Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 24 June 2010 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 13 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

13 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2496)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I have a range of engagements to carry forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The Tories’ savage budget will hit Scotland hard. [Laughter.]

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I assure colleagues opposite that they are the only ones who are laughing.

Nicola Sturgeon was right to complain that the VAT bombshell in the budget will cost our national health service £26.5 million, but she could do something: she could get Alex Salmond to cancel his rates revaluation, which will also cost our NHS millions—£1 million in Grampian alone. That has been done in Northern Ireland. Will the First Minister do it here?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
No. A business rates system must be subject to revaluation, otherwise we could not sustain a rateable system. As Iain Gray knows from previous discussions, the substantial majority of businesses throughout Scotland will be no worse or better off as a result of the rates revaluation. Our system of rates, through the variety of packages of aid and reliefs that we offer in Scotland, is superior to that anywhere else in these islands. If, in addition to it, Iain Gray wants us to introduce a further scheme, as was suggested by the Liberal Democrats a few weeks ago, he had better identify where the public funds would come from.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
If the rates revaluation system is income neutral, as the First Minister told me two weeks ago, the measure that I propose would help the NHS and would not cost him anything at all.

What about our games industry? The budget cancelled Labour’s tax break for the industry. The Scottish National Party says that that will cost 200 jobs in Dundee, and I think that it is right, but let us not just complain—let us actually do something for a change. John Swinney told us yesterday that he has £300 million in the bank. We can take £5 million of that—equivalent to the tax break—and find a way to support the games industry anyway. Let us save those 200 jobs, despite the Tories and the Liberals. Will the First Minister do that?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I will first correct Iain Gray on business rates. What I told him a few weeks ago is that revaluation is essentially a neutral process. What that does not take account of is the additional move that the Scottish Government made to reduce the rateable poundage by 15 per cent and bring it down, for the first time in history as far as I know, into line with the rateable poundage for England and Wales. That is a cost of £200 million in addition to all the other reliefs that are available. I am sure that Iain Gray would not want to ignore the fact that reducing the rateable poundage helps every business and, indeed, every public sector organisation, including the health service in Scotland.

As far as the games industry is concerned, I deeply regret that the Government in Westminster has chosen to cancel the proposed tax relief and I agree that it is a short-sighted decision. I think that the centre of the games industry in Scotland is a jewel in the crown of Scottish industry; it is fantastic for the city of Dundee and I cannot see that it is sensible to jeopardise that performance. I thought that the Independent Game Developers Association—TIGA—the representative body for the games industry, put forward a powerful case for why that particular tax concession, or another tax concession, if one can be identified, could substantially help to generate jobs, employment and, therefore, revenue over the medium term.

Iain Gray says that we should act on the games industry. It might be instructive to look at what the industry itself is saying about the setback in the budget. Richard Wilson, the head of TIGA, which is an excellent trade body, says that the Scottish Government should have tax-raising powers, so that it can protect the games industry and introduce such a tax incentive. If the games industry is calling for that, when on earth will the Labour Party realise that we must have fiscal responsibility so that we can boost our industry?

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister is an awful lot better at explaining what he cannot do than he is at explaining what he can do and why he chooses not to do it.

What does someone have to do to get help from the Scottish Government? They have to put on a kilt and call themselves a clan chief. Then they can have a secret, interest-free loan, with no questions asked. Here is the best bit: they do not even need to pay it back; they just need to promise the First Minister a photo opportunity in a beaver hat and name their price. What do the NHS, the games industry and businesses that are not The Gathering 2009 Ltd have to do to get action from the First Minister?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Given Iain Gray’s passionate concern for the tourism industry in Scotland, I know that he will not want to ignore that the gathering event generated £8 million in revenue for our tourism industry in the city of Edinburgh and £10 million across Scotland.

