Good afternoon. Welcome to the sixth meeting in 2010 of the Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee. We have received one definite apology, from John Farquhar Munro, who still has an illness. I indicate to all members and to people in the public gallery that mobile phones and other electronic devices should be switched off, in case they interfere with the broadcasting system.Item 1 on our agenda is consideration of new petitions. I point out to elected members that there are additional papers for each of the new and current petitions that are before us this afternoon. We will deal with those as we deal with each petition.The first petition for consideration is PE1319, from Scott Robertson and William Smith, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Government to investigate the legal status and appropriateness of professional Scottish Football Association clubs entering into contracts with children under 16 years of age; the audit process and accountability of all public funds that are distributed by the SFA to its member clubs; the social, educational and psychological effects and legality of SFA member clubs prohibiting such children from participating in extra-curricular activity; and the appropriateness of so-called compensation payments between SFA clubs for the transfer of young players under the age of 16 years. The petition also calls on the Parliament to urge the Government to increase the educational target from two hours’ curricular physical activity to four hours per week and to develop a long-term plan to provide quality artificial surfaces for training and playing football at all ages in all regions of Scotland.We have received additional information and are aware that some of the issues that the petition raises are part of the on-going review that the SFA is due to publish shortly and of the continuing discussion that member clubs have with the SFA. I welcome both Scott Robertson and William Smith to the committee. Is it okay if I call William by his Sunday name today?
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Youth Football (PE1319)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- William Smith 14
- The Convener Mr Frank McAveety 8
- Scott Robertson 7
- Bill Butler Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab 6
- John Wilson Central Scotland) (SNP 4
- Nigel Don North East Scotland) (SNP 4
- Rhona Brankin Midlothian) (Lab 4
- Anne McLaughlin Glasgow) (SNP 3
- Trish Godman West Renfrewshire) (Lab 3
- Des McNulty Clydebank and Milngavie) (Lab 1
- Kenny MacAskill Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (SNP 1
- Robin Harper Lothians) (Green 1
The record
56 contributionsYes.
A number of elected members have expressed an interest in the petition. I welcome the three members of the Scottish Parliament who are here to indicate their broad support for it. I invite opening comments from either William Smith or Scott Robertson.
Good afternoon. Steven Whittaker, Colin Nish, Kevin Thomson, Andy Driver, Kenny Miller, John Collins, Allan McGregor and Darren Fletcher—those are all local footballers who are national successes in our game. I ask the committee: does anyone know of a player who has successfully come through the youth initiative programme?Willie and I are part of the real grass roots. We launched our petition on 27 January and also opened a website. Since then, we have had just under 6,000 visitors to the website from all over Scotland, and we have recorded 170 surveys, which contained 20 questions. I want to give you two or three statistics. Ninety-two per cent of those who replied said that young children should have the right to choose whether they play for their school or not; 82.6 per cent said that the youth initiative programme is not producing talented young players in this country; and 93 per cent said that funds from the Government—from the public purse—should be channelled into juvenile boys clubs or schools football and not given to the SFA or professional clubs.Andy Roxburgh once famously said that recreational football sits at the very bottom of the football pyramid and, without it, the whole pyramid collapses. We want to redress the balance between the professional clubs and the real grass-roots game in Scotland.
I have been in the voluntary sector for 45 years. In our opinion, the petition provides sufficient grounds for concern, particularly in relation to children’s welfare and rights, to ask the committee to recommend to the Scottish Parliament that, with immediate effect, all future funding given directly or indirectly to the Scottish Football Association or its member clubs should be frozen until the Parliament is satisfied that it is receiving value for its money and that the funding is not in any way being used to the detriment of children’s legal rights or social wellbeing.Given the downward spiral of our national game at grass-roots, club, European and international level, the objectives set out almost 14 years ago, when the professional youth initiative was established, have clearly not been met. As such, it seems to us that the benefactors of the funding have failed in their obligation to the taxpayer. In their arrogance, the football authorities expect the taxpayer to continue to pour millions of pounds into private businesses without the SFA conceding that the taxpayer is entitled to expect positive results and that independent assessment procedures should be in place for that purpose.The professional youth initiative is so out of control that children’s rights are of little or no concern. For example, should we not be concerned about children’s safety and welfare when clubs are taking young children as far as Inverness and Aberdeen on return journeys on a Sunday just to play a non-competitive game of football? What implications are there for the child in terms of exhaustion and stress? The petition will highlight many more serious abuses of children’s rights under the law in the contractual or registration procedures currently used by the SFA and its member clubs. Thank you, convener.
