Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 8 September 1999 Education, Culture and Sport Committee Procedure 86 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

86 contributions
Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

A number of issues have been raised this morning that we might want to pursue. I am open to members' guidance as to how we continue but I suggest that we pursue a few points in particular. The first relates to discussion and consultation with young people, which we should deal with soon. Fiona had some suggestions on how we could improve the methodology on that. The second issue relates to elections to and membership of school boards. The third issue is teacher development and professionalism. The fourth is how the inspectorate should be resourced and developed.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I agree with your choice of areas for discussion, Mary. I am sorry to come back to an issue that I raised earlier, but I would like to take you up on an offer that you made. I think that the negotiations on teachers' pay and conditions are central to the education debate and I suggest that we invite Mr Galbraith back—possibly to our next meeting—to question him for half an hour on the state of the negotiations and on what can be done to break the deadlock.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

I am not sure that we should invite the minister to deal with that subject; it would be more useful to invite representatives of the two negotiating parties. It would be meaningless to put the minister on the spot at this stage. The deadlock will be broken by the result of the teachers' ballot.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

With all due respect, do you want the minister to throw a pot of gold at an unresolved situation?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I remind members to speak through the chair.

Brian Monteith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

As has been pointed out, the Scottish Joint Negotiating Committee for Teaching Staff in School Education is tripartite. We could ask representatives from all three sides to come; we may want to talk about different things to each of them. We might ask the minister what he can do to bring the sides together and we could find out from the others what we can do to bring them closer together.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Are there any other views before I comment on that?

Jamie Stone LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
link

I am happy to defer to you.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

The tripartite negotiations are important but, as has been said, Hampden needs an immediate answer. We will want the minister here next Tuesday to answer questions on that.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

Why do we need an immediate answer on Hampden? I missed that.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

It was raised earlier in the meeting.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Fiona, why do you think that we need an immediate answer on Hampden?

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

I have asked questions in every conceivable forum since July and have not received answers. The committee will want to know whether the National Stadium is paying its bills and can operate as a national stadium.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

It is obviously up to the minister to deal with Hampden, but I take on board Fiona's point that this committee may have concerns about it. If the committee has concerns about Hampden, I am happy to invite the minister to discuss it. Is that the feeling of the committee?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

No, it is not. We have just had a discussion with the minister, which dominated the whole meeting. There are many things which I would like us to move on to, within and outwith the bill. Although Hampden is important, it is not a priority for the committee, and it can be pursed through other avenues.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

I have explored every other avenue that is open to me and have not got answers. It may not be a priority but it is an urgent issue. We need to know whether the bills for which McAlpine issued a writ against the National Stadium were paid last month.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

What is our locus in this? Is it because the Government is a minority funder?

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

The Government is not a minority funder; £40 million of the £63 million is public money.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

You are talking about lottery funding, which is separate from our powers. There are other funders, including Glasgow City Council. We need to get this into perspective. Nobody is more interested than I am in ensuring that the blessed Hampden is financially stable. I wish that it had never been bloody built. It is not a pressing issue for this committee.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I suggest that we leave the question of Hampden until the committee considers its priorities.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

No, we will return to it. We have left Hampden on the table so that we can discuss it under the priorities that this committee will have for future meetings.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

I think that we need the minister here next week to give an answer. I have gone down every possible route and have not got an answer. This committee has the power to ask not just the minister but the board members to explain what is going on. If that is the only way in which to get an answer on £40 million of public funding, we have to do it.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I understand your concern that you have not had an answer to the questions that you have rightly been putting, but I wonder whether that is for the committee to pursue, or whether you should pursue it as a member of this Parliament.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

It could be put to a vote of the committee.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

May I finish? It is up to the committee to decide whether it wants to deal with this matter. I suggest that we leave it on the table to be discussed along with the other issues that the committee needs to deal with. It may be that members will agree that we put Hampden at the top of the agenda, but we must consider that alongside other issues.First, I want to deal with the teachers' wage settlement and whether we want to invite the minister and, as Ian suggested, the other two negotiating parties—the teachers and management—to discuss it.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

I do not know when the result of the ballot will be known, but the involvement of this committee will serve no purpose until then.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

On the contrary, I think that it is important that negotiations continue. The danger at the moment is that both sides are taking increasingly fixed positions. If we can investigate ways in which the deadlock can be broken, we should go ahead and do it.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

In that case, everything will be fine, but if it does not, I would like to think that this committee had in the meantime done everything in its power to bring about a speedy solution.

Brian Monteith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It is quite apparent to many of us, both in this committee and elsewhere in the Parliament, that this Parliament has a great job to do in winning back the confidence of the people. One of the committee's tasks—as well as bringing the Hampden issue to light and exploring what, if anything, has gone wrong—is to take up issues such as the teachers' pay dispute. We should not allow ourselves to be governed by the time scale of the parties involved; it is for us to take the issue by the scruff of the neck and find out information that might be helpful.There is nothing to fear from investigation. It is easy for journalists to reach the parties and the minister involved and to run stories in the papers, but we seem to be saying that we should hold back. The Scottish public would like to see politicians taking some action. Through this committee, we have the ability to bring people before us and ask them pertinent questions. Hopefully, that will help the process along. I suggest that we move on this as soon as possible.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Whenever industrial discussions are in progress, it is not necessarily for politicians to get involved as immediately as Brian suggests. People do not want politicians to start playing party politics with an issue, as—unfortunately—sometimes happens.However, I am warming to the idea of inviting the minister and the other parties to a committee meeting. I would like the committee to suggest when that should happen, because I have some sympathy with the view that we should not issue invitations while the teaching unions are holding a ballot.

