To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2111)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Alex Fergusson 5
The record
17 contributionsLater today, I will take forward the Government's programme for Scotland. Immediately, ministers are going to another meeting of the ministerial resilience committee, which gives us all the opportunity—which was well received this morning—to thank all the workers in the gritters throughout the local authorities, and our third sector who are making heroic efforts to keep the country moving.
I join the First Minister in paying tribute to all those who are working to keep our roads clear, all those who are working to keep our care and emergency services moving, and the often unsung heroes who are doing what they can to help out their friends and neighbours.
However, the Scottish people rightly expect the Scottish Government to do its bit too, so they must have been astonished on Monday to hear a bumbling John Swinney say that, as far as he could see, there were "perfectly adequate walking conditions" in Scotland. There is no wonder that one headline read, "John Swinney rubs salt into public's wounds", and that another read, "Emergency? Not in Swinney world". Does the First Minister agree that Mr Swinney's statement was perhaps just a little bit on the complacent side?
However, the Scottish people rightly expect the Scottish Government to do its bit too, so they must have been astonished on Monday to hear a bumbling John Swinney say that, as far as he could see, there were "perfectly adequate walking conditions" in Scotland. There is no wonder that one headline read, "John Swinney rubs salt into public's wounds", and that another read, "Emergency? Not in Swinney world". Does the First Minister agree that Mr Swinney's statement was perhaps just a little bit on the complacent side?
No. I would say that Mr Swinney—in sharp contrast with some United Kingdom Government ministers, including the Secretary of State for Transport—had been working with other ministers to ensure that there was ministerial direction of the resilience committee, which was meeting every day at official level in order to ensure that Scotland had such leadership throughout the holiday period. [Interruption.]
I hear some questions as to what I am talking about. I notice from the ministerial rota that the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change worked on Christmas day—as, indeed, he should have done, because Scotland experienced cold conditions on Christmas day. His counterpart in the UK Government was reported as being on a skiing holiday—not in Scotland, where there would have been plenty opportunity to ski, but elsewhere. Mr Swinney worked on new year's day. We expect our ministers to do that and it is right that they should work. The reason is that, throughout Scotland, there are gritters and road workers who have not had a holiday over the festive period because they have been working round the clock.
Everyone is doing their bit—the Scottish Government, local authorities and voluntary organisations. Instead of totally missing the moment, as Johann Lamont did earlier, Iain Gray should try to rise to the occasion and get together with the all-Scotland team that is taking Scotland through the crisis.
I hear some questions as to what I am talking about. I notice from the ministerial rota that the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change worked on Christmas day—as, indeed, he should have done, because Scotland experienced cold conditions on Christmas day. His counterpart in the UK Government was reported as being on a skiing holiday—not in Scotland, where there would have been plenty opportunity to ski, but elsewhere. Mr Swinney worked on new year's day. We expect our ministers to do that and it is right that they should work. The reason is that, throughout Scotland, there are gritters and road workers who have not had a holiday over the festive period because they have been working round the clock.
Everyone is doing their bit—the Scottish Government, local authorities and voluntary organisations. Instead of totally missing the moment, as Johann Lamont did earlier, Iain Gray should try to rise to the occasion and get together with the all-Scotland team that is taking Scotland through the crisis.
We know that John Swinney was working on Monday; we just do not recognise the Scotland that he described when he went on national radio. I am not alone in that, nor in hearing from many elderly constituents who have been housebound for almost three weeks and do not know what to do. Walking conditions have not been "adequate" for them; they are impossible for them. Many of those people usually manage on their own, so they do not have carers coming in and do not know where to turn. Where was the hotline that they could phone? Where was the Government advice on radio? Where were the adverts on television telling them what to do?
This morning, we heard that the Government is only now putting that information on its website and talking to local radio. Is not that a little late in the day? How complacent is a Government that takes three weeks to provide advice to vulnerable people?
This morning, we heard that the Government is only now putting that information on its website and talking to local radio. Is not that a little late in the day? How complacent is a Government that takes three weeks to provide advice to vulnerable people?
