It strikes me that the theme and the motion for the debate stray somewhat from the approach that is generally taken to members’ business. That is no bad thing and I congratulate Joe FitzPatrick on securing the debate, notwithstanding the slight ambiguity in the motion’s title.
British politics is said to be in flux, but the speeches this evening confirm that a game-changing movement towards a cross-party consensus on nuclear power is unlikely. However, I acknowledge Lewis Macdonald’s point about the healthy debate that has happened in all our parties on the issue.
Like others, I will start by reiterating my party’s position. The Scottish Liberal Democrats oppose the development of new nuclear power stations. That position is reflected throughout the UK and does not apply solely in Scotland.
Mr FitzPatrick’s motion refers to
“the will of the people”.
That factor is important and is not simply a gut reaction to an abstract proposition. It is worth reflecting that the nuclear aspect of the wider energy debate is perhaps given more prominence than any other aspect. To some, that is a source of frustration and complaint. I understand that frustration to a degree. Nevertheless, it means that public views are shaped by greater exposure to the arguments for and against new nuclear power stations, which is significant.
It is generally accepted that there are no easy or inexpensive solutions to decarbonising our economy and meeting our future energy demands—to reducing harmful emissions, safeguarding security of supply and eradicating the scourge of fuel poverty. However, that does not mean that no options exist.
The options are well set out in the report by Garrad Hassan and Partners, “The Power of Scotland Renewed”, which was published last year. It suggests that renewable energy can meet between 60 and 143 per cent of Scotland’s projected annual electricity demand by 2030—that depends on the levels of energy saving and of new renewables. The base scenarios that were used assume increased energy consumption and stable peak demand but, as the report’s authors made clear, that is a worst-case scenario, as one hopes that current and future efforts to reduce consumption and manage peak demand will bear fruit over time.
An increased commitment to widespread and significant energy efficiency measures is essential, as is investment in grid upgrades—including subsea cables—and in interconnectors and storage options, to reflect the changing nature of energy generation. That was a central theme in last week’s excellent debate on transmission charging. I reiterate the need for the charging structure to underpin the renewables revolution that we all want and certainly not to work against it, as at present.
I do not dispute that all that comes at a significant up-front cost, but the benefits in the longer term for emissions reductions and security of supply and for more managed and affordable energy costs more than justify the investment. When we add the opportunities for job and wealth creation—not just in Dundee but in remoter parts of the country, such as the islands that I represent—it is self-evident that we should strain every sinew to deliver those aspirations.
The risk is that new nuclear build diverts investment—including vital research and development funding—from genuine renewables. It is worth reflecting on the Scottish Government’s record. The importance of the saltire prize—Mr Salmond’s vanity project that will pay out nothing until 2017 at the earliest and might pay out later—has constantly been elevated above the need for more immediate and targeted R and D funding for the marine sector. The point about R and D in Mr FitzPatrick’s motion is well made. Another risk is that the picture is distorted for decisions about grid, other infrastructure and supply-chain development.
New nuclear is touted as a cheaper solution in the short to medium term, but such an approach to policy making has landed us with the problems that we now face. Given that we still have no acceptable solution for waste disposal—perhaps the minister will say whether his Government is considering disposal options for nuclear waste—and given the longer-term issues with sourcing uranium and the serious concerns about the impact on the development of genuine renewables, the case for new nuclear is at best superficial.
I congratulate Joe FitzPatrick again on securing the debate, although I fear that his hope that it will allow the Parliament to speak with a clear voice on the issue was a little overoptimistic.
17:29