No doubt that is what the Auditor General for Scotland, Robert Black, was thinking of yesterday when he told the Public Audit Committee, in relation to the decision to award the loan:

“clearly time was not on anyone’s side by the summer of last year, because the event was committed and was about to proceed. The Scottish Government”

took

“the not unreasonable view that in order to allow the event to proceed it should assist the short-term cash flow problems of the company delivering the event.”

I have no doubt that the Auditor General made that remark in response to questions from the committee because he realised that it would have been a bad thing for jobs in Scotland and a blow to the tourism industry in Scotland to cancel an event that turned out to generate £10 million for the Scottish economy. If Iain Gray wants to complain retrospectively about the decision, it behoves him to explain to the visitor and tourism industry in Scotland where it would have got the £10 million that the Labour Party wanted to deny it.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I do not expect that the First Minister wants to ignore the fact that Edinburgh businesses appeared on the news last night, explaining how they had had to make people redundant because of the mishandling of the event by his Government. I hear nothing from him about what he will do to help them.

Audit Scotland’s report, “The Gathering 2009”, shows that the First Minister can take action when it matters. It shows that he spent a month cold calling everyone he could think of, to try to get them to buy up his bad debts on the clan gathering.

One phone call today could cancel the small business bombshell and help the NHS. One more call could put £5 million of support into our games industry in Dundee. Those are the kind of calls that a real First Minister makes. I will even lend him my phone. Will he make the calls?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Iain Gray’s phone is not the best prop that we have seen at First Minister’s question time.

I point out to Iain Gray that the reason for the attempt to find someone to take over the gathering event was precisely to help the small businesses about which he says that he is concerned. I do not quite follow his argument. If he is concerned about those businesses, why does he criticise the attempt to have the gathering taken over? His position makes no logical sense whatsoever.

Iain Gray should, at some stage, face the reality of what was published this week about the finances affecting the health service and every other public authority in Scotland on page 16 of the budget report. It shows that £83 billion of cuts by 2014-15 are planned by the coalition Government at Westminster. It also shows for the first time that £52 billion, or two thirds of the proposed cuts were embedded in the Labour Party’s plans. Jobs will be lost in Scotland as a result of the coalition Government’s cutbacks, and the loss of two out of three of those jobs will be the result of the destruction of this country’s finances by the Labour Party. For every £3 million that is cut from every public service in Scotland, including the NHS, £2 million is the responsibility of the Labour Party. It is no good whatsoever—Iain Gray being a one-party, one-man political cycle—to cause the problem, destroy the country’s public finances and then to blame everyone else for the consequences.

  1. Tourism Debate · 78
  2. Free Personal Care Debate · 40
  3. Pyrolysis Questions · 5
  4. Council Tax Freeze Questions · 6
  5. Air Conditioning Systems (Inspection and Maintenance) Questions · 5
  6. Council Tax Freeze Questions · 4
  7. Care Leavers Questions · 4
  8. St Ninian’s High School (Catchment) Questions · 4
  9. Language Skills (Five-year-olds) Questions · 6
  10. Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi Questions · 9
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
  14. Emergency Budget First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. Cancelled NHS Operations (Statistics) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. Research Institutes (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. NHS Lanarkshire (Capital Funding) Questions · 8
  18. Caithness General Hospital (Maternity Services) Questions · 6
  19. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 4
  20. National Health Service Board Elections (Pilot) Questions · 6
  21. Front-line Health Workers (Protection) Questions · 6
  22. Private Letting Agencies (Regulation) Questions · 6
  23. Sight Loss (Early Intervention) Questions · 8
  24. National Health Service Dentists (Orkney) Questions · 4
  25. Low-cost Initiative for First-time Buyers Questions · 6
  26. National Health Service Boards (Expenditure Reduction) Questions · 10
  27. National Health Service Staff (Disabled Employees) Questions · 4
  28. Patient Care Questions · 6
  29. “Independent Review of Sheriff and Jury Procedure” Debate · 39
  30. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 16
  32. Deaf Awareness Week 2010 Members’ business · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.