presumably, get on to the broad question of what the fundamental purpose of Scottish Enterprise is. In that sense, the bigger, more important question is whether the money that has gone into any of Scottish Enterprise’s activities is being used better than it would be in education, infrastructure or something else. I think that Scottish Enterprise currently claims a cost benefit ratio of 8.8. I would take that with more than a pinch of salt; such evaluations are usually done on the basis of surveys. I think that the internationalisation evaluation was based on £5 million spend and the inward investment one was based on £6 million spend, which are tiny figures compared to Scottish Enterprise’s overall budget. They are making heroic assumptions and there are fundamental flaws in a lot of these surveys, some of which I have carried out myself, on the positive side of getting a good result. If the ratio was 8.8, you should be considering vastly expanding how much Scottish Enterprise gets, but it is not.
It is good that this has turned into a truth and reconciliation meeting. We have to follow up Mike Danson’s point that others have moved away from the model of enterprise development that we have here. Do either of you want to expand on that to allow us to contrast what is happening elsewhere with what we have here at present?
We did work for the previous Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee—I think that it was the first research done for the Parliament. We followed that up by doing work for Scottish Enterprise in 2003-04, as did Firn Crichton Roberts Ltd for the Parliament and the training and employment research unit for the Scottish Government around the same time. We all came to the same conclusion: Scotland is fairly unique. It is very difficult to find anywhere else in the world that has a similar range of powers—that is not an independent nation—and that has an agency of this size and sort, with such a huge range of functions. The whole environment here is different.Places such as Germany and America have a strong enterprise culture and strong employers associations and so on. Belgium is different and
so is Sweden. Everywhere is different in its environment and so on.Why did others begin to move away? They thought that there were benefits in having specialised-focus agencies, which had a lot of autonomy from central Government. That was the big difference. Previously, small authorities tended to be very close to Government and very closely managed. What we saw in this decade in Scotland and England was RDAs getting more and more powers up to 2007, with a lot of autonomy. It contrasted more and more with everywhere else in the world, apart from England.
The argument is that other people have moved away from the model that we have to achieve success and perhaps, as John McLaren said, we overestimate the success of our model out of hope more than sober expectation.
I am not quite sure what we mean by success in this case. In the past, part of the role of regional development agencies such as Scottish Enterprise has been to reduce the gap in growth between different parts of the country through regional selective assistance and things like that. The other week, Vince Cable said that that has signally failed in England, although it could be argued that it has not failed so much in Scotland over a certain period. We can discuss that later, if you like.It could also be argued that Scottish Enterprise has improved the growth rate for Scotland as a whole, although it is difficult to determine whether that is true. There is not a lot of strong evidence for that or people out there saying that that is true, but that is partly due to the fact that the statistics are of a poor standard and we cannot take an awful lot from them.It is extremely difficult to say what Scottish Enterprise has contributed to economic growth as a whole or even to economic growth in different areas. Ekosgen undertook a study of that. Although it came out with a very high cost benefit ratio, it also found that two thirds of survey respondents said that Scottish Enterprise support had no impact on anything that they did—on employment, on increased growth or whatever. If that is true, there is a hell of a lot of dead weight there. Can that be taken away, or is it just an inevitable consequence of making fairly risky investments? I do not think that the research has been done to tell us how good Scotland’s situation is in that respect.There are areas that have had more successful regional policies, such as Ireland or post-war Japan. However, those tend to be examples of catch-up, using industries that already exist. For example, the automobile industry was taken from America to Japan, where it was done better. When a country is at the forefront of new technologies such as renewables, there is much more of a guessing game as to whether it succeeds.
There are differences in what is done and what is supported. The internationalisation of work and jobs, business start-ups, research and development and innovation, and commercialisation are four areas of spend that we have been looking at. We have compared Enterprise Ireland with Scottish Enterprise and have found that far greater amounts have been invested in those four areas in Ireland than in Scotland. Does that begin to answer the point that John McLaren has just made? Scotland is going into new industries and we are creating a very new economy at the moment. Are the enterprise networks coming under scrutiny because they are not placing emphasis on those areas? Is it even their job to provide support in those areas, or should somebody else be doing that? For example, should academe be given more money for research and development and innovation? I know that academics would say so. Some thoughts on that would be of interest.
As I said, everywhere is different. Enterprise Ireland has had certain tax regimes and so on. You could also look at Finland and Sweden, which have been innovative in innovation. They disaggregated the regional development agency into different parts and gave them lots of autonomy, and they have been highly successful in supporting innovation and research and development. There are peculiarities in Sweden, such as the fact that professors retain intellectual property rights, patents and so on. That is quite different from the situation in many other countries. You need to look at the whole rather than just at the headline figures of how much is spent in different areas. That then leads to all sorts of problems with the attribution of successes, which John McLaren has described.11:00
On things such as enterprise support and business start-ups, again, I struggle to think of an example of a policy almost anywhere that has improved things. We have been trying to do that in Scotland for a long time, but I cannot remember a startling success in those areas. That is probably also true of many other countries, although there might be individual countries such as Finland or Israel that we know less about. Some work was done in America that looked at business start-ups over a 20-year period and found that the numbers were virtually constant year by year regardless of the policies that were in place or the state of the economy.The questions are difficult ones to answer and I do not think that we have got very far in answering them.
