Before we commence this part of our business, I remind members that the issues of sub judice still apply and the advice from the Presiding Officer is still relevant. Members need to exercise their own judgment to ensure that they do nothing that would prejudice any action that is still under way in the courts.Item 3 is the section 23 report “The Gathering 2009”. With us this morning are Councillor Dawe, who is leader of the City of Edinburgh Council; Councillor Steve Cardownie, who is the depute leader of the council; Mr Tom Aitchison, who is the chief executive of the council; and Mr Jim Inch, who is the director of corporate services of the council. I welcome them all to the committee.We want to explore a number of issues. I will explain how we are going to structure the session. Going back to front, we will come finally, at the end of our session, to the issue of the letter to Mr Springford of Destination Edinburgh Marketing Alliance that Councillor Buchanan drafted. Before that, we will look at the issue of the press release and the events that surrounded it. Prior to that, we will consider the attempts to save the company, but we will start with some discussion about the steering group. Before we do that, does any member of the panel wish to make an opening statement? If not, I will ask the first question. I do not know whether it is for Councillor Dawe or for one of the officers. How did the City of Edinburgh Council see the role of the steering group? Was it an advisory steering group? Did it have specific functions and responsibilities?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“The Gathering 2009”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Inch City of Edinburgh Council 141
- The Convener 127
- Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD 61
- Councillor Cardownie 52
- Tom Aitchison City of Edinburgh Council 52
- George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab 43
- Murdo Fraser Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con 34
- Councillor Dawe 25
- Mr McAveety 7
- Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP 4
- Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP 3
- Bill Kidd Glasgow) (SNP 2
- Councillor Jenny Dawe City of Edinburgh Council 1
- Councillor Steve Cardownie City of Edinburgh Council 1
- Mr Frank McAveety Glasgow Shettleston) (Lab 1
The record
554 contributions · showing 1–200Personally, I did not know anything about the steering group. I learned of it through the evidence that has been given to the committee as much as anything else. It was not a group on which councillors were represented. As far as I am aware, it was an officer group, so it would probably be better for either Jim Inch or Tom Aitchison to answer the question. As councillors, we tend not to get involved in the operational delivery of matters, for obvious reasons.As I understand it, the steering group was not something that I would have expected anybody other than officers to be involved in. I cannot really help you on what I thought its role was, because I have learned what I know about it since then. I think it was mentioned in the Audit Scotland report, and it has certainly been mentioned in evidence to your committee over the last while.
Just before the officers come in, can I pick up on that? It is astonishing that the leader of one of the largest local authorities in Scotland, and certainly the one that attracts the most international interest in terms of tourism and related events, was not told by her officers about a significant initiative to promote tourism. Was that the only time that you were kept in the dark by your officers or is it custom and practice that your officers do not tell you and other councillors about what is going on in the council?
There are two issues there. One is about the specific steering group. I would not have expected to be made aware of it. The council’s involvement with The Gathering 2009 Ltd at the time was that we had taken a decision to give it a grant, as had other public bodies. In terms of the grants that the council gives, it was not a huge sum of money, and I would not expect to be personally involved in day-to-day operational matters such as that, so I am not surprised.As for whether I am kept in the dark, obviously, if I am kept in the dark, I do not know that I have been kept in the dark. You will be aware that, on some aspects of the matter, I certainly felt at times that I was not given due information. However, once I became aware of what was going on, I made absolutely sure that I was totally informed from then on as to discussions and so on.
I entirely accept what you say about not being involved in day-to-day operational matters. It is important that councillors and officials are clear about the proper lines of demarcation. It is sometimes too easy for councillors to interfere in proper management decisions; equally, officials should not engage in decisions that are properly within the remit of councillors. However, is there not an issue here? Although you are not involved in day-to-day issues, should not your chief officers make you aware of what they are doing in making decisions about things that could well have significant political implications? I find it astonishing, and indeed a bit disappointing, that your officials do not bother to tell you how they are handling such major events.
I become involved and am given information when the events planning operations group, which involves the police, the fire service, the national health service and a range of other people who deal with major events in the city, comes into being. I am made aware of the fact that the group has met and of its discussions. The most recent example of that concerned the papal visit, when I was aware of what was taking place. That is the level at which I am involved. When an event has the potential to have an adverse impact on the city or to bring in tourists, I am kept aware of what is happening.I would genuinely not expect to be made aware of all of the meetings that our officers attend. I am the leader of the council and, at the end of the day, the buck stops with me, but bear in mind that we also have a convener of culture and leisure and that Councillor Cardownie is responsible on the elected member side for events and festivals. There are occasions when it may be appropriate for them to be aware of what is happening. If there are issues of concern, I expect them to make me aware of them. I understand that, when the steering group met, there were not issues of concern that I would have expected to be brought to my attention.
Was Councillor Cardownie aware of the steering group’s existence?
I was not aware that it had called itself a steering group. I was aware that officials were meeting other officials, as I would expect and as Jenny Dawe has indicated, to get on with the day-to-day running of business and to look at issues relating to events.We work with a number of organisations, and our officials are well versed in dealing with such matters. We put on a huge number of events, including 12 major festivals, throughout the year. I assumed that the officials would organise themselves. We wanted to see what would come out of that organisation, to receive reports and to be asked to make political decisions about whether we should go ahead. I did not think that there was anything sinister or duplicitous about officers meeting in that fashion. They do so on a daily basis, come to us when they have reached conclusions and ask us for a political steer. If they wanted to set themselves up as a steering group, I was not going to lose any sleep over that.
