I do not think that item 4 will take as long as the previous two items did, but we will see. The procedure is similar—we are dealing with an affirmative instrument. I ask the minister to introduce his colleague and to make opening remarks. We will then have questions, after which we will consider the motion.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2010 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Mather 11
- The Convener 8
- Lewis Macdonald 6
- Neal Rafferty Scottish Government Business, Enterprise and Energy Directorate 6
- Stuart McMillan 4
- Christopher Harvie 1
- Rob Gibson 1
The record
37 contributionsI am joined by Neal Rafferty from the Government’s business, enterprise and energy directorate.Thank you for the opportunity to speak. I know that the committee is familiar with the obligation and that it appreciates the obligation’s importance not just to the renewables sector but to the ambitious targets that we have set, on which there is much consensus.The obligation was introduced in 2002. Since then, renewables generation in Scotland has almost doubled—its share rose from 12 per cent in the obligation’s first year to 22 per cent in 2008. The legislation remains fundamental to the renewables sector and to the development of new capacity and technologies. The obligation needs to balance a stable climate for investors and controlled costs for consumers with the ability to respond to changes in the market and elsewhere.The draft order introduces important changes to the obligation. The same changes are contained in an identical order that has been laid before Westminster in respect of the obligation that covers England and Wales.The extension of the obligation’s lifetime by 10 years to 2037 will give investors the long-term certainty that is necessary to incentivise them to invest in new generation up to 2020. However, to avoid overcompensation and thus limit the costs to consumers, we will limit support for new stations to a maximum of 20 years. That limit will apply to stations that receive full accreditation on or after 26 June 2008, up to the 2037 end date. New or additional capacity that is added to any generating station will also qualify for 20 years’ support.We will remove the 20 per cent cap on the size of the obligation, to allow renewable electricity generation to grow as much as possible, and we will increase the margin that is set between the predicted demand for and supply of renewables obligation certificates—known as headroom—from 8 to 10 per cent to ensure stability in the ROC market. Using headroom to set the obligation level creates stability, which is a valuable commodity, as it should make it easier for project developers to forecast revenues and secure investment.The increase to the offshore wind band arises from a review conducted by the UK Government, based on evidence that demonstrated an increase in the costs of developing such projects. Based on that evidence, the review and the responses of our consultees, we are introducing the same increase to the offshore wind band under the renewables obligation Scotland. Although it is not certain that the timelines will catch any offshore wind capacity in Scottish waters, we believe that it is important to have consistency, as well as to send the signal that the bands will remain set at appropriate levels in future. The introduction of feed-in tariffs for small generators and microgenerators, which is due to happen on 1 April, is a very welcome measure. The scheme provides a much simpler and more effective reward for such generators than the ROS. That is why our amendments will transfer from the ROS all the microgenerators in technologies that will be eligible to claim feed-in tariffs, enabling them to join the new scheme from its start. That means that feed-in tariffs will be the only available support scheme for microgenerators in anaerobic digestion and hydro, solar and wind power. New generators above a certain size will have the choice in future between support under the renewables obligation Scotland or joining the feed-in tariffs scheme. Members will be aware that any changes to the renewables obligation Scotland need to be notified to the European Commission. That has been done, and we expect to have the Commission’s response by the middle of this month. The draft order that is before the committee today will be made only if the Commission approves the amendments. We are confident that that will happen but, if it does not, we will withdraw the draft order and re-lay it at a later date. I am happy to inform the committee in writing as soon as we have the Commission’s response.These important changes will improve the running of the obligation and increase confidence among stakeholders, whom we have consulted. Before I move the motion on the draft order, I am happy to respond to any questions that the committee may have.
Thank you for those opening remarks. What happens if the Commission does not give the approval that is required under the state-aid rules? There is some reference to the obligation being annual—it runs from 1 April to 31 March. Therefore, I presume that the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order 2009 applies up to 31 March 2010. I ask for absolute clarity on whether, if the draft order is not made, the 2009 order rolls forward until such time that a new order is made. Is there no cut-off date for the legislation?
Absolutely. However, it is important to put on record that there is no reason to believe that the Commission will not give its approval. As I said, we have given a commitment that the order will not be made without the Commission’s approval. Should that approval be delayed or denied, the draft order will be withdrawn.
I just want to be clear about what happens if the draft order is withdrawn. On 1 April 2010, would a renewables obligation Scotland scheme still operate using the existing legislation?
Exactly so.
The consolidation of the schemes is excellent news. The development of our renewables is encapsulated by the draft order. Will you give us a little bit more detail about how the feed-in tariffs will be rolled out so that we can get the very best news story out of the discussion?
