Item 2 is a follow-up to two reports that have previously been presented to the committee. We have before us Sir John Elvidge; Paul Gray, who has taken up a new post since his previous appearance at the committee; Dr Kevin Woods; and Geoff Huggins, to whom we spoke recently. I welcome you all and thank you for taking the time to be here today. Sir John, is there anything that you want to say in advance of the committee’s questions?
Official Report · Committee
Section 22 Reports
“The 2008/09 Audit of the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland Administration”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sir John Elvidge Scottish Government Permanent Secretary 109
- The Convener 91
- Dr Woods 46
- George Foulkes Lothians) (Lab 34
- Nicol Stephen Aberdeen South) (LD 22
- Geoff Huggins Scottish Government Primary and Community Care Directorate 21
- Cathie Craigie Cumbernauld and Kilsyth) (Lab 14
- Murdo Fraser Mid Scotland and Fife) (Con 13
- Paul Gray Scottish Government Director General Rural Affairs, Environment and Services 9
- Willie Coffey Kilmarnock and Loudoun) (SNP 6
- Bill Kidd Glasgow) (SNP 5
- Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP 3
- Dr Kevin Woods Scottish Government Director General Health and NHS Scotland 1
- Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
The record
375 contributions · showing 1–200It is not my usual habit to detain the committee from questioning for long and I do not want to break that habit, but I will say two or three things. Convener, you made the point that Paul Gray is in a new role. It might help the committee to know that his new role provides continuity of responsibility for the human resources and corporate services function that is relevant to the committee’s interest in this case. Although the nature of Paul’s role has changed, that does not cut across his ability to help the committee.In a sense we are two teams: Kevin Woods and Geoff Huggins in relation to the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland issues; and Paul Gray and me in relation both to the Transport Scotland issues and to such general issues as may arise. As I sought to bring out in my letter, distilling the general issues from the individual cases in front of us would not appear to be the most straightforward process, especially given that the committee has covered some helpful ground in the past. Also, we have reached a conclusion of one phase, in which we agreed to all the recommendations on Transport Scotland in the committee’s previous report. We have given some thought to how we can help the committee with general issues. Two things occur to me. First, I believe that the committee’s work on the reports has opened up some complex and difficult issues to do with the application of the law, some of which are still being explored. There is an interesting wider set of issues there. Secondly, there is a territory to do with proactive disclosure, which is relevant here in a general sense. I am conscious that that is a territory on which there is currently a great deal of activity at a United Kingdom level and to some extent at a Scottish level. One of the conclusions that I draw from that is that, with so much around the issue of proactive disclosure under debate, it is slightly difficult to get our bearings at the moment. However, one of the things that I—and I hope the committee—would find helpful is to try to crystallise positions on the issue of proactive disclosure as those various debates coalesce. It would have been my intention in any case to have discussions with the variety of bodies that will be affected by the crystallisation of those positions. However, I hope that it is helpful to the committee if I make it clear that we would be happy to embrace Audit Scotland within the boundaries of those consultations, so that it is an integral part of helping to formulate future positions, rather than simply being left in the role of commenting on that after it has happened.
Thank you. To clarify, does Paul Gray still have responsibility for human resources?
That is right.
Human resources is now part of the rural affairs team.
It is part of my oversight as director general. The HR and corporate services directorate reports to me.
That is an interesting combination, but I am sure that there is a logic to it. Committee members will ask some general questions, and then we will separate out Transport Scotland from the Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland Administration, because we are aware that there are specific and sensitive issues in relation to the tribunal that may mean that we need a slightly different approach. As far as is possible, we will separate the discussion on the two issues.
Good morning, gentlemen. Sir John, I refer you to your letter to the convener of 17 February, in paragraph 5 of which you pointed out that a small proportion of departures from the civil service involve a compromise agreement. You stated:“One key reason for using a compromise agreement is to ensure that an employee discontinues or agrees not to commence litigation against the public body leading to a saving in public expenditure and avoidance of disruption to organisational effectiveness.”Can you give the committee examples of when the risk of litigation may arise?
Yes. Most commonly, the risk of litigation arises when there is a possibility of action that might lead to the employer wanting to terminate the employment of the employee. If, as is often the case, the employee is going to contest that process through an employment tribunal, substantial legal costs are often associated with that process. That is the most common example.There are two halves to the overall process: the internal disciplinary process, which can be lengthy; and the process that might follow. During the internal disciplinary process, one of the things that one cannot do, without constructively dismissing the person, is to fill their job with a new substantive employee. One of the business disruption issues is therefore that one must freeze a position. That matters less at more junior levels, and the vast majority of compromise agreements are with relatively junior staff, but the more senior a person is, the more relevant that becomes to the functioning of a part of the business. That is therefore the broad picture.Litigation and disruption do not always go together. There might be a disruption risk that involves no litigation risk, and there might be a litigation risk that involves no disruption risk. They are therefore separate categories; sometimes both will occur in the same case, but sometimes only one will be present.
You said that one of the risks might be that an employee will proceed to an industrial tribunal to contest the decision. Would you always seek to find a compromise agreement? If you felt that you had a strong case, would you take it to the tribunal?
Comparing the volume of cases that go to employment tribunals with the volume of compromise agreement cases, we find that the latter volume is very much smaller. We do not automatically use compromise agreements in all cases; in the majority of cases, we do not use them. A judgment is made about the circumstances of each individual case.