No one is suggesting for a minute that there was anything sinister or duplicitous about it; we are merely trying to find out whether councillors had been informed of what was happening. You say that you were aware of the fact that meetings were taking place but not of the fact that those involved had called themselves a steering group. If you were aware of the fact that officials were meeting, did you think that the group of individuals involved was merely an advisory body, or did you think that it had a formal role in a decision-making process?
Such groups are prohibited from making decisions—matters must be referred to the leader and to councillors so that decisions can be made. Officials work up proposals, discuss the ramifications, consequences, funding and so on, and tell us what they have concluded and what they recommend. We then meet in our respective groups and as a coalition to reach a view on the officials’ recommendations. They are charged with the responsibility of working up recommendations; our responsibility starts when they need a political decision to be made. Officials are not empowered to make decisions on behalf of councillors; we make the final decision, and our officials know that. That is what happens—or should happen—in all 32 local authorities in Scotland.
I do not know whether Mr Aitchison or Mr Inch were involved in arranging the meetings to which Councillor Cardownie has referred.
I am probably best placed to address the issue. It is our common practice when staging events in the city to set up a group such as the one that participated in the gathering. There were differences in this instance, because the group was purely advisory. In normal circumstances, the groups that we set up are more steering groups than advisory groups, because most of our events are funded jointly with other public bodies, such as EventScotland, VisitScotland and Scottish Enterprise. Most of the big events in the city involve a collaboration of interests to deliver one event. In those circumstances, it is much more important that we operate in a directive fashion.10:15
The gathering was signed off way back in March 2007 by the then executive of the council, who gave support to homecoming Scotland and the gathering. The committee report gave the go-ahead for the work to proceed. I guess that that took its normal course.The advisory group, which some of my officers participated in, was influential at certain times, as problems were seen to be identified. In particular, the phasing of the release of the funds was changed in order to help with the cash flow problems that The Gathering 2009 was experiencing. That is not to say that people went beyond the bounds of the money that had been approved. Rather, the money was re-engineered to provide for better cash flow. While the group was advisory, it had an important role in trying to keep the show on the road as problems began to emerge.
You say that the group was advisory and influential and helped to keep the show on the road. Did you tell the councillors that there was an advisory group doing that work?
As Councillor Cardownie mentioned, it is custom and practice in the council to operate in that fashion. It would be wholly inappropriate for us to report back on every group that we set up. We were working within the boundaries that were set by the council in terms of delivering—or assisting to deliver—an event. In this instance, the event was very much run by the Scottish Government, and a private operator was involved. That was somewhat unusual in terms of the normal way of running events in the city.
We accept that it was somewhat unusual. You have indicated that there were issues about funds, that there was a need for your officials to try to influence matters to keep the show on the road and that you were aware of the significance of the event to the council and the Scottish Government, yet are you saying that you did not tell the councillors that there was an advisory group?
As Councillor Cardownie explained, he understood that such a group would be operating.
He might have understood that, but you did not tell him that an advisory group had been set up.
Had the advisory group come to a view that a particular event was becoming a major problem, that would of course have been reported back to elected members.
But you said that you were trying to keep the show on the road.
Yes, and that is normal practice when managing an event such as the gathering. However, the advisory group was not aware that the Scottish Government had put in an additional £180,000, so when the group was considering the actions that needed to be taken, along with the directors of the company, it did not take that into account.
Was it not disrespectful, and perhaps a bit dangerous, that key members of the advisory group, who were the ones who advised councillors who made the decisions, were not aware of a significant loan that had been made by the Scottish Government?
It was very disappointing.
And did you articulate that disappointment?
It was articulated as the problems of The Gathering 2009 Ltd emerged.
It was articulated to the Scottish Government by you.
It was reported to the council as part of the wash-up following the gathering event.
When did you become aware that the loan had been made?
I have never formally been advised that the loan was made. My awareness of it came probably after the rescue package—if we may call it that—had been put in place.
Right. Let us leave aside the loan issue for a moment. Did you ever tell Councillor Dawe about the discussions that took place? Did you ever advise or brief her on any matters relating to the gathering? Did you tell her about the meetings that your officials were having?
No, I certainly did not, and it was not reported to me that a problem was emerging of a nature and scale that would require me to report back to the leader or deputy leader of the council.
The event ran into difficulties, but it was seen as a major event for the city of Edinburgh. Councillor Dawe said that she was informed of the discussions about the papal visit. The First Minister certainly saw the gathering as a significant event, but you did not tell the leader of the council that your officials were meeting in a group that had an advisory function, and you did not give her any briefings about developments. The leader of the council found out about some things only through newspapers and post events. Is that not astonishing? Does it not pose fundamental questions about councillors’ relationships with officials and others?
No. I simply do not accept that that is astonishing. What happened was quite normal in how the council operates. In recommendations in our wash-up report in the name of the chief executive, we referred to the need to tighten up on some aspects. However, in terms of how we have conducted the very successful events programme in the city, that has not been a necessity.