A number of elected members are here to give their comments and views. I invite Kenny MacAskill to start those comments.
By one of the quirks of fate, we are meeting today with the spectre of the resignation of the SFA chief executive hanging over us. I pay tribute to Gordon Smith—indeed, I was having a cup of coffee with two members of the SFA earlier today.We must remember that there is a football family and that we are all on the same side, whether in the SFA, the Scottish Premier League, the Scottish Football League, youth or women’s football. We need some mutual respect and understanding. As I said, I pay tribute to Gordon Smith and I also wish his successor, whoever he or she may be, all the best, but I echo what Scott and Willie said: the future success of Scottish football has to be bottom up and not top down. The role of the chief executive is vital to Scottish football, but the success of Scottish football in turning round what has been a steady decline over many years will come from the bottom up. The real praise must go to Scott Robertson and Willie Smith. I know the hours that Scott puts in in Musselburgh and elsewhere. He and Willie are two of many who, throughout the length and breadth of this country, give their time. All members will know numerous teams and clubs in their own constituencies where people do the same. They give their time and it costs them a lot of money because they receive no remuneration. They give their hearts and souls and often receive little gratitude. As a Parliament, we should acknowledge how important that is. Besides giving people the possibility of going on to be successful international footballers, such as those Scott listed, it also has the benefit of keeping kids out of trouble, making them healthier and keeping them on the straight and narrow. We owe a debt of gratitude to the real grass roots of football.I support the petition because I recognise that there is a problem in Scotland. We have our difficulties, some of which have come about for proper reasons. We had to bring in Disclosure Scotland and that had an impact. It was not cost free, either financially or in the problems it caused for schools and boys clubs. However, everyone acknowledges that we have to have it. Equally, we all recognise that facilities—and that was the purpose of my discussion with the SFA today—are inadequate, not fit for purpose and, to some extent, shambolic. We must change that. It will not be quick or easy. We did not get into this overnight and we will not get out of it overnight. I support the direction of travel that Scott Robertson and Willie Smith propose and the template that they are setting, and I have no doubt that my view is shared by colleagues. We recognise that we must draw a line in the sand and ensure that we invest in the game of football. It is part of Scotland’s psyche and soul. Equally, we must ensure that, as well as appointing a new chief executive, we build from the bottom up and support the grass-roots game, not simply on the basis that it is from the grass-roots game that the success of the national team will be built, but in order to promote community spirit, citizenship and all those matters.Not everything can be delivered. There are financial constraints. The replication of Toryglen regional football centre is something that we aspire to, but in the current financial climate it is hard to see that happening.
Nevertheless, I give my full support to travel in the direction of the real grass roots.
I know that Trish Godman has raised this matter with the SFA in the past.