You also cited the difficulties in ensuring that business continues and the job gets done, particularly with posts at a senior level. Are you able to bring somebody in to fill the position concerned while any litigation is on-going?10:15
We can bring somebody in temporarily, but we cannot substantively replace the person. Bringing someone in temporarily covers some of the needs of a business, but it does not have the same effect on the running of a business as having a substantive replacement. Of course, it also doubles the costs. Someone who might return to work is being paid to be at home and someone else is being paid to substitute for them. In addition to the legal costs, that is one of the cost issues in the value-for-money calculation.
You would pay somebody to stay at home if they were suspended from their role, but not if they were dismissed from it.
Indeed. However, we cannot go straight to dismissal without a disciplinary process, so there are no circumstances in which we would not have that period. To be clear, it is not inevitable that disciplinary proceedings against somebody will mean that they are suspended from their post. The individual circumstances must be considered. Sometimes, disciplinary proceedings proceed while someone is still in post, although you will appreciate that it is not a perfect arrangement for the smooth running of an organisation to have someone in a role and to go through disciplinary proceedings against them. However, it is not always the case that disciplinary proceedings mean that we pay the cost of someone not being at work. That is why a case-by-case judgment must be made about such issues.
These may be questions for Paul Gray to answer although, obviously, the witnesses themselves will decide who answers. I have one general question and a couple of specific ones. In Sir John Elvidge’s letter to the convener, he says that guidance is not issued to directorates on compromise agreements and confidentiality clauses because those are agreed with the HR directorate. What guidance and criteria does the HR directorate use in those instances? How does the HR directorate ensure that consistency and value for money are achieved? What reporting is made to accountable officers?
I have three points on the criteria. First, in entering into any such agreement, we have direct regard to the provisions of the “Scottish Public Finance Manual”. We must have a value-for-money assessment and certain conditions are laid down within which that takes place. Secondly, any compromise agreement must be consistent with the current legal framework, so we always take legal advice before we enter into such an agreement. Thirdly, we must have regard to the particular circumstances of the case. The cases are varied and, generally, the circumstances are relatively unique. I can put that into context for the committee if it would be helpful. I cannot give a breakdown year by year, because we would run into identifying individuals but, in the past three years, there have been fewer than 10 compromise agreements in total for Scottish Government core staff, which is set against a total of 753 people leaving during that period. That gives the committee a sense of proportion.On value for money, I have already referred to the constraints of the “Scottish Public Finance Manual”. On consistency, such cases are always dealt with by our HR professional advisers team—that is not the team’s only role, but we would not enter into such agreements without going through that team.On reporting to accountable officers, the reports to the corporate audit committee in the Scottish Government would refer to any such agreements. I am happy to tell the committee that I have been questioned by the corporate audit committee in the past about these matters. The permanent secretary, as the principal accountable officer, is of course supported by the corporate audit committee in the discharge of his duties.
You said that each of these circumstances has different elements, which have to be negotiated separately, and legal advice has to be taken on each of them. Does each organisation have unique requirements or does the background of the individual senior staff member necessitate the negotiation in each instance?
In referring to 10 compromise agreements, I was referring not just to senior staff but to all staff across the Scottish Government. The uniqueness of the circumstances arises from the fact that in each case a different issue might have given rise to the need to enter into this kind of discussion. This is not about unique contracts or organisations; I am talking about the core of the Scottish Government, in which, in broad terms, I would expect everyone to be operating under roughly the same contractual conditions. You will appreciate that I am speaking in general terms and not about unique contracts.
Sir John, I am interested in what you said about proactive disclosure and change of culture at Government level. I take you back to paragraphs 8, 9 and 10 of your reply to Hugh Henry’s letter, in which you respond to question 4. We asked whether you shared the view of the Auditor General for Scotland that, as a general principle, the Parliament and this committee have a right to know the amounts spent on senior officials, including any amounts that are covered by compromise deals. You have given us quite a detailed and comprehensive reply in those three paragraphs, but I would like you to give a slightly more general response, particularly in the light of what you said earlier. Do you think that Governments should be working towards that general principle?
The direction of travel is towards more proactive disclosure. I am deliberately using the words “proactive disclosure” because, as we all know, the committee has the power to obtain disclosure of anything it chooses. This is not a debate about whether disclosure happens but a debate about how it happens. The general debate is moving in the direction of more proactive disclosure. I understand the reasons for that and I see the merits of it. What I do not know is at what boundary those debates will settle. They are not purely Scottish debates.
Okay. I will perhaps put that question again in a slightly different way. All I am trying to draw out from you is whether, as a matter of principle, you accept that there should be disclosure.
As a matter of principle, I certainly accept that there should be disclosure. The arguments about proactive disclosure are different. When we disclose proactively, we are putting into the public domain detailed information about individuals. The question that we always have to ask is why are we doing that and what is the public interest reason for it. I know that some people take the view that absolutely anybody who is paid from the public purse should expect their rights to privacy to be negated as a consequence of that fact. That is not the view that I take, and it is not where the general debate seems to be. The question that one must ask is when does the public interest that would be served by proactive, automatic disclosure, as opposed to selective disclosure for a reason, override the rights that people who are employed in the public sector share with other citizens. Self-evidently, that is not the most straightforward debate in the world.In the past, the line has been drawn around the groups of individuals who control the running of public sector organisations. It is around the remuneration of those groups of individuals, such as the board of the Scottish Government or the board of Transport Scotland, that the line is currently drawn, although the debate is moving in the direction of disclosure of the remuneration of a wider range of people, perhaps by reference to post or salary. I can see the debate, but I cannot yet clearly see the principles that will determine the outcome of it.My objective is that we should fit into a pattern of best practice. That is why the interaction with the wider debate is important, as I said in my opening remarks.