So it is quite normal for the City of Edinburgh Council to keep its leader in the dark about major events, progress on them and officials meeting other agencies. In effect, councillors are treated like mushrooms—they are best kept in the dark.
I totally refute that. That is simply not how things happen. The City of Edinburgh Council did not run the event; it was run by the Scottish Government. It was distinctly different from the events that the council operates. We did not have an EPOG. Councillor Dawe mentioned that she gets reports on EPOG-type activities. The papal visit is a good example of an event in which we had a real grip on what was happening. The gathering was promoted by the Scottish Government and operated by an independent company with two directors. We simply had an advisory role at the back of that.
The Scottish Government kept officers of the City of Edinburgh Council in the dark, and they clearly kept the leader of the council, Councillor Dawe, in the dark.
The only thing that I would have to accept that we were kept in the dark about was the £180,000 loan.
That was the only thing. So you were fully aware of the attempts that were made to sell the company.
The attempts to sell the company were made at a later date. We are getting the chronology out of sync.
I accept that, but you said that the loan was the only thing that you were not aware of. You were aware of the later attempts to sell the company.
Absolutely.
Okay. We will come back to that. That is helpful.Do members want to ask any other questions about the steering group?
You have said that the steering group acted in a purely advisory capacity, but we have been told that it received financial reports from the company’s directors. What was the nature of that financial reporting? Were you satisfied with the reports that were given to you at the crucial time in the run-up to the event?
I was not personally part of that advisory group, but my feedback was that the information that was coming back from the directors was good-quality information. When further information was requested—when the advisory group was not wholly satisfied that it was getting all the information—the directors returned with the necessary information to satisfy the group. Only in that way was the advisory group able to participate in sorting out some of the cash flow problems that were clearly materialising. There was very close monitoring of ticket sales and of the fact that income was not coming forward at the anticipated pace.On reflection, and as the advisory group concluded, some of the company’s projections were more than optimistic, even in the later stages, when it was apparent that the recession had kicked in, that ticket sales were not materialising and that sponsorship was not coming forward as had been anticipated. Some of the later projections were still optimistic.
We have been told that the biggest gap was in sponsorship, which is normally put in place quite early in the process of a major event. It has become clear to us that, without the £180,000 loan from the Scottish Government, the event could have been jeopardised. Were you, as someone in the council and a member of the steering group, aware of that?
The short answer is no, we were not aware of the £180,000.
Indeed. That is why I am pressing you on the matter of the quality of the financial information. If you were not told about a £180,000 loan, which was crucial for the event, it seems that you in the steering group were not being given adequate financial information. Does one not follow from the other?
I take your point. There is no doubt that there is a connection between the two. The advisory group, and indeed the directors, had always anticipated that it was unlikely that the event would wash its face in any case. It was a first stab at putting on a very ambitious event. According to the norms for event planning and event development, in the first year of such an activity it is quite common to take a loss. I guess that the advisory group understood that there was likely to be a loss with the first iteration of the gathering event. The intention had always been to hold subsequent events.I cannot remember from having gone through the Official Report whether or not Lord Sempill said this, but in conversations with me he advised me that if he did the event again he would do it somewhat differently, and that he would change a number of things about the way in which the exercise was undertaken. That learning—that intellectual property—is just something that we have to accept in the first instance.
Was the City of Edinburgh Council ever asked for a loan or for additional grant to help to resolve the financial difficulties that the company was facing?
The council was not asked, but EventScotland put an extra £80,000 on the table to assist with the marketing of the event at a later stage, as it became apparent that ticket sales were not going as anticipated. EventScotland came to the table with those additional funds; the council did not. We made it very plain that we were working within fixed boundaries.
Did you have one official who attended all the steering group meetings? How were you represented on the steering group?
I would have to check whether it was just one official, but it was mainly one official, although there might have been occasions when that official was not able to attend a meeting. The advisory group had been set up jointly, although it was EventScotland that took the lead role on the group.
Who was the official?
It was a member of my events team.
Can we have the name of that person?
Her name is Jane Bremner.
I wish to clarify a point that you made earlier. In response to questions from the convener, I think you said a couple of times that the event was run not by the City of Edinburgh Council but by the Scottish Government. That was not the case, though, was it? The event was actually run by a private company called The Gathering 2009 Ltd. The Scottish Government might have been a funder, to an extent, but it did not run the event. Can you confirm your understanding of who was in charge?
The Gathering 2009 Ltd ran the event. The fact is that the company saw itself as reporting to the Scottish Government and not to the City of Edinburgh Council.
So your perception, as it was represented on the steering group, was that the Scottish Government was in the driving seat.10:30
The Scottish Government set up The Gathering 2009 Ltd. It was the Government that appointed the company in the shape of Lord Sempill and Jenny Gilmour. The City of Edinburgh Council had nothing to do with that.
My question follows on from that. The steering group was formed from three public sector bodies—EventScotland, the council, and Scottish Enterprise Edinburgh and Lothians. Is that right?
Correct.
You are involved with SEEL as well, are you not?
SEEL is a separate entity.
The steering group was formed with company directors. The Scottish Government was not represented on it at all.
That is correct.
