Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Youth Football (PE1319)

Tuesday 29 June 2010 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 8 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
The Convener
link

Our last current petition is PE1319, by Scott Robertson and William Smith, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to investigate the legal status and appropriateness of professional Scottish Football Association clubs entering into contracts with children aged under 16; the audit process and accountability of all public funds distributed by the SFA to its member clubs; the social, educational and psychological effects and legality of SFA member clubs prohibiting such children from participating in extracurricular activity; and the appropriateness of compensation payments between SFA member clubs for the transfer of young players under the age of 16. It also calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to increase the educational target from two hours to four hours of curricular physical activity per week; and to develop a long-term plan to provide quality artificial surfaces for training and playing football at all ages across all regions. We have two MSPs with us to talk to the petition. I invite Trish Godman to say a few words in support of the petition.

Trish Godman West Renfrewshire) (Lab
link

I ask the committee to continue the petition for some sound reasons. There is still a lack of clarity about what happens when a registration form is signed by young people—there seem to be few opportunities for them to be released.I have spoken to the chief executive of the Scottish Premier League and he informs me that it is not a registration form but a commitment form, but from looking at the form I do not know what the difference is. He also informs me that there is a 28-day opt out. From speaking to boys and their parents, I know that they were not aware of that. I believe that registering or committing a very young boy—or young person, as a few girls are involved—in that way is wrong. It is certainly questionable, as there seems to be a lack of clarity about what they are committing themselves to.The petition mentions compensation. If the boy who signs up is not the best player and another club is unwilling to pay a fee to move him, he will have to continue with a club where he is not happy. That is not good for a child of the age that we are talking about. It is not good for a child if he is not playing with his peers, is not allowed to play school football and has to continue to play with a club where he is not happy. If someone is with the club for a season and it transfers them to another club, the fee is about £3,000. If they are there for two years, the fee is £6,000 and if they are there for three years, it is £9,000. We are talking about quite a bit of money for moving young boys around. I would be interested to know how many of these boys are transferred.Clubs get funding for their youth football from the Scottish Government and the cashback for communities fund. I have yet to get clarification of where the £3,000 that I mentioned comes from. Neil Doncaster’s argument was that some money had to be paid for the amount of training and commitment that the clubs had given the young boys.One of my main concerns is education. These young boys usually play and practise football three or four times a week and all day on Sunday. I do not know who checks their academic progress, whether that is done now and again or whether there is a system. I am sure that there are good systems in some clubs, but not in others.I know that the committee has not considered the report by Henry McLeish in great detail. A good chunk of that report is about youth football. It would be good if the committee considered the report and what I have said. There is a lack of clarity about what happens. We need to ensure that we protect children, particularly young boys who sign up to clubs thinking that they will be the next David Beckham. Only around 4 per cent of them move into any kind of professional football. We could do with a really good Scottish team in the long term, but I do not think that we will get it through the approach that has been taken. We need to look carefully at what is happening out there.

Iain Gray East Lothian) (Lab
link

I, too, have come to the meeting to speak in support of the petition. The petition and the issues that it addresses were brought to my attention by Scott Robertson, who is one of the petitioners and a constituent of mine. He coaches Musselburgh Windsor, which is a youth football team that is based just outside my constituency, but which draws many of its young people from within the area that I represent. Musselburgh Windsor has been an important institution in East Lothian for a long time, and it has had a great deal of success in boys’, girls’ and mixed football.In considering the petition, it is important to understand that it was lodged as a result of the frustrations that are felt by the many volunteers who put unbelievable efforts into running our youth football. The time and energy that they give are unbelievable. I think that they would say that the frustration that they feel at what happens when their players show promise and are picked up by senior teams is not the most important thing; rather, they are most concerned about what happens to many of those young people.As Trish Godman said, all young footballers who attract the attention of senior teams believe—their parents often believe this, too—that they are on an inevitable course to stardom, but the hard fact is, of course, that very few of them will see that path out all the way. William Smith, Scott Robertson and others have argued that the system can often treat hopes, aspirations and dreams cruelly in order to suit the concerns and interests of the senior teams.High numbers of young people are signed up. Sometimes groups of players are signed up in order to get a commitment from one of their number. The hope is that a person will come along if their friends come along. Of course, that necessarily means the inevitable rejection of a good number of young people after a period. That is inevitable, but the system can often drive those who have been rejected by a team out of football altogether. Trish Godman talked about that. If a person has signed a commitment form and leaves or falls out with a club, they may find themselves unable to play football for anyone else for two years, by which time they will probably have lost any drive that they had to play.It may be true that young people or their parents have 28 days to change their mind, but it seems to me that, if the truth is that the young person will not make it or will not benefit from an arrangement with a club, that may not become obvious within as short a period as 28 days. That protection still seems to me to be quite limited. Often, perhaps because of their excitement about an opportunity opening up before them, people might not be aware of that protection. An even more fundamental question is whether we are asking children who are as young as 10 to sign what is, in essence, a legal contract. If so, the contract would be not legal but illegal, because such children are much too young to be legally bound by such a contract.The committee sought evidence from the SFA, the SPL, the Scottish Government and others. The SFA and the SPL have replied that they do not recognise any of the problems and that the system is working well. The temptation is to say, “They would say that, wouldn’t they?” The Scottish Government does not opine on whether the arrangement is proper and says rather that it is up to those who enter into contracts with young people to decide whether they are legal, which is rather dodging the question.The most powerful evidence to the committee is the letter from Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People. He does not give an opinion, but it is clear that he believes that questions need to be answered about the legality of some arrangements and about the extent to which they uphold or breach our children’s rights. For that reason alone, I argue that the proper course for the committee is to continue the petition and perhaps to ask the appropriate parliamentary committee to take evidence and look further into the concerns that Tam Baillie, Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People, has summarised well.

