Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 7 October 2010 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2617)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Monday will be the 10th anniversary of Donald Dewar’s death. As that will fall during the recess, I thought that members might like to join me in recognising the vision and intellect of Scotland’s first First Minister. [Applause.]

As to my duties for the rest of the day, I will be joining the leaders of the other devolved Administrations in speaking up for jobs and families and, by means of a joint declaration, protesting at the depth and ferocity of the coalition’s cuts and the threat that they pose to economic recovery.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
On behalf of the Labour Party, I thank the First Minister for his kind recollection of Donald Dewar.

The First Minister’s rates bombshell is costing the national health service £5 million. NHS Grampian alone will be hit for more than £750,000, but it has a great plan to get back £400,000 of that cost. It is asking nurses to work an extra shift for nothing. In June, those same nurses got a nice letter from Nicola Sturgeon saying

“none of you will ‘lose’ your job ... it is job security I think you deserve.”

She did not mention that they would have to work for nothing to keep their jobs. Does the First Minister think that that is what our nurses deserve?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Before talking about the national health service, Iain Gray should check his facts. It is simply not true that nurses in Grampian are being asked to work for nothing. What is true is that when this Administration took office it pledged to spend more on the national health service than the Labour Party, which, it should be remembered, was going to make the NHS cut its cloth. Also, Iain Gray recently declared that he would not guarantee to allocate the Barnett consequentials to national health spending in Scotland.

Whatever Labour’s position on the national health service, we can be sure that more money will be spent more effectively by this Administration than would be spent by any other party in the chamber.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister needs to check his facts. What Labour has said about the NHS budgets is identical to what John Swinney has said. There is no difference whatsoever.

I think that the First Minister will find that surgical nurses in Grampian are being asked to work an extra shift and, in return, they are being given unpaid 15-minute breaks throughout their other shifts. In my book, that is being asked to work extra for nothing. I suppose they should be glad of it, because if they accept that proposal they will have jobs. The fact is that the NHS is cutting 4,000 jobs, of which 1,500 are nursing jobs. At the same time, health boards plan to spend £30 million on agency nurses to fill the gaps. Does the First Minister accept that we cannot cut 1,500 nurses from the health service without impacting on patient care?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Iain Gray’s second question gave away the inaccuracies in his first one. Those nurses will be working the same number of hours for the same salary; that does not sound to me like working for nothing. If Iain Gray was paid per question, nothing would be overpayment for him.

The guarantee that we have given the national health service is clear. There will be no compulsory redundancies in the national health service and more people will be working at the clinical end of the national health service at the end of the current Administration than there were when we took office in 2007. The reason that we are able to give that guarantee is our commitment to pass on the consequentials to protect national health spending in Scotland.

Iain Gray might think that that is inconvenient. I happened to be watching “Newsnight Scotland”, when he was asked that very question, and he refused to give that guarantee. If he has changed his mind under the tutelage of Andy Kerr, perhaps he should tell the chamber.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The nurses in Grampian will be delighted to hear that the First Minister believes that they are making up what they have been asked to do because, as far as they are concerned, they are being asked to work more for no more money.

Let us talk about patients and guarantees. Let us talk about Janet Adams, who is living in pain while waiting for surgery in Grampian. Her general practitioner referred her to the orthopaedic clinic on 14 July. The Scottish Government guarantees her an appointment by this week, but she has been offered an appointment by Christmas. She does not have that guarantee. Is the First Minister’s NHS waiting time guarantee just another promise that he cannot be bothered keeping?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Let us be clear about the start of that question: I would never accuse nurses in Scotland of giving misleading information; I suggested that Iain Gray was not in command of his facts. The reason why I suggested that is that nurses are not being asked to work extra hours; they are being asked to work for the same salary. Those are the parameters of the NHS Grampian consultation.

