To ask the First Minister, in light of the announcement by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body that the Parliament is seeking to reduce its budget by up to 15 per cent by 2013-14, what projections the Scottish Government has made in relation to its budget over the next decade. (S3F-2350)
Official Report · Chamber
Budget Projections
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 7
- Nigel Don SNP 2
- Jeremy Purvis LD 1
- Margo MacDonald Ind 1
- David McLetchie Con 1
- Derek Brownlee Con 1
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
14 contributionsAs John Swinney said in last week’s debate on the economic recovery plan, we have commissioned an analysis of current plans for United Kingdom expenditure over the coming years and their implications for Scotland. Obviously, that work has been conducted to inform the work of the independent budget commission, and I will ensure that a copy of the report is placed in the Scottish Parliament information centre for Nigel Don and other members.
Based on the chancellor’s most recent budget statement, in broad terms, the analysis shows potential real-term reductions in Scottish Government expenditure of 3 per cent per annum between 2011-12 and 2014-15. Projecting further forward, the analysis forecasts a period of up to 12 to 15 years before 2009-10 levels of expenditure are reached again. That represents a cumulative loss of between £22 billion to £35 billion of public spending over that period, depending on what assumptions are made in the forecast.
I am probably not the only member who finds those figures somewhat chilling. Will the First Minister expand on the Scottish Government’s thoughts on how those substantial cuts, which, as we are well aware, result from mismanagement down south and the biggest deficit in history, will be accommodated in the Scottish budget so that we protect front-line public services as far as possible?
The civil service in Scotland produced that analysis. Obviously, the analysis takes the budget and projects it forward, based on what we know about the current Government’s assumptions in London. The civil service does not criticise or endorse in any way; rather, it has tried to give context to the independent budget review. However, Nigel Don is right to describe the figures as chilling.
I will say two things. First, the forecasts are extremely sensitive to economic growth. We should consider the experience of the past few months and, indeed, this morning, when it was announced quite quietly but nonetheless significantly that there was a further improvement of £4 billion in the UK’s public finances because growth has been faster and unemployment has been lower than was forecast even a few weeks ago in the budget. Some £6 billion here and there has been argued about in the election debate. Experience should indicate to many people that economic growth is the most sensitive aspect of a forecast. Perhaps we should concentrate a bit more on how to secure economic growth, instead of the other matters that have preoccupied the election debate.
Secondly, in a context in which, even with enhanced growth, public spending will be at a premium, many people—including those who hitherto might have taken a different attitude—will now concentrate their minds on the question whether spending more than £100 billion of vital public money over the next generation on a cold war system of mass destruction and Trident missiles can be justified when health, education and other vital budgets will be under pressure.
The independent budget review group has said that no budget line in the Scottish budget should be ring fenced going forward. The Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy told the Finance Committee on Tuesday that, given a 15 per cent reduction in the overall Scottish budget, if health and wellbeing expenditure were ring fenced, disproportionate reductions of 25 per cent would have to be made elsewhere. As the Government is now asking civil servants to do modelling of the future Scottish budget, have civil servants been asked to exclude any reductions in the health and wellbeing budget lines?
No, but one of the sensitivity analyses takes us to the lower point of what are admittedly huge totals of £22 billion to £35 billion with the assumption that front-line services would be protected and therefore that, under the Barnett formula, consequentials would be allocated to Scotland. Whatever the Liberal Democrats’ proposition is in this economic debate, this Government will continue as far as possible to protect front-line services as we have done to date.
I, too, am interested in whether the Scottish Government is modelling. Based on the admission of all three parties that are likely to be in the next Government that there will be reductions in services, there will be big effects on the employment scene. Edinburgh is the financial, governmental and administrative centre and will inevitably face big unemployment. Will the First Minister assure me that modelling on future unemployment trends is being done for Edinburgh and its travel-to-work area?
I repeat my point that I am talking about a civil service analysis that is based not on endorsing or criticising the policies that can be interpreted from the UK budget, but on what would happen if such policies were carried forward in a range of scenarios. In doing that and in having the independent budget review group, we are far in advance of anything else that is being done throughout these islands—
Thanks to us.
Mr McLetchie is claiming the credit. Obviously, his foresight does not extend to his colleagues south of the border, where the parameters of the Tories’ vision seem to extend to two-year periods. In addition to the threatened cuts to Scottish public spending, they want to have a specific Tory Cameron cut that would make those figures even worse.
The parameters of the civil servants’ forecast are to inform members, the public and, in particular, the independent budget review group about the potential seriousness of the situation that we face. As the political debate continues, it will be up to Margo MacDonald and me to articulate that there is a course, both for public spending and for the future of this nation, that is different from the rather dismal prospect on offer from Westminster.
Almost a year ago, on 30 April 2009, the First Minister and all his SNP colleagues voted for an amendment in my name that called on the Scottish Government to prepare contingency plans in light of a potential reduction of £3.8 billion in the Scottish departmental budget. Is he now telling us that nothing happened until after this year’s budget?
No. I am saying that we are far in advance in looking at the parameters. However, I say to Derek Brownlee, for whom I have an enormous amount of respect—[Laughter.]
Order.
Without meaning to do any long-term harm to the young man’s career, I say that I have enormous respect for him within the parameters of political opposition—I hope that that helps him in the Official Report.
These forecasts are important because they have been done in an objective way. My interpretation of the high end of the forecasts is that they would affect some of the policies that Derek Brownlee’s colleagues in London intend to pursue. Therefore, perhaps he could use his good offices to explain to them that there might be more important items than £100 billion Trident missile systems. It would be inadvisable for the Conservative party to propose a specific Scottish cut in spending, particularly at a time when, under any forecast, it will be hugely reliant on the vast resources from Scottish oil and gas.
In this meeting
Everything on 22 Apr 2010 →- Business Motion Business motions · 4
- Economy Debate · 132
- Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi Questions · 10
- Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (Fossil Fuel Levy Account) Questions · 6
- High-speed Rail Link Questions · 4
- Perth and Kinross Council (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Machrihanish Royal Air Force Base Questions · 4
- Non-domestic Rates Questions · 11
- Concessionary Rail Travel (Fife) Questions · 6
- West Lothian Council (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Budget Projections First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Rape Conviction Rate First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Youth Unemployment First Minister’s Questions · 4
- On-screen Smoking Questions · 11
- North America Plan Questions · 6
- Gaelic Education (Kilmarnock and Loudoun) Questions · 4
- Scotland Week Questions · 8
- United States of America (Ministerial Visits) Questions · 4
- Community Arts Initiatives Questions · 4
- BBC Alba Questions · 4
- Children (Additional Support Needs) Questions · 4
- Teacher Numbers Questions · 8
- Homophobic Bullying Questions · 4
- Family Mediation and Couple Counselling Questions · 4
- Bullying Questions · 4
- Arts Education Questions · 6
- Teacher Numbers Questions · 4
- Free School Meals Questions · 6
- Control of Dogs (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 19
- Control of Dogs (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 15
- Volcanic Ash Cloud Statement · 35
- Decision Time Decision time · 13
- Veterans (Criminal Justice System) Members’ business · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.