Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Alcohol (Minimum Pricing)

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 29 April 2010 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Jamie Stone LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
link

To ask the First Minister when the Scottish Government will confirm its preferred minimum price per unit of alcohol. (S3F-2365)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link

As Jamie Stone knows, a highly constructive debate is taking place in the Health and Sport Committee on the principle of minimum pricing as a measure to reduce consumption and harm. As the Deputy First Minister indicated to the committee, we will come back to Parliament with our preferred minimum price. I am sure that Jamie Stone will appreciate the importance of that. Parliament will be able to scrutinise the specific price with the same energy that it is giving to scrutinising the policy. Of course, it is greatly encouraging to those of us who believe in minimum pricing that support for the principle continues to grow. There is a willingness by some colleagues to scrutinise the evidence closely and to look at the issue in terms of the long-term benefits to Scotland as well as the principle that is involved.

Jamie Stone LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
link

Will the price be announced before the bill is approved at stage 1? Does the First Minister agree that it is impossible for the Parliament properly to assess the Government’s policy of minimum pricing without a stated price, given that the price determines the legality of the policy, its impact on consumption and—one might add—receipts to the Exchequer? He will be aware of the Health and Sport Committee’s work on the bill, but is he also aware that the Subordinate Legislation Committee has asked for more information? Given that the delay in stating the price has delayed the bill, will he now listen to the Parliament’s serious concerns and commit to naming the price before the Parliament approves the bill at stage 1?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link

The price will certainly be named before any final vote in the Parliament.

I say to Jamie Stone that it is important—as I am sure Mr Rumbles will appreciate—to consider how much support there is in principle for the concept of minimum pricing. I said that I was greatly encouraged by the growing consensus, but I was particularly impressed by page 41 of the Liberal Democrat manifesto, which declares that the Liberal Democrats are

“in favour of the principle of minimum pricing”.

I was even more encouraged by Norman Lamb, who is the UK health spokesman for the Liberal Democrats. On the BBC’s “Daily Politics” show yesterday, he said that he fully backed minimum pricing as a concept. There is a growing support and a reservoir of concern, which is exemplified by the advocates of change in principle south of the border—[Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link

When Mr Rumbles gives us the same support north of the border, that growing concern will be reflected in growing support for the policy in this Parliament, to match the growing support outside it.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

The First Minister will be aware of the growing concerns about the legality of the proposed measure. Does he believe that the European Union should be notified now about any aspect of the Alcohol etc (Scotland) Bill, under the technical standards directive? If not, at what point does the European Union get notified about the minimum pricing proposals? Is it when the price is set? If that is the case, will the First Minister, in the interests of transparency and parliamentary scrutiny—he believes that he has nothing to fear—tell us when he will name the minimum price?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link

The member will have looked at the comments of Alcohol Focus Scotland about the claims of illegality under EU law, which I know Jackie Baillie would not wish to misrepresent in any way. It says that the opinion by the Advocate General to which the Scotch Whisky Association has referred

“relates to specific cases of minimum pricing for tobacco and cannot be interpreted as a judgement on the legality of minimum pricing in general. Indeed, the European Commission confirmed in a written statement”

to a Labour MEP

“earlier this year that EU legislation did not prohibit Member States from setting minimum retail prices for alcoholic beverages.”

Now that Jackie Baillie has been reminded of the excellent work of her colleague in the European Parliament in eliciting that clarification, she will not wish to give any impression that she and her colleagues are somehow trying to dodge the question of principle, which so many Labour members south of the border are prepared to embrace and support.

It seems passing strange that parliamentary representatives in England, where there is a serious problem with alcohol, are prepared to support minimum pricing, whereas some people in this Parliament in Scotland, where we have an even more serious problem with our relationship with alcohol, are trying to dodge the issue. Particularly at this time, because we wish to demonstrate the virtue of a consensus Parliament with a balance between the political forces, members of this Parliament are called on to put principle before political objectives when the health of Scotland is at stake.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have closely scrutinised the evidence on this matter, and I remind the First Minister that the new data on minimum pricing from the University of Sheffield now predict almost half the number of alcohol deaths that the first estimate did, and 38 per cent fewer hospital admissions over 10 years compared with previously. How can the Health and Sport Committee and the Parliament reflect an accurate account of the Sheffield modelling when there have been such significant changes in the predictions?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link

Surely Mary Scanlon would be the first to accept that the figures from Sheffield still indicate a substantial number of avoidable and preventable deaths and, moreover, widespread damage to the general health of the population. Mary Scanlon would not wish to give any impression that a substantial number of deaths through the absence of minimum pricing would be acceptable. Even less would she wish to give the impression that she is oblivious to the substantial body of research that tells us that the policy is one of a number of measures that can help to reorientate Scotland’s relationship with alcohol, improve the public health of Scotland, save lives and protect our young people from harm.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The only piece of evidence in support of minimum pricing was the University of Sheffield study, which has been fatally undermined this week by the revisions to its figures. Why will the First Minister not drop the unwanted and probably illegal policy of minimum pricing, so that we can get on, develop a consensus and move on with proposals on which we can all agree, such as the proper enforcement of the current laws?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link

We all agree on enforcement of the current laws and we all agree that the issue requires to be addressed. I find it surprising that some members seem to be saying that, because the current University of Sheffield assessment of deaths and damage, if it is correct, is lower than the previous assessment, it is somehow acceptable. Surely the evidence indicates that minimum pricing can help to prevent deaths in Scotland and social and health damage in the general population. If Murdo Fraser accepts that aspect of the research, why on earth does he not find a consensus with those of us who want to address the problem and protect the health of Scottish society?

12:30 Meeting suspended until 14:15.

14:15 On resuming—

  1. Living Wage Debate · 71
  2. Democratic Reform Debate · 67
  3. Glasgow City Council (Recycling) Questions · 6
  4. Schools (Indiscipline) Questions · 4
  5. Child Protection Strategy Questions · 6
  6. Tax Havens Questions · 4
  7. Domestic Aviation Questions · 8
  8. A96 (Inveramsay Bridge) Questions · 4
  9. Freedom of Information Questions · 6
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
  11. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Pregnant Women (Smoking) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Curriculum for Excellence (Implementation) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  16. National Health Service (Budget Pressures) Questions · 6
  17. Dispensing General Practitioner Practices (Rural Areas) Questions · 6
  18. Energy Assistance Package Questions · 13
  19. Palliative Care Staff Questions · 6
  20. Scottish-Islamic Foundation (Reallocation of Funding) Questions · 4
  21. Housing (Barnett Consequentials) Questions · 8
  22. Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) Questions · 8
  23. Aberdeen City Alcohol and Drugs Partnership (Priorities) Questions · 4
  24. Isle of Man (Reciprocal Health Care Arrangements) Questions · 4
  25. Pharmacy and Dispensing Services Questions · 5
  26. Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) Questions · 4
  27. Affordable Housing (Barnett Consequentials) Questions · 4
  28. Social Services Workforce Debate · 23
  29. Decision Time Decision time · 29
  30. Grampian Cardiac Rehabilitation Association Members’ business · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.