I am glad that Iain Gray at least gives me the opportunity, because of the nature of his question, to talk about the weather wise advice section of the Scottish Government website. I advise all MSPs, as well as everybody who is watching the First Minister's questions programme, to consult the advice site if they can, because it has valuable information, including details of the local government helpline numbers across Scotland, weather information, health advice, particular information for older people, information on the Government's excellent energy assistance package—which is particularly important at this time—and up-to-date information on travel and schools.
No doubt, when Iain Gray gets time to look at the site—when he left the chamber halfway through the question time that followed the Government's statement this morning on the severe weather, I thought that he was perhaps going to inform himself of the detail that was available—and when members get time to do so, they will see how it pulls together the efforts that are being made across the country.
I understand full well the frustration of people across Scotland about local roads and, indeed, about pavements and walking conditions. However, I know that people in Scotland understand the point that was made to me yesterday by the leader of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, Pat Watters, which is that, in the circumstances, all of us—Government and local authorities—have to husband our supplies of salt and grit in order to be able to cope with expected further weeks of severe weather. Believe me, nobody would want to thank the Scottish Government or local authorities if we fell into the trap that Iain Gray apparently advocates of not husbanding supplies and being unable to respond to the worst possible circumstances over the next few weeks. If that is understood by Labour leaders of COSLA and by local government across the country, why on earth is it not understood by the Opposition leader in this Parliament?
No doubt, when Iain Gray gets time to look at the site—when he left the chamber halfway through the question time that followed the Government's statement this morning on the severe weather, I thought that he was perhaps going to inform himself of the detail that was available—and when members get time to do so, they will see how it pulls together the efforts that are being made across the country.
I understand full well the frustration of people across Scotland about local roads and, indeed, about pavements and walking conditions. However, I know that people in Scotland understand the point that was made to me yesterday by the leader of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, Pat Watters, which is that, in the circumstances, all of us—Government and local authorities—have to husband our supplies of salt and grit in order to be able to cope with expected further weeks of severe weather. Believe me, nobody would want to thank the Scottish Government or local authorities if we fell into the trap that Iain Gray apparently advocates of not husbanding supplies and being unable to respond to the worst possible circumstances over the next few weeks. If that is understood by Labour leaders of COSLA and by local government across the country, why on earth is it not understood by the Opposition leader in this Parliament?
The First Minister is right. I did go earlier this morning to the Scottish Government website to see what advice was readily available for older people who might have turned to it in recent days. As far as I can see, if they looked in the past week at the news site, which is the front page of the Scottish Government website, they would have had two bits of advice: a press release telling them to get outdoors in 2010, which they are trying to do but cannot; and a press release entitled "Cold comfort for garden birds". I, too, feed the birds in my garden, but that is not my first priority at a time like this. That is the information that has been readily available over the past two or three weeks.
This morning, in response to questions in the chamber, Mr Swinney told us that the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing had been fully "absorbed" in the emergency. Really? Why, then, was she not on the radio giving advice to the vulnerable? [Interruption.]
This morning, in response to questions in the chamber, Mr Swinney told us that the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing had been fully "absorbed" in the emergency. Really? Why, then, was she not on the radio giving advice to the vulnerable? [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Yesterday, ministers finally met council leaders. Was the health secretary there to discuss services for the vulnerable, or was she not?
Strangely enough, I wondered whether Iain Gray's early departure from questions on the severe weather situation meant that he was running to the website. I anticipated that he would do that, so I brought along a printout of the web page, because I would not want any member to suffer from any possible misinformation from the Labour leader in Scotland. I have the full information from the website, which I will go through again. Incidentally, it is timed with the information on a similar United Kingdom website for the rest of the country.
The website links to every local council in Scotland, with the local emergency numbers. There is also weather information, health advice, information specifically for older people on winter fuel payments, as well as information on—of course—the Government's keep warm, keep well campaign and the energy assistance package, and on a range of measures that we have to help people in Scotland. The site goes on to provide specific and up-to-date information on travel and schools, and on the NHS 24 service, which operates its emergency lines in all circumstances.
Instead of coming along and trying to find any possible fault in the ministerial response, which has been comprehensively better and superior to anything else that has been happening in these islands, perhaps Iain Gray will finally come to the realisation that he should get on board and try to rise to the occasion in finding a constructive role for the Opposition, and stop trying to deflect attention from the chaos of the Labour Party south of the border. Interestingly, the only things that have kept the cold weather off the front page are stories about Labour's leadership crisis.
