1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2576)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Alex Fergusson 3
The record
16 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2576)
Later today, I have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Two weeks ago, I called for a cross-party campaign, together with trade unions, on the aircraft carrier contracts. I am pleased that that has happened.
At one of the meetings in St Andrew’s house, I could not help noticing on the wall a large, North Korean-style slogan, with a great leader-style quote:
“Our one central purpose is to increase Scotland’s economic growth.”
It was signed A Salmond. If that is the First Minister’s purpose, has he not failed miserably?
At one of the meetings in St Andrew’s house, I could not help noticing on the wall a large, North Korean-style slogan, with a great leader-style quote:
“Our one central purpose is to increase Scotland’s economic growth.”
It was signed A Salmond. If that is the First Minister’s purpose, has he not failed miserably?
Here was me thinking that Iain Gray was going to centre on a consensual point about all the parties represented in the chamber uniting to defend Scottish jobs. As we unite to defend the key jobs in the defence sector in Scotland, which is reliant on the air force bases and the carrier contracts, we should also reflect on the other challenges to Scottish economic recovery. Those challenges are partly in the public sector, with the swingeing cuts that are forecast—two thirds from the previous Administration and one third from the current one. There is also the inability to get finance to our small and medium-sized business sector, which is crippling many companies. Those are the challenges that Iain Gray should focus on.
Despite everything, I am still prepared to welcome the consensus that we have established to fight for Scottish jobs, and we should all be proud of that.
Despite everything, I am still prepared to welcome the consensus that we have established to fight for Scottish jobs, and we should all be proud of that.
Those are indeed the challenges of the day. The question of the day is this: why is Alex Salmond’s Government failing them?
Let us take yesterday’s report from the independent Joseph Rowntree Foundation, which said that Scotland is getting poorer faster than England. One of the report’s authors spelled it out:
“It had enjoyed a good three years between ... 2005-2008 but since then things have slipped away steadily and are still getting worse and that is before one has talked about the possible effects of the cuts.”
Is that not a damning indictment of the First Minister’s Government?
Let us take yesterday’s report from the independent Joseph Rowntree Foundation, which said that Scotland is getting poorer faster than England. One of the report’s authors spelled it out:
“It had enjoyed a good three years between ... 2005-2008 but since then things have slipped away steadily and are still getting worse and that is before one has talked about the possible effects of the cuts.”
Is that not a damning indictment of the First Minister’s Government?
I do not worry so much about Iain Gray’s inability to predict the future; it is more when he cannot correctly interpret what has happened. Actually, Scotland went through the recession better than the rest of the United Kingdom did, with a lower fall in output. Our difficulty is a fragile economic recovery. When we try to build an economic recovery, we must consider how public sector investment can be maintained and how the private sector can be given the funds to enable it to invest. Those are the challenges for Scotland. The biggest asset in meeting those challenges would be for the Parliament to have the economic powers to raise the Scottish growth rate and take us forward to prosperity.
The First Minister is simply in denial. Let us interpret the present. As of today, unemployment in Scotland is still going up, whereas it is going down in the rest of the country. Compared with last year, there are 50,000 more Scots sitting at home because they cannot get a job. They see Alex Salmond sitting at home in Bute house doing nothing and they are asking, when is the First Minister finally going to take some responsibility?
Let us talk about what the Government is doing today to increase Scotland’s economic prospects. Today, the Minister for Housing and Communities will be announcing a £130 million investment in the Scottish national housing trust, and 12 local authorities have agreed to participate. That will generate 1,000 jobs in the construction industry. Today, I will be announcing officially that Scotland’s renewable energy target is being lifted from 50 per cent of consumption in 2020 to 80 per cent of consumption in 2020, thanks to the 35 major renewables schemes that the Government has authorised in its term of office. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Mrs Craigie, stop please.
That is the action that will secure Scotland’s prosperity.
I turn to the other thing that is desperately needed. Just as we suffered during Labour’s recession, we do not want to see our recovery impeded by a coalition that is determined to cut public investment without securing the private funds that are required to stimulate the economy. On that subject, Iain Gray and Labour have nothing to say, because they will not accept that this Parliament and this Government need to have the economic powers to do the job for Scotland.
I turn to the other thing that is desperately needed. Just as we suffered during Labour’s recession, we do not want to see our recovery impeded by a coalition that is determined to cut public investment without securing the private funds that are required to stimulate the economy. On that subject, Iain Gray and Labour have nothing to say, because they will not accept that this Parliament and this Government need to have the economic powers to do the job for Scotland.