The way in which you have set that out is extremely helpful.How do you think that we will come to a conclusion in that debate and who will help us to do so?
That is a jolly interesting question.The UK Government will have a significant role to play in formulating general propositions on that. The issue for us will be about where there might be a case for a different approach to be adopted in Scotland, in so far as we have authority to depart from the general UK position. The drawing of conclusions, or at least the formulating of propositions that might be consulted on is likely to take place at UK level, and there is a reasonably active debate between the UK Government and the Westminster Parliament on those issues.
Good morning, Sir John. I will stick with the issue that Murdo Fraser raised in relation to paragraph 8 of your response to the convener. You say that employment contracts do not always include an obligation to disclose remuneration. We have talked about that in general terms. I hope that you agree that there is a perception that the public want to know more about the salaries, bonuses, expenses and compromise agreements of senior staff. The direction of travel that you describe is to be welcomed.Is the shift towards greater openness such that we should obtain people’s agreement at the contract stage, when we take them on, to the disclosure of such matters, should something subsequently happen that would require that, or do you still think that that would be overridden by guidance such as that which is contained in the financial reporting manual? What are your views on that? Will we eventually arrive at a point at which there is a shift in the balance whereby we favour what the public want to know rather than what the private individual wishes to keep private?10:30
Yes. It is my unequivocal view that that is the direction of travel—I am quite clear about that. As I said to Mr Fraser, I can see the direction of travel clearly enough, but I cannot see the end point of the journey.At the risk of getting abstract and philosophical on you, I suggest that privacy is a social construct in individual societies. Where the boundaries of privacy lie is a judgment that each society makes for itself, and societies make different judgments on that at different times. Nevertheless, I recognise the point that you make, that we seem to be seeing a shift in social views about boundaries of privacy. That is observable, and it is one of the things that make me think that the direction of travel is clear.
What is your view on the specific point about the contract, though? Do you think that we can do something at this stage, even in the framework in which we are living? In taking people on, could we ask them to consent to disclosure if something were to happen subsequently during their employment, or would we still be bound by the framework and rules within which we operate?
My honest answer is that I am not certain. I am convinced that everybody wants to explore how far in that direction we can go. Broadly speaking, I think that there are separate issues for us in relation to those who are employed below the senior civil service and those who are employed in the senior civil service. I do not have the same flexibility to make a determination about the nature of standard contracts for the senior civil service that exists in relation to staff who are below the senior civil service.The question is whether that is in line with general expectations of what employers ask of people or whether one might be creating a barrier to recruitment. It would be asking someone to sign up for disclosure in future circumstances of which they could not possibly have any knowledge. It would be asking them to agree in advance to disclosure irrespective of the circumstances in which they may find themselves. Typically, people are reluctant to enter into contractual conditions whose consequences they cannot predict. It is roughly the equivalent of—although not as immediate as—saying to people, “We will pay you whatever we feel like paying you at the time,” rather than giving them certainty about what they will be paid.Everybody wants to get as far with disclosure as they can and I suspect that, if making it a mandatory stipulation that people agree to disclosure in all circumstances proved feasible, that is where we, as employers, would like to get to. However, a contract is a relationship with two sides and what the employer wants is not the only consideration.
We have referred to the fact that the UK Treasury has been consulting on proposals to amend the reporting of civil service exit packages in the accounts, among other things. In paragraph 11 of your letter, you rightly say that you are going to wait for the outcome of that consultation. However, you then state:“Nevertheless, we believe that we should operate on the basis that disclosure will be expected, other than in exceptional circumstances.”What exceptional circumstances do you have in mind? Can you give us an example?
I will try, although “exceptional circumstances” is a phrase that allows for the fact that none of us can imagine every possible future circumstance that might exist.The most obvious situations are those in which the individual already has the right to refuse disclosure and exercises that right, or in which the individual can—exceptionally—make a compelling case that disclosure would have consequences that are disproportionate to any benefit.I will hypothesise—I do not have specific cases in mind. Let us imagine a case in which the disclosure of information about an individual would impact negatively on the interests of third parties.
In such situations, one might at least pause and ask whether there is an overriding argument against disclosure. I do not find it particularly easy to think of cases in which that would be so, but I can imagine the theoretical possibility.
Who would decide which circumstances were exceptional?
Ultimately, we have to decide the terms on which we employ people. In so far as that is bound up with the initial discussion pertaining to their employment, it takes us back to the question of contracts. In that context, it is us.Where it is not a contractual right of the individual, then again, ultimately—well, in some circumstances, it is us, as the individual. I am sorry—I am trying to get my logic clear. If there is an agreement to be disclosed, it is always us, ultimately. There will be cases in which, if we make it plain that we intend to disclose, the result will be that one will not have an agreement with an individual. However, that is not what my words are intended to cover; my words must cover circumstances in which there is something to disclose, rather than those in which there is not, because an agreement was never reached.I am sorry if that was a convoluted answer, but trying to imagine the circumstances in which a general principle would not apply is not the most straightforward thing to do.