Young guys should enjoy football. I know that they all want to be David Beckham or, dare I say, Henrik Larsson, and maybe their parents want that too, but they should be enjoying their football. They should be able to play in the kind of team that Willie Smith and Scott Robertson have or for their schools. I am concerned about two things. One is the contract under which some of these boys have been put and the way that they are moved about. It seems to me that that is manifestly wrong and that it cuts them off from playing football for their schools and from involvement and interaction with other kids in their schools. Every bit as important is the fact that the Government is giving money and that it is very difficult to get an audit trail of that money. Indeed, I am awaiting an answer from the minister about where the money has actually gone. I question children’s rights under the law when children as young as 10 or 11 are being asked to sign contracts. I am not sure that that is legal. If it is, perhaps it is something that we should look at.What Willie Smith said at the beginning is absolutely right. The only talent that we will get is from the bottom up. If we look back a few years at the footballers who were playing for Scotland—when it was an honour to play for Scotland, although it does not seem to be now—many of them were signed on S forms. I can understand young players being signed on S forms. It means they are given some tuition and help from a club but continue to play for their schools, are watched and eventually brought into the club system. That is a much more visible and easier way of doing things. I have deep concerns about the issues that both Scott Robertson and Willie Smith have raised. I hope that the Public Petitions Committee will be able to support what they are asking for.14:15
I would like to highlight two particular issues of concern. One is that the contracts that have been signed appear to allow clubs to restrict the extent to which people under the age of 16—or indeed 17 or 18-year-olds—can move to play for a different team if that suits them. It seems to me that the best judge of whether a young player is enjoying his or her football is that young person themselves, along with their parents or other people who have their best interests at heart. It seems that the mechanisms of the contracts that prevent children from moving on for playing reasons, social reasons or other reasons are not in the best interests of the child.The second issue, which underpins that, is that children are seen as assets that belong to a particular club and, to some extent, have a price on their head. They can move, but only provided that a bigger club is prepared to pay off the initial club to free up the contract. That is understandable in some highly specialised cases, such as Wayne Rooney or other very special players, but the extent to which it is happening is not in the interests of the young people involved or the interests of football more generally. Scott Robertson made a point about the number of players coming through the youth scheme and whether that is in the best interests of Scottish football. That is one consideration, but the most important consideration is the human rights of the child in those circumstances. Children should not be seen as the chattels or assets of any organisation, least of all a football club, that can buy and sell their services at the age of 16 or under.The system does not have appropriate safeguards. Its principles are very much open to question. Its impact on individual children would not be tolerable in any other context. If we took the word “football” out and transposed the scenario into another sport, activity or area of life, would we allow people’s rights to be signed away in that way? It requires only a moment’s consideration to say that that would not be allowed. I do not think that football can be a special case; we have to pay particular attention to the rights of the child and ensure that minors do not enter into contracts without appropriate legal advice or that they do not enter into contracts of any kind that fetter them as football teams’ assets. We need to change that situation.
From what has been said so far I understand that there are two issues. The first is, to put it simply, the human rights of the children involved. Secondly, the petitioners talked about the amount of money that is going into football and where it is going. I invite you to confirm the sums of money involved, not because I think that it is the most important issue, but because it is the one on which I would like some clarity. I can give you a clue in that the data in front of me, which the Scottish Parliament information centre has kindly provided, suggest that something like £1.5 million goes to the SFA for youth development and something like £1.5 million a year seems to be cashback for communities. I look to the minister for confirmation of that. Are those sums of the right order of magnitude? Are other sums involved? I am just trying to understand the scale; I am not worried about getting the figures down to the last hundred thousand.
There was a parliamentary question on that. Over the past three years, the sums of money channelled either directly to the SFA or indirectly—through sportscotland or the Scottish Football Partnership—totalled just over £12.5 million.
So, that is £4 million a year, which is marginally more than I have just described. Does that include cashback for communities?
We believe so.
Okay, so the sum that we are talking about is something like £4 million a year. Thank you. I just wanted to put that on the record.
Good afternoon, gentlemen. I think that it was Mr Robertson who said that the Scottish youth football initiative is a failure. Can you tell me why it fails, in your view? What are the main reasons for its lack of success? If you had your way, how would you turn it round?
I will keep my comments brief. The magnitude of the system is one aspect. The system was put in place for the elite players in Scottish football. This season, 139 teams are operating in the youth initiative system. If every team registers its capacity of 20 players, that will give us 2,780 young players. Do we really have 2,780 elite players in Scotland?To break that down, one of the Edinburgh-based clubs has 120 players in its youth initiative system. We have to ask how much time it can dedicate to them. If the club had, say, only 40 players, it could surely focus on them and really start to identify talent. We seem to be harvesting young kids and putting as many as possible through the system to try to find the one gem.
Mr Smith, would you like to add to that?
Yes. Some time ago, this proud nation produced players for Manchester United, Arsenal and Liverpool—for the great English clubs. Even at that time, 20 or 30 years ago, clubs needed the transfer money to survive. The clubs now produce players of a quality for no more than the championship in England. That reflects the failure of the pro youth initiative. As far as I know, none of the top English clubs has a scout in Scotland any more. That says it all.
I take your point. I remember when even the team that I support, Partick Thistle, produced Alex Forsyth for Manchester United and Alan Hansen for the BBC, and before that for Liverpool. Laughter. There were players across the board in the old first division, so I take your point.You identified what you see as the problem—the harvesting of players, and too many young people being signed up to the initiative with no real prospect of progressing. How can we turn the initiative round and make it a success? Should we scrap it and start again?
