To ask the Scottish Executive what assessment it has made of the capacity of schools to timetable for pupils to study multiple national courses at secondary 4 level after their introduction in 2013. (S3O-9442)
Official Report · Chamber
National Courses
Europe, External Affairs and Culture Education and Lifelong Learning
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael Russell SNP 3
- Alison McInnes LD 2
- Ken Macintosh Lab 1
The record
6 contributionsAs at present, the number and range of qualifications that are undertaken by young people will be for schools, education authorities, colleges, parents and young people themselves to decide. The new qualifications will be designed to build on prior learning and will be flexible enough to be timetabled in many different ways. Our aim is to raise the level of achievement and to ensure continued breadth in the S4 to S6 senior phase. We expect young people to have the opportunity to study up to eight qualifications from S4.
Under this Government, work is being done at national and local levels on appropriate structures and to build schools capacity in order to offer a range of qualifications and other opportunities for personal achievement in the senior phase. I know that that is supported by members across the Parliament.
Under this Government, work is being done at national and local levels on appropriate structures and to build schools capacity in order to offer a range of qualifications and other opportunities for personal achievement in the senior phase. I know that that is supported by members across the Parliament.
Last week, the Scottish Secondary Teachers' Association claimed that the new national courses will lead to "timetable chaos" unless pupils drop some subjects. Currently, as the cabinet secretary has said, many pupils sit eight subjects over two years, but one year's study is more suited to five subjects. If pupils are obliged to reduce the number of subject areas, surely that runs counter to the curriculum for excellence agenda.
Given the conflicting responses that we have heard—from the Scottish Government's director of schools last week, advising that the courses should be started in S3, and from the minister today—will he agree to meet representatives of the SSTA, the Educational Institute of Scotland and parents to explore the concerns that have been raised so as to ensure that young people are not forced to restrict their subject choices when the new courses are introduced?
Given the conflicting responses that we have heard—from the Scottish Government's director of schools last week, advising that the courses should be started in S3, and from the minister today—will he agree to meet representatives of the SSTA, the Educational Institute of Scotland and parents to explore the concerns that have been raised so as to ensure that young people are not forced to restrict their subject choices when the new courses are introduced?
I can do much better than that. I met the SSTA recently and spoke about the issue that Alison McInnes has raised and other issues, and I met the EIS last week. I continue to have a useful and detailed dialogue with a range of bodies on curriculum for excellence and how we can engage the whole Scottish education community in ensuring that it is the best it can be. That dialogue is not helped by artificial divisions.
What will help is our ensuring that we are all going in the same direction and contributing positively—I stress "positively"—to the shaping and development of curriculum for excellence. The quality of what we get at the end of the process will be directly proportional to the input that we have from all teachers and teaching organisations, everybody in education and parents. We are going in that direction; I want us all to go in that direction. Everyone will find me very willing to work with them if we are working in a positive manner.
What will help is our ensuring that we are all going in the same direction and contributing positively—I stress "positively"—to the shaping and development of curriculum for excellence. The quality of what we get at the end of the process will be directly proportional to the input that we have from all teachers and teaching organisations, everybody in education and parents. We are going in that direction; I want us all to go in that direction. Everyone will find me very willing to work with them if we are working in a positive manner.
Does the cabinet secretary envisage any pupils sitting national courses in their third year, rather than their fourth year? If so, how many pupils will do that?
I envisage a continuing discussion about what is best for each young person. If Mr Macintosh wants to be part of that process—I hope that he does—let us engage on whether his suggestion would be useful or sensible for the young people involved.
I hope that last week we witnessed the end of the type of spat that does not help curriculum for excellence, in which it is suggested that decisions are being made secretly or perversely. There is a management board: I am listening to the management board. The management board consists of representatives of the trade unions, the management side and education organisations, and it is keen to take part. Parents are welcome to contribute, too. Last week I launched a parental toolkit. I want more parental involvement.
I repeat this point because it is so important: the reality is that if there is positive input on development of curriculum for excellence, day by day, week by week and month by month, and if we honestly and openly debate how curriculum for excellence is to be implemented, we will have what we are meant to have: a wonderful new system for the 21st century. Some people think that it could be the best in the world; it will be the best in the world only if we all put our energy and imagination into it, rather than carp about it.
I hope that last week we witnessed the end of the type of spat that does not help curriculum for excellence, in which it is suggested that decisions are being made secretly or perversely. There is a management board: I am listening to the management board. The management board consists of representatives of the trade unions, the management side and education organisations, and it is keen to take part. Parents are welcome to contribute, too. Last week I launched a parental toolkit. I want more parental involvement.
I repeat this point because it is so important: the reality is that if there is positive input on development of curriculum for excellence, day by day, week by week and month by month, and if we honestly and openly debate how curriculum for excellence is to be implemented, we will have what we are meant to have: a wonderful new system for the 21st century. Some people think that it could be the best in the world; it will be the best in the world only if we all put our energy and imagination into it, rather than carp about it.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Feb 2010 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 4 February 2010 Debate · 1
- Business Motion Business motions · 12
- Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 310
- Social Care (Procurement) Questions · 4
- Domestic Abuse (Male Victims) Questions · 13
- Public Service Vehicles (Shared Fuel Depots and Management Systems) Questions · 4
- Minister for Housing and Communities (Discussions with Local Authorities) Questions · 6
- Aberdeen City Council(Single Outcome Agreements) Questions · 8
- Community Health Services(Areas of Multiple Deprivation) Questions · 4
- National Insurance Contributions(Scottish Budget Impact) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- 2012 Olympic Games First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Education (Local Authority Budgets) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Water (Structure and Ownership) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Commission on Scottish Devolution Questions · 6
- Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland Questions · 6
- READ International Book Project Questions · 4
- Youth Music Initiative Questions · 8
- Lisbon Treaty Questions · 8
- Haiti (Emergency Relief Effort) Questions · 6
- Joint European Resources for Micro to Medium Enterprises Questions · 4
- Schools (Community Access) Questions · 6
- Skills (Unpaid Carers) Questions · 4
- School Exclusions Questions · 8
- Skills Development Scotland (Number of Staff) Questions · 6
- National Courses Questions · 6
- School Closures (North Lanarkshire) Questions · 8
- Marine (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 116
- Marine (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 22
- Points of Order Procedure · 10
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 6
- Scottish Railway Museum Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.