The website links to every local council in Scotland, with the local emergency numbers. There is also weather information, health advice, information specifically for older people on winter fuel payments, as well as information on—of course—the Government's keep warm, keep well campaign and the energy assistance package, and on a range of measures that we have to help people in Scotland. The site goes on to provide specific and up-to-date information on travel and schools, and on the NHS 24 service, which operates its emergency lines in all circumstances.
Instead of coming along and trying to find any possible fault in the ministerial response, which has been comprehensively better and superior to anything else that has been happening in these islands, perhaps Iain Gray will finally come to the realisation that he should get on board and try to rise to the occasion in finding a constructive role for the Opposition, and stop trying to deflect attention from the chaos of the Labour Party south of the border. Interestingly, the only things that have kept the cold weather off the front page are stories about Labour's leadership crisis.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
This is all taking far too long. We are running out of time. Your final question should be brief, please, Mr Gray, and the response should be equally brief. [Interruption.] Order.
We have, indeed, heard the ministerial response from Mr Swinney in recent days. On Monday, he told us that the pavements were fine. Yesterday, he told us that he is "not a player" in contracts with salt suppliers. This morning, he told us that he has no contingency funds to deal with any kind of emergency. Therefore, there is no problem, there is no contingency fund, and the matter is nothing to do with him. I have a constructive suggestion to which the First Minister can give a simple answer. Will the First Minister get a grip of the matter and within the next 24 hours get a national single hotline number set up for vulnerable people, instead of taking three weeks?
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
The First Minister should be brief, please.
If Iain Gray ever talked to his colleagues in local government, he would know that they specifically asked for information to be publicised about their telephone numbers. They do not want a number that would supplant the emergency and help numbers for every service at local level. That was the specific advice from Councillor Pat Watters, who represents COSLA. I do not know whether Iain Gray engages in conversations with his own political party, never mind with ministers, but I know that people in Scotland expect better of their Opposition leader, just as people expect the Scottish Government to work as it has done over the holiday period, unlike the United Kingdom Government.
I have two final things to say to Iain Gray. First, the last entry on the Scotland Office website was for 24 December.
I have two final things to say to Iain Gray. First, the last entry on the Scotland Office website was for 24 December.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
You should be brief, please, First Minister.
Secondly, Iain Gray should take a leaf out of his predecessor's book. Earlier today, his predecessor came to the chamber when Iain Gray was already absent and made an entirely constructive suggestion about how local authorities could fill up gritting bins around the country with sand and other materials to help communities to help themselves. That is exactly what the Scottish Government and local authorities are recommending. Iain Gray should take a leaf out of his predecessor's book and come to the chamber with something constructive to say. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Jan 2010 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 7 January 2010 Debate · 1
- Severe Weather Statement · 65
- Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 98
- Community Hospitals Questions · 6
- NHS Grampian (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Bus Services Questions · 6
- Christmas Bonuses Questions · 4
- Aberdeen Airport (Globespan) Questions · 7
- Zero Waste Policy Questions · 5
- Aviation Industry (State Aid) Questions · 4
- Army Cadet Force Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Legal System (Peter Tobin) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Climate Change Targets (Insulation) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- NHS Dental Care First Minister’s Questions · 14
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- International Student Visas Questions · 4
- Class Sizes (P1 to P3) Questions · 6
- Apprenticeships (Central Scotland) Questions · 6
- Teacher Numbers Questions · 11
- Synthetic Phonics Questions · 4
- Scottish Literature Questions · 6
- Colleges (Support) Questions · 4
- Education and Lifelong Learning Questions · 1
- Joint Ministerial Committee (Meetings) Questions · 4
- National Collections (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Scottish Culture (Local Newspapers) Questions · 9
- Aberdeenshire Art and Culture Questions · 6
- Commonwealth Games 2014 (Culture) Questions · 6
- Scots Language Support Questions · 4
- Creative Scotland (2010-11 Budget) Questions · 4
- Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 104
- Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 16
- Asbestos-related Diseases Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.