I reconvene the meeting. The second item on the agenda is consideration of further subordinate legislation on the protection of vulnerable groups. The committee will take evidence from the Minister for Children and Early Years on the draft Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 (Miscellaneous Provisions) Order 2010 and the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 (Corresponding Disqualifications) Order 2010.I am pleased to welcome Mr Ingram to the meeting. He is at meetings of this committee nearly as regularly as committee members are, so he should probably have a permanent seat at the table. He is joined by Andrew Mott, whose face is not unknown to the committee, and Michael Proctor, both of whom are from the Scottish Government.I understand that the minister wants to make an opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 (Corresponding Disqualifications) Order 2010 (SSI 2010/346)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ken Macintosh 12
- Adam Ingram 11
- The Convener 8
- Michael Proctor Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate 5
- Andrew Mott Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Directorate 4
- Elizabeth Smith 2
- The Minister for Children and Early Years Adam Ingram 1
- Kenneth Gibson Cunninghame North) (SNP 1
The record
44 contributionsYes. Hello again, and thank you very much for giving me the opportunity to make an opening statement about the orders, which form part of the implementation programme for the protecting vulnerable groups scheme. With the convener’s permission, I would also like to update members on progress on implementing the PVG scheme more generally.Members will recall that the PVG scheme was established by the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007. In essence, its aim is to ensure that people who have a past history of inappropriate behaviour are unable to work on a paid or voluntary basis with children or protected adults. I will give a brief recap of the scheme.The scheme will bring about a streamlined disclosure process for individuals who work with vulnerable groups by replacing static enhanced disclosures with a dynamic membership scheme. For the first time, a Scottish adults barred list will be established, which will make it much harder for people who are unsuitable to work with so-called protected adults to harm them through their work. Finally, the scheme will integrate the disclosure and listing processes for the first time, so that disclosure information will be assessed and may lead to the individual being considered for listing.Before I give a general update on progress and speak to the two orders, I inform the committee that the Scottish Government has decided to delay the PVG scheme’s going live to February 2011. I have written to the convener and committee members to inform them of that decision. We will notify stakeholders and the media today.As I explained in my letter, the delay results from some challenges in the delivery of the information technology system. Those challenges have now largely been resolved, but the additional effort to complete that work has left insufficient time in the programme to complete the final elements of the system. We have a very good disclosure system in Scotland, and I was not prepared to switch to the new system, which will bring about additional benefits and protection, until I was absolutely sure that it was fully ready. That is an unfortunate position to be in so late in the implementation process, but we simply have to get things right. It is apparent to all of us who saw what happened when the disclosure service was introduced in 2002 that the decision that was taken then was made on the basis of timing rather than quality. The result of that decision was long delays in processing applications after the system was introduced. I do not think that that decision was right. We need to get the quality right. If that means a short delay, it is right to have it. We have learned lessons from the past.11:15
Many members will recall that the implementation of the Protection of Children (Scotland) Act 2003 was also problematic. In particular, voluntary organisations were not supported in preparing for implementation. We have learned the lessons from that experience and provided a wide range of materials to help individuals and organisations to become familiar with the PVG scheme, including: comprehensive guidance on all aspects of the scheme; training materials, including a presentation that anybody can deliver in their own organisation; e-learning packages, which include test questions to help users to ensure that they understand the material; a regulated work self-assessment tool to help determine whether or not an individual is doing regulated work; an information booklet about the PVG scheme that covers some of the most commonly asked questions and more and is available in different languages and formats; answers to frequently asked questions on Disclosure Scotland’s website; posters on the PVG scheme; and sample PVG application forms. We launched a new PVG scheme help service at Disclosure Scotland on 30 June 2010, and it has handled hundreds of queries from organisations. We also continue to communicate directly with stakeholders through regular progress updates. Finally, the central registered body in Scotland is running free PVG scheme training events, which to date have attracted more than 500 delegates from voluntary organisations.The two orders that are before the committee today deal with cross-border information provision and the full recognition of other United Kingdom barred lists in Scotland. The timing and need for the two orders is