Even when the Government put a £100,000 grant into the project, it did not seek to have a representative on the steering group.
That is my understanding.
How can you therefore say quite unequivocally that the event was run by the Scottish Government, which is quite unusual for an event in Edinburgh?
I have corrected that somewhat, on the back of Mr Fraser’s question. The event was run by The Gathering 2009 Ltd. There can be no doubt about that. However, The Gathering 2009 Ltd was promoted by the Scottish Government. The Gathering 2009 Ltd saw itself as answerable to the Scottish Government because the gathering was part of homecoming Scotland’s overarching programme of events. The Scottish Government, I think, accepted that it would have overarching ownership of The Gathering 2009 Ltd.
So the steering group was just your way of keeping in touch with what was happening, but Jamie Sempill and Jenny Gilmour were directly responsible to the Scottish Government for what they were doing.
They were primarily operating on a budget that was set by the Scottish Government.
Did they feel that they had any responsibility or did they, because it was a private company, feel that they were not responsible to the Scottish Government?
You would have to ask them that. My perception is that they would have seen themselves as answerable to the Scottish Government in the first instance, primarily because the gathering was a major element of the homecoming Scotland programme.
Jane Bremner was on the steering group, and she kept you in touch with what was happening and the problems that were coming up in relation to the gathering.
Jane Bremner is a senior events officer. She reported to a more senior officer and, on occasion, he came to tell me what was happening with the advisory group. There were probably only two occasions when it was clear that the release of money needed to be changed—he wanted my approval for that—and we had to change the dates. We set up a programme of dates for the release of money, which we had to change in order to deal with the emerging cash flow problem.
In April 2009, the then Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution was involved in a meeting. In May 2009, people were so worried about the situation that the steering group started to meet every week instead of every month. Did you know that?
I knew that it had quickened the frequency of the meetings to try to get a better grip on what was happening.
Did you not think it necessary to inform Councillor Cardownie or Councillor Dawe that there was a looming problem?
There was a possibility of a looming problem—only a possibility. At no time was I going to go back to Councillor Dawe or Councillor Cardownie seeking additional moneys. We were working within the parameters of the budget.
No—I was talking about alerting them to the problem. When I was the chairman of an Edinburgh council committee many years ago, I expected the officers to tell me what was coming up and whether there was a problem looming, but you did not see fit to do that. Did you tell Tom Buchanan or any other councillor?
It did not go to elected members because, although what you point out was certainly a change in direction in terms of the advisory group, that sort of adjustment is not unusual through the course of an event of the gathering’s nature.
In July, The Gathering 2009 Ltd had to get an overdraft facility and the WorldPay money was not being released. The situation was getting critical, but you still kept Jenny Dawe and Steve Cardownie in the dark on all those events.
None of those events was triggering sufficient concern for us to request a review of our position with regard to the gathering. The council was committed to the gathering within the parameters that it had set. The problem that we had with the event was that delivery was through a private sector organisation. The advisory group existed to advise and seek information to satisfy itself that things could still be delivered. Indeed, they were delivered. The proof of the pudding is that The Gathering 2009 Ltd delivered the gathering event. It did so with serious financial consequences, of course.
Ministers in the Scottish Government were informed. They knew what was happening. They knew the problems, that the steering committee was meeting more frequently, that the overdraft had to be found and that they had to put in £180,000. They were kept informed, but you did not see fit to inform the council leader or deputy leader.
No—I have to go back to the fact that the Scottish Government was not represented on the advisory group. Therefore, some of the information that you suggest that the Scottish Government knew was not known to the advisory group.
Councillor Cardownie, did you know through other channels about the financial problems that were looming with The Gathering 2009 Ltd?
No.
You were not aware of them in any way.
No.
Mr Inch, you said that the Scottish Government was not involved in the steering group so you would have no way of knowing about the looming problems. Scottish Enterprise Edinburgh and Lothian was represented on the group and it is a moot point whether it was aware of any problems. EventScotland was on the group and it is a moot point whether it knew. Are you saying that neither EventScotland nor Scottish Enterprise Edinburgh and Lothian reported to the steering group the fact that there were developing financial problems?
We had an open discussion with the steering group. EventScotland eventually put £80,000 of additional money into the event to assist with the marketing. At a certain level, there was an understanding that problems were emerging. My point—
I am not asking that. I am asking whether those organisations reported to the steering group about developing financial problems.
It is self-evident that that was discussed in the advisory group.
How is it self-evident?
The advisory group changed the payment profile. Therefore, it is clear that the group discussed difficulties.
So the advisory group was aware of developing problems and you were aware that the issue was discussed at the advisory group.
That is correct.
So you were aware of developing financial problems. At this stage, though, you were not discussing whether to pull the rug from under the event; as you said, you were not going to advise councillors to withdraw from it. However, even though you knew about the developing problems, you did not think to tell the councillors about them. Is that correct?
That is not correct.
So you told the councillors.
What I meant is that your suggestion that I did not tell councillors—
I am sorry, but let us be quite clear. You told us that you were aware of developing financial problems through what was said at the steering group. My question is whether you told councillors that there were developing financial problems.
No.
Why not?