To go back to the fundamental principle, what is the objective of enterprise agencies? Under the current structure, we have Scottish Development International as a semi-autonomous agency, Scottish Enterprise with an apparently national remit, and Highlands and Islands Enterprise with an explicitly regional remit. What is your view of the fundamental purpose of the existence of such agencies? Is that tripartite structure the right one, either in practice or in theory?
If we go back to first principles and consider why we have development agencies rather than putting
the money into local government, central Government or the market, we could go on for hours about the rationales. There are good, strong academic reasons why development agencies perform some functions well and why they should work at the national and regional levels—for example, there are synergies in the sharing of experience and learning between areas, and there are economies of scale for certain functions.You identified the three agencies. If we look back over time, the population of the Highlands and Islands has grown significantly and the economy has grown even more significantly. It is not difficult to suggest that the Highlands and Islands Development Board and then Highlands and Islands Enterprise have been critical in that turnaround. The problems in the Highlands and Islands are different from those in much of the rest of Scotland. As you know, Scottish Enterprise deals with the rest but, sensibly, it also has some functions that cover the whole of Scotland rather than just the areas outside the Highlands and Islands. Certain other activities, such as those of Scottish Development International, could be differently configured. They could be taken even further away from Scottish Enterprise or brought back into it. Again, however, there are some good, rational arguments why having it as a semi-autonomous agency is beneficial across the board for business and so on.That is probably an academic answer that goes round in circles.
The objective as it is seen in Scotland—and probably in the United Kingdom—has changed over time from being a regional objective to reduce inequalities to one that is more about improving the productivity of Scottish companies and, through that, improving economic growth. Scottish Enterprise is supposed to do those things, I guess, by solving some of the market failures that are involved in low productivity and low innovation. Whether it does that is a moot point. Does work on clusters really address market failure or does it merely involve trying to second-guess the market? I imagine that almost every city, region or sub-region of the UK is looking at the same clusters. Because of what Michael Porter said, or whoever is the new Porter, we are all going after the same things, and we cannot all win them. I do not think that the approach really addresses market failure.On a wider scale, if you are thinking about improving productivity and innovation, an organisation that does not look to inward investment or even the private sector might offer greater returns. Such an organisation would consider productivity and innovation as a whole, including the public sector, where there are more clear-cut examples of how things are done in other countries to lean on. That might be more fruitful than continuing with a narrow band of private sector areas.
You have both redefined my question a bit, but you have not said that there is a simple, single answer, which I did not expect you to do.Would it be fair, in summarising what you have said, to say that the HIE model has had a specific remit and a measurably successful process for implementing it? You mentioned growing the economy and the population of what was, 50 years ago, a highly disadvantaged area; there has been a demonstrable input from the enterprise agency and the development board in achieving that end. That seems to be the clear proposition that Mike Danson presented.With regard to Scottish Enterprise, John McLaren said that its objectives have changed over time, and raised the question whether the agency is addressing market failure or doing something else. Perhaps it is doing something else, and I wonder whether that is legitimate. If HIE’s work has been about addressing the market failures in the Highland regional economy, is the purpose and practice of the Scottish Development Agency and now Scottish Enterprise to do the same on a larger scale for a larger area? Is it a regional development agency in the same way that HIE is, except on a larger scale?
Both agencies have always addressed market failure and other aspects. They have constantly undergone change, with staging posts along the way such as changes of Government and the move from the SDA to Scottish Enterprise. The agencies acquired many more functions in the late 1990s and into this decade, which have partly been framed by UK and European changes. The problem in the Highlands was not so much market failure: the market was operating, but it created uneven development, which has become more and more uneven. That can be a problem, in which case we would want to intervene anyway.
In terms of economic and population growth, it looks as if the Highlands has done particularly well. It seems that HIE played a greater role in contributing to that, although it is difficult to be precise. That may have been because HIE had clearer objectives. Although it covers a large area, HIE was clear in what it was doing and had a better understanding of the industries on which it wanted to focus and which it thought could be built up. In that sense, it is more like Ireland was in the past, when it had a clear idea of and focus on what it was doing.Scottish Enterprise covers the rest of Scotland; it is trying to save some industries that are declining and make bets on new industries that are expanding. It has had a more difficult task, and has arguably not done as well in achieving that.
You said in answer to my first question that we may need to think about different ways to promote productivity and innovation, rather than following the clusters route that you say has been common throughout the UK during the past 30 years. You are probably aware of the intermediary technology institutes. ITI Scotland was created a number of years ago but has now ceased to operate as a separate entity. Would it fulfil the description that you offered of an agency whose remit was not dispersed in the way that Scottish Enterprise’s is but focused specifically on promoting, incentivising and encouraging innovation and backing winners—energy, life sciences and information technology—in a way that concentrated on technological innovation rather than wider economic market failure issues?