unaffected by the delay that I have announced.The miscellaneous provisions order makes the devolved provision that is required to ensure that there are no gaps in the provision of information to and from Scotland in support of the PVG scheme and the vetting and barring scheme for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. The UK Government is progressing the reserved provision that is required through Westminster in two section 104 orders, one of which is affirmative and the other is negative.The miscellaneous provisions order also amends the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 to ensure that Disclosure Scotland can operate the cross-border protocol that was agreed with the previous UK Government in all possible permutations. The cross-border protocol is designed to ensure that where there is any ambiguity, either Disclosure Scotland or the Independent Safeguarding Authority will deal with an individual’s case.Members will be aware that the Home Secretary announced in June that the implementation of the vetting and barring scheme would be halted pending the outcome of remodelling work“to bring the criminal records and vetting and barring regimes back to common sense levels.”Last month, the Home Secretary announced the terms of reference for that work. Although the UK Government is making the necessary legislative provision at Westminster for the PVG scheme to go live, the remodelling work has halted work to deliver the legislative and system support for the cross-border protocol in the rest of the UK. In the meantime, Disclosure Scotland is putting in place interim arrangements with the ISA to ensure that there are no gaps in protection in Scotland.I would like to take the opportunity to welcome the review of the vetting and barring scheme, because it provides an opportunity to bring it closer to the PVG scheme in scope and proportionality. We are not reviewing the PVG scheme, because it was the subject of extensive consultation and engagement with people who work with children and protected adults in Scotland throughout its development. I stress that the delay that I have announced today results from some challenges in the delivery of the IT system that are now largely resolved. There is no review in Scotland and we are not changing the shape of the PVG scheme in any way at all. Scottish stakeholders’ continued interest and views on the PVG scheme have helped us to shape a system that strikes the balance between robust regulation and proportionate protection, without compromising on the need to minimise bureaucracy.The PVG scheme applies only to people who work with vulnerable groups, not to personal arrangements that people make with friends or family, or to work positions in which there is no opportunity to cause harm to vulnerable groups.The corresponding disqualifications order provides for the PVG scheme to recognise all the other barred lists in the UK. It preserves current barring arrangements with regard to work with children and puts in place barring arrangements for work with protected adults.In conclusion, I commend the orders to the committee as an essential part of ensuring that the PVG scheme interacts smoothly and effectively with the Independent Safeguarding Authority and other UK bodies. That is important to prevent any loopholes that could be exploited by those who seek to harm children or protected adults. I am happy to answer any questions that the committee has.
Thank you, minister. Your decision to delay implementation seems sensible to ensure that the system is effective and successful, but are you confident that it will be able to go live by February?
Yes. I am acting on recommendations that the PVG programme board made in its readiness review of the scheme that it reported back to me on Monday. The board is confident that a launch in February is both achievable and realistic. We will now revisit the programme that we established for a launch at the end of November and reschedule elements of it. I will be able to announce a specific go live date before Christmas.
Okay. Does the short delay in introducing the new scheme have any implications for those organisations that were preparing for the changes?
As I said in my remarks, we are in close contact with all the relevant stakeholders. I will be sending out information to them on the back of today’s announcement to explain what we are doing. For example, the marketing programme that we set out will be rescheduled to take account of the different timetable. We will ensure that everyone is made fully aware of what we are doing.
Minister, thank you for your comments. As you know from my past record at committee, I am slightly reluctant about some aspects around the protection of vulnerable groups, but nonetheless I understand what you say about the need to ensure that all loopholes are closed and how the instruments that are before us will do that. I hear exactly what you say about how you are not revisiting the scheme, and I do not want to do that, but I put on record again that there are issues—voluntary groups and people such as the Scottish Parent Teacher Council have presented them to you—about the balance that you have just enunciated between legal protection and a commonsense approach. As you know, the coalition Government down south has been looking at the matter, because the last thing that we want is for the legislation to be overly bureaucratic and to stop that commonsense approach to many activities. There is still a need to allay the concerns of some groups about that. I ask you again to put on record that you will do everything possible to ensure that as much help as possible is given to those groups.