Because I did not think that the developing financial problems were of a scale that necessitated such a move, although of course that is not what came out at the end of the day. As I said earlier, it is not uncommon in the development of a complex programme of events such as the gathering for financial difficulties to emerge and for people to change tack and alter and adjust the original planned approach. In fact, it is probably very common in events programming and planning and does not necessitate going back to elected members. Given that I was not going outwith the council’s financial commitment to the gathering, I did not feel it necessary to report the matter back. Of course, we did not have certain information—about the £180,000, for example—that might have caused more alarm and would inevitably have caused more alarm bells to ring in the advisory group.
The question we are trying to pursue is not whether you thought it proper to go back to the councillors to ask for more money. Like George Foulkes, I have been a councillor; indeed, I have been a council leader. There were times when the chief executive would say to me, “Look, there’s a problem developing. We’re not going to bring it to committee just yet, but you need to be aware that this is happening”. Likewise, each of my conveners on the council would often be told by their director, “We’re not ready to bring this to you formally, but you need to be aware that a problem is developing.” However, you, as the key official, knew that a financial problem was developing but did not think to say to Councillor Cardownie or Councillor Dawe, “Watch out—a problem’s developing. We’ll tell you if it becomes critical.” You just did not bother telling them at all.
It is true that I did not tell either Councillor Cardownie or Councillor Dawe of my belief that a problem was emerging with the gathering. Day and daily, I advise members of difficulties and issues that are arising. I do so on a proportionate basis, by which I mean that I raise not every issue that is going around but issues that are, in my view, material. As a local government officer of 37 years’ service, I think that I know my way round the local government scene and have managed things pretty well. In this particular instance, I did not think that the issues arising with the gathering, as we in the advisory group understood them, were material.
Did you tell Mr Aitchison that a problem was developing?
No.
So he did not know either.
No.
Apart from your official, you were the only one on the council who was aware of the developing problem.
That is correct.
Okay.
On that point, do you believe that you and other members of the advisory group were misled about the company’s financial position at that time?
I believe that we were not aware of loans being made to the company, The Gathering 2009 Ltd, which meant that our position and our advisory group were compromised.10:45
You are very careful in the wording that you have used, but you have not answered my question. Do you believe that you were misled at that time in relation to the financial position of the company?
I would have to continue to say that I think that our position was compromised. I am not sure whether we were misled. I believe that we were let down by not having all the information to hand. However, I am not sure that having all the information to hand would have made a lot of difference, because the advisory group’s role did not enable it to take any more radical action.
Would you have told the councillors and your chief executive if you had known the full extent of the position?
Yes.
Thank you.
You said that you were let down. By whom were you let down?
In most other instances in all my dealings with them, the directors of the company were very open, straightforward and helpful, but they did not convey to me or the advisory group that little gem of information about the loan.
There were a number of things of which the directors were not aware either. For example, they did not know that the First Minister was trying to sell the company.
I cannot comment on that.
On the advice that the advisory group was giving you—given its place in the steering of the gathering—were you being told about the achievements that The Gathering 2009 Ltd was delivering on the ground and how it was keeping up with the plan that had been laid before EventScotland and the City of Edinburgh Council at the beginning?
I am sure that that would have been part of the discussions in the advisory group, because I think that the pattern was that Jamie Sempill or Jenny Gilmour reported to the advisory group in the first instance on progress being made and issues arising. As I said, I did not participate directly in any of those group meetings, but I know that that was the pattern and the process that was adopted.
Thank you.
You said that an issue would have to be of material interest before you would determine that other people would have to be kept informed, whether that was your chief executive or senior members of the council. It strikes me that a £180,000 loan would be of significant material interest. You have affirmed that if you had known about it, you would have had to address a number of issues with your chief executive and elected members. Given the good relationship that you understood you had with The Gathering 2009 Ltd, why do you think that it did not tell you about it?
I cannot answer that. I simply do not know.
Have you asked?
No, because the latter discussions with the directors of the company were very much to do with trying to find a way forward—a rescue package. We did not look backward; we tended to look forward.
Did you get the impression that the directors of the company were not willing to tell you because perhaps they were told not to tell you?
I have no knowledge whatever of where the two directors were coming from in not conveying that information. A simplistic view would be that, at that time, they did not see the materiality of the information. That might sound odd, but I think that the directors had some odd financial management ideas.
In your years of experience in local government and running events—I have been involved in a number of these things over the years in different capacities and I know that they are fraught with potential difficulties—have you ever experienced anything similar?
No. I have had a lot of exposure to events over the years, but this was the first time that I had been involved in an event that was being run by a private company, that had significant Scottish Government involvement and in which we were being asked to participate in a rather unusual way—we were asked to perform an advisory as opposed to a more hands-on role. That was a unique arrangement in my experience, and it is not something that I would suggest should be treated as a formula for the future.
So the lesson that you learned is not to put together an event in that fashion ever again—although you did not put it together; other people did.
I think I mentioned earlier that the council received a report from the chief executive that identified a number of actions with regard to lessons learned from our experience of involvement in the gathering. One or two of those referred to the need to be a little more careful about events that have private company involvement.