Ian Jenkins LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

I agree that if we are not seen to be asking questions, people will be surprised; I really feel that. However, I would be upset if we appeared to be trying to do the negotiation.

Ian Jenkins LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

Well, there has been some suggestion along those lines. That is the agenda that seems to be being pursued. It would be fine for us to have exploratory questions sessions, but I do not think that we can try to solve the problem.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

We got off to a very bad start with what happened first thing this morning—that is not a party political point—but let us see whether we can make better progress. There is sense in saying that the ballot is a process in which we should not interfere, but as soon as all the ballots are over we should endeavour to speak to the parties involved. Perhaps we should advise the minister that we will also need to speak to him if he is going to be one of the parties. Brian is absolutely right—we have to play a role in this process.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

Does Michael Russell agree with me then?

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

In the spirit of the new politics, a compromise should be possible in this committee. I hope that that would be welcomed by Labour members, too. However, we can do things the other way; we can take entrenched positions—as committee members did this morning—and create difficulties. Alternatively, we can make the sort of compromise that we are working on. It is up to the members around this table.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Can I suggest that that was what I said, although perhaps not as well as Michael Russell? I said that we should invite the parties to appear before us, but discuss the timetable for doing that. From the muttering around the table, it seems that people know when the ballot will be completed. Does the clerk have any information on that?I have been informed that it will be over by 15 September.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

That is a sensible compromise. In response to Ian's point, there is no suggestion that this committee should do the negotiation. That is what the SJNC is for and will, I hope, continue to be for. However, it would be useful if this committee could play a role.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I do not have a diary on me, but I believe that 15 September is next Wednesday.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Can we agree that we will invite all parties on the following Wednesday—22 September—if that is acceptable to those who are negotiating?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

That is the next Wednesday meeting.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

If it cannot be 22 September, in view of the fact that we need to get everybody's diaries together, we should find the nearest date thereafter.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Let me assure you that I am as keen as everybody here that we make some progress on this. What I do not want to do is interfere in a haphazard way that could damage any negotiations that are going on. Do we agree on that?We have 10 minutes to discuss other items of business that the committee may wish to raise. At the conveners meeting yesterday, there was a clear feeling that we will have difficulty with our work programme if we do not set out some proposals to a timetable. When emergency items arise, committees will need to deal with them, but we are keen that we should set some kind of timetable in the first instance, to give the clerks and researchers some guidance. I will take people's comments on that, if I can get round the table in 10 minutes.

Jamie Stone LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
link

As I forewarned you twice today, I will come at this as a structural issue. School performance and teacher morale and performance are linked to the structure of schools. As I said, schools in my area—and Thurso and Wick high schools in particular—are in bad nick. Thurso High School is in a disgraceful condition, and that is affecting the delivery of the service to pupils. We are boxed in by section 94. Sam has rightly moved in a good direction with the comprehensive spending review, but we know that that is not enough. As a committee, we must look at how we address that issue, which applies to every one of us. It may be a matter of freeing up capital from current revenue or of using balances or other forms of finance. I entirely accept Sam's point about moving funds across boundaries. I was twisting his tail slightly, as I knew fine well what the answer would be. My former authority would go berserk if there was any suggestion of using section 94 to move funds to Aberdeenshire or Morayshire. This is desperately important to people out there. If we talk about improving our schools, they will say, "What about the hole in Castletown Primary School?" I know that I am getting a bit local here, but I hope that all members agree that the problem is bad.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

My first point—about the inspectorate—relates to the four points that you raised, convener.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Are we agreed on the four points that we will discuss further?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Does that mean that those four points will be on the agenda next time?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

We will progress those points, and any others that anyone wants to add.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

East Renfrewshire is one of the authorities that have been inspected. I recommend that we learn from that inspection and invite the director of education here or go to East Renfrewshire.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

We will come to that if we have time.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

My second point is the one that Nicola raised—the broader context of the bill. The bill talks about the structure of education, but it will operate in a wider context, particularly in relation to the sustainable education that Nicola alluded to. It is important that we have that on the agenda and talk about the overall philosophy of our approach to education.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I have quite a list of points. I thought that we were listing points and then deciding on some priorities. We must not forget that we are a cultural committee, too, but on the education side I have raised the issue of rural schooling. We need to look closely at the criteria for closures, as well as finding a positive way of encouraging rural education, particularly rural primary education. We must get to grips with the fact that, although we want rural primary education to continue, there are lots of questions about how it is resourced.I referred to the Nicolson Institute and the Lewis Castle College, which raise a range of issues about how schools merge and how communities get involved in that. Many people regard this as an issue of maladministration in education, and the courts reviewed it as such. We should consider whether to examine it specifically, as it would open up the issue of how parents are consulted about the way in which education provision is made.The committee has a role in examining how the national cultural strategy is progressing. We have a commitment to invite Greg Dyke and Sir Robert Smith to meetings, which we have not yet honoured. There is the perennial question of the Scottish film industry—three different sets of studios, or possibly four, have been proposed— and there is the question of production in Scotland having reached something of a watershed. We should consider those issues as part of our culture remit. Finally, although Scottish publishing is a growth area, it presents a huge number of issues. An investigation into Scottish publishing might provide some very useful material for this committee and for the Scottish arts community in general.