It will be a much more appropriate scheme for microgenerators than the renewables obligation. It will mean that many microgenerators in eligible technologies will cease to be part of the renewables obligation scheme, but it will motivate many more of them to come forward.Although this is not exactly feed-in tariff territory, we ran a session on the renewable heat incentive last week in Glasgow. We had 180 people in the room to debate that—I expect that we will do exactly the same with the feed-in tariffs. That was a two-hour session in which we interacted with specific elements of the forum for renewable energy development in Scotland, the Department of Energy and Climate Change and a wide array of technologists, developers, housing associations, academics and local authorities. What was interesting was the mix of people in the room, the connections that were being made and the fact that, after we called time on the session, it took us a further 55 minutes to clear the room. Chemistry exists around initiatives such as feed-in tariffs and the renewable heat incentive. We are really getting across the message about their implications and the synergies that are possible when people co-operate and collaborate to take advantage of those new moves.
I welcome the broad thrust of the draft order. Paragraph 3.13 of the regulatory impact assessment says that“small generators already accredited under the”renewables obligation Scotland before feed-in tariffs“were announced will remain there”.That might need to be the case for solid legal reasons. Do contractual circumstances require that, or does the measure protect the interests of existing microgenerators?
I believe that the answer is the latter, but I ask Neal Rafferty to expand on that.
That is the case. It is also connected to the fact that people who were accredited under the ROS before feed-in tariffs were proposed made their investment and installed their technology on the basis of the returns that would be available, so no additionality would be present if they were transferred to the new schemes, and any additional costs that consumers incurred would result in no new capacity. The reason is to avoid any deadweight costs and to take account of the fact that those people would continue to receive support under the obligation.
So it is because those people’s plans were made on that basis. However, for the same developers proposing new projects and for new developers, the feed-in tariffs are a more appropriate and tailored response.
That is right.
That is helpful.The net effect will be an increase in costs to consumers over a period. Were consumer representative bodies consulted? If so, what were their responses?
Such bodies were included in the consultation, which was a wide exercise, as usual, but we did not receive representations from consumer bodies or consumer representatives or any comments about costs.The regulatory impact assessment contains information about the likely impact on costs. The Office of Gas and Electricity Markets estimates that the obligation will add £12 a year to consumers’ bills. All the way along, we have been careful to ensure that everything that the obligation does and all the proposed changes have consumer costs in mind, which should be as controlled as possible. We do not hide from the fact that what the obligation aims to do will cost an additional amount, but we make clear the reasons that are behind that.
You are not concerned that consumers or consumer representative organisations are unaware of the implications, which is why no responses were made to the consultation.
I do not think that they are unaware. The obligation is long established and we have had such exchanges before, which gives us confidence that people know that it exists and understand how it operates. However, if we can do more to ensure that that is explicit, we will look to do that.
I welcome the suggestion of higher banding for offshore wind at this critical point. The banding will be increased for a short time. What is the rationale for selecting that period? What capital pressures does offshore wind face that need to be addressed in that way in the next four years? How confident are you that those pressures will cease at the end of that period?
The change is about momentum and achieving economies of scale that allow us to scale up the sector in the coming years. It became clear on our visit to Bremerhaven that, although people there were tooling up and doing much, they were already—and were liable to continue to be—supply constrained. Anything that we can do to encourage investment here, such as the recent announcement that Iberdrola will open its offshore wind centre in Glasgow, is helpful in moving in the appropriate direction, so that we capitalise as much as we can on such developments.12:15
If supply constraints are the issue, are there things outwith the scope of the ROS that the Government might do to enable the offshore wind sector to maximise its supply chain resource in Scotland?
I think so. That is the key function of our continuing dialogue with the sector through FREDS and its sub-groups. I think that, in total, 170 people in FREDS and its sub-groups are in regular dialogue. They represent a variety of organisations, from engineering organisations to academic organisations. We intend to keep that dialogue going. Indeed, at the all-energy conference in Aberdeen this year, we intend to ensure that we bring together the totality of the Scottish energy sector, including the traditional elements that have existed in Scotland for many years, to ensure that there is a more collaborative and synergistic approach and that skills, capabilities and capital can be transferred from sub-sectors to other sub-sectors within the greater energy sector in Scotland.