Has the council explored that model before? I concede that it was not your event, but you are one of the largest authorities in Scotland and you have significant experience of putting on highly innovative events. As I said at our previous meeting, as a Glaswegian it is hard for me to concede this, but the City of Edinburgh Council’s track record in putting on a range of events such as the hogmanay celebrations, and the MTV Europe awards—which were held when I was the minister with responsibility for culture, so I know what a critical partner the council was—is exemplary. I acknowledge the hard work that you do. You are saying that you would never consider using the structure that was used for the gathering as a model for putting together future events.
I do not think that I would never consider using it, but I would be extremely careful about how it would be taken forward and I would ensure that the governance arrangements were more robust than they were with the gathering.
Given your accountability to the elected members who are seated beside you, would it have been courteous and helpful to you if a Government minister had informed you about the Government’s loan to The Gathering 2009 Ltd?
I think that that responsibility lay with the directors of the company.
I invite the council’s chief executive, Mr Aitchison, to comment on the two issues that have arisen so far. The first is whether the existence of all sub-groups, advisory groups and steering groups is known to elected members of the City of Edinburgh Council or, indeed, of any local authority. The second is the issue of the shortfall in funding or the £180,000, and how significant that turned out to be for the council’s participation in the project. Can you give us an overview of those points?
I will do my best to help you.Your first question goes back to the convener’s question about officer-member relationships in the City of Edinburgh Council. I like to think that, as my colleague Jim Inch said, there is pretty much daily contact at senior level between members and council officers. This might not a be a good example to give, but members of the committee have probably read the article on the front page of today’s Scotsman about the Edinburgh tram project. I have been speaking to members of the council about it for the past week or so. Last night, I got hold of all the group leaders to brief them on the story before it hit the press. I would not want us to convey to you that there is not an intensive relationship between officers and members, both formally and informally.Mr Inch has tried to explain the unique nature of the event that we are talking about. When the council is in sole charge of an event, the position is quite clear cut. A report would go to a committee, a budget would be allocated and monitoring reports would be produced. If things were not going well, they would be reported to the council and corrective action of one sort or another would be taken. The situation surrounding the gathering was, as has been brought out in discussion over the past 10 or 15 minutes, very unusual all round.As council officers, we are trying to say to you that had we formed a judgment about the severity of the problem, that would have been conveyed informally to the leader and deputy leader of the council. That, in turn, begs the question what corrective action, if any, the council would have been asked to take. That is speculative, so there is no point in going into the mays and mights of that.In 2009, we were trying to control our budget tightly. To my knowledge, we received no further requests to put additional moneys into the project. It was clearly seen as an event within the 12-month event of the homecoming programme as a whole, which tracks back to the previous Government. There was a report to our council in March 2007 to articulate that and to explain that the gathering was one of the key cornerstones of that event. In terms of elected member reporting, we can point to some factual information on that. All I can do is to reinforce Mr Inch’s comments. We know more about it now than we did at the time, and I would not want to be in a situation in which a similar set of circumstances was coming together.As Mr McAveety said, we have a long, proud track record on events in Edinburgh. It probably sounds a bit vain to say it, but we are recognised throughout the country as one of the best events planning teams anywhere in the United Kingdom. The team is multi-agency—it works with the police. There is a clear distinction between what needs to be reported politically and the executive authority that is given to council officers. We all understand that. We are politically astute in the council—we have political nous. We know when things have to be reported to councillors. I have had a long career in local government and I find it quite extraordinary in its circumstances.Your second point was about the £180,000. Council colleagues and I probably did not know about that until it came out in the Audit Scotland report. It was completely new to all of us.
I am trying to get a handle on how significant the £180,000 was for the City of Edinburgh Council. As I understand it, the liability for that would not have fallen on the council. Is that a possible explanation for why that information was not circulated around the council to elected member or senior officer level?
Again, I cannot really speak for other people in that situation. If it had been known to us at the time, it would have been a fairly clear signal that something could be going badly wrong, which may or may not have triggered action on the council’s part. However, that revelation was made to us after the event rather than before it.
I was going to ask Jim Inch about that, although either he or Tom Aitchison could answer my question. What would you have done had you known that the Government had given a £180,000 loan? Why would you have wanted to know? I guess that the reason that you would have wanted to know is that, as you have just said, it would have been a clear signal that the event was in more trouble than you had realised.Mr Inch said that it might have caused alarm. Is that perhaps why the directors did not tell the steering group? The event was so close that, had word got out that it had required a loan of £180,000, companies that were crucial to the running of the event, and participants, might have been put off attending. Companies might have been less likely to become involved for fear that the event would not go ahead. Is that a possible reason why the directors did not let the steering group know?
That is a kind of double-edged sword. You could argue it the other way and say that the Government coming in with £180,000 would have given confidence to promoters and others who were participating in the event. It would have signalled to the advisory group that what we believed to be a financially awkward and difficult project was more difficult than we had anticipated.I do not know what we would have done about that. It was probably too late in the day to do very much. I cannot imagine that it would have changed the direction of travel. In such situations, information is all. The more information that we had had, and the more that people had been involved in finding solutions, the better. There were elements of the gathering programme that could have been reviewed if that information had come on stream earlier. It might have enabled us to be a bit more efficient.