Let us now move on to the specifics, dealing first with Transport Scotland. Before I invite members to ask their questions, it would be useful if you could clarify some aspects of detail.Dr Reed indicated that he wished to exercise his right to take early retirement. Is that right?
No. As he said in his evidence to the committee on 14 January 2009, he was not taking early retirement; he was over the age of 60.
Sorry.
He said that, if it was in the interests of the business, he was prepared to go before the end of the period to which he was contractually entitled to employment. It is important to be clear about this. He did not say, “I want to go”; he said that he could see that there were reasons why it might be in the best interests of the business to change chief executive at a certain point in the cycle of the business of the organisation. He was prepared to go, in those circumstances.
So Dr Reed approached Paul Gray and said, “If it is in the best interests of the business, I am entitled to go just now—I can go on my pension. It is not early retirement; I have the legal entitlement to go, and I am prepared, in the best interests of the business, to leave early if you think that that will help.” And you said yes.
Yes.
He made that generous offer to go in order to help the business, and he was at an age and had the length of service that gave him entitlement to his pension.
Let us leave length of service aside for a moment, because there are two different issues here. He was at an age at which he was entitled, if he left, to take his pension immediately.
Without any clawback, which is sometimes available if someone goes early.
Yes.
So he was entitled to the full pension that he had accrued.
Yes—he was entitled to the pension that he had accrued; that is why I am putting to one side the length of service issue. He had not maximised his pension entitlement. Had he stayed in employment, his pension entitlement would have grown.
Right. And he retired under civil service pension conditions.
Yes.
How does that scheme operate? Is it on a system of eightieths, fiftieths, sixtieths or seventieths?
It is on a system of eightieths. So that there is no lack of clarity, I should say that I do not have the precise details of Dr Reed’s length of service in front of me, but the general provisions of the civil service pension scheme are based on eightieths, and a lump sum is associated with that.
Yes—and the lump sum is usually three times the pension that a person leaves with.
We need to be a tiny bit cautious here, because there is now more than one civil service pension scheme. The long-standing civil service pension scheme has been superseded by two alternative pension schemes.
Let us leave the alternatives aside and focus on the scheme under which Dr Reed left. You would know about that scheme, because you agreed to it.
I am saying that I do not have the precise details of Dr Reed’s pension entitlement in front of me today.
Leaving that aside, you signed off the decision that he could leave, so you would know which of the various schemes he left under.
I would, but I would need to check that for precision.
Okay. You can come back and tell us which specific scheme it was, and what the general terms were for anyone in that scheme. How significant are the differences between the schemes? Is the system of eightieths affected?
Yes.
What are the alternatives?
One of the schemes, which requires higher contributions from the individual, is based on sixtieths, and the lump sum is not an automatic part of the pension—that scheme gives the individual more flexibility to trade between a lump sum and the pension entitlement.
Okay. It would be interesting to know which scheme it was, because it is clear that the scheme significantly influences what an individual gets.For argument’s sake, let us say that someone who may not have reached 40 years’ service, but who had certainly reached in excess of 30 years’ service, was on the system of eightieths and retired on a salary of £122,000. That would have been Dr Reed’s salary at the time, because we know that he got £61,000 in lieu of six months’ notice.Someone with forty eightieths would have been entitled to a pension of £61,000 a year, and someone with 30 years’ service would have been entitled to a pension of £45,000. We can assume that if it was the eightieths scheme, and if the person had somewhere between 30 and 40 years’ service—which Dr Reed probably had, given that he had a long history of working in local government, Strathclyde passenger transport and so on—the pension would be somewhere between £45,000 and £61,000 a year. Is the lump sum under that scheme three times the pension?
Yes.
So he would have retired on a lump sum of anywhere in the region of £150,000 to £180,000.
You are making an assumption that—
But it is that scheme.
No—you are making an assumption that Dr Reed transferred his non-civil service employment into the civil service pension scheme when he joined the civil service, where he was employed for a relatively short time. I do not know the answer to that question.10:45
But the local government scheme also works on eightieths and has similar provisions. Dr Reed was at an age at which he could have taken most if not all of his pension if he did not commute it into the civil service scheme. We could be a bit out, but I am assuming that it would not be any less than £45,000 to £50,000, and it could be as high as over £60,000, with a lump sum, if that applied, of between £120,000 to £180,000. So he approaches you and says, “If it is in the interests of the service, I am prepared to go,” and you say, “Good idea,” knowing that he will go with a very generous pension and possibly also a lump sum. You decide, because it is a structural issue—we will come to that in a minute—that you will give him another £61,000. Is that right?
Yes.
So he was given another £61,000 on top of what he had legally accrued and was entitled to—I am not quibbling with that aspect, as that is what is provided by the scheme. We are talking about someone going out with a pretty generous pension and a pretty generous package generally. However, you decide that, for structural reasons, it is a good idea for him to go and that you will give him £61,000 and get somebody else in, even though the only saving might have been for the period when no one was in post, because this was not a case of putting three posts into two or four into three or whatever. That is the general background.