I have a tiny point to make. When I have talked to schools in Fife, I have found that there has been quite an interest in something that I have produced, to which I wonder whether any cash could flow. I have done surveys of existing watercourses that have been used for power generation in the past for things such as textile mills. With the new, very advanced and efficient turbines, quite a lot of those could, for conservation and power supply reasons, become useful microgenerators. Who knows? Schools might adopt them to guide young people into being entrepreneurs, for example.
That is an interesting thought. It is clear that renewable energy social enterprises have a great facility to generate cash and trigger other things. If bright young minds are triggered, that is a plus.Nick Forrest has carried out a detailed study of Scotland’s hydro potential—mainly, I think, of run-of-the-river systems that would operate with minimum environmental damage. His initial report identified 657MW, but I think that he has augmented that figure. I cannot categorically say that that includes traditional, sometimes Victorian, watercourses—I am thinking about the Greenock Cut, for instance. We will see whether we can get some thinking done on that.
You mention the Greenock Cut. I am working with a constituent who has put forward that type of proposal. There is another element. You know the Greenock area and Inverclyde well. If such a proposal were in operation, it would have a massive knock-on effect on flood prevention in parts of Inverclyde, which has been a major issue in recent years.
Sure. We are in an interesting place. The more we get people from different disciplines talking, the more other things will emerge.On synergies, I was recently at Celtic Connections, where I met Susan Deacon, who is a former colleague of Lewis Macdonald and Wendy Alexander. Susan Deacon and I have come from different trajectories to arrive at the same conclusions for solving problems. My approach involves getting everyone in a room; her approach, which is somewhat more modern than mine, involves getting everyone in the same space. The more we do that and get conversations going, the more things will emerge that none of us had in our heads or hearts beforehand.
One problem that we have had in trying to move forward the scheme in Inverclyde is with the ownership of the watercourses and culverts. The Scottish Environment Protection Agency hosted an event before Christmas at which there was a debate about two or three watercourses in Inverclyde. A couple of my constituents and I were at that event, and the three of us spoke to the folk at the Scottish Water table, who told us that it does not own them and that the council does; we then spoke to the folk at the council table, who told us that it does not own them and that Scottish Water does. That long-running saga is hampering attempts to move matters forward. We have looked at many different avenues to establish who owns the watercourses. I am sure that it is an issue across the country, not just in Inverclyde. Unfortunately, some potential developments will be hampered until we have established the ownership of watercourses.
Yes. Sometimes we can bounce off various agencies and end up with nothing resolved and nothing concrete to show for our efforts. However, if we can get agencies into the room at the same time and get a debate going, especially if other stakeholders who can bring out the best in them are present, we will get a result.
The two sides were about 2m away from each other but were saying different things and blaming the other organisation. That was extremely frustrating, especially for the constituents who were present. I was glad that they were there to see and hear it, because it is one of the frustrations that I have had when trying to move the project forward.
We have unleashed a powerful force in the shape of Russel Griggs, who runs the regulatory review group and is the manifestation of binning the blame game to try to get a more collegiate approach. The good offices of Russel or others could be brought to bear to help you.
Thank you.
I return briefly to the issue of feed-in tariffs, which Lewis Macdonald raised. Are people who already have microgeneration eligible to apply for such tariffs? If so, how far back will you go? Is there a cut-off time, beyond which people are not allowed to apply for feed-in tariffs?
The feed-in tariff levels were proposed on 15 July 2009. Anyone who accredits between that date and 31 March this year will be eligible for feed-in tariffs, rather than the renewables obligation. In future, all microgenerators will automatically be eligible for feed-in tariffs only. The same argument applies to those who did not apply for accreditation beforehand. They installed microgeneration without needing additional support, so they will not be eligible for the feed-in tariff mechanism.
So if someone went ahead with microgeneration before 15 July 2009, without applying for support under the ROC scheme, they are not eligible to apply for feed-in tariffs.
Yes.
That clarification is helpful.Motion moved,That the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee recommends that the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2010 be approved.—Jim Mather.
We will move straight to the question, if I can find the right page in my notes. The question is, that motion S3M-5847, in the name of the minister, on the draft Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2010, be agreed to.Motion agreed to.
Apologies for the slight delay—there are too many bits of paper for this meeting.That concludes the public part of today’s business. I thank the minister and his officials for their attendance. At our next meeting, we will take evidence from a range of companies, trade bodies and trade unions on the issues and challenges facing the whisky industry, in one of our series of occasional state-of-the-economy sessions. We will also continue to discuss in private and, I hope, finalise the draft report of our banking and financial services inquiry.12:24 Meeting continued in private until 12:45.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Mar 2010 →- 09:30 International Trade Inquiry Committee business · 15
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 197
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 37
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.