The trouble with focusing on any area in Scotland is that we do not really understand the Scottish economy well. As an example, you might have seen it mentioned in the papers over the past couple of weeks that the Scottish gross domestic product figures were revised last month hugely. It now appears that construction, for example, hardly grew in Scotland from the mid-1990s to the mid-2000s—that is not a popularly shared view, but it is what the statistics say. Before that, it had grown greatly—at about three times the current rate—and the UK still grows at that fast rate. Then, between 2005 and 2007,
it suddenly grew by 17 per cent. What happened? No explanation is ever given for the figures when they are published, and I do not understand it. The same happened in hotels and restaurants. They have not contributed to GDP growth in 10 years, so do we actually do tourism well? Financial services have fallen roughly 20 per cent since 2007 but did not fall at all in the UK. What are we doing so badly in Scotland? There is no analysis of those figures, and we can go through almost every area like that. If we do not understand our economy, why are we trying to pick winners? How do we know what the financial services sector needs?The most obvious sector to pick is renewables. It is a risky one to pick because we do not know where it will go in the end and what the relative prices will be, but it seems to be the most obvious sector in which we have a relative advantage and it will be a growth industry in future. If we pick anything else, we are taking a stab in the dark. Perhaps that has been the problem.Ireland had a better idea of what it was doing, plus it was getting American companies in much of the time or taking in well-established practices from Japan and doing them better. That is a different ball park.
The uncertainties that you describe in relation to the revised GDP figures could be an issue for economists. Perhaps it is for you guys to provide better data so that policy makers have more to go on.
The Scottish Government provides the data. Let us put it this way: economists should be analysing the data but, if we had analysed all the old data, we would have come to the wrong conclusions because they were so wrong. If we analyse the new data, which I think are wrong, we will come to the wrong conclusions again. What are we supposed to recommend for policy if we cannot rely on the data? That is a fundamental point, because the purpose of this Government—and, obviously, previous Governments—is to improve the sustainable growth rate. For a start, we have outgrown the UK economy in four of the past six years and, in terms of GDP per capita, we have outgrown it for the 2000s as a whole quite easily. We have achieved that, allegedly—or have we? Those are fundamental points. If you are going to put economic and industrial policies on top of that, we need to know what is happening.
That is a fundamental point, but you will appreciate that you are not necessarily adding to the clarity and certainty with which we can approach the issues, as you simply highlight the fact that no statistics or data on the matter are, in your view, reliable. That makes public policy formulation quite a challenge.
It does, but the point is important, because it means that policy makers should not have false certainty in what they try to do. If there is little certainty in one area, they might want to think about spending the lower funds that will be available in the future on sectors in which returns are more certain, such as infrastructure or education.11:15
Even with all that uncertainty, in evaluating or looking at the development agencies, we have the counterfactual question of what would have happened in their absence. Would the Scottish economy have grown less quickly? Rather than look for direct outcomes from what development agencies have done, we need to second-guess that or have an idea of what would have happened if the agencies had not been there and to consider whether we have good benchmarks elsewhere. Again, that is problematic for data reasons and so forth.
Were the changes in the methodology for calculating GDP UK-wide, which meant that they had an impact on Scotland, or were they specifically Scottish changes?
They were specifically Scottish changes. New information that is available on input-output studies is supposed to be better than the previous information. The only trouble is that the profile that is provided makes less sense than the old profile—construction is the classic example. We have the usual issue, in that the data might tell us something but, if they do not make sense, we need to understand why they tell us something. We might find out something interesting or we might find that the data are wrong.
If GDP figures are not necessarily a reliable indicator of growth, should we consider using alternative indicators?
In a country the size of Scotland, I would not have thought that it would be too difficult to know what is going on in some areas. For example, it is alleged that no growth has occurred in hotels and restaurants in Scotland in 10 years, although that has been one of the fastest-growing sectors in the UK. From walking down any high street in a major town or city in Scotland, we can tell by our own eyes that that claim is untrue, unless all such establishments make no money, which could be true. I presume that people in the industry could give the committee better information.I imagine that people who are involved in the construction industry—not many big firms exist—should be able to give members a reasonable idea of whether the profile is sensible. Until we can overhaul the statistics and make them more reliable, perhaps we should rely a little more on expertise, industry by industry. The financial services are another sector of which our understanding is woeful.
So is the understanding of people in financial services. Laughter.
The issue is really important. David Roberts’s review of where we have reached in the inquiry shows the risk that we will become lost in the minutiae of the institutional architecture and not lift our eyes to what is happening in the Scottish economy. I am mindful that we are about to leave the inquiry for two months and focus on the budget, when we will look closely at some of our agencies and how they are supported. As members will remember, we spent years on trying to persuade VisitScotland to give us 10-year trend data on spend and so on as VisitScotland understands it.I will make a suggestion, to which we can return when we are in private session. As the committee that deals with the economy, it is a test of our seriousness to hear about major and profound revisions to the GDP figures. I say this on a cross-party basis. It is inconceivable that, in a sovereign nation—were Scotland to be such—we would allow the GDP figures to be wildly inaccurate and change enormously, or allow the Treasury of the day or those with responsibility for public finance not to comment on why the changes were significant. All that is a plea for discussing in private session the wisdom of inviting John McLaren to provide a brief paper on the subject, which I think would attract widespread interest and attention.We should seek from the Scottish Government its views on the matter, in the context that we are aware that significant changes will occur to VisitScotland, Scottish Enterprise and HIE because of the reducing budget, which we want to understand. I say that not least because it would be easy to identify 10-year trend data in the tourism, financial services, food and drink and energy industries. That would obviously be more difficult in the creative industries and universities but, for four out of the six big industries, we could have clear trends. I put that on the record and I am happy to return to that.I have another question about financing. A difficulty that we have had in the inquiry is Scottish Enterprise’s opaqueness on its actual spend on functions. Our assessment is that on a like-for-like basis, Scottish Enterprise is spending 16 per cent less than it was three years ago. In the case of HIE, the figure is 43 per cent less.The evidence seems to indicate that Scottish Enterprise has moved from being a national economic development agency to being more of a business development and business support agency for 2,000 account-managed companies. Does the panel have any idea which area has borne the brunt of those 16 and 43 per cent real-terms cuts in the budget in the past three years? The cuts are without precedent in the Scottish public sector. Below the institutional changes, has there been something of a transition from a national economic development agency towards a business support agency for key companies?
