7. To ask the Scottish Executive what action it is taking to ensure that best use is made of the open prison estate. (S3O-11548)
Official Report · Chamber
Open Prisons
Scottish Executive Question Time Justice and Law Officers
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kenny MacAskill SNP 3
- Robert Brown LD 2
- Angela Constance SNP 1
- Trish Godman Lab 1
The record
7 contributions7. To ask the Scottish Executive what action it is taking to ensure that best use is made of the open prison estate. (S3O-11548)
Scottish Prison Service staff in the closed and open estate work closely together to ensure that all those prisoners who meet the criteria for open conditions and who would benefit from the open estate regime are located there at the most appropriate point of their sentence.
Earlier, the cabinet secretary mentioned training for freedom. Does he accept that we are now in a rather unhelpful and wasteful situation in which the open estate, which is very much focused on training for freedom, is operating at about 60 per cent capacity whereas the closed estate remains substantially overcrowded? Given that most of the prisoners in the closed estate will be released at some point, does the cabinet secretary agree that the underuse of the open estate might result in greater risk to the public from prisoners who have committed serious crimes being released direct from the closed estate? Will he have a fresh look at the issue across the whole estate and take account of all the risks to the public?
I accept the spirit in which Mr Brown asks his question. We all recognise that there is underuse, and the figure of 60 per cent is correct. However, I think that the situation is the result of the Scottish Prison Service being a victim of its own success. Quite correctly, procedures have been tightened up. When I had to stand in this chamber and make a statement about Robert Foy, everyone was extremely concerned about which categories of prisoner were held in the open estate. It is not a question of the underuse of the open estate; it is a question of its appropriate use. We would like more use to be made of the open estate because when there is undercapacity it is clear that we are not getting the best benefit from it.
I think that Mr Brown will agree that we all learned from the consequences of the Robert Foy case. We have to ensure that prisoners who go to the open estate are capable of meeting the criteria. We cannot guarantee the safety, security or law-abiding actions of all such prisoners, but we must recognise that the criteria have been brought in to try to ensure public safety, and I do not think that they should be varied or reduced. If the Scottish Prison Service can increase the use of the open estate but keep the criteria to preserve public safety, I will be more than happy. I give an assurance that the matter is under constant review by the Scottish Prison Service. We welcome Mr Brown’s support for the open estate but, as I said, we have to recognise that the criteria have been correctly tightened for reasons of public safety.
I think that Mr Brown will agree that we all learned from the consequences of the Robert Foy case. We have to ensure that prisoners who go to the open estate are capable of meeting the criteria. We cannot guarantee the safety, security or law-abiding actions of all such prisoners, but we must recognise that the criteria have been brought in to try to ensure public safety, and I do not think that they should be varied or reduced. If the Scottish Prison Service can increase the use of the open estate but keep the criteria to preserve public safety, I will be more than happy. I give an assurance that the matter is under constant review by the Scottish Prison Service. We welcome Mr Brown’s support for the open estate but, as I said, we have to recognise that the criteria have been correctly tightened for reasons of public safety.
link
Will the cabinet secretary comment further on the success of the reforms in cutting the number of abscondees?
There has been significant success, which again comes down to the action taken by the Scottish Prison Service. The Robert Foy incident was horrendous for the victim and the community and we had to take action. A review was requested, and it was carried out by Professor Alec Spencer.
I return to the point that I made to Robert Brown: to some extent, underuse is perhaps a perverse result of the Scottish Prison Service’s success in reducing the number of absconds. That has come at a price, in that fewer people are going to the open estate. The reason for that is that people are not meeting the criteria, because it does not look as if they can be trusted, and public safety must be paramount. I welcome the results on absconds, although they have come at that price, and I assure the member that the Scottish Prison Service has always acted in such a way as to ensure that public safety is paramount.
I return to the point that I made to Robert Brown: to some extent, underuse is perhaps a perverse result of the Scottish Prison Service’s success in reducing the number of absconds. That has come at a price, in that fewer people are going to the open estate. The reason for that is that people are not meeting the criteria, because it does not look as if they can be trusted, and public safety must be paramount. I welcome the results on absconds, although they have come at that price, and I assure the member that the Scottish Prison Service has always acted in such a way as to ensure that public safety is paramount.
Question 8 has been withdrawn.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Sep 2010 →- Higher Education Debate · 142
- Education (Performance) Questions · 6
- Rosyth Passenger Ferry Service Questions · 6
- Poverty Questions · 4
- Stornoway to Ullapool Ferry Service (Consultation) Questions · 6
- Councillors (Salaries and Allowances) Questions · 4
- Literacy Questions · 6
- Achbuie Respite Unit Questions · 6
- Construction Industry Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Obesity First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Hospitals (Cleanliness) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Commonwealth Games 2014 First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Scottish Policing Board (Structural Reforms) Questions · 4
- Methadone (Prisoners) Questions · 8
- European Convention on Human Rights Questions · 4
- Antisocial Behaviour Notices (Landlords) Questions · 5
- Prisons (North-east Scotland) Questions · 8
- Open Prisons Questions · 7
- Court Processes Questions · 4
- Waste (North-east Scotland) Questions · 7
- Flooding (Inverclyde) Questions · 10
- Scottish Food and Drink Questions · 6
- Waste Processing Facilities Questions · 6
- Milk Prices Questions · 4
- Green Cities Questions · 5
- Portencross Coast Site of Special Scientific Interest Questions · 5
- Johne’s Disease Questions · 4
- Tribunal System Reform Debate · 55
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
- Offshore Renewables Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.