Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

School Building Programme

Scottish Executive Question Time Education and Lifelong Learning

Thursday 17 June 2010 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link


7. To ask the Scottish Government how the school building programme aims to maximise the number of schools benefiting from improved facilities. (S3O-10935)

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Skills and Lifelong Learning · Ochil
link
The Scottish Futures Trust is managing Scotland’s schools for the future on our behalf. It will bring extensive expertise to bear to ensure that efficiencies are realised through authorities working together to avoid unnecessary duplication of effort and to maximise the number of schools across Scotland benefiting from improved facilities while delivering value for money for our investment.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link
The Scottish Futures Trust has made some pretty impressive claims about the number of schools that it will be able to fund through its funding streams, based on driving down procurement costs. Is there scope to reduce the cost of procurement of schools further without negatively impacting on the educational experience provided within them? How many more schools could have been built in the past under the previous school building programme if construction costs similar to the ones that the SFT seems to be confident that it can deliver had been adhered to?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Skills and Lifelong Learning · Ochil
link
The second question is quite speculative, so I will have to take some time to come back to the member with the answer, which I am sure will take a fair bit of working out. However, he is right to point out that the SFT has identified that savings can be made by authorities working together. I know from my own experience that small councils found it extremely difficult and expensive to put together private finance initiative projects, because they had to take on all the paraphernalia of consultancy fees and devote large amounts of their senior officers’ time to them. They were often replicating work that was being done in a neighbouring authority. Having authorities work together is one way in which the SFT can bear down on costs. By centralising some of the expertise that it has, not least in relation to architecture and the design of schools, it can also increase both the efficiency with which we build the schools and the number of schools that we can build.

The other point that Derek Brownlee rightly raises relates to construction costs. I think that some of the confusion over costs has arisen because we have announced our programme of school building at 2009 prices, even though what councils receive will be at the price they have to pay—obviously, the costs will be inflated over the years of the construction. The SFT has identified a reduction in construction costs of perhaps 20 per cent because of the recession. It is right that we take the maximum benefits of low construction costs while they are there.

I will get back to Derek Brownlee on his second question in due course.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link
Is it the case that the Scottish Executive is funding schools only on a like-for-like basis and that any improvement to the facilities must be funded by the local authorities themselves and not by the Scottish Executive?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Skills and Lifelong Learning · Ochil
link
In essence, what the member says is true. We have said to each council that has presented a proposal for either a secondary or a primary school that we will replace the school—it is not exactly like for like as it takes into account the development of the school roll over time—but we will not fund as part of that programme the additional costs of, for example, new community or leisure facilities. We are taking that approach because it maximises the number of schools and the number of pupils we can benefit throughout Scotland. We have taken more than 100,000 pupils out of sub-standard schools already and aim to do much more than that in due course.

One of the constraints that we face is the legacy of previous private finance initiative/public-private partnership costs, £60 million of which was unfunded, which has created a legacy cost for individual councils. As Lord Myners said,

“There is nothing progressive about a Government who consistently spend more than they can raise in taxation, and certainly nothing progressive that endows generations to come with the liabilities incurred by the current generation.”—[Official Report, House of Lords, 8 June 2010; Vol 719, c 625.]

Jeremy Purvis LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link
Is the minister aware that the three PPP secondary schools in the Borders, which he seems to criticise, offer accommodation in excess of that to which the Scottish Futures Trust would contribute? Is it not the case that the generation of schools that were constructed before the Scottish Futures Trust’s one-size-fits-all approach will be better and offer better facilities for our young people than those with a design prescribed centrally by one agency for all schools in Scotland that are funded through the programme?

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Skills and Lifelong Learning · Ochil
link
Perhaps the key fact to bear in mind is that we are spending more—around £700 million per year on average—than the previous Administration did. Also, we are bringing schools to fruition more quickly than the previous Administration did. It took that Administration six and a half years, I think, even if we give it the first two years of the Labour Government in the United Kingdom.

We must try to maximise the number of pupils who can benefit from the programme. I do not criticise the PFI/PPP schools themselves, but I criticise the funding method, which has left us a legacy under which, before they spend 1p on a teacher or any school materials, councils spend 5p in every £1 towards PFI/PPP costs. We cannot simply allow that figure to rise over the next few years if we are not going to damage our children’s education, so it is right that we maximise the value for money that we can get for the programme, which means trying to get as many pupils as possible out of poor conditions.

  1. Schools Debate · 104
  2. Carers Strategy Questions · 10
  3. Adaptations and Home Care Packages (Children) Questions · 4
  4. Business Rates Transitional Relief Scheme Questions · 8
  5. International Flights (Costs) Questions · 6
  6. Renewables (North-east Scotland) Questions · 4
  7. United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Questions · 6
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
  9. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  10. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  11. Asylum Seekers (Detention of Children) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Police Interviews (Procedure) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. Free Personal Care (Affordability) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Publishers Questions · 6
  15. Commercial Television (Local News) Questions · 6
  16. India Questions · 4
  17. Dance and Musical Theatre (Support for Young People) Questions · 6
  18. Malawi (LGBT Citizens) Questions · 6
  19. European Union Accession Eight Countries (Cultural Links) Questions · 4
  20. Taiwan Questions · 6
  21. Schools (Pupil Safety) Questions · 4
  22. New Teachers (Employment) Questions · 4
  23. Dyslexia (Early Identification) Questions · 4
  24. Higher Education (Financial Accountability) Questions · 4
  25. “Go Outdoors!” Questions · 5
  26. School Building Programme Questions · 8
  27. New Primary Schools (East Dunbartonshire Council) Questions · 4
  28. Scots Language Resources (Curriculum for Excellence) Questions · 4
  29. Economy (Support for Young People) Statement · 24
  30. Poverty Framework Debate · 69
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 21
  32. Glasgow’s Subway Members’ business · 25

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.