The figures are pretty difficult to follow, especially if they are over a number of years, because there are so many changes. There are big changes, such as Skills Development Scotland, but there are smaller changes even within that. Over a longer period there will have been a move away from funds for inward investment and so on. That was quite big a decade ago and will now be smaller. However, that is demand driven, so it is not necessarily up to the Scottish Government where it puts that money.I am surprised that HIE’s spending has fallen by 43 per cent. That seems extraordinarily high compared with the Scottish Enterprise figure. Unfortunately, I do not know the details. If that is true, I would be interested to find out where the reduction occurred. I know that I am supposed to tell the committee that—if you find out, I would be interested to hear it.
It is not clear to me either what was stripped out but had not disappeared—for example, what had gone to Skills Development Scotland—so it is difficult to answer that.You mentioned food and drink. We did a study a few years ago of the Scotch Whisky Association and the unions. When we asked Scottish Enterprise for data on the whisky industry, it stonewalled us and eventually admitted that the area is so big that it cannot handle it and so it ignores it. It is interesting that Scottish Enterprise has nothing to say about the biggest, and in some ways most important, part of the food and drink sector in Scotland.
We have had a lot of evidence on institutional arrangements, but there has been less about the character of governance. Those of us who have been in the field for a long time get the impression that both agencies—Scottish Enterprise and HIE—have become much closer to Government. That is evidenced by the fact that there has been no public comment by the chairmen or the boards about the budgetary changes that I have mentioned. The boards appear to have moved to an operational rather than a strategic role. There seems to have been not only greater risk aversion, but proximity to their being simply reflections of governmental policy in the enterprise field rather than strategic drivers of governmental policy. Does the panel share that perception? If so, is that good or bad? Where should strategic leadership on enterprise policy lie?
I mentioned at the start the rationales for a regional development agency. A major rationale is that the agency is semi-autonomous—it is arm’s length from Government. There were times in the late 1980s when that appeared to be under threat. That would have been unfortunate, because there are good reasons for development agencies to be arm’s length. Overall strategy can be set by Government or the Parliament, leaving the agency to make difficult day-to-day decisions and so on. If we start eroding that distance, we lose the benefit of having a separate development agency and we might just as well take it into central Government as the Welsh Assembly Government did, although that has not been an overwhelming success.The other side of governance is about who is doing the governing. The RDAs in England were established with the involvement of trade unions and other social partners, and that has never automatically been the case in Scotland, either at the national level or in the local enterprise companies when they were around. That was a failure to make full use of the development agencies and to ensure that they were embedded into the regional community at the Scottish level or the lower levels.
It is interesting to consider what has happened in Wales since the enterprise agency was taken back in-house and to see how that has affected where Wales invests its money and what its approach has been. It is too early to say whether that initiative has been a success, but it will be interesting to see how it changes the character of the body. There has been a move away from risk aversion, possibly because of earlier controversy. When Robert Crawford was head of Scottish Enterprise, the agency was in the news quite a lot; sometimes Governments do not like that, so they might say to the agencies, “Keep the noise down. We don’t want you to be in the news quite so much.”Strategic leadership is important in such a body, especially when it is semi-autonomous, but that has to go hand in hand with the Government’s strategic leadership in the area of the economy. They have to be synchronised to be most effective. There is probably a lack of balance there. Strong leadership might mean that you will be in the press a bit more because some people will not like what you say, so you have to make your case and the people who do not agree with that case will criticise you. However, if you do not make your case, people will be less sure about what you are trying to do, and the pace at which you make progress will probably be slowed.
Obviously Scotland has had a tougher time recently with attracting inward investment. It was never going to be possible to maintain the 100,000 electronics jobs a year that were being attracted in the 1990s. However, when the Locate in Scotland joint venture between Scottish Enterprise, HIE and the Scottish Government was set up, the Government was essentially a sleeping partner. The joint venture was very much led by the enterprise agency and that continued in the early days when SDI was formed.It is interesting to note Scotland’s relative slippage in performance on inward investment. I do not think that SDI has had a dedicated head for a number of years now. The role has been combined with the Scottish Enterprise chief operating officer role for some time and it has been vacant for the past year, when there has been a critical change in leadership. The chief executive is answerable not just to the joint venture but to each individual Cabinet member, with a wider ambassadorial role. There is some concern that that might take the focus away from single-minded pursuit of inward investment.I invite your comments on that sort of governance change, in which what was essentially a sleeping partner role for the Government has become much more active, and whether that has a detrimental impact on the body’s trade and investment responsibilities, given the significance of export growth for our future prospects. Are you aware of any work or any thoughts on that?