We must analyse how to deal with the problem. The first objective is to get the kids back to playing in a environment where they can develop naturally—playing with their friends in school football, or playing with Hillwood boys club or Musselburgh Windsor under 10s, 11s, 12s or 13s.We have the ridiculous situation in which one child has signed a form for an SPL football club for four years. That is an illegal document. He is eight, and he has signed it. What is worse, his parent signed it as well. It is not even recognised by the SFA, although it is aware of the situation. It is not the first time that that has happened. Four or five years ago, I wrote to the SFA—I have a copy of the letter—to warn it about the use of T forms. The T stands for training. All clubs were written to and told that they would be brought before the SFA’s general purposes committee if they were found to be using that document. Sadly, however, in its current structure, the general purposes committee is made up of the very clubs and people who are doing that.You can see that, for us, it is like banging our heads against a brick wall. That child is not the only one. Many are signing contracts at seven or eight years of age. I have a copy of the form that I mentioned, and the convener should have a copy of it. That child is only eight and he has signed a document for four years, or so he thinks. The document is not recognised by the SFA, so technically speaking he has been deceived.
Mr Robertson, do you want to add something?
You ask what I would do. For starters, I would scale back the numbers. We do not have nearly 3,000 elite young players in Scotland. If only. We dream of that. So we need to scale back the numbers. When we take those players in, whether they be eight or 12 or 13, we give them a false sense that they will be football players. I have been in schools football for 21 or 22 years, and kids of 12 or 13 in their first year at secondary school will say to the teacher, “Ah but, miss, it disnae really matter what happened at the battle of Hastings or if that is the chemical formula for water; I’m gonnae be a football player.” Headteachers will tell you that that undermines what we are doing.Holland has an entirely different scenario. If someone is not successful in attending and doing their studies, there is no football. I am keen—and I think that Willie Smith is the same—that we look after the whole child. The clubs are interested in that person only as an asset or football commodity. That is wrong. We want to look at the child as a whole. It is not good to take a nine, 10 or 11-year-old out of their natural environment. It is football, for goodness’ sake. We play it because we enjoy it, and for the love of the game.Back in 2004, John Gold wrote about the drop-out rate of 96 per cent because of the system. He wrote to one of the MSPs to say that we should leave the kids to enjoy their football, to have fun and build relationships with their friends, and get the clubs to come in and deliver the coaching locally. Why take one player from the east, one from the west, one from the central region, and put together a team that comes together only once a week and who barely know one another’s names? That means putting the kids into a pressure situation. It is football; let them enjoy the game.
I am obliged. Thank you.
I have listened to your presentation with interest and a great deal of concern. Scott Robertson said that the numbers need to be scaled back. Do you agree that some practices are so intolerable that scaling back is not all that needs to be done? Even if only 20 young people were involved in the initiative, things are happening that should not happen to 20 brilliant young footballers no matter how much promise they show.
I agree with you. We have, in effect, 30 or 31 academies in Scotland. We are a nation of 5.5 million. If we look over the water at Holland, it has a population of 16 million, but only 12 academies, such as Ajax and FC Twente. Why do we have so many? Can we really monitor all the poor practice that is going on at so many academies? Yes, we want to identify talent, and we want that talent to be successful for the national team, but not at the risk of some of the activities that Mr McNulty has mentioned, and certainly not to the detriment of the thousands of young kids who will not make it as football players.
What you are striving to do is entirely laudable. I have concerns about the possible impacts on the young people, who have to be the centre of our concerns. The clubs are clearly highly competitive businesses and are at pains to protect their investment. We can recognise that but also think that that may run contrary to the rights of individual children. Where in the world has the best system? We have so many youth academies in Scotland because they are based at individual club level and, given the competitive nature of clubs, we might not know how to change that. Is there a model somewhere that protects young people’s rights while also developing their potential and creating players for the future? What is that model, and how hard is it for us to begin to think about adopting it? What are the barriers to doing that?14:30
I know that we have referred to Holland several times. It is not the only country, but we will focus on it to give you an idea of the quality of the system there. In Holland, the club has shared objectives, which are in both its interest and the interest of the child. Holland is the perfect example.We have a problem in this country. If a child signs a contract for one year, the club has a hold on that young player for a further two years. When a 15-year-old player concludes the contract that he signed, he cannot leave if the club will not let him go. All that the club has to do is drop a recorded delivery letter to him at the start of the following season and the season after that saying, “We are retaining you.” A young guy who cannot get released from a club is heading down the road to disaster; at 16 or 17, he is heading for a perilous period in his life.