I take your point about the double-edged sword. It could have given comfort; it could have caused alarm. I suppose that there was a judgment to be made.We more or less accept that, had the loan that was given not been forthcoming, there would have been a danger that the gathering would not go ahead. What would have been the implications for the city of Edinburgh of the gathering not going ahead?11:00
There was probably a combination of factors. First, the reputation of the city would have been damaged, not the reputation of the City of Edinburgh Council. That relates to the point that I made earlier about Edinburgh’s national and international reputation as a venue for events.Secondly, there would have been an effect on small businesses in the city of Edinburgh and the surrounding area, which we may discuss later. Post the event, rather than before the event, that became a prime consideration for us. Many—perhaps most—of the companies that were involved were local companies, and they were the ones that would have suffered financially from that. That would have been a direct concern of the City of Edinburgh Council.So, there would have been a financial impact on our community and a wider strategic impact on the city’s reputation in the events field. That is where some frustration comes in that the gathering was not a City of Edinburgh Council event. It was an event that was organised by others—by an advisory group, not a group over which we had executive authority. You probably understand our point from the various comments that I and my colleagues have made. That is where a degree of frustration comes into our dealings with the gathering.
I would like clarification. Tom—you had regular meetings and regular contact with Sir John Elvidge: you now have such contact with his successor. I presume that Jim Inch has regular contact with his counterpart in the Scottish Government. Was neither of you informed by Sir John Elvidge or any officials about the £180,000 loan?
No. My contact with Sir John Elvidge emerged after the event—not before it—in October last year.
Likewise.
Are you disappointed that they did not tell you about the Government’s £180,000 loan and the circumstances?
The answer must be yes. There was meant to be a spirit of partnership and joint working. In my experience, that works best when it is based on trust, and that trust must sometimes be exercised confidentially, in a restricted way. We have said it two or three times now, but it was a bit of a revelation to find out after the event that the £180,000 loan had been granted. It would have been nice to know that in advance—if nothing else, just as a courtesy between two major public sector partners.
You would have kept the information confidential, as you keep confidential many other things that you are told.
I would have told the council leader.
Would she have kept it confidential?
Absolutely.
Let us move on to the next section, which deals with attempts to save the company. When did the council first become involved in discussions about the future of The Gathering 2009 Ltd and who exactly was involved in those?
I can help with that initially, convener. I received a phone call from Councillor Cardownie on—I hope that I get the date right—the afternoon of Friday 9 October. I was not in the office when I took that phone call. Councillor Cardownie explained that there was a real risk of the company going into administration and a risk, therefore, to small businesses in Edinburgh. I phoned my colleague, Jim Inch, from outwith the office to get him thinking about it on that Friday afternoon, so that he could perhaps try to gather some information over the subsequent weekend. I got the chance to see Councillor Dawe at about 8.30—first thing—on the Monday morning and began to brief her on what had happened over the weekend. That is the chronology—for me, personally, and, I think, for the City of Edinburgh Council—according to which the events started to unfold in October last year.
So, the Scottish Government officials did not contact you to tell you that there had been discussions about the future of The Gathering 2009 Ltd.
It did not contact me on that particular Friday.
Councillor Cardownie, who told you about it?
I got a phone call from the First Minister on the Friday afternoon. I remember it well because I was in the Cask and Barrel in Broughton Street at the time and was surprised to be taking a call from the First Minister. He told me that there was an issue surrounding the gathering. As I was the festivals and events champion for the city, he wanted to alert me to that and asked whether I would be able to come along to a meeting that was due to be convened, I think, the following Tuesday afternoon, bringing the appropriate official with me. I then passed on the content of that telephone call to Tom Aitchison, the chief executive.
Is not that highly unusual? The First Minister has this army of highly paid expert officials. Something is going wrong. He knows that a steering group has been set up, in which EventScotland and Scottish Enterprise are involved along with the council, but he does not ask Scottish Government officials to contact City of Edinburgh Council officials. We know that, because you told us that you knew nothing about what was going on. The First Minister of Scotland picks up the phone to a councillor who is having a pint to ask, “Can you fix this, or can you help us to fix it?” You then have to quickly finish your pint and contact the chief executive, and then the chief executive has to get his officials involved, although poor old Councillor Dawe does not find out until a few days later. What kind of country are we running?
I have several points on that. First, I did not finish my pint—
It was so urgent that you left it.
I went back in and finished it. I immediately went outside and phoned the chief executive. In a previous life, when I was a member of the Labour Party, I used to get calls from ministers such as Frank McAveety and others on my mobile phone asking me for my view on certain matters, so I did not regard that as unusual. I have known Alex Salmond since I became a member of the SNP.
Hold on, Councillor Cardownie. The phone call was not asking you about your views. The First Minister was asking you to fix something and to get the chief executive to line up a series of players for a meeting on the Monday.
It was the Tuesday.
Sorry, the Tuesday.
He did not ask me to fix anything. He said that there were issues surrounding The Gathering 2009 Ltd and he wanted to discuss them. He asked whether I, or whoever, would be able to come along to represent the City of Edinburgh Council on the following Tuesday.
So—he did not want the chief executive; he wanted you.
I beg your pardon. I have been corrected—the meeting was on the Monday.
I thought so.
I am sorry. That was my fault.The First Minister contacted me, as festivals and events champion who had overall responsibility for festivals and events in the city. I presume that the First Minister would not know who the most appropriate official was in that regard.