There is not a lot of work being done on that, or on many other parts of the Scottish economy. As an aside, John McLaren and I could mention a handful of economists who are working on the Scottish economy, and there are not many more than that. The committee might want to address that situation at another time.11:30
The response to the question is similar to the one that was given earlier. Although elsewhere we have seen a disaggregation of larger development agencies into smaller ones that are focused on and dedicated to particular areas, but with lots of autonomy, it appears that Scotland has gone the other way. In the past decade, more and more functions were thrown at Scottish Enterprise, and many of them were then taken away again, but it appears that a lot of autonomy was also taken away. We have gone in a direction that is different from that which many development agencies, regions and nations throughout Europe and beyond have taken. That raises issues. John McLaren said that some of that is to do with the Government and the Parliament overscrutinising day-to-day decisions and announcements, which has an impact in the short term and the longer term on how those who are operating feel that there is freedom and space to make difficult strategic decisions.
I do not have much to add to that. At the moment, it is difficult to know what inward investment policy to have, and it will probably be difficult to know that for some time. I guess that China to some extent will be doing the investing around the world, but even its position is uncertain. Before, we knew what was happening—America and a few other countries such as Japan would invest—but the game is different now.The significance of exports is little understood. We have some statistics—I am not sure about their quality—that cover a very narrow range of manufactured exports, which are dominated by drink and electrical engineering. They account for more than 50 per cent of all exports in that area. The statistics do not give us a very good picture of Scotland’s export performance as a whole, where its performance has been growing and where it might have a competitive advantage.
Both of those sectors are totally dominated by multinational organisations, which results in problems with data and so on. That also tends to squeeze out or crowd out Scottish indigenous operations.
Earlier in the discussion, Professor Danson highlighted that, in the past, it was difficult to compare Scotland with anywhere else. He highlighted why making comparisons was difficult in a number of areas. Do you know of any work in which Scotland has been compared with places such as the state of Victoria in Australia? I know that the Australian states have a tremendous amount of power. Obviously, that area is a lot larger than Scotland, but its environment is probably quite similar to Scotland’s.
Comparisons were made in the studies around 2004 by Firn et al, the University of Glasgow and ourselves that I mentioned earlier. Comparisons have probably become more rather than less difficult over time because, for reasons that I gave earlier, the environments are very different. Individual projects and programmes, what they do and what the institutions are might be considered, but one will often end up saying, “Well, let’s look at the high-level statistics such as GDP per head.” We have heard why that is problematic. Things are even more problematic when we cross international boundaries, because of purchasing powers and so on.An interesting aspect of our research is that we asked agencies around the world to reflect on Scottish Enterprise. Ten years before, they could have had no problem at all with that. Although we contacted hundreds of agencies around the world, well fewer than 100 were able to make any comment. In some cases, one in 20 of those who responded were able to say anything about Scottish Enterprise. That indicates that conditions have changed a lot, and that development agencies around the world and other authorities are so different from one another now that they cannot benchmark. They cannot say how others are doing, never mind comparing themselves. It is a simple question, but it is difficult to answer.
Where do you see the likes of the enterprise agencies in Scotland being in, say, 10 years’ time? We hope that, in 10 years’ time, we will not still be in the current economic climate. What should the Scottish situation be in 10 years’ time?
The economy might not be in the same situation, but it has a downturn every 10 years, on average, so we should just be entering the next downturn.
Hopefully not.
The economy might have improved, but I do not think that the funding that is available will have improved. We will probably have five years of negative real-terms funding growth. Even if things get better, that will still leave the UK with a fairly high level of debt compared with GDP, which will have to come down. So, there will be at least another five years of only small real-terms growth, which will certainly be way below the 5 per cent real-terms growth that we have had, on average, so far post devolution.There will still be pressure on funding from long-term care and health services because of the demographic impact. Because the enterprise agencies are one of the areas that can most easily be squeezed, I do not think that they will have built themselves up—in fact, I suspect that they will get a significant cut in the next few years, and I am not sure that they will get that funding back.That leads me to the conclusion that what enterprise agencies do should be seen in the wider context of where the best place is to put the money to improve productivity or innovation as a whole. Is it universities? Is it some other kind of research and development? Is it transport infrastructure? Is it inward investment or training? There will not be much money around and those things must all be considered together in deciding what will bring the best return. That sort of holistic approach would be better than putting them all into silos and salami slicing a bit here and a bit there.
The environment will be different. The constitutional arrangements and so on will be different from what they are now. We might have Calman, Calman plus or something beyond or less than that. As I keep stressing, what is important is what is done, who does it and so on, as John McLaren has just said.The development agencies have been especially important in periods such as this, as they can take a strategic view, looking forward. They have often been under pressure to support lame ducks, yet they have said, “No. We need to invest in the future.” SDA, Scottish Enterprise and HIE have been very important in times of difficulty; therefore, one could argue that those are not the times in which to cut their budgets.Will economic development agencies still be around in 10 years’ time? They are well embedded in all regions in Europe apart, ironically, from England, which appears to have been the last to get them but the first to be getting rid of them. Everywhere else in Europe and beyond has development agencies in one form or another. Undoubtedly, we will still have them; the question is what form and function they will have, and that will evolve just as it has evolved over the past 30 years or more.