The 136,000 Scots on the dole are sick of hearing from Alex Salmond what he cannot do rather than what he can do. It is not just the unemployed who are suffering; it is the 260,000 children who are living in poverty. The rate in Scotland is increasing—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
It is increasing twice as fast as the rate in the rest of the country—on his watch.
The Salmond slump cost Scotland 40,000 jobs. He cut 3,000 teaching jobs and 4,000 jobs in the national health service. This First Minister inherited a Scotland where employment was higher than it was in the rest of the country, unemployment was lower and child poverty was dropping faster. He has thrown all that away. This First Minister is leaving Scotland poorer than he found it.
Now the Tory cuts are coming.
The Salmond slump cost Scotland 40,000 jobs. He cut 3,000 teaching jobs and 4,000 jobs in the national health service. This First Minister inherited a Scotland where employment was higher than it was in the rest of the country, unemployment was lower and child poverty was dropping faster. He has thrown all that away. This First Minister is leaving Scotland poorer than he found it.
Now the Tory cuts are coming.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Come to a question, please, Mr Gray.
Is that not a legacy of miserable failure?
I think that Iain Gray should occasionally glance at what the Joseph Rowntree Foundation said about the poverty record of the previous Labour Government—it tore it to shreds.
Iain Gray should also know that, when I met the Scottish Trades Union Congress yesterday, it pointed out to me that the number of construction jobs in Scotland had risen by 20,000 in the last quarter, which Iain Gray does not realise or does not accept. I had a look at the comparative statistics on Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom. In the last quarter, construction employment in Scotland went up by almost 9 per cent; in the UK, it was down 5 per cent. I know that those statistics are new to Iain Gray, but he really must keep up with the results of the public investment in housing and other things that the Government has supplied.
As far as what will happen in elections is concerned, I am grateful to Bill Jamieson for the election strategy that he offered me today. He said:
“Salmond needs only to whisper the two most deadening words in Scottish politics, a whispered name that could cause his most raging critics to slump comatose on the parliament floor. It is a name that reduces barking dogs to a whimper and makes the most neurotic cats sleep through a march past of mice. Throw away the sedatives and repeat until the urge to fall asleep closes totally in: Iain Gray.”
Iain Gray should also know that, when I met the Scottish Trades Union Congress yesterday, it pointed out to me that the number of construction jobs in Scotland had risen by 20,000 in the last quarter, which Iain Gray does not realise or does not accept. I had a look at the comparative statistics on Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom. In the last quarter, construction employment in Scotland went up by almost 9 per cent; in the UK, it was down 5 per cent. I know that those statistics are new to Iain Gray, but he really must keep up with the results of the public investment in housing and other things that the Government has supplied.
As far as what will happen in elections is concerned, I am grateful to Bill Jamieson for the election strategy that he offered me today. He said:
“Salmond needs only to whisper the two most deadening words in Scottish politics, a whispered name that could cause his most raging critics to slump comatose on the parliament floor. It is a name that reduces barking dogs to a whimper and makes the most neurotic cats sleep through a march past of mice. Throw away the sedatives and repeat until the urge to fall asleep closes totally in: Iain Gray.”
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Sep 2010 →- Forensic Science Services Debate · 101
- Emergency Question Questions · 1
- Commonwealth Games (Delhi) Questions · 14
- River Esk (Management) Questions · 6
- Use of Consultants (Guidelines for Public Bodies) Questions · 6
- Rail Freight (South-west Scotland) Questions · 4
- Banking Services (Rural Areas) Questions · 7
- Road Accidents (Access to Police Reports) Questions · 4
- Road Improvements (A92) Questions · 8
- Sheltered Workshops Questions · 6
- Birds of Prey (Protection) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Prisoners (Right to Vote) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Teacher Numbers First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Public Sector Salaries First Minister’s Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Questions · 7
- Services for Vulnerable People (Equality Duties) Questions · 6
- Breast Cancer Ward (Victoria Infirmary) Questions · 7
- NHS Scotland Resource Allocation Committee Formula (Rural Areas) Questions · 6
- People with a Visual Impairment (Health Information) Questions · 4
- Life Expectancy (Effects of Deprivation) Questions · 6
- Computed Tomography Scanner (Orkney) Questions · 4
- Cleft Palates Questions · 4
- NHS Forth Valley Questions · 4
- Housing Benefit (Reform) Questions · 9
- Housing Strategy (Community Benefit Clauses) Questions · 4
- Triage Services (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
- Emergency Care Questions · 4
- National Health Service (Effects of European Working Time Directive) Questions · 4
- Capital Resource Allocation (NHS Grampian and NHS Tayside) Questions · 5
- Low-carbon Economy Debate · 84
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 24
- Leuchie House Members’ business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.