Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 29 June 2010 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee About 14:30 Procedure 17 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
The Convener
link

Item 3 is an update on our work programme. Are there any comments? Have any issues been missed from the paper that we should consider?

Gavin Brown
link

According to the paper, we have to agree today whether we wish to appoint an external adviser for our budget scrutiny.

The Convener
link

I will come to that. Are there any other comments on the work programme?

Lewis Macdonald
link

It is already a very crowded work programme, so we should exercise caution in how we approach it. Paragraph 5 says that“no further legislation is anticipated”,but we know from experience that legislation can appear unexpectedly from left field, so we should be aware of that possibility.On paragraph 8, clearly, the appraisal of homecoming 2009 and the gathering may take up a bit of time. I know that a parliamentary statement on the gathering is scheduled for tomorrow; nonetheless, there are wider issues that will merit the committee’s attention.

The Convener
link

Thank you for that information. I was not aware of the statement on the gathering.

Lewis Macdonald
link

I am reliably informed.

The Convener
link

If there are no other points on the work programme, we can look specifically at the issue of the budget adviser. My recommendation on this occasion is that we do not seek to appoint a budget adviser, partly because we are one of the committees that receive additional support from the financial scrutiny unit in SPICe. We will probably receive as much advice on the budget from that unit as we require. However, I am open to other thoughts on the matter.

Rob Gibson
link

That is a vote of confidence for SPICe, as far as I am concerned.

The Convener
link

There do not seem to be any dissenting voices, so on this occasion we—

Ms Alexander
link

I think that we should have an external budget adviser, as we had before. Peter Wood served us well in the past, although I do not insist that he should be the budget adviser. Certainly when I was convener of the Finance Committee, we were anxious to see that all subject committees had an external budget adviser. Given that the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth has said that the cuts are the deepest since 1948, that they cover a four-year horizon and that we have already seen cuts of 30 and 40 per cent over the past three years in the two principal agencies that we cover, I think that we should have an external budget adviser. Of course, the work of the adviser should be supplemented by the financial scrutiny unit, as usual. However, I think that an external perspective is always helpful.

Lewis Macdonald
link

I think that that is right. At the moment, it is not clear whether the budget timetable will follow precisely the dates set out in the work programme but, in so far as we can predict the timings, I think that it would be helpful to have an expert adviser. They have certainly been helpful in previous years and, given my suspicions that this budget process will not be any easier than previous processes, I think that it would probably be good to do the same again.

The Convener
link

I will not go to the wall on this. I am not convinced that we get that much value out of budget advisers, but that is just my personal view of the quality of some of the advisers I have had on previous committees. If the committee in general is content to have a budget adviser—

Rob Gibson
link

I would like to be able to choose from a wider range of people, if that is possible. It is always good to get a fresh pair of eyes.

Stuart McMillan
link

If we put out the call and get a range of CVs, do we still have to appoint an adviser?

The Convener
link

No.

Stuart McMillan
link

Okay.

The Convener
link

We will seek CVs for a potential budget adviser and then decide nearer the time whether anyone fits the bill.

  1. 14:30 Enterprise Network Inquiry Committee business · 33
  2. 14:30 Protection of Workers (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 2
  3. 14:30 Work Programme Procedure · 17
  4. 14:30 Energy Inquiry Committee business · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.