Do you think that our expectations of the enterprise agencies are too high? I base that question on what you said a few moments ago about politicians perhaps sometimes having overscrutinised the day-to-day operation of enterprise agencies.
One way in which their modus operandi changed, in the 1990s in particular, and on into the following decade, was that they had to work more and more in partnership. Ironically, they got more and more powers but, more and more, they were not stand alone. They worked with local authorities, businesses, Europe, the Government and so on. The point goes back to the leverage that they claim, although others also claim some of that. How do we measure the benefits of partnership working or networking, and how do we evaluate what the counterfactual would have been? The situation has become much muddier and more difficult. Therefore, when you try to identify inputs and targets that you want to achieve, you might not be comprehensive and might miss some of the important activities that the enterprise agencies undertake. That might lead you to focus on particular things, as we did in the past on job creation, rather than on an enterprising culture or better networking between or clustering of companies. On the 100,000 foreign direct investment jobs that we all welcomed every year, there were alternative ways of investing in the Scottish economy, which were traded off for those jobs.
My final question is on exporting. A few moments ago, we heard that more than 50 per cent of exports are attributed to a couple of sectors—food and drink, and one other.
It is just drink, and electrical engineering.
I grew up in Port Glasgow, where shipbuilding was important. There is still a yard there and there is still shipbuilding on the Clyde, but the industry has declined tremendously in the Inverclyde area. One thing that has been interesting for me in the inquiry, and prior to it, has been the point that Scotland and the UK cannot manufacture things because doing so is way too expensive. However, taking the shipbuilding industry as an example, we should compare the costs of shipbuilding and the cost of living here with those elsewhere. The average wage per hour for manufacturing in Sweden is £17.25, but in the UK it is £13.49. There are other costs in Sweden that make it more expensive, but Sweden can still manufacture ships, as can Finland. However, in Scotland and the UK, shipbuilding involves predominantly naval orders rather than commercial ones.I find it bizarre that we lose out on that market. The shipbuilding market globally is extremely buoyant, if you will pardon the pun. It is not as if nothing is being built, so we are missing out on something there. I am sure that a range of factors is involved. I do not know whether there is an element of the enterprise agencies not playing a full part in promoting the industry in Scotland and what it can do. There might be other factors. I am really at a loss to explain the situation, because we can do things more cheaply here, but we still lose out on orders. Are there any comments on that?
Generally, we do not do manufacturing because most less skilled manufacturing can be done more cheaply elsewhere—it was eastern Europe for a while and now it is Asia. On your examples of Sweden and Finland, I do not know, but I suspect that it is probably very specialised shipbuilding that is done there. The most obvious example is Germany, which still manufactures quite a lot, but it is very highly skilled manufacturing. China imports quite a lot from Germany because it cannot produce those things. Germany has kept at the forefront of technology and is still better in a number of areas of manufacturing. We have not really done that in Britain, although some companies in Scotland have, and they export all over the world—they probably do not need any help. They are engaged not simply in manufacturing but in manufacturing at the very top end, where the more developed countries, if we can call them that, can still win. However, companies need to be focused and to be world leaders in what they do.11:45
A lot of those industries were nationalised when they disappeared. The SDA was not allowed to intervene in nationalised industry areas, including steel, shipbuilding and heavy engineering. I am thinking of Rolls-Royce, British Leyland and so on. When those industries were destroyed in the early 1980s it was difficult for the SDA to get involved. It was difficult to reproduce the skills, the equipment and so on.The industries of Sweden and Finland have shrunk from what they were in the past. Considering how shipbuilding has evolved and how oil rig production has developed, we might observe how Dutch and Norwegian companies have their own capacity at home. There is strong evidence showing how they took over yards in the 1980s and 1990s to take out the competition. We should consider matters of ownership and control—we used to do a lot more of that in previous decades.
The largest cruise liner in the world was launched only a few months ago from a yard in Finland, which is not perceived to be a cheap country to live in. That is one of the points that I am trying to make.
It is probably a very specialised ship, and its manufacture will have been at the very forefront of technology. Companies will not be building oil tankers there—nobody is doing so at the minute, in fact. They will not be doing the more basic construction, anyway. Defence is a bit different, with national elements involved.If our yards were able to do such work, we could compete, but we do not have the skills, and perhaps we do not put in the investment in areas into which it might be possible to attract specialised investment. That would mean putting in quite a lot of money. How many big ships of the sort that you mention are built every year? There is a reasonable amount of risk that, even if the investment was made, Finland might still win the order. We would need to be careful and bet on a winning industry.
The liner is certainly high tech, although it is more high tech to build a naval vessel than it is to build a commercial vessel. We have the skills base. I take your point, however, that, because that sort of work has not been done here for some years, we are very much behind countries such as Finland and Germany in that game.
Talking of Germany, Christopher Harvie is next.