Robin Harper
link

This is the second time that we have considered the petition. What has been described is far too close—frighteningly close—to the exploitation of minors and has little to do with encouraging young people to become involved in football.The SPL, the Scottish Football League and the SFA replied so late that the petitioners have not had time to respond to us, so we cannot discuss the petitioners’ feelings and consider their analysis of those responses. Some organisations have yet to respond to us, which is appalling. The aforementioned SPL, SFL and SFA deserve a rap on the knuckles for taking so long to respond, but the others must be asked to respond urgently on the situation, because the issues are important. We must continue the petition. The organisations should realise that responding so late creates difficulty for the committee, because we have a heavy workload. Time at today’s meeting was set aside to give the petition due attention, but we cannot do that at this meeting, which is regrettable.16:15

Bill Butler
link

Scott Robertson has replied to the committee, but Robin Harper’s point has legitimacy, because the petitioners had only six days in which to think about and turn round their response. That is disappointing.We considered the petition on 20 April. As always, the committee’s clerking team sent letters within 24 hours to all the organisations to which the committee had asked the clerks to send our initial correspondence. The organisations were given a deadline of 17 May to respond. However, it was 11 June before we received a reply from the SPL; 14 June before we received anything from the SFA; and 15 June before we got the SFL’s reply. As far as I know, responses are still outstanding from the Scottish Amateur Football Association; unhappily, I have to say, from the Scottish Trades Union Congress; the Scottish Child Law Centre; the local authorities in Edinburgh and North Ayrshire; and the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills. That has been very unhelpful because, as Trish Godman and Iain Gray have pointed out, the petition raises very serious issues about our young people, how youth football is progressed in this country and the deficiencies in the current system that are there for all to see.I note, first, Trish Godman’s comment that someone told her that the form was not really a registration form but a commitment form. If I may say so, that is just an exercise in semantics. Indeed, it is a nonsense; it does not mean anything. I could go on but I will not, because I might be impolite.Secondly, the very powerful evidence that Iain Gray referred to is indeed that—very powerful. In fact, I want to read into the Official Report a paragraph from the response from Tam Baillie who, as members know, is Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People. In reply to the question“What concerns do you have about the demands and impact (the legal, moral and general as the petition states) this is having on under 16 year olds signing on with professional football clubs?”he said:“I am not in a position to offer legal advice and my comments should not be relied upon as such. I do believe, however, that the issues raised in the petition highlight a range of potential breaches of children’s rights under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child”.That is a pretty powerful statement. He then goes on to detail possible breaches in“The nature of Youth Initiative (Performance Tier) registration documents”,“The issue of compensation” and “Fairness and equality”. Those are very grave issues. Obviously we should continue the petition but the committee should also write both to the organisations that have replied to us very tardily and to those that have yet to reply, making it clear that we are a committee of the Parliament of Scotland and that they need to reply to us in good time.At the moment, however, we are left with no other alternative but to reallocate a time slot to take another look at all the evidence and to invite Mr McLeish along to talk to us. I know that it will not be easy to do that—the clerk has said that although the petition could be timetabled for a meeting in September, that would not be particularly convenient—but I really think that we need to fit it in.Moreover, despite the fact that these issues are very serious, some of the responses that we have received are simply not real and detailed enough. We should ask the respondents to address the detail of the petition, not to give us an offhand response that they probably think is a way of being polite. Actually, not responding to a petition that is under discussion by this Parliament and this committee is really the model of impoliteness. I really am very annoyed—as we should all be, colleagues—that not only the committee but, above all, the petitioners have been treated in this fashion. Our message should be that that is completely unacceptable. We need real, detailed answers and we need them back in double-quick time with no excuses. When we get those responses, we can take a serious look at the evidence. This should be their last warning: September—and no later.I hope that I have made myself clear, convener.

The Convener
link

Eminently so.

Anne McLaughlin
link

I agree with Bill Butler. I have to say, though, that if he had been my teacher in a previous life, I would never have been late with my homework more than once.I draw attention to what Tam Baillie, Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People, said about potential breaches of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. He wrote:“Article 36—child’s right to protection from other forms of exploitationI am concerned that children are potentially being exploited by a system which is meant to provide them with opportunities and develop their talents. Whilst this may be an unintended consequence of the registration process, it does need to be urgently reviewed to ensure that children and young people’s rights are adequately protected.”That is quite a powerful statement, which we should take seriously.

The Convener
link

I think that the committee agrees to continue the petition. I understand that the committee wants to write in no uncertain terms to make plain our views about the lack of responses from some organisations and the tardy and inadequate responses from others. We can also invite Henry McLeish to appear before the committee. He was not aware of his previous invitation until too late, which is unfortunate. Do we agree to give him the opportunity to come to the committee, to continue the petition and to consider it at a meeting in September?Members indicated agreement.

  1. 14:00 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 14:00 Temporary Convener Procedure · 3
  3. 14:00 Convener Procedure · 4
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 14
  5. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 28
  6. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 11
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  22. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  23. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  24. 14:00 New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
  25. 14:00 Work Programme Procedure · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.