Absolutely. I endorse your comments. We have tried to create the robust protection regime that we need to protect our children and vulnerable adults in such a way that it does not constrain normal activities that parents and others would try to—
What I am asking, minister, is if we found that the new legislation constrained certain activities, would you reconsider it?
Obviously, we have taken a great deal of trouble to try to ensure that we do not end up with a system where that happens. We have consulted widely to try to make the scheme as proportionate as it possibly can be.You mentioned the SPTC’s criticisms, and I have responded to them. The examples that it put into the public domain were slightly misleading, in that none of the activities described would have required disclosure checks. As you might know, we are pretty rigorous in trying to ensure that inappropriate disclosures are not made.We have a compliance regime in Scotland that includes measures such as registration. Disclosure Scotland has refused registration to about 35 organisations in the past 18 months, because it did not believe that they were related to regulated work of the kind that we are concerned with. There is an audit of organisations, so if a flood of applications come in that are not particularly appropriate or about which we have concerns, they will be investigated. People can raise complaints against inappropriate requests for disclosures. We are trying to build into the system all the checks and balances that are needed.
Just as a matter of interest, I was approached by a teacher a week and a half ago who raised yet another example of the absence of disclosure checks proving to be an obstacle to a school trying to organise an activity that required parent volunteers. That was for a one-off activity for which any exercise of proper judgment, in my mind, would have shown that such checks were simply unnecessary. The local authority was protecting its own back rather than protecting the interests of children. I mention that just to make the minister aware that our battle—and it is our battle, communally—goes on.One big improvement in recent Scottish statutory instruments on the matter has been the introduction of disclosure portability. Does the delay mean that the portability part of the new system will also now be delayed until February?
The new scheme will be launched in its entirety in February, so the current service that is being provided will continue until that point. The portability kicks in along with the new scheme when it is launched.
I appreciate that the complexity of the two orders that are before us is mostly to do with the transitional arrangements and the different timings north and south of the border and in Wales and Northern Ireland. I want to return to the underlying principles, just to remind me and the committee of them. What is the relationship between a barred list in England and a list in Scotland? Does an individual who is barred in England automatically go on to our list in Scotland and vice versa, so that all names should be on both lists?
Andrew Mott wants to say something on that specific point.
Basically, when an individual is listed, they are listed in only one jurisdiction, but the other jurisdictions can choose to recognise that listing. For example, an individual might have been considered by the Independent Safeguarding Authority and included on the children’s barred list under the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006, which would prevent them from doing regulated activity in England and Wales. The corresponding disqualifications order ensures that, for all the different lists, that person is barred from doing regulated work in Scotland.Currently, under POCSA, all the other UK children’s barred lists are recognised so, in effect, the corresponding disqualifications order simply preserves the current arrangements. Obviously, we do not have an adults list at present in Scotland, so although all the barred lists from around the UK are disclosed on an enhanced disclosure for working with protected adults, there is obviously no bar. However, with the PVG scheme, we are implementing the recognition of all those lists so that an individual who is on the protection of vulnerable adults list or the SVG act adults barred list would be barred from doing regulated work with adults in Scotland. In short, an individual should be listed only once in one place, but they will be barred throughout the United Kingdom.11:30
That makes sense. I could not make sense of why the corresponding disqualifications order talks about which list somebody should be on. You are saying that, in practice, when an organisation or employer applies to Disclosure Scotland to find out whether an individual is listed as unsuitable to work with children, Disclosure Scotland will automatically check not just the Scottish list, but the English, Welsh and Northern Irish ones.
That is right. Under enhanced disclosure in the PVG scheme, an organisation that applies to Disclosure Scotland for the appropriate disclosure can be assured that all the relevant lists have been checked. So that connection is made.