About three weeks ago, I employed an idle hour on an aircraft flying back from Stuttgart looking at the Handelsblatt calculations of gross domestic product per capita in Europe. I will not go into the figures for the small nations yet, but I noted that the UK comes in at fourth among the large nations, behind Italy and just above Spain. The UK’s GDP is $35,300 per capita. France is top of the list. Germany comes lower down, as it is still paying off the investment in the neue Bundesländer—the east—and it comes in at $40,900 per capita.Turning to the smaller nations, with the exceptions of ex-imperial Portugal, and Greece, which has its own problems, per capita incomes run from that of Belgium, at $43,500, up to that of Norway, at $79,100. Of course, there are particular reasons why Norway should have that level of income. Denmark is at $56,100. They are all nations with a population below 10 million.It might seem that I am grinding an old SNP organ here, but an amalgamation of Government enterprise effort in a single, sovereign authority—as sovereign as it is possible to get, anyway—seems to be more efficient, and seems to work. Stuart McMillan has mentioned examples from Scandinavia that prove that.At another level, is it right to say that the paradigm for the regional development agency goes back to the Cassa per il Mezzogiorno in Italy? It is not the best paradigm, because it was used as the milk cow of the local elites, but I cannot help seeing certain parallels with it in Scotland. Here, we keep together a cosy element of the upper professional classes to compare reports, do presentations and go to international meetings, but there do not seem to be any inputs from banking, from training or from entrepreneurial experiment and activity. We hear comments such as, “We have not really done that,” and, “People do not really know what is happening,” but surely a state that had its own responsibility for organising the economy would make damn sure that such statistics were there.I produced my history of North Sea oil very fast in 1994. I do not want to claim any particular credit for that, but the official history of North Sea oil that was started at that time is yet to appear. The historical logging of past economic developments is of crucial importance. A general who does not study military history will not be a general for very long. It seems to me that, as far as the notion of the recording of past performance and the making of statistical projections is concerned, what you have told us is pretty shaming.One or two areas have come up that meet Stuart McMillan’s criteria for areas of substantial innovation. Renewables is one such area. The opening up of the north-east passage from the far east, which will provide a route that is 7,000km shorter than the voyage through the Suez canal, will have obvious implications for break-bulk cargo handling, and Scotland is about the only country that can do that. What sort of—let us say—previsionist economic analysis is being done of those possibilities?I know that Voith, which is the biggest producer of marine turbines in the world, wants to set up in Scotland but has found it extraordinarily difficult to get through the one-door entry into the Scottish renewables field. The same could be said of Siemens. There are various factors. Alongside the areas that we can exploit, there are barriers to innovation and to attracting foreign investment, which in my view ought to be at the head of any serious economist’s agenda. Let us face it—we are back to serious economics because financial services have gone phut.
I will try to go through bits of that. On the issue of small versus large, I notice that you did not mention Iceland or Ireland.
I did, in fact. Ireland’s GDP per capita is still $44,300, which is quite a lot higher than Scotland’s—
GDP does not make sense when we are talking about Ireland. Its gross national product is at about the same level as the UK’s.China is quite big and it is doing quite well. Laughter. An important point about small countries is that, potentially, they have a better idea of how their economies work. That is not true of Scotland. Because we do not have good statistics and have almost no analysis by economists or anyone else of how our economy works, we are stabbing in the dark. Countries such as Ireland and, I suspect, Denmark and Norway know what they are good at, so it is easier for them to direct money the right way.If Scotland were independent, a host of things would happen. Inevitably, it would have to take its statistics and analysis more seriously. That does not necessarily mean that better decisions would be made, but people would be better armed to make them. However, there is no reason why we cannot collect better statistics and do better analysis now. I admit that that would be forced on us if we were an independent country, but we could still do a lot better than we are doing at the moment.
A lot of academic research suggests that in recent decades coherent, consensual societies and economies have been far more successful than larger nations. You have been given some figures on that, and the International Monetary Fund, World Bank and so on give the same overall impression over and again. There appears to be something in that: being able to present one view to the world, getting things working quickly and so on.Over the decades, one area for which Scottish Enterprise has been praised is its one-door approach. When an inward investor appears, they are not swamped by every local authority—or, in the past, every local enterprise company—in the land trying to attract them. That work is done at the national level by Scottish Enterprise, which filters it down to where the universities, the local authorities, the water board and so on all come together. That coherent approach exists, and it has been a great success of the Scottish partnership approach. With new sectors, such as renewables, that approach takes a while to be formalised. It needs leadership from above, which is perhaps the place not of Scottish Enterprise or HIE on their own but of the Government.Development agencies in Scotland have been extremely good at innovation. They have been extremely innovative with a series of policies, programmes and approaches. Clusters have been mentioned. Scotland was the first place in Europe to import the concept of clusters from North America. Like many other innovations, they did not work here, and we passed them on elsewhere where they worked. That does not mean that it was not right to experiment, but because of factors such as ownership and control it was perhaps not possible for the cluster approach to work here: if a country dominates in certain sectors with branch plants of multinationals, a cluster approach cannot work.I will leave it at that—I have spoken about the issues elsewhere. However, what comes through is that coherent nations or states within federal countries tend to perform better than parts of big nations. The UK has suffered from that for a long time.
