The next item is a report from the Auditor General for Scotland on managing NHS waiting lists.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Managing NHS waiting lists”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland 8
- Willie Coffey 6
- The Convener 5
- Angela Canning Audit Scotland 2
- Cathie Craigie 2
- Murdo Fraser 2
- Anne McLaughlin 1
- Ffion Heledd Audit Scotland 1
- Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
The record
28 contributionsI invite Angela Canning, who led on the project, to introduce it to you.
A report on new arrangements for managing NHS waiting lists was published on 4 March 2010. The new waiting times guidance, known as new ways of defining and measuring waiting times—or new ways—came into effect in January 2008, and our report examines whether boards are complying with new guidance for managing patients and recording information. It also considers the impact on patients.The committee will see that we have included in the key messages document cross-references to relevant sections of the main report in response to a suggestion from Willie Coffey. We welcome any feedback from the committee about the new approach.I will start with our findings on waiting times. Our review did not focus on performance against waiting times targets, although we have provided that as context. As the committee will be aware, waiting times targets have reduced in recent years and waiting times have come down in every board since the new ways guidance was introduced, as we highlight in exhibit 4 on page 9 of the main report.The new ways approach has stopped the practice of excluding people from waiting time guarantees, which used to be referred to as hidden waiting lists, and has stopped people waiting indefinitely for treatment. Patients who would previously have been excluded from the waiting time guarantee because they were unavailable for treatment for medical or social reasons—such as being on holiday or having another health condition that needed to be managed first—are now entitled to the same waiting time guarantee as other patients on the waiting list.I will set out how the new guidance is applied. The new system is intended to ensure that patients are managed fairly. It is a relatively complex system, which needs support from many different people to make it work effectively. Exhibit 1 on page 4 of the main report illustrates how it works in practice. Introducing the system to all NHS boards in Scotland was a big task for the NHS. It involved significant changes, including different working practices for staff, extensive training programmes and major changes to local IT systems. That has all taken time, but the system’s aims are now largely being achieved.Boards are able to apply some elements of the guidance differently to reflect patients’ clinical needs, which has led to some differences in how patients are managed. For example, if a patient does not or cannot attend their appointment, boards can refer them back to their GP or keep them on the hospital waiting list. That discretionary element has led to some variation among boards in how patients are managed that is unlikely to be explained by clinical needs alone. We have given more information about that on page 17 of the report.We found that boards record most of the information that they need to manage their waiting lists, but there are some gaps. For example, patients whose waiting time clock has been stopped due to unavailability should have their cases reviewed after 13 weeks but, according to our case-note review, that information is not always routinely recorded, which means that there is a risk of patients slipping through the net.I will outline what the new arrangements mean for patients and the NHS. Patients now get less notice of appointments, particularly as waiting times continue to come down. Since April 2009, NHS boards need to give patients a minimum of only one week’s notice of their appointments, so it is important that they ensure that they provide information that people can understand and that patients understand their own responsibilities. As I mentioned, if patients fail to attend their appointments, they may be referred back to the end of the waiting list or back to their GPs. However, the amount and type of information that patients are given about the implications of failing to attend varies. Two thirds of patients in our survey did not recall receiving any information from their GPs about what might happen if they could not or did not attend an appointment.Good communication is especially important for people who may need additional help to understand information or attend their appointments—for example, older people and people who are homeless, who have learning difficulties or whose first language is not English. We found that NHS boards do not always have a record of patient needs for additional support, such as access to translation services or information in large print, and we recommend that NHS boards improve systems for recording that information and putting in place appropriate support for people who need it. That would help patients have a better experience and help hospitals improve how they communicate with people about their appointments.Colleagues and I are happy to answer any questions that the committee might have.
Thank you, Angela. The recommendations on page 21 say that NHS boards should“review the reasons why patients are coded as being removed from the waiting list as treatment is no longer required and ensure that patients are being managed appropriately and in line with the guidance”.I have read the section in the report that that recommendation refers to. Is there a suggestion that patients have been removed from the waiting list because it was said that treatment was no longer required, when in fact they might have still required treatment? What is that recommendation about?
We did not find any evidence to suggest that people were being removed inappropriately, but the numbers looked quite high. When we followed them up with some of the boards and talked to ISD Scotland, which collates the statistics, one issue that came up was the coding of some information. For example, we were told that, if patients are subsequently treated at the Golden Jubilee hospital, Stracathro or another such service, the code of no longer requiring treatment may be applied. There are, therefore, some coding issues that the NHS is sorting through.
So it is a technical issue. If, for example, someone was referred to the Golden Jubilee hospital, their local board would code them as “treatment no longer required” because they were not being dealt with locally, even though they were in fact being treated.
