Item 3 is consideration of petition PE825, from Rosshall academy student council and higher modern studies section, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to ensure that every Scottish secondary school provides lockers for pupils. I am pleased to welcome Jonathan Cunningham, Colin Kerr and Mahreen Iqbal, who are students at Rosshall academy in Glasgow. They are accompanied by Lesley McCallum, who is a teacher of modern studies at the school. We have received written evidence, which is included in the papers along with a briefing note from the Scottish Parliament information centre.I ask the petitioners to make any opening statements, after which members will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Secondary Schools (Lockers) (PE825)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jonathan Cunningham Rosshall Academy 13
- Iain Smith LD 8
- Frank McAveety Lab 5
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 4
- Colin Kerr Rosshall Academy 2
- Rosemary Byrne Sol 2
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
- Elaine Murray Lab 1
The record
36 contributionsThank you for that welcome. We are from Rosshall academy, which is a secondary school in Glasgow. We decided to present a petition to the Scottish Parliament's Public Petitions Committee after we moved into a newly built public-private partnership secondary school and found that it was far too small to fit in the number of pupils who are supposed to be able to fit into it—1,250. We lodged the petition because we have to carry heavy bags around the school all day and feel that locker provision should be a requirement for new schools. We surveyed different year groups in the school and found that pupils carry between 6kg and 11kg, depending on the subjects that they take. For example, physical education equipment adds a lot of extra weight. Extra-curricular activities such as swimming or skiing and snowboarding, which we can now do, require equipment that we have to carry to school, which makes our bags even heavier.We gathered the evidence and considered the effect that our bags have on health. We estimate that pupils lift their bags 10 times or more a day, depending on the number of periods in the day. We have seven periods a day just now, but we may go on to eight when the 33-period week is introduced. We multiplied the figure of 10 by 180, which is the number of school days in a year, and worked out that, on average, we lift 9,797kg per school year, which is massive. All that weight is on our backs, because we cannot store our books in lockers.We did further research and found that scoliosis is a common back problem among young people. It can be put down to carrying a rucksack or bag and creates an S or C shape in the spine, which can stay with a person for life. The health-promoting option is for schools to provide lockers. That is what we want, and that is why we lodged our petition.
Do any of the other witnesses wish to say anything at this stage?
We encourage pupils to walk to school instead of catching the bus or travelling by car. That will create healthier people.
We echo that.
It is valuable for us to have this information. If some schools remain without lockers, what advice should pupils be given to avoid back strain? What would be the best way of delivering such guidance?
If schools remain without lockers, there should be a system for storing books that the school supplies, perhaps at the back of classrooms. Books might not need to be given out, given the technology that exists today. However, although a lot of information is available on computers, it could take years to make all the required books available in computer format. I believe that lockers must be provided—they are not just an option.
Why should the Scottish Parliament legislate on the matter rather than leave it to local authorities, as has been recommended?
When the then director of education of Glasgow City Council, Ronnie O'Connor, responded to the Public Petitions Committee, he stated:"The minimum required overall floor area according to design guidance available at the time of design … was assumed to be 7.54 m2 per pupil. The overall floor space provided at Rosshall was 9.22 m2 per pupil ie 1.68 m2 per pupil or 2100m2 above the requirement."He said that Rosshall academy provides more than enough space. When I took that back to the pupils, their response was that it was a lie, in a way. We have to carry our bags around. There is not enough space to fit in all the pupils at lunch time, let alone to provide lockers.In a later letter Ronnie O'Connor stated:"It would certainly be impossible to find sufficient space to provide lockers for every pupil in any school."That is practically a contradiction. Perhaps he looked at the matter again. After he sent his first letter, we invited him to Rosshall academy to pinpoint an area where we could fit lockers. He could not attend, which was a shame. The school board and the pupils surveyed the school to try to find a space for lockers—even a small space where some lockers for more senior pupils, who have more books, could be placed—but there is none.The matter should not be left to local councils. The best option is for the Scottish Parliament to pass a law requiring all councils to provide space for lockers in new schools.
What are the conditions in classrooms, given the weight and size of bags and the fact that pupils carry laptops, musical instruments and other things? Are classrooms cluttered? Is it difficult to move around in them and to get space?
Yes. It is very difficult to get space in classrooms, especially for those with musical instruments. I am a musician, and carrying instruments causes problems because the desks are not very big. If a pupil has a huge bag and a trumpet or a tuba, they will not have much room. There are also problems with leg room. You do not want to be all squashed up when you are trying to revise and to go over your school work. If you are, it will be difficult for you to concentrate on your work.
You have surveyed a number of pupils to find out whether they have back problems. Such problems could be caused by a range of things. As well as being caused by carrying heavy bags, they could be caused by factors such as lack of exercise, obesity, bad posture while using computers for long periods of time and so on. How sure are you that the problems that pupils report are caused by bags rather than other factors?
When we first submitted the petition to the Scottish Parliament, we included documents from BackCare and the British Chiropractic Association. BackCare noted that numerous studies show that, by the age of 14, half of all children are suffering from back discomfort. Among the suggested causes are heavy and awkward-shaped bags, badly designed or ill-fitting furniture, lack of exercise and sitting at computers. The British Chiropractic Association was in total agreement with our petition. It distributed 25,000 leaflets entitled "Watch Your Back" to secondary schools in Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council's area. It did so because, during its half-term health check campaign, it noticed that back pain in young people was related to their backpacks. There is a lot of evidence to support the view that backpacks are one of the main causes of back problems in young people.
I apologise for being slightly late. Our background papers say that California passed legislation that required the state board of education to adopt maximum weight standards for student textbooks. No absolute cap was set, but publishers were required to provide different options of weights of books. How many of the books that you have to carry are extremely thick? Would it be useful to do something about that, irrespective of what is done on the lockers issue?