That is one way of looking at it.
Okay. What other way of looking at it is there?
If you were him, you would have a series of entitlements and could stay in your job and earn your full salary for the remainder of the year until you were 65. You would also increase your pension entitlement, both through time and because the base figure might change over that period. So you have all your pension entitlement in your hand and, as an individual, you are making a choice between having additional income of £X by staying in employment and considering what will happen to you if you leave employment. Your pension entitlement is a neutral element between those two choices. There is also a framework of decisions for what happens when people leave employment. We did not think, “Let’s invent a framework for this individual case.” The civil service compensation scheme exists to create a general framework for discussions about people leaving employment. We worked within the framework of that scheme in the circumstances of this case.
I understand that. However, Dr Reed decided, for very altruistic reasons, that, given everything that was going on at the time, it would be in the best interests of the organisation if he left, as that would enable the organisation to move on.
I think that you are putting his position a bit too firmly.
For whatever reason, he decided to leave early. You told us that he approached you and said, “I think that it might be in the best interests of the organisation if I left.”
He did, but you are characterising that as him deciding to leave; I do not think that that is an accurate characterisation.
He made the offer.
He said that he was willing to have a discussion about it in the interests of the business.
He made the offer and you accepted it. You then decided, after he made that offer, that you would be entitled under the scheme, if the decision was made for structural reasons, to give him six months’ pay in lieu of notice, and you paid him £61,000 on that basis. Is that correct?
Yes.
Okay.
I do not mean to split hairs, but I did not decide what we were entitled to do. We examined what his rights were in a discussion about his situation.
I do not want to split hairs, but if he had said, “I would like to leave, as I am entitled to do, because I can take my pension,” and you had said, “That is fine. I think that, given your age and the service that you have given, we are comfortable with that, so we will part ways. Thank you very much for your long and outstanding service,” that could have been done. Instead, you decided—it was not his decision—that there were structural reasons, so you paid him £61,000.
If he had said, “I am going, and I do not care what you think,” that would have been his right and he would have been in one set of circumstances. However, that is not what he said. He said, “Let us have a discussion about what would be in the best interests of the business.” Implicitly, that discussion was also about what would be fair to him.
I do not dispute any of that. I am merely trying to establish the fact that he approached you with an offer, which you reflected on; you then decided, “Yes, that would be a good idea.” You then looked at the rules governing the situation and realised that, if his departure was for structural reasons, you would be liable to pay £61,000. If it was not for structural reasons, there would have been no entitlement to £61,000. Is that right?
There would have been an entitlement to three months’ salary, which would be half that amount.
A person would be entitled to three months’ salary if you decided that you were happy for them to leave. However, that would not apply if someone just walked out the door saying, “Look, I’m leaving.” There would not necessarily be an entitlement to three months’ salary if the person just said, “I have had enough.”
You are absolutely right—
It seems that you decided, “That is a good idea. We can either let you go with three months’ salary or with six months’ salary if the departure is for structural reasons.” I will come back to those issues. George Foulkes and Cathie Craigie have some further questions.
Good morning, Sir John. I thank you for your helpful written reply to the convener’s letter, which asked various questions. In paragraph 14 of your letter, you state:“I had identified the need for a re-examination of the structural relationship of Transport Scotland”.When did you identify that need?
I had been thinking about that in the course of 2008.
When did you come to a conclusion that that was required?
Do you mean was there a single moment when I thought, “Yes, we must do this”? I am not sure that it works quite like that.
So you do not have the dates on which you made decisions. When did you intimate to Transport Scotland that you thought that a restructuring would be appropriate?
I intimated that to Transport Scotland in a sense when I intimated to Dr Reed that this was part of our thinking, but I did not—
When did you intimate to him that that was part of your thinking?
In the course of the discussions about whether there were business reasons for him to go.
Can you give us a date or a month?
I cannot do that without checking.
You knew that you were appearing before the committee today. You knew that you had written that down. Presumably, you might have anticipated some of the questions that we might ask.
I might have anticipated some of those questions.
Did you not anticipate that some of us might want to know when that was communicated to Dr Reed? Whether you made that decision before or after Dr Reed decided to take that option is absolutely material to the whole issue that the convener has pursued.
It is material up to a point. As I have said, the issue was in my mind before Dr Reed intimated that he was open to a discussion about whether he might leave the organisation.
When did he intimate to you that he was open to such a discussion? You state in your letter that“He expressed this view to me in discussions during the final quarter of 2008.”Can you tell me exactly when?
I could probably do that by checking my diary, but I do not have that information in my head.
Did you not anticipate that we might ask about that? Absolutely material to the whole issue that the convener has been pursuing is whether your decision to restructure came before or after Dr Reed’s decision to go.
I have just told you. It came before.
Which came before?
My thinking about restructuring came before Dr Reed’s conversation with me.
When did you tell Dr Reed about that thinking?
In the course of the discussions, out of fairness, I made Dr Reed aware in general terms that there was a structural dimension to our thinking. However, I did not set out to have a discussion with him about what the structural changes would be.
Okay. Let us examine your decision, then. You say in paragraph 14 of your letter:“In particular ... it had been 3 years since the Agency’s inception”.Is it part of your policy to review the position of chief executive after three years? Dr Woods might be interested in your answer.