Two of the countries that Christopher Harvie mentioned were Norway and Denmark, and I suspect that Finland and Sweden are not doing too badly either, in terms of GDP per capita. Those Scandinavian countries are obviously taking a more socialist approach. On the other side are Ireland, Luxembourg and Switzerland, which are small nations with low taxation. They are different types of economies, succeeding in their own different ways. It is important to understand the drivers. For example, if Nokia goes down, Finland is in big trouble, but who is to say that Nokia will go down? Switzerland has an extremely high standard of living and an extremely low growth rate. Is that good or bad? How long does it take to go from good to bad?
May I come back on one or two of those points? One thing that Switzerland has is a very strong transport sector, and it will become even stronger when it becomes Europe’s central railway hub, with the construction of the alpine tunnels. Our public transport in Scotland is lamentable. As an article in The Scotsman showed recently, public transport is essential to innovative company thinking because, with good public transport, people are not futilely driving around in their cars but working in high-speed trains. That aspect counts.Transportation preceded the industrial revolution in Japan: the Shinkansen lines started in 1961, before the Japanese economy really got into its commanding position. The system was based on up-to-date, modern public transport. Here, we have a railway line to Aberdeen that is still single track in places—and Aberdeen is the centre of our oil and offshore industry.12:00
A tourism-centred country is one in which you feel that you can come to a city and easily hop on and off public transport. I do not know why we consider transport such a bad investment, when many other countries consider it a good one. That even applies to roads. I do not know whether any of you live in Glasgow, but it is like navigating a rural Mexican town these days. You have to keep your eyes on the ground for the enormous potholes everywhere. It is not good.
That concludes the questions to John McLaren and Mike Danson. Thank you for coming along today—your input has been extremely interesting and will, I hope, add valuable data to our inquiry. On the data, it would be useful, if the committee agrees, for us to write to the Scottish Government to ask it for a briefing note on the changes that have been made to the GDP statistics. We can ask what the changes are and what the rationale behind the changes is so that we can at some future date consider whether we wish to do any further analysis.
I would like to pursue that, but I am happy to do so in private, if you want. The Government has chosen not to produce any evidence. We should undertake some research at our own hand, but I am happy to discuss that now or—
I suggest that we ask the Government for that information so that we can, as a committee, decide whether we wish to pursue the matter further.
The Government has published the revisions and has chosen not to give any explanation. That has been well documented in the media. The enterprise agencies will come before us in the next three weeks. The opportunity for analysis by a third party of what has happened in the past 10 years would be valuable, given the timetable that has been forced on us. It is a highly specialist area, which is why I suggest that we seek expert advice on it. I suggest that those who have raised the issues should be allowed to produce a briefing paper to allow us to judge the enterprise and tourism budgets, as they will be presented next Wednesday. Our commentary on those budgets will be informed by an understanding of the changes to the GDP statistics that were made public by the Government some three weeks ago.
I note your point but suggest that we ask the Government for a full briefing on the matter. Without that, we cannot do the analysis. If John McLaren is willing to provide us with his take on it, he is more than welcome to do so.
I have done some analysis. Tourism is an important and interesting area because there are such conflicting views on what it contributes—or does not contribute. We are not overly funded at the CPPR so it would take a bit of time to do any analysis.
I am conscious of the timescale.
There are two timescales—
I need to get the information from the Government about what it has done and why it has done it—
It is published. It is publicly available.
The explanation is not.
The explanation is not. That is the point. We do not know why it was done. The figures have been published but we do not know the rationale behind the changes. We need to get that from the Government in time to use it as part of our budget process. No further analysis would be possible, given the timescale for the budget, but it may be an issue that the committee would wish to address once we have the Government’s response. That is the programme that I suggest. It is the only logical way forward.
Is it possible perhaps to do a parallel process, in which we seek the Government’s explanation while at the same time considering whether we might ask the CPPR or another body to consider the matter? That would not happen in the two or three-week timescale that you have been describing for the budget process, but it would happen in advance of our return to the issues under investigation in this inquiry in the new year.
That is a possibility, but I would rather discuss it next week, once we have asked the Government for an explanation. We should ask for the explanation for next week, ahead of the publication of the budget.
I am happy with that. Perhaps the clerks could liaise with the Scottish Parliament information centre on what might be possible and what has been said. The Government has been repeatedly asked for an explanation and has gone on the record about what it is and is not prepared to say. A briefing paper from the clerks would be helpful for our budget discussion next week.
What the Government will be able to give the committee is a technical explanation of why it has changed the GDP statistics. It can tell you what has happened with its own statistical collection, but not the real economy.
That is why I want the Government to give us a rationale for what it has done, as well as a technical explanation. That brings us to the end of the public part of the meeting. I remind members that the business in the Parliament conference starts tomorrow evening and continues on Friday. It appears that there will be record attendance at the conference this year and that it will be an extremely successful event. Next week, we will consider the briefing from our budget adviser on our budget scrutiny report. I hope that we will also consider the draft stage 1 report on the Protection of Workers (Scotland) Bill and a draft submission to the independent commission on banking.12:05 Meeting continued in private until 12:50.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Nov 2010 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 09:30 Protection of Workers (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 70
- 09:30 Enterprise Network Inquiry Evidence session · 89
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.