I am in sixth year, so I have only four subjects to study, but first-year pupils have eight subjects to study. The mathematics book is about an inch thick. In modern studies, you get three or four books that are all about that thick. If you do music, you get lots of music books that are about that thick. Eight of those books would be a lot for a small first-year pupil to carry. In fact, one of our small pupils was on the BBC with his massive bag, which was full of massive books. You could see how it weighed him down. The thickness of the books is unbelievable.
A simple and practical thing to do would be to work, over a period of time—Interruption. That is my phone. I am sorry—it is the first time in a year that I have done that.
You will get detention for that.
It is the locker room for you.
Sorry about that. As I was saying, in the longer term, work could be done with the publishers to reduce the size of the books or to produce them in several volumes. Is the situation worse for first-year pupils?
It is definitely worse for first-years. Sixth-years also have more books, because although they have only four subjects, there is a lot more to their courses. The number of books for first-years is unbelievable, because they have eight subjects. As you go up the school, you get fewer subjects, but there can be more books for those subjects. First-years have the same number of books as sixth-years, even though sixth years take fewer subjects. Reducing the size of books is a great suggestion.
Rather than seeking primary legislation, we could ask the Government to produce guidance. We quite often have a debate about the power of guidance. We have guidance in other areas, such as health and safety issues for school transport. How would you feel if we thought about producing guidance on this issue, which might not affect you but might affect pupils elsewhere? Bearing in mind that you may not have space for lockers anyway, how would the pupils at your school feel? Would you be letting them down if you were helping other pupils but not necessarily helping yourselves?
Rosshall academy will never have locker space. The school has been squashed into a small park, so there is absolutely no space for lockers. An extension to the school is being considered, which might have locker space. The pupils of Rosshall know that lockers will not be provided, but they are happy that Rosshall academy is the school that has raised the issue. We do not want only to help Rosshall academy—we want to help the future schools of Glasgow and the rest of Scotland. There will be a lot of PPP schools and we want to ensure that those new schools for the pupils of the future have locker provision for those pupils.
Most schools, whether new or old, do not have a lot of space. Those schools in which the school roll has gone down may have a bit of space to spare. Given the number of lockers that would have to be provided to give one to every pupil, should priority be given to providing them for every first-year pupil, or every first and second-year pupil, rather than trying to provide one for every pupil in the school?
Definitely. Rosshall could not provide 1,250 lockers, but a newly built PPP school in East Renfrewshire, Williamwood high school, has a document showing that the school supplied 1,700 lockers for its pupils—that was planned into the design of the school. It was not a case of, "There's a space—let's put lockers in it." The decision was made to have a locker area for the pupils. Some councils have got it right; others have got it wrong. As the convener said, if lockers were provided in Rosshall, it might have to be for certain people, perhaps the first-years, who have the most subjects, or the sixth-years, who have a lot of books.
When a new school is being designed, should young people be more involved in considering the practical issues and saying what they want out of a school? Architects probably cannot remember when they were last at school.
That would be excellent. It was said that Rosshall pupils were more involved with the building of the school. In fact, the only thing our pupils got to be involved in was the school uniform. The only thing we got to decide on was the colour of our tie. Perhaps pupils who are experiencing newly built PPP schools could go to areas in which new PPP schools will be built and say, "This is what's wrong with our school, so maybe yours shouldn't be like that." They could give their opinion on what is wrong with their school and what should not be done in the new school.
I am sorry for being late. I presume that members have already asked about the response from the local authority and your capacity to engage in that process. Is that door still closed, or is there an opportunity to consider partial solutions, even within the existing framework of the school?
Are you asking about looking at solutions with the local authority?
Yes.
I do not know, but I am sure that there were surveyors in the school, who were maybe planning how the school could be extended. A local primary school that has been closed could perhaps be used to extend Rosshall academy, but it is well off the campus. I think that the door is closed, because there is no space. Rosshall academy was squeezed into the site. The community was not in favour of the school because it was built on an open, green space. We cannot even get a perimeter fence round the school. The community was against the school, so it was squashed into the smallest bit of the park and the other space was left open for the community. I do not know what the council is doing behind closed doors.
As well as lodging the petition, which we have been dealing with, have you thought about inviting some of the elected members from the school's catchment area to visit the school or getting a delegation of students to lobby councillors at their surgeries to draw their attention to the issue? Perhaps councillors are not as focused on it as you want them to be. Do you think that lobbying them, as well as raising the matter here, would be an appropriate course of action?
Do you mean speaking to the community and inviting them in?
I and a number of other members sitting round the table have served as councillors. If you lobby the councillors at their surgery and invite them into the school to see the real impact, rather than just having a notional discussion on paper, that could draw to their attention the limitations of the site, given the number of students. Would you consider doing that as an add-on to the commendable work that you have done in raising this issue in the Parliament?
Yes. We have considered that. We contacted the councillor for the area, Gordon Macdiarmid, who responded to us. However, I do not know whether he can do any more if the response from the guy who deals with education is that the council provides more than enough space—full stop. I do not know how much more Gordon Macdiarmid could do if the guy at the top says, "This is how it is." We could get back to the council and ask whether we could consider another option. We could work as a team on that. That might be a good idea.
Thank you all for coming today. Please take a seat in the public gallery while we consider our next step on the petition.I thank the pupils from the student council at Rosshall academy for making a well-prepared case, which was helpful. I wish all witnesses were as well prepared. I suggest to members that we might want to reflect on what we have heard today and discuss suggestions for the way forward at our next meeting. Are members content with that?Members indicated agreement.
We will put the matter on the agenda for our next meeting.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Feb 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education Committee Tuesday 27 February 2007 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- Witness Expenses Committee business · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 36
- Petitions Petitions · 29
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.