Is that the case in Holland?
No, sorry, that is the Scottish case. In Holland, if a player signs for a club for three years, the club has to commit itself to the player for three years—he is in a contract that is equal. In Scotland, the contract means nothing on the club’s side. The club can tear up the player’s contract within a week, whether he likes it or not.
Is the system the same south of the border? I have visited various youth academies, such as the one at Liverpool Football Club, which has had a very good reputation over the years and has produced players such as Michael Owen.
To be fair, I am not familiar with the English system; I do not know whether Scott Robertson is. I do not think that it is that dissimilar to the one that operates in Scotland.
I have a question on the issue of the clubs signing these young people up. Is any money changing hands? Are payments being made by the clubs? When the parents sign off on these contracts, is some form of financial retainer being awarded for the signing of these forms?
No, it should not be.
It is a crucial point. I understand that money should not change hands to get these forms signed, but I also understand that in some cases it does. The difficulty is that, when it comes to under-16s, child labour laws apply. It is concerning that major clubs in Scotland are using a system that is equivalent to child labour and which would be outlawed by United Kingdom legislation. Can Scott Robertson or William Smith confirm that that is common practice and that clubs are, to their knowledge, using financial inducements to get young people to sign these documents?
We have heard of such cases, but we have no concrete evidence to back that up. I would be grateful if the committee would consider the compensation payments that we know about. Compensation payments have been placed on children as young as 12. There is the case of one young lad in Dumbarton, Kieran Gibbons, whom Hamilton Academical will not release because nobody is willing to pay £9,000 for him. He has not kicked a ball since last May and he is only 14.I believe that respected members of this Parliament wrote to the authorities and said, “Please do not raise the fee of £3,000 a year.” They raised it to £5,000 a year, so it is now £15,000 for a player in similar circumstances, and they dropped the age at which it is applicable. We have compensation fees now. In my opinion, it does not matter whether you play for Rangers and sign for St Mirren or go from Inter Milan to Rangers or whatever, it is a transfer fee. “Compensation” is just a nice word, but it is a transfer fee. It is a scandal and we have to stop it.
That raises the question of clubs putting a price on the heads of young people who want to transfer to another club. Under child labour laws and employment legislation, no employer would be able to do that in any other aspect of society in the UK or Scotland.There are clearly issues that we need to look at closely because the employment rights of children under the age of 16 rest with the local authorities. Under UK employment legislation, it is local authorities that are supposed to monitor the situation because they are the ones who give young people under the age of 16 permission to work. I will raise the role of local authorities later. Both witnesses have indicated that local authorities are concerned about how young people perceive their future career paths if they are signed up at the age of eight, nine or 10 thinking that they will go into football. As has been said, the drop-out rate of 96 per cent is substantial and reflects how a lot of young people’s lives are destroyed because they have expectations that are never going to be met.
John Wilson raises an important point that I was going to raise. At our previous committee meeting, we were at a school in Fife where the pupils spoke to a petition that highlighted the fact that child labour laws are not being adhered to. The issue is worth looking into.I understand that you had a meeting with Tam Baillie, Scotland’s Commissioner for Children and Young People. I know that you cannot speak for Mr Baillie, and I assume that the committee will write to him. Nevertheless, can you tell me anything about the meeting? What sort of things did you discuss?
Generally, the meeting was very cordial. Tam Baillie was a good listener and understood the situation although, at that time, he would not commit himself to direct action. My gut feeling was that he was very sympathetic to what was going on. He told me, in parting, that he expected his involvement to be on the sidelines until the Parliament requested his view on the matter but that he would be more than willing to give it then. His predecessor—I cannot remember her name—
It was Kathleen Marshall.
Yes. She was concerned about the situation as well.
