Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Using locum doctors in hospitals”

Wednesday 8 September 2010 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 30 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

30 contributions
The Convener
link

I invite the Auditor General to brief us on the report, “Using locum doctors in hospitals”.

Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will introduce the report briefly, as I am conscious of the pressures on your time this morning. As ever, I will rely heavily on the Audit Scotland team to answer any questions that you might have.This report on locum doctors was published on 17 June, just before the parliamentary recess. We undertook the work because, clearly, locum doctors have an important role to play in ensuring that hospitals are adequately staffed and can provide patient care around the clock.I will highlight three sets of issues in the report. First, the spend on locum doctors and opportunities to get some efficiency savings out of that spend; secondly, managing the demand for locums; and, thirdly, the important issue of ensuring patient safety.Over the past decade, expenditure on locum doctors has more than doubled in real terms. It rose from around £17 million in 1996-97 to at least £47 million in 2008-09. Around three fifths of the spend was on agency locums, and the balance was spent on internal locums who were employees of the NHS. Exhibit 1, on page 6 of the report, shows that six boards reduced their expenditure while seven others, plus the Golden Jubilee hospital, increased their spend. NHS Highland is not included because it could provide expenditure data for 2008-09 only.In 2004, NHS National Procurement set up a national contract for agency locums. In 2006, the Scottish Executive instructed health boards to use only the agencies that are included in that contract. However, relative spend on non-contract agencies has not gone down; in fact, it has increased marginally over the past three years, from 31 per cent to 33 per cent. The national contract lapsed in May 2009 and was not replaced until June 2010, which led to the boards negotiating their own hourly rates with agencies, with some boards paying higher rates than they had been paying during the contract period.The team thinks that the health service could save around £6 million a year if it used locum doctors more efficiently.Exhibit 2, on page 7, shows a wide variation in spend on locums as a percentage of total spend on medical staffing. The percentage ranges from 2.4 per cent in NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde to 11.4 per cent in Orkney, with NHS Dumfries and Galloway being the highest mainland board, with a percentage spend of 11.2 per cent. NHS Western Isles is an extreme outlier at 36 per cent, which reflects the difficulties in recruiting permanent staff to that island board.We recognise that some boards will find it difficult to reduce spend without more significant changes in the way in which health services are delivered, but we think that all boards should be able to make some savings by improving their procurement procedures and by making improvements to their workforce planning.The second set of issues is on managing demand. Demand for locum doctors in hospitals has increased in the past three years. Seven boards were able to provide us with information and we found from those data that the number of requests for locum doctors almost doubled between 2006-07 and 2008-09. It is impossible to quantify fully the levels of demand, as not all boards hold or can access easily information on requests for agency and internal locums. However, we know that there are wider workforce issues affecting the demand for locums, which include difficulties in filling vacancies, the full implementation of the 48-hour week under the European working time directive and changes to junior doctors’ training. At the same time as those pressures were arising, the agencies were finding it more difficult to meet the requests for locums. Their ability to meet requests fell from 83 per cent in 2006-07 to 71 per cent in 2008-09.The final set of issues relates to patient safety, which clearly remains paramount. The team examined how that is safeguarded by health boards when employing locum doctors. We must recognise that locum doctors help NHS boards to maintain appropriate staffing levels so, in that way, they contribute significantly to safe and appropriate care for patients. We should bear that in mind when we take account of the potential risks to patient safety, particularly where locums are unfamiliar with the department or hospital in which they are hired to work.Exhibit 15 on page 24 highlights the three key stages at which risks occur. The first is appointment, the second is induction and supervision and the final one is performance management. All health boards have a checklist that sets out the documents that they should receive when employing locum doctors, but only half the boards formally set out who is responsible for each element of the appointment process in their locum procurement policy. That means that there is a risk that not all checks will be completed properly. For example, that could happen if the arrangements for hiring a locum doctor are made out of hours when the staff who are normally responsible for those checks are not available.Few health boards have corporate induction and supervision policies relating to locum doctors, and performance management arrangements for locums are not well developed. Most of the feedback tends to be informal, which means that there are no formal mechanisms for sharing information about the performance of individual locum doctors among health boards.That is a brief outline of the report. As ever, there is a lot more in the report than I have been able to cover, but the team will be happy to answer questions.

The Convener
link

Thank you for that. You have identified that the demand for locums has increased since 2006-07, but the ability of agencies to meet the requests has fallen. Has that affected the price that agencies charge? In other words, if there is a scarce resource, can agencies push up the fees? Does it cost the health service more because the demand cannot be met?

Mr Black
link

There is some evidence of that. I invite the team to give you the details.

Nick Hex Audit Scotland
link

It is fair to say that it is very much a supply-and-demand issue. If supply of locum doctors decreases, generally, there is an issue of increased cost. However, it is hard to quantify that. We found that we cannot necessarily quantify exactly how much the costs go up by, because that depends on the individual doctor and circumstances and, obviously, the post to which they are appointed.