The permanent secretary and his officials would have known that, would they not?
I would have hoped that they would, but I do not know whether they did.The First Minister contacted me and I immediately contacted the chief executive and left the matter in his hands. As you know, a meeting was convened on the Monday afternoon, which Jim Inch and I attended.
So the first inkling that you had that the company was about to go belly up was the phone call from the First Minister.
I had no idea that the company was going to go belly up, because I had no idea what the First Minister wanted to discuss. He said that there was a meeting to discuss The Gathering 2009 Ltd and asked us to come along on that Monday afternoon. The First Minister did not apprise me over the telephone as to what the issue was.
So it could have been that the First Minister was bringing you in to say, “This is one of the biggest success stories we’ve ever handled, and it’s so good that we want you to be part of selling the success story.” That was one option. The other option is that he thought, “We’ve got problems—we’d better phone Steve Cardownie and see if he can sort it out.” He told Sir John Elvidge, “Don’t you bother your backside, because you’ve got more important things to do. Don’t get your officials involved because, all the way along the line, they haven’t been telling the council what is going on. I’ll sort it out with Steve, and then Steve can get the chief exec to sort out the mess.”
That is not true. The First Minister called me and told me that there were issues surrounding The Gathering 2009 Ltd. Obviously, I had been involved for a long time, so I knew that the meeting was not going to involve passing round ice cream and celebratory slaps on the back. I knew that something must be amiss. He asked me whether I was free on the Monday afternoon to come to a meeting that would be convened in St Andrew’s house. I immediately contacted the chief executive to let him know, and he then contacted Jim Inch. I would have contacted Jim Inch, but I went through the proper chain—I went through the chief executive first. The chief executive also alerted Jenny Dawe, as the council leader, to the fact that the meeting was taking place. I knew that Jim Inch was the one who would perhaps have the information that would be required at that meeting on the Monday afternoon. Because the chief executive is not involved directly in events and festivals but Jim Inch is, Jim was the most appropriate senior official to take with me.
Mr Aitchison, did you or Mr Inch prepare a briefing for the councillors ahead of the meeting?
No. As I said, the sequence of events was that I spoke to Councillor Dawe first thing on the Monday morning. The meeting took place, I think, early in the afternoon that same day. Over the weekend, my colleague Jim Inch went through the files to gather background information where appropriate. I guess that, until my colleagues got to the meeting on the Monday afternoon, the exact scale of the problem was not defined.
Which officers attended that meeting?
Councillor Cardownie and Mr Inch attended that meeting on behalf of the council.
Was the suggestion made at that meeting that DEMA might be a potential purchaser of the company?
No.
What was said at that meeting?
There was a variety of representatives at that meeting, including a large number of civil servants, the First Minister and the permanent secretary. A number of representatives from Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo Ltd were there, together with the council’s director of finance, Donald McGougan, who is also involved with the tattoo and was there in that capacity. I think that the purpose of the meeting was to tell the assembled group about the scale of the problem that was emerging in relation to The Gathering 2009 Ltd. None of us was aware of it until that point. It was also to suggest that the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo might like to consider whether it would be the proper vehicle for carrying on with the gathering.
Was that asked at that meeting?
Yes.
The First Minister had made a phone call to the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo about that.
I do not know that.
It is mentioned in the Audit Scotland report.At that meeting, the First Minister suggested that the tattoo organisation might be interested. What did its people say?
There was a discussion about the pros and cons of the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo taking over the gathering, but it is fair to say that the tattoo was not overwhelmed by the prospect. That is probably the way things were left.
At what point did it emerge that DEMA might be a suitable vehicle?
That emerged on the day after the meeting on 12 October, which we have just been talking about. I attended a meeting with the permanent secretary to discuss the available options. The permanent secretary had concluded from the earlier meeting on the Monday that the tattoo option was not going to fly. The suggestion had not been dismissed completely, because the tattoo board had to consider it, and I recollect that it still had to meet that week.The meeting that I had with Sir John Elvidge was to explore whether there were options other than the tattoo. The conversation was in two parts. Sir John Elvidge explained to me why the Scottish Government could not just deal with the matter directly. He told me that there were issues around state aid and other difficulties with the Scottish Government dealing with the problem, so it was important to find some other way forward.It was also accepted that there was common cause between us. The City of Edinburgh Council would like to see the gathering repeated at some future date, and we were obviously keen to find a way of protecting the large number of creditors, many of whom were based in the city of Edinburgh. So there was a mutuality around our discussion.The permanent secretary had a notion that the council had delegated authorities to deal with matters of this type, but I had to advise him that that was not the case, that the council would have to approve an investment of that sort, and that there was a process that had to be followed. The council was meeting on Thursday 15 October, so it was far too late for anyone to make a report to the council with any such suggestion. Also, given that the council was dealing with difficult financial issues at the time, it would have been difficult for it to endorse expenditure of that nature out of the blue, so the idea that the council could have dealt with the situation was highly unlikely.11:15
As far as the sequence of events is concerned, the meeting took place on 12 October, which was a Monday. There was a discussion about the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo taking over the gathering but, by Wednesday 14 October, someone from the council contacted DEMA to find out whether it would be interested in taking the event on.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Nov 2010 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 554
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.