Okay. I expect that we will write to the children’s commissioner. I just wanted to get an idea of what had been discussed at that meeting.
It was a general discussion on the football side of things. I explained why we had lodged a petition and tried to give Tam Baillie an understanding of everything that was going on. To be fair, he is a football man, so—
He is a man.
Yes. He was aware of the serious issues that we are bringing to the Parliament today.
I want to touch on an issue that Rhona Brankin raised about the model that we have. Jim Fleeting and others at the SFA go round Europe and, indeed, I attended a forum in August.
There are good models out there. Inter Milan has 100 feeder clubs, so the kids stay locally. In Holland, there is a restriction on how far a club can go to sign a player. Barcelona also has feeder clubs and it has a community spirit. Unlike its big rival, Real Madrid, which buys big players, Barcelona has a philosophy of bringing players up.One of the problems with the SFA is the fact that Jim Fleeting or Neil McIntosh can go out, undertake studies, bring back best practice and make a good presentation to the board, but the board is made up of club members who have a vested interest and think, “That’s great for Scottish football, but for my club? No. We’re not releasing all our players.” The board of the Dutch FA, the KNVB, is completely autonomous and none of its members is connected to clubs—they are looking after the welfare of their national game. In Scotland, we have given the lunatics the keys to the asylum, so to speak. There are too many vested interests in our game.
We are trying to map our way through the petition, which has three or four different elements. Clearly, in broader terms, the plea to all parliamentarians on investment in facilities and the effective use of education and the curriculum will have to be dealt with by all of us through our discussions in the Parliament.We have focused on two fundamental issues. One is the process issue of what happens to a young man or woman who is signed up. There is increasing participation by women in football, so professional opportunities will emerge in that regard for young women in Scotland as well as elsewhere. The second issue is the football initiative itself. I had ministerial responsibility for sport for a period, and the idea at that time was that we would deal with the governing body, because it is autonomous, to try to put together a structure that clubs at all levels would feel comfortable with. What has happened in the intervening years is that a number of substantial grass-roots clubs have felt that the initiative has not really connected with the way in which they see players developing. We all have opinions on models for development, and it is about how we get the best models. I have heard Jim Fleeting of the SFA speak on a number of occasions about trying to increase the numbers who participate and how we identify individuals and take that through.Two things that I found during that period and in subsequent years—I think that Scott Robertson touched on this in his final point—is that club academies, whether those of Hibs, Hearts, the old firm or any other club, are very protective of individual players or structures. He has given us two or three pointers about other models to look at. Equally, opportunities may emerge from the turbulence in the SFA because of the loss of its chief executive and the impending report from the former First Minister, Henry McLeish, which, according to reports at the weekend, will address areas on which Scott has expressed views. I wonder whether we can invite the former First Minister to come to a meeting of the committee to follow through on the issues in his report, once it is published.People in the current Government and people who were in the previous one know how frustrating it is to try to navigate the SFA’s structures, because none of us has the right blazers on. Scott Robertson, who is wearing a blazer, is at least halfway there. There is concern about who is talking on behalf of the organisation and whether they can carry the organisation with them. It strikes me that the dilemma that faces all of us as elected members is where to start. The SFA is quite a defensive organisation when it comes to these debates.I am sorry that I have taken so long on this, but it strikes me that that is where we need to focus the petition in order to move things forward. I will finish on that, and invite Bill Butler and Trish Godman to speak, as I know that they are interested in the issue. We will try to pull together our final points after everyone has spoken.