Iain Gray should bring forward the facts on individual cases within the national health service and they will be answered case by case. However, let us remember that waiting times in the national health service in Scotland are at an all-time low under this Administration. The reason for that is the record investment that we have made in the NHS in Scotland. The Labour Party did not guarantee such investment at the previous election, which is one of the reasons that it lost in 2007, just as Iain Gray’s refusal to guarantee consequentials is a reason that it will lose in 2011.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Here is what the Royal College of Nursing says:

“This change in working arrangements is clearly to the detriment of our hard-working and overstretched members who are bearing the brunt of the cuts that are being made by NHS Grampian.”

The First Minister is making it up as he goes along, and so is Nicola Sturgeon. Yesterday, she cancelled a new health centre in Mull and, today, she uncancelled it in a hastily arranged radio interview. John Swinney plundered £5 million from her hospitals while her back was turned. [Interruption.] Nurses are being asked to work for nothing. Nursing jobs are being cut and millions wasted on agency replacements. Kirkcaldy accident and emergency—[Interruption.]

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Kirkcaldy accident and emergency unit is closed by staff shortages. Procedure rooms in half of Scotland sit idle most of the time. The Scottish Ambulance Service call centre has crashed twice in the past few months. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing is asleep at the wheel. When will the First Minister tell Nicola Sturgeon to get a grip?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
For the fourth time, I clarify that nurses are not being asked to work for nothing. The terms of the consultation are the same hours for the same salary. It could not be clearer than that. Of course, the quotation that Iain Gray used from the RCN did not allege that nurses were being asked to work for nothing. At some point during or after this question session, he will have to retreat from his position yet again.

I would have thought that Iain Gray would welcome the fact that we are able to go ahead with the capital investment for the health centre on Mull. That seems a good thing to me. We are able to do that despite the fact that, although we might think that the coalition Government’s statement that it would protect real-terms spending on health would include the capital budget and the revenue budget, we have been unable to get any clarity about that over the past few months. The coalition Government’s confusion about whether the protection of real-terms spending on health includes the capital budget is similar to Iain Gray’s confusion about whether the consequentials would be passed on to the health service in Scotland.

The position with the national health service is that patient satisfaction is at a record high and waiting times are at a record low, thanks to the investment of this Government.

Before Iain Gray talks about accident and emergency, he should remember that if it had been up to the Labour Party, accident and emergency wards would not exist all over Scotland.

  1. Supported Employment Workplaces Debate · 79
  2. National Dementia Strategy Questions · 8
  3. NHS Highland (Dunbar Hospital) Questions · 6
  4. Victims and Witnesses (Support) Questions · 5
  5. People Trafficking Questions · 4
  6. Carers and Young Carers Strategies (Implementation Group) Questions · 4
  7. School Mergers (Consultation) Questions · 6
  8. Supported Employment Questions · 5
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  10. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
  12. National Health Service (Alcoholic Parents) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Rate Revaluation (Successful Appeals) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Managed Diagnostic Imaging Clinical Network (Emergency Teams) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Finance and Sustainable Growth Questions · 1
  16. High-speed Rail Questions · 4
  17. Youth Unemployment Questions · 6
  18. Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 6
  19. Public Authorities (Island Areas) Questions · 7
  20. Council Tax Freeze (2011-12) Questions · 10
  21. Indoor White-water Rafting (Edinburgh Waterfront) Questions · 8
  22. Infrastructure Projects (Community Benefit) Questions · 4
  23. Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (Transmission Charging Review) Questions · 4
  24. Underdeveloped Commercial and Industrial Land (Urban Areas) Questions · 5
  25. Tax-varying Powers Questions · 8
  26. Co-operative Sector Questions · 4
  27. Fossil Fuel Levy Questions · 6
  28. Renewable Heat Incentive Questions · 4
  29. Recruitment Questions · 4
  30. Skills Strategy (Refresh) Debate · 35
  31. Climate Change (Annual Targets) (Scotland) Order 2010 Debate · 12
  32. Decision Time Decision time · 12
  33. Sport Members’ business · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.