That is fine.I turn to another element that I am not quite sure of. The explanatory note for the miscellaneous provisions order states that the order will“extend the provision that no proceedings are competent against Scottish Ministers to cover information provided to them in pursuance of any other power or duty”.I am not suggesting that Mr Ingram should appear in court to defend actions. I can understand the measure from one point of view, because we are dealing with information and I presume that the point is that ministers are not responsible for the accuracy of that information. However, how would an individual about whom information is incorrect challenge the authenticity of that information?
To take an example, if information was provided by an English employer or police force and on that basis we put an individual under consideration for listing, and it then turned out that that information was not right, the individual would make representation about the information as part of the consideration for listing process. It might be found that there was a problem with the information and that it was not accurate. The provision to which Mr Macintosh refers will mean that there cannot be any action for damages against the Scottish Government or Disclosure Scotland, which would have processed the information in good faith. There might be issues with the organisation from which the information originated, but that would be a matter for the individual to pursue. However, in relation to the Scottish Government’s responsibilities, Disclosure Scotland would have processed information that was received in good faith and handled it appropriately. The individual would have the chance to make representation, and when the problem came to light the consideration for listing would end. The legislation provides for us to do everything in our powers to ensure that such cases are handled fairly.
There was a high-profile case that made the newspapers recently involving a man in Edinburgh whom the local authority said was a murderer. He went to hospital and was applying for something, and the staff suddenly changed their attitude to him because the information had been circulated. Once the information was out, it was almost impossible for him to unpick it. The original source of the information was difficult to find out, and there was another issue about who was misusing the information. I appreciate that the minister cannot be held responsible for the authenticity of some information, but there clearly must be a duty on Government, local government, the employer or somebody to ensure that information is not misused. If people cannot sue ministers, whom can they sue? I am not saying that people should necessarily sue anybody, but how do people correct information if ministers have no obligation on that?
As you will appreciate, several cases have been sent to me by members and others involving people with concerns about the quality of information that appears on their disclosure certificate. Most of that information emanates from police computers. We usually direct people to the relevant police force and ask it to review the information that it holds. That is normally the first port of call.We have discussed in the committee how things move from there and the three different kinds of dispute through which the issues can be addressed. I am as concerned as anybody about individuals’ civil liberties and the potential for miscarriages of justice or the equivalent happening. We always need to be vigilant.On who can be pursued, can I—
Let us put things this way. Ministers cannot be pursued in the courts, which is fine, but do they have a duty to rectify or address such matters if they are brought to their attention?
It is important to be clear that, for the purposes of the PVG scheme, the answer to that is absolutely. If information comes to light on an individual’s disclosure certificate or leads to their being considered for listing, the individual can challenge it. The minister has just described how an individual can dispute what is on a certificate. Equally, if the individual is being considered for listing, they can make a representation on any information that is being considered. Therefore, by the end of those processes, the information in the PVG scheme or the information that leads to their being listed or not being listed will have been corrected for PVG scheme purposes.The residual issue for the individual is whether they need to take action about the source. If, for example, an individual believed that an organisation had malevolently or mischievously made a referral, they might want to take action against it because of the reputational damage that had occurred. Members can rest assured that what is in the PVG scheme and what leads to consideration for listing will be accurate, as the individual will have every opportunity to engage in the process. The individual may want to pursue in the courts or elsewhere issues relating to how other organisations have behaved, if they have residual problems with that.
I want to explore that. There is a balance to be struck. Much is being done in the minister’s name, and the power of Government is being used to introduce and enforce a law, so it is important that there is a way of holding the Government responsible for its role.Finally, I noticed that the miscellaneous provisions order allows for costs to be paid from Disclosure Scotland to the Scottish Police Services Authority. I did not realise that there was a transaction from one public body to another for the sharing of information. Are the costs significant? How much will be transferred? Is it a significant income for the Scottish Criminal Record Office?