That could be the case. The numbers look quite large, so we included the recommendation that we want boards to be sure that people are not being removed from the list inappropriately. There is still a risk, so we wanted boards to check.
I thank Audit Scotland for the changes in the summary report that Angela Canning mentioned. As members will have noticed, it leads us into the main report and gives specific references. It gets us there a lot more quickly, so the change is much appreciated.I want to ask about the new ways procedure and the algorithm—the rules about when the clock starts ticking, is reset to zero and so on. What happens if a patient accepts a reasonable offer but the hospital cancels it? I was following the process and thought, “Oh, what happens in that case?”
The patient would not be adversely affected.
Does the clock go back to zero, and does the patient go back to the end of the queue?
No, their clock would keep running.
Would the waiting time increase because it was the hospital that made the cancellation?
No, I think that the patient’s clock would keep running because it was the NHS, not them, that cancelled the appointment. The patient would still have the guarantee to be seen within 16 weeks.
I apologise for asking about that but, from my previous life as a computer scientist and looking at algorithms, I thought, “There’s something missing here.”I am also interested in the point about the qualitative information to potential patients and the short notice period that people experience. Is that having an adverse impact? Is there any hint that people are cancelling more because of the short notice period?
When someone needs to make arrangements such as child care or does not understand English and needs additional help to understand their letter, there may be instances in which that is made more difficult by the fact that they receive, for example, only a week’s notice of their appointment. We did not look at the situation in enough detail to point out huge increases in numbers, but we have heard examples of that.
Time will tell.
There is obviously a balance to be struck between the waiting time targets coming down and giving patients enough notice so that they can make it to the appointment that is booked for them.
Yes, we would not want the shortened notice period to lead to more cancellations by the patients because they cannot organise child care, for example. It will be interesting to see whether that develops any further.
I want to ask about the figures for patients not attending appointments, which are in exhibit 6 on page 14 of the main report. It is interesting that there has been no reduction in the numbers of those not attending out-patient appointments. Can you give us a flavour of what more you think health boards could do to reduce the figure? In NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, the statistic is more than 12 per cent. That is one no-show in eight appointments, which obviously puts a substantial financial and administrative burden on the health service. If we could drive the numbers down, it would make for a much more efficient service.
We have made some recommendations about better communication with patients, and boards have talked about moving towards a system of communicating with patients about their appointment. The process is more iterative: they might contact the patient to ask them to phone to arrange a suitable appointment date. Some boards are doing that to an extent at the moment, but the numbers were not big enough to see any clear relationship between that and a reduction in did-not-attend rates. However, more boards are seeing the opportunities and are trying to move towards communicating a bit more by using things like the text reminders that people get from some dentists, for example, and other ways of being interactive with patients.Areas such as Glasgow and Lanarkshire have high levels of deprivation, so a multitude of factors can affect did-not-attend rates.
It might be worth different boards trialling different methods of contacting people, such as phoning them up to remind them on the day before their appointment, or sending them text messages, to see whether that could help. Great savings could be made if the problem could be addressed.
They might want to consider alarm calls. I know a 19-year-old who did not get her operation because she slept in; I was quite astonished by that. Perhaps the boards should consider waking people up in time.
They could send a taxi to take them to hospital. Where do we stop?
I have agreed with Murdo Fraser twice this morning. Like him, I am concerned that the number of patients who do not show up has not gone down. Your report points out the need to take account of when people have special needs and require support, whether it is to get to the appointment or perhaps to overcome a fear of going. We need to pay attention to that.I have had correspondence with the minister about when the ambulance or hospital transfer service just does not turn up to collect a patient. Did you do any work on that?
We did not look at that as part of this study.
I know about it because I have a constituent who is tallying up the number of no-shows for appointments because of the failure of transport.Could you explain something about exhibit 13? The column headed “Special needs flag” tells us that it has been used very few times.
That is our language. We gave the column that heading, but there is no code as such. We used it when there was evidence of something being recorded in the patient’s case notes or in the electronic system to flag up that the patient needed additional support. It is not that the field was left blank; we found no evidence of any of that information having been recorded. We would have expected more people than that to have had some additional needs.That is one of the issues around how the system is linked together. That information is not routinely collected and available to hospitals. The systems are not there automatically to transfer the information from the GP, who might be closer to it.
As there are no more questions, we will end this meeting on the positive note of Cathie Craigie agreeing twice with Murdo Fraser. Thank you for your contribution.12:14 Meeting continued in private until 12:39.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Mar 2010 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 134
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 28
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.