The Convener
link

Do you have an idea of how much more expensive it is to employ a locum doctor than it is to have someone on the payroll?

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

Exhibit 6 on page 11 gives an indication of the different types of pay rates at April last year when the national contract for locum doctors was still in place. For internal locums, there are nationally set pay rates and then there are national contract rates, which were in place until May 2009 last year, until when the national contract ran. Then there are costs for locums from agencies that were outwith the national contract. As you can see from the exhibit, the pay rates for external locums, particularly non-contract locums, were much higher than those for internal locums.

The Convener
link

You refer to NHS internal locums. Does that mean that the NHS already has its own system to plug gaps but that it is not sufficient to do everything?11:30

Nick Hex Audit Scotland
link

By internal locums, we mean staff who are already substantively employed in the NHS, who may either fill gaps in service where there is a requirement, or work at a different hospital or for a different board. There is no specific system yet, but we make the point in the report that the Government is considering the establishment of locum banks.

Mr Black
link

For a few years, the NHS has been running nurse banks of direct employees. The intention is to see whether the model can be developed and implemented effectively for doctors, too.

Nick Hex Audit Scotland
link

That is correct.

Bill Kidd
link

Is there concern that the limits that are set by the working time directive will be exceeded if, as well as doing their own jobs, people are taken on as locums, through internal banks?

Mr Black
link

Yes, we identify that risk in the report. It is up to individual doctors to behave in a professionally responsible way, but there is nothing to prevent a doctor from doing locum work in a health board other than the board of their main employment. It is appropriate to ensure that people who do that do not work excessive hours.

The Convener
link

That is an important point. So, there is no way of checking how many hours a doctor is working if they work as a locum in different areas.

Nick Hex Audit Scotland
link

That is correct. Health boards ensure that the staff whom they employ do not breach the terms of the working time directive, but if a doctor chooses to work additional hours elsewhere, there is currently no mechanism to monitor that.

Mr Black
link

It is possible that people will be in the position of working excessive hours, but we do not highlight that as a major risk in the report.

The Convener
link

Should the board that takes on a locum require them to sign a document indicating how many hours they have worked in the current period, or a declaration that they have not worked excessive hours? Surely boards should seek guarantees from those whom they employ when they take them on.

Mr Black
link

The question is probably best addressed to the health directorates.

Nick Hex Audit Scotland
link

Boards must undertake pre-employment checks on locums whom they intend to use. Currently, they are not required to check the number of hours that a locum has worked. The development of locum banks will help to address the matter, because a centralised system will make it possible to monitor such issues much more closely.

Murdo Fraser
link

My question relates to another issue of patient safety. From time to time, we hear—at least anecdotally—concerns about the employment of locum doctors from foreign countries, whose command of English may not be particularly strong. There are concerns that such doctors may have difficulty communicating with patients or other NHS workers. Have you identified that as a risk in your report?

Mr Black
link

We did not have that information; I am not sure how we could get it. However, as Nick Hex said, health boards are required to carry out pre-employment checks, which should provide some kind of safeguard. At UK level, arrangements for employing in the NHS overseas doctors from outwith the European Union have been tightened up.

Kirsty Whyte Audit Scotland
link

Doctors from outwith the EU are required to undertake a proficiency in language test by the General Medical Council when they come into the country, but doctors from other countries in the EU are not required to do that. The issue has been in the media recently, and I know that earlier in the summer, the UK Government said that it would look into it, with a view to tightening up the system.

Nicol Stephen
link

I have a general question to ask in the context of the Auditor General’s report. Is it his experience that the information that is available to the NHS in Scotland, which is both critical to and criticised in many of his reports on the NHS, is the best in the world?

Mr Black
link

The short and not very helpful answer is that I am the Auditor General only in respect of Scotland and not the rest of the globe.

Murdo Fraser
link

That is a good answer.

Nicol Stephen
link

Taking a wider view—

Mr Black
link

A more helpful answer might be to remind the committee that late last year, we presented a report on the management of information in the NHS, which it is fair to say presented a very mixed picture of progress in developing information systems that are fit for purpose. We recognise that a lot of effort is being put into that, as we heard this morning. Given the urgency of the issue in Scotland, the pace of that work continues to be extremely important.

Willie Coffey
link

On the point about excessive working hours, would not that be revealed through the pay-as-you-earn tax system? Notwithstanding the recent problems with the tax system, surely it would pinpoint the fact that a person had worked in excess of 48 hours.

Mr Black
link

That is an interesting question, but it is well outside the scope of the report, as you might imagine. We all know that HM Revenue and Customs is extremely careful about data protection issues and about releasing anything to do with the financial circumstances of people who pay tax. I do not imagine that there would be any realistic prospect of getting access to those data for such a purpose.

The Convener
link

If there is nothing else, I thank the Auditor General and his team for their report.We now move on to item 5, which we will take in private.11:37 Meeting continued in private until 12:26.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 138
  4. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 30

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.