You are talking about two separate issues: whether I review the position of chief executives; and whether I review structural issues.
Well, the two are—
No, they are not; they are completely different subjects. As it happens, the civil service has a general policy for people who move towards being four years in any post of reviewing whether they are still the right fit for a post. The requirements of posts change over time, and the person who is absolutely right for a job at one point in time may not be absolutely right for that job four years later. Right across the board, we have a general policy of looking at individuals in that position. However, that is not what happened here. What I did was look at a major and relatively recent shift in organisational structure. The decision to create Transport Scotland was a major machinery-of-government decision by the previous Government. Three years or so in, I thought that it was the right moment to ask, “Has this machinery-of-government change delivered the aspirations that underpinned it? Is it still the right machinery-of-government arrangement for the circumstances that we are now in?”
Okay. Well, can you tell the committee what changes there have been in the machinery of government—the structure of Transport Scotland? How is the situation different from what it was when Dr Reed was in charge?
It is not substantially different at the moment, but a significant amount of review work has been proceeding. We may make an announcement about those issues shortly, but I cannot pre-empt that.
But you made that decision in the final quarter of 2008, and it is now 2010.
I know.
So Dr Reed left his post in February 2009, on the basis that you were restructuring. It is now a year later, but you have not made any decisions yet about restructuring.
That is right. We are talking about the right structure of government to administer more than £2 billion of public expenditure.
We know that, but—
I do not make those decisions overnight. I did think that we might come to some decisions quickly. One of the first things that I asked the new chief executive to do was to have a fresh look at the situation and tell me whether he thought that there was a clear-cut and overwhelming case for changes that we might act on in the short term. His advice was that the issues were more complex and would require more extensive work, which is why we have undertaken more extensive work.
And that is irrespective of the fact that you said in reply to me earlier that you had considered and discussed restructuring during all of 2008—it was the subject of detailed discussion.
No, not detailed discussion. Just because I can see that there is a major issue, that does not mean that I know what the right solution is going forward. It is perfectly reasonable to say that there is a question to be answered but not to know immediately what the answer is.
But you obviously chose your new chief executive—in rather a strange way, by the way—
There was nothing strange about it whatsoever.
We will no doubt come back to that. In fact, you said that he was selected“taking into account the skills and experience required for the post, from the group of around 40 Director level staff”.David Middleton was at the Scotland Office, which I know quite well. He was previously head of local government and external relations, and head of agriculture. What has that experience got to do with running Transport Scotland?
You are being a bit selective about his career.
But that is his career in the Scottish Executive.
Well, it is his career in the Scottish Executive, but previously in his career in Scotland he had been a head of one of the transport divisions and a head of one our finance divisions, so he had a useful combination of experience and skills.11:00
More so than any of the other 40 director-level staff?
That was my judgment.
Why did you not consider anyone else? Did you intimate to people within the Scottish Government or Scottish Executive that the post was vacant?
Who else do you expect me to have considered?
I am asking the questions. Did you intimate to people in the Scottish Executive that the post was vacant?
No. I—
No, you did not. So you just considered people whom you wanted to take on the job.
No, I considered the entire population of people who were already at that level within the Scottish Government.
The post was not publicly advertised and it was not intimated around the Scottish Executive so that anyone could apply. You just chose your man to do your bidding. Is that right?
I and the board, as we frequently do, reviewed the stock of people whom we had at a particular level and made a choice from the skills that we had available. This is entirely routine practice.
It may be routine practice, but is it sensible, wise and appropriate, in appointing someone to a position as important as that of the head of Transport Scotland, who is now responsible for the Forth replacement crossing and a range of other major things, to appoint someone internally who has almost no experience of the area? Is that appropriate? Is that sensible?
You can malign David Middleton’s reputation—
I am not maligning him.
Yes, you are. You are implicitly criticising his fitness to do the job.
I am going to move on—
I am asking a question.
No. Excuse me—
Of course I thought it was sensible, or I would not have done it.
I am grateful to you for your answers, Sir John.
Okay. Thank you for that, Sir John. We remain on structural changes. I call Murdo Fraser.
Will you remind me when Transport Scotland was set up? Was it in 2005?
Let me try to track it. It was a manifesto commitment before the 2003 election and it was part of the partnership agreement in 2003. My recollection is that Transport Scotland was fully vested in April 2005. Mr Stephen might know the answer better than I do.
The notes that we have been given state that it began to operate in January 2006.
Okay. Well, I may be wrong.
Just so that I am clear, is it correct that Dr Reed was the chief executive from the outset?
Yes.
He was there from January 2006, so he was in the organisation for less than three years.
Yes.
Why was it felt necessary, given—
If my memory serves me correctly—perhaps someone can help me—I do not think that we appointed him after the organisation had formally commenced business. We appointed him to bring the organisation into existence, so he was employed for a longer period.
It might help if I give the committee the facts that I have in front of me. Dr Reed joined the Scottish Government as chief executive of Transport Scotland on 8 August 2005. Before that, Dr Reed had an inward secondment from Strathclyde Passenger Transport Authority to the Scottish Government from 25 June 2002 to 31 December 2004 as a rail policy adviser. Those are the straightforward facts of the matter.
Thank you. What I am trying to get at is this. Transport Scotland was up and running in January 2006. It was less than three years after the organisation became fully functioning when you started to come to the conclusion that it needed reform or that, as you put it, there were structural reasons why Dr Reed should be replaced.