The fee is charged by the Scottish Police Services Authority.
The SPSA provides the criminal history system. Currently, we do not pay any fees to it for the provision of information. The National Policing Improvement Agency in England provides the police national computer, and it charges Disclosure Scotland fees for the provision of access to that as part of its cost recovery model. It is the same fee that all the police forces are charged for their access to the police national computer. Arrangements that are in place mean that the Scottish Government pays the NPIA for Scottish police access to the PNC. Disclosure Scotland pays the NPIA for access to the PNC for disclosure purposes. Those costs are fully covered within the fees that are charged for Disclosure Scotland services.
I want to clarify matters. There would be no fee transactions or cost transfers for most cases in Scotland, but what if people were looking for information from England or Wales? If somebody was on the list in England, there would surely not be a cost for finding that out. Would there be a cost only if someone wanted to go to the Scottish Police Services Authority to find out more information?
The system works in two ways. The NPIA provides us with nominal information—that is, the names and dates of birth of everyone it has a record of. We pay an annual cost to access that information and receive daily updates on it. The provision of that information involves a significant transaction for the NPIA.
Does it pay a cost to the SPSA similarly?
No.
So it is only one way: we pay it, but it does not pay for our—
No. Sorry—I thought you were asking whether Disclosure Scotland pays.
Does it pay a similar cost to Disclosure Scotland?
I am not the world’s leading expert on this. Our colleagues in the justice department deal with all that, so perhaps the easiest way for me to be sure to give you the correct answer is to go away and confirm the position. My understanding is that English forces do not access the criminal history system at all. All the information that is on the CHS is updated on to the PNC, so there is not an equivalent transaction for us.
It would be good to get further clarification on cost.
We shall write to the committee about that.
Minister, this week I have had two constituents raise issues about disclosure and multiple applications. Ken Macintosh talked a wee bit about the commonsense approach. I have a constituent who got Disclosure Scotland approval in September from the General Teaching Council for Scotland, but the local authority to which they applied—East Renfrewshire Council—said that it wanted an additional disclosure check. There is an issue about portability and the unwieldy nature of the system. A lot of people are really quite concerned about the bureaucracy that they have to go through. Surely it is a nonsense when a local authority refuses to accept a disclosure check by the GTCS. Those issues have to be addressed.
Absolutely, and that is the purpose of the protecting vulnerable groups scheme. Obviously it is disappointing that we are not able to launch as we planned to do at the end of this month, but there is only a short delay. I hope that your constituents’ frustrations will be addressed very soon and we can do away with multiple applications. The problem is essentially that disclosure is only a snapshot in time, whereas with the membership scheme we will be able to update the information continuously. We will be able to flag up to employers if a person in their workforce has become unsuitable through getting a conviction or new information becoming available. It will be a considerable improvement and will address the issues that you have just described.
That concludes our questions to you and therefore our consideration of item 2. We will move straight to item 3, which is formally to consider the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 (Miscellaneous Provisions) Order 2010. I invite the minister to move motion S3M-7180.Motion moved,That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 (Miscellaneous Provisions) Order 2010 (SSI 2010/draft) be approved.—Adam Ingram.
We have up to 90 minutes to debate the motion, which I hope we will not take.No member wishes to speak and the minister has no closing remarks to make.Motion agreed to.
Agenda item 4 is formal consideration of the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 (Corresponding Disqualifications) Order 2010. No motion to annul has been lodged. No member wishes to comment on the order. Do members agree that we have no recommendation to make on the order?Members indicated agreement.
We will now suspend the meeting to allow the minister’s officials to leave, although I ask the minister to remain with us.
I will be here.
I hope that he will soon be joined by some officials from another section of the Scottish Government.11:45 Meeting suspended.
11:48 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Nov 2010 →- 09:00 Further and Higher Education Evidence session · 102
- 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 44
- 09:00 Children's Hearings (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 47
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.