It seems to me, having listened to all the petitioners’ and members’ comments, that the issue is basically about the rights of young people versus the vested interests of private businesses. We need to progress the petition, which has a number of important aspects regarding facilities, education, how young people are treated, how the whole approach seems to be skewed to the interests of private businesses rather than the interests of young people, and the need to deliver coaching locally. The petitioners have rightly touched on all those and other, associated issues. In supporting the petition, we should ask the Scottish Government whether it will carry out the investigations that the petition asks for, especially with regard to the audit. We should talk, too, to the SFA, the SFL, the SPL, the Scottish Trades Union Congress and the children’s commissioner, asking what their views are on the petition and the issues that we have discussed today. Perhaps when we get that information back, the committee can consider inviting the former East Fife player and former First Minister, Henry McLeish, to come and give his views to the committee. However, I do not think that anybody would gainsay that we should support unreservedly action on the important and serious issues that the petition has raised.14:45
I welcome Bill Butler’s suggestions. Bearing in mind what Scott Robertson said earlier, I suggest that we also write to the Dutch football association. How we take forward youth development in football for the future of Scottish football, whether for boys or girls, is at the heart of the petition. We need to get an idea from the Dutch football association of how it progresses youth initiatives in Holland.As I said earlier, we also need to write to a selection of local authorities—possibly Glasgow City Council, the City of Edinburgh Council and one or two smaller authorities—to find out the impact on young people in education who are signed up at a young age and whether those authorities monitor how those young people are treated. William Smith gave the example of young people being asked to travel 200 miles there and 200 miles back to play a knockabout game of football on a Sunday. That has an impact on them. I think that an employer would be allowed to employ such a person for only up to six hours on a Sunday. It can take children anything up to 12 hours to travel such distances. It might be worth while asking local authorities how they monitor what is happening and taking things forward from there.
I agree with all the suggestions that have been made. Perhaps we should also get advice from a lawyer who specialises in children’s law and children’s rights.
I was going to say what Bill Butler said. It is important that we get an audit trail from the Government; we are, after all, talking about public money.I have had an interview with Tony Higgins of FIFPro. The good practice out there seems to suggest that, if a person does not attend to the academic side of things at school, they should not get a game—they should not be allowed to play. There should be a quid pro quo. I know that that happens in Holland and other places. People are not chosen to play if there has been an impact on their education.I am a wee bit concerned. I understand what John Wilson said about work, but I wonder whether the way of getting round that is by saying that we are not talking about work. John Wilson talked about local authorities giving permission for certain things. I am thinking of ways by which things can be got round. It would be good to bring in a lawyer who knows about children’s law, and the children’s commissioner, as I suspect that things can be got round.
I am conscious of the time and that we need to consider other petitions.
I am thinking about the people to whom we should write. I hope that the amateur game has its own grass-roots associations. I am not sure what they are, but I hope that the clerk will find out and that we will write to them as well.We must be careful about the legal advice. This is not just about employment law; it is also about the restraint of trade and whether a minor can enter into a contract, money or no money, for example. We need specialist legal advice on a range of issues, and we need to throw matters wide open and not ask too pointed a question.
As I said, I am conscious of the time. People have had many opportunities to speak.Both petitioners are passionate about the issues involved, and the petition probably contains everything about football that they have ever felt cheesed off about. I think that we are all worried and concerned, because we know how important the sport is for our self-confidence, general activity and enthusiasm.We want to pull together all the responses. Obviously, there is an imminent report that will allude to some of the issues that the petitioners have raised. We will consider that in due course. We will maybe write to the former First Minister Henry McLeish to ask him to give us early sight of the report, as soon as it is published. The fact that it was discussed in the papers at the weekend suggests that that will happen pretty soon. When we have seen that report and we have the responses, the committee can return to the issue. The process will take time. To be fair to the individuals who are involved, we need to hear the views of clubs and the SFA and others in the process so that we get a sense of where they are coming from. We can then respond more appropriately.I invite the petitioners to make any final comments.
What I would like out of the work that we have put in is for any child who is under the age of 16 to have a get-out clause in any registration document, with 28 days’ notice to the club. That is currently in the Scottish Youth Football Association rules. That proposal was put to Gordon Smith and the executive of the Scottish Football Association, but it was rejected out of hand. That is my objective.I have one final parting comment on the model and the player pathway. On the video that Mr Fleeting has released, he says that we have gone to Brazil, Germany and other places and taken a wee bit from there and we are making that the way forward. Try selling that to a bank as a business plan.
You nearly had me believing that we are going to win the world cup. That was amazing. I thank both witnesses for the petition and for their time. We give a commitment that we will explore the issues that you have raised in the petition. You will be kept fully informed and up to date. The clerks are happy to receive any further information that relates to the petition with which you wish to furnish us. We are certainly keen to pursue the issues. I thank the members who have expressed an interest in the petition.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Apr 2010 →- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 56
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 27
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 35
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 19
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 22
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 8
- 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 8
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 14:00 New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.