I thought that there were questions to be asked. Some of the assumptions on which Transport Scotland was created seemed to me to be no longer valid. In case I frighten lots of people, let me say immediately that I had not concluded that it was wrong to create Transport Scotland or that it should be discontinued. I had concluded that material things had changed and that we needed to ask whether we still had the right organisational structure.
Was that conclusion in any way related to Dr Reed’s performance as chief executive?
No.
You concluded that structural changes were required within Transport Scotland, but as of today, more than a year later, those changes have not happened.
Yes.
Why was it necessary to have Dr Reed depart his post in such a rush and at a cost of £61,000 to the taxpayer if those changes have not happened a year later?
The structural changes were not the sole reason for the decision: there were two broad sets of considerations. One was that Transport Scotland had just brought to a natural break point three major pieces of work. Apart from the renewal of the rail franchise that we have talked about extensively, the planning of the Forth replacement crossing had reached a major break point in its development, and the strategic review of the trunk roads network had just been concluded. All those issues had occupied the chief executive considerably, and the next phase of action was going to need substantial chief executive involvement. One part of the reasoning, which was the part that Dr Reed could see, was that on two of those three fronts—the Forth replacement crossing and the trunk roads programme—the organisation was moving into major new phases of work. Dr Reed asked whether having discontinuity in the post of chief executive nine or 10 months into those new phases of work would be in their best interests. That was one dimension of the argument.The other dimension of the argument was that I thought that it was a good time to reflect on structural issues. As I said earlier, I rather hoped that that might be a quicker process than it has turned out to be. However, the work that we have done has substantiated the view that significant and complex issues had to be explored, which is why it has taken us a long time, although I hope that we are very near to a conclusion and an announcement.
I understand your point about the work programme, but changes in the work programme do not constitute the structural grounds that would trigger the additional payment in lieu of notice to the chief executive. So, although that might be interesting, it is not relevant to the terms of Dr Reed’s departure. The only thing that is relevant to that is the structural changes. I am concerned that those structural changes that were so significant that you deemed it to be appropriate to give him six months’ salary have not happened more than a year later.
I can understand that, but the whole case does not have to be structural. My position was that there were various reasons why it was in the interests of the business, some of which were slightly intangible value-for-money reasons. Effective management of the trunk roads programme and the Forth replacement crossing project—the largest single capital infrastructure project that we have ever progressed in Scotland—include substantial value-for-money issues. Ensuring that we are managing those projects in the most effective way possible is about value for money.The fact that part of the case was structural led us to the conclusion that we would have been being dishonest in our dealings with Dr Reed if we had not acknowledged that there was a structural dimension to our side of the decision.
I have a final question, which I must put to you, Sir John. Had none of this anything to do with the concerns that had been expressed by Audit Scotland and others about the director of finance and corporate services at Transport Scotland?
It had nothing at all do with that. I delayed Dr Reed’s departure slightly because he was so keen to come, as the accountable officer, to the committee to articulate the views that you heard from him. It will not have been lost on you that Dr Reed had strong views about the Audit Scotland report on the First ScotRail refranchise, and strong views about the implicit criticism of the governance of the organisation under his leadership. There was no element of wanting to get him out of the line of fire on those things, nor was the fact that those things had happened any part of the case. Although, as I said earlier, the governance around the interests could have been better conducted, I absolutely share Dr Reed’s view that the fact that there were flaws in the governance had no material influence on the First ScotRail refranchise. There was nothing in that episode that would have led me to form negative views of Dr Reed’s capability as a chief executive.
Can I just stick with that for a moment? You have said this morning that a range of issues were involved in deciding whether it would be appropriate to allow Dr Reed to go. In paragraph 15 of your letter to us, you say:“The contractual terms of Dr Reed conferred an entitlement on him of six months notice ... if structural grounds were involved. Consequently, we took the view that he was entitled to rely upon the longer period of notice ... and I agreed to payment on this basis.”That is, you agreed to payment on the basis that structural grounds were involved. So, the reason for the payment had nothing to do with the other factors; it was based purely on structural grounds. Yet, we have heard this morning that there were no structural grounds—there has been no change to the structure.
That is not the same as saying that there are no structural grounds. If I may say so, that is a complete distortion of the arguments.
Okay. Forgive me—I do not operate at the same level as you. Nevertheless, a payment on the basis of structural grounds indicates to me that there is going to be some change to the structure, but there has been no change to the structure. For the life of me, I cannot see where the structural grounds are.
You may see when we complete the process of considering the structural issues.
That may or may not happen at some time in the future—Dr Reed could have stayed and you could have made the decision about his going at that point. Nothing happened after you decided to use £61,000 of taxpayers’ money on the basis that there was a structural change. There was no change to the structure, irrespective of the fact that you have in your head a change that might happen in the future. Nothing has happened in that period. Is that correct?
There have been modest structural changes during that period
What “modest structural changes” took place—as a result of the chief executive leaving and a new chief executive coming in—that were pertinent to that post?
You are right to believe that they are not related to the chief executive post. There have been structural changes—
So, we did not need to pay £61,000 to make those structural changes.