Brian Monteith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We should invite representatives from St Mary's Episcopal Primary School to give evidence on the education bill. Its publication is a significant event for that school, whose views it would be important to hear. On the national cultural strategy, I raised in the chamber the issue of the national theatre for Scotland. There are a number of players whom we could ask about that. I shall return to the development at Hampden later, as I have already given notice that I was concerned about it. I should also mention—I bring this up under any other business—that there should be separate sub-committees.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

On a point of order. I move to extend the time for this committee. We are obviously up against it, and I do not think that we will be chucked out immediately if we want to continue.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I think that there is another meeting in this room, so I would be reluctant to extend our time, even though there are a number of issues that members want to raise. If members want to put on the agenda items that the committee can consider over the coming months rather than immediately, I shall ask Gillian, the committee clerk, to speak to them and write down the ideas that they want us to consider. Members can e-mail those ideas, if that is considered more suitable. We will try to put together a programme that will include everything. As Mike said, we still have the cultural strategy to examine. I am also more than aware that we have not yet had a briefing on sports issues, and I know that sportscotland is anxious to meet us. There may be items from that meeting that members will want to include as well. As we have had a briefing on arts issues, does the committee agree that I should arrange with sportscotland a suitable time for a briefing on sports? After that, we could consider what items the committee wants to include. Mike, you are shaking your head.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I would like some clarification of the process. All the issues that we have raised and more—if we e-mail you others—will go into a paper that the committee will confirm as its work programme for this session. Is that what will happen?

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

So we are not reaching any decisions today; we are just throwing ideas into the melting pot.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I hope to leave it as open as possible, so that committee members can include as many items as they are interested in.

Brian Monteith Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

When we discuss what the committee might consider, can we have on the agenda the notion of sub-committees investigating culture and sport separately?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Yes. There is a paper on sub-committees and travel, but we do not have time to deal with that just now. I suggest that we put that on the agenda for Tuesday's meeting. I take it that the committee is in agreement that we should have a meeting next Tuesday, as we will need the time.

Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab Stirling
link

If we are to have a sports presentation, could we try to have it when no other committees are meeting? I know that that might be difficult but I, for one, would like to attend that debate.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

That is extremely difficult. We are having problems with members' availability, because most of them are on more than one committee.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

I understand why you say that. I hope that the briefing from sportscotland is agreed and that we can go ahead and organise it without waiting until the next meeting. One thing that I would like us to do as a matter of urgency—this links in with travel—is to visit some community schools. If we do not do that, we are talking blind.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

Before we leave, I want us to decide, as a committee, whether we are inviting Hampden and all those associated with it to come to us by—I would suggest—28 September to give us a clear picture of what is going on. I would like to find out whether the committee wants to do that.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I suggest that we write to the minister and ask questions along the lines of those that you have been putting, Fiona. We might get an answer before 28 September. If we do not get a suitable answer by that date, we can give a commitment to invite Hampden back.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

That process can be truncated. If we ask the minister Fiona's questions and there is no reply by next Tuesday, we should be in a position to say that we must treat the issue as a priority. That gives the minister a week's grace.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Are we saying that we will decide whether this is a priority issue when we decide the rest of the agenda?

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

No, the proposal is that a letter is written on behalf of the committee asking these questions and, in the light of the answers—or lack of answers—we will decide what to do next Tuesday.

Ian Welsh Lab Ayr
link

I am at one with Fiona on the need for us to understand what is going on. I am sure, however, that it will be a question of resolving the funding issues—whatever they might be—and that the partners will be trying to do that. I am no more party to this than anyone else here, although I have some information from the Scottish Football Association side which I will not throw into the pot here. In principle, the scenario is no different from the balloting issue. The partners must resolve things and I do not want us to go clodhopping in and disturb that. On the other hand, it would be helpful to have, at least, a holding position to clarify the issues. I am saying that, but it would be nice if the funding partners said it, too.

Fiona McLeod SNP West of Scotland
link

I am not asking the committee to clodhop. I am asking exactly what Ian has just asked. We must have the issues clarified.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

We will write as a committee to the minister.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

And in the light of the response we will consider our next move. We want a response by next Tuesday. I am sure that the minister can provide that.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

We must conclude now. Thank you for your attendance, and thank you to those in the public gallery who have sat it out.

Meeting closed at 12:33.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Wednesday 8 September 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 14
  2. Improvement in Scottish Education Bill Bill debate · 195
  3. Work Programme Procedure · 86

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.