No: my view was that, if we were to take a completely fresh look at a range of structural issues, we would be assisted in doing that by having a chief executive bringing a fresh pair of eyes to it. This was not a set of issues specifically about whether there was a structural change around the chief executive post. There were a range of structural issues that I wanted to examine, and I wanted a fresh look at those issues.11:15
We experimented with some structural changes including, as you know, changing the organisation of Transport Scotland’s finance function and pushing together two senior posts for a period to see whether that gave us a better functioning solution. However, there were—and are—wider structural changes that I think might be possible. You are right to say that at that stage I did not know how long it was going to take to get the answer to that. However, I was clear that it would be difficult to start the process without a fresh pair of eyes.
Yes, I know, but let us suppose for argument’s sake that it was decided to reduce six clerical and administration posts in Transport Scotland to three. Would such a structural change, which has nothing to do with his post, be sufficient to justify paying the chief executive £61,000 to leave?
It would not, in my view, but you are making a false comparison. A decision on the structure of the board on which the chief executive works is a decision that cannot, in my view, be taken without the chief executive’s engagement. I have been talking not about clerical assistants, but about board-level posts. I understand that you are frustrated that the structural change has not yet happened. I hoped that we would be able to get to structural changes earlier that would give us a better way of handling the whole of the Scottish Government’s transport business, but we are not there.
Are the changes that you are about to make with Mr Middleton in post solely dependent on Dr Reed’s having left when he did?
No. As I have said, I thought that the examination of a series of choices, some of which might not necessarily be perceived as being in Transport Scotland’s organisational interests, would be better conducted using a fresh pair of eyes. That was why there was a structural dimension. It is not necessary for 100 per cent of the reasons for Dr Reed’s departure to be structural for there to be a structural element to all this. In my view, we would have been dishonest in our dealings with Dr Reed not to have acknowledged that one half of the argument was structural.
So—one half of the argument was structural. Can you confirm for the record that at the time of the audit you did not mention that there were structural reasons and that what you mentioned were exceptional circumstances?
Audit Scotland had no dialogue with me whatever.
Okay—not with you, yourself. When I say “you”, I am speaking about you collectively. When Audit Scotland discussed with your team the reasons for Dr Reed’s departure, structural grounds were not mentioned. Instead, what was mentioned were exceptional circumstances.
I cannot pretend to know the detail of all the exchanges with Transport Scotland.
Okay. Would Paul Gray know?
No, convener. That is largely because I was not there in the intervening period. If it is helpful, we can try to find out, but I just do not know and would not pretend to know.
As staff from Audit Scotland are with us, we can establish whether Audit Scotland was told that. Do any of you have any documentation or information that might confirm whether or not that was what was said?
The section 22 report advised the Parliament that the chief executive’s contractual notice period was three months and went on to say:“In this instance, the Scottish Government exceptionally agreed to pay him six months’ salary in lieu of notice, totalling £61,000, along with untaken annual leave, as they considered it would provide organisational advantages in respect of Transport Scotland’s delivery”of the“programme.”That was the basis on which we put the report together.As you can imagine, I have asked the Audit Scotland team about this and my understanding is that they were informed that there were exceptional grounds. That is helpfully explained in Sir John Elvidge’s letter, in which it is stated that, in this case, the exceptional grounds involved restructuring. As a result, there is a clear link from our report to Sir John’s letter.
I would like to try to help the committee. The handling of the matter has cast the spotlight on a potential flaw in our arrangements for liaison with Audit Scotland. It is entirely natural that Audit Scotland should conduct its audit of Transport Scotland in discussion with that body, but issues that were dealt with in the Scottish Government, not Transport Scotland, came into the realm of the issues that were considered. I do not think that we tied together the communications between the three entities as well as we might have done.
Okay. Thank you.
I would like to return to points that were made about the appointment of Mr Middleton before the lengthy conversation that has just taken place, and which Sir John Elvidge has not had the opportunity to answer. It has been said that the man was somehow hand picked without due process being carried through and that he had little or no experience to do the task for which he was appointed . Would Sir John respond to that and clarify the position for the committee?
It is not our general practice, or it certainly was not at the time, to cast open, on their becoming available, each of our senior posts to self-nomination from our senior civil service population. There are significant issues to do with disruption to business—to service to ministers and effective management of the organisation—around moving individuals at particular times. Our normal process is that the board will consider the need to fill a post and the pool of talent that is available to us, and judge how we can best deploy that pool of talent, or whether we need to go outside it to meet the requirements of a post. In the case in question, we did exactly what we do across the range of our director posts.I am anxious not to turn the meeting into a confirmation hearing about Mr Middleton’s ability to do the job. The committee is well placed to judge Mr Middleton’s stewardship of Transport Scotland through its ability to examine him as the accountable officer. It was clear to me that he has a range of relevant skills and experience that make him a good fit for the post. He is a better fit for it than any other option that was available to us internally and a better fit than I thought I was likely to get through going to external competition at significant additional cost.
It is right to put on the record that we should not cast any aspersions on Mr Middleton in any way. He will be proven on the basis of what he delivers, and his record of achievement will be examined through the normal routes of accountability.I accept the point that you make about the costs involved in external advertising, but some very senior posts in the civil service are not filled through people expressing an interest in them. They are not even advertised internally, never mind externally; rather, you decide who you think the best person would be and then appoint them.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Feb 2010 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 375
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.