To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2094)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 7
- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Fergusson 2
The record
14 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
Under the ministerial code, ministers are expected to behave according to the highest standards of constitutional and personal conduct. The First Minister is the ultimate judge.
Two weeks ago, Mark MacLachlan, an aide to Michael Russell, was identified as the anonymous author of a blog with a track record of smears and abuse of political opponents. On BBC Scotland, Mr Russell was asked:
"Did you know he was doing it?"
He replied, "No." Today, however, Mr MacLachlan says that Mr Russell was not only aware of the blog but even "suggested possible subjects." Is the First Minister undertaking an investigation under the ministerial code to establish whether Mr Russell told the truth to the BBC?
Two weeks ago, Mark MacLachlan, an aide to Michael Russell, was identified as the anonymous author of a blog with a track record of smears and abuse of political opponents. On BBC Scotland, Mr Russell was asked:
"Did you know he was doing it?"
He replied, "No." Today, however, Mr MacLachlan says that Mr Russell was not only aware of the blog but even "suggested possible subjects." Is the First Minister undertaking an investigation under the ministerial code to establish whether Mr Russell told the truth to the BBC?
No. What I have ascertained is that, as Mike Russell has made repeatedly clear, he was shocked to be told about the matter, knew absolutely nothing about it and accepted, of course, Mr MacLachlan's resignation.
I deprecate attack blogs. I do not think that any political party should have anything to do with them. I do not think that that is what the internet is for.
This week we have seen a huge issue with the collapse of Globespan and the enormous planetary issue that is being debated in Copenhagen, and yesterday we saw the first drop in unemployment in Scotland in 18 months. Does Iain Gray not consider that those are some of the issues that the people of Scotland would expect the Opposition leader in Scotland to raise, rather than to focus on personality and process?
I deprecate attack blogs. I do not think that any political party should have anything to do with them. I do not think that that is what the internet is for.
This week we have seen a huge issue with the collapse of Globespan and the enormous planetary issue that is being debated in Copenhagen, and yesterday we saw the first drop in unemployment in Scotland in 18 months. Does Iain Gray not consider that those are some of the issues that the people of Scotland would expect the Opposition leader in Scotland to raise, rather than to focus on personality and process?
I have already made clear how important I believe the climate change talks in Copenhagen are—frankly, they are rather more important than an attempt at a photo call with Arnie Schwarzenegger. This morning, I have made very clear my concerns about the 800 employees of and the 4,000 travellers with Globespan. However, the First Minister cannot use those job losses to hide behind in order to avoid answering questions about this matter.
If Mr Russell did not know about this "black ops" blog, there is no impediment to his coming to the chamber to set the record straight. Will the First Minister instruct Mr Russell to come to Parliament and confirm whether he knew of the blog?
If Mr Russell did not know about this "black ops" blog, there is no impediment to his coming to the chamber to set the record straight. Will the First Minister instruct Mr Russell to come to Parliament and confirm whether he knew of the blog?
Mr Russell has already said repeatedly that he did not know of the blog, and Iain Gray has absolutely no evidence to suggest that that statement is inaccurate.
I used the words "personality and process" deliberately, because Labour members should remember that in Iain Gray's St Andrew's day speech, which he made on 2 December, he said:
"We focus too much on personality and process and not enough on the issues that the Scottish people care about.
Our politics needs the chattering classes, but we have to be sure that we are chattering about the right things."
I submit to the chamber and the Opposition leader that the people of Scotland would expect him to be chattering about the things that he says he cares about but does not bother to raise at First Minister's question time: the state of the Copenhagen summit and what is going on there. Let us debate that. Let us debate the plight of the staff and passengers of Globespan. Let us debate the unemployment figures in Scotland, which show the first decrease for 18 months. Those are the issues that he should be raising, not personality, smears and process.
I used the words "personality and process" deliberately, because Labour members should remember that in Iain Gray's St Andrew's day speech, which he made on 2 December, he said:
"We focus too much on personality and process and not enough on the issues that the Scottish people care about.
Our politics needs the chattering classes, but we have to be sure that we are chattering about the right things."
I submit to the chamber and the Opposition leader that the people of Scotland would expect him to be chattering about the things that he says he cares about but does not bother to raise at First Minister's question time: the state of the Copenhagen summit and what is going on there. Let us debate that. Let us debate the plight of the staff and passengers of Globespan. Let us debate the unemployment figures in Scotland, which show the first decrease for 18 months. Those are the issues that he should be raising, not personality, smears and process.
It is exactly because I care about Scottish politics that I wish to see these anonymous blogs rooted out and got rid of. That is why, six months ago, when one of those blogs was spreading smears and rumours about me and my marriage, I asked the First Minister to take action. He refused to do so and said that those blogs were nothing to do with the SNP, but now we discover that the author of one blog worked for one of his ministers.
The First Minister says that Mr MacLachlan resigned, but Mr MacLachlan says that he did not resign and that Michael Russell phoned him to say that he had to go. Mr MacLachlan says that an apology that was issued in his name was written by Kevin Pringle, who is the First Minister's most senior adviser. If that is true, a cover-up has been attempted that involved the First Minister and his office. Did the First Minister order Mr Russell to sack Mr MacLachlan and order Kevin Pringle to draft a resignation statement for Mr MacLachlan?
The First Minister says that Mr MacLachlan resigned, but Mr MacLachlan says that he did not resign and that Michael Russell phoned him to say that he had to go. Mr MacLachlan says that an apology that was issued in his name was written by Kevin Pringle, who is the First Minister's most senior adviser. If that is true, a cover-up has been attempted that involved the First Minister and his office. Did the First Minister order Mr Russell to sack Mr MacLachlan and order Kevin Pringle to draft a resignation statement for Mr MacLachlan?
Iain Gray descends from bad to worse. Mr MacLachlan is not an appropriate person to work for any MSP.
Iain Gray mentioned six months ago. At that time, a Tory blogger—Iain Dale—wrote:
"Readers in Scotland and Wales may be having a wry smile at the fact that the grubby Red Flag blog didn't quite make it to the internet in time"—
if we remember, that blog was connected with the Damian McBride affair—
"For in those two countries, Labour has indeed started up versions of the Red Rag"—
[Interruption.]
Iain Gray mentioned six months ago. At that time, a Tory blogger—Iain Dale—wrote:
"Readers in Scotland and Wales may be having a wry smile at the fact that the grubby Red Flag blog didn't quite make it to the internet in time"—
if we remember, that blog was connected with the Damian McBride affair—
"For in those two countries, Labour has indeed started up versions of the Red Rag"—
[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
He continued:
"In Wales we have the Aneurin Glyndwr blog … and in Scotland A Leaky Chanter (started in December 2008)"—[Interruption.]
"In Wales we have the Aneurin Glyndwr blog … and in Scotland A Leaky Chanter (started in December 2008)"—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
He continued:
"They are not as salacious as the Red Rag was intended to be, but they clearly exist as attack blogs".
Here is the challenge: if we want to talk about conduct in politics, let us condemn attack blogs from whatever source. After Damian McBride and the Leaky Chanter, the Labour Party should not pretend that it has not had serious involvement in such things. As a Parliament, can we not agree to deprecate such conduct?
"They are not as salacious as the Red Rag was intended to be, but they clearly exist as attack blogs".
Here is the challenge: if we want to talk about conduct in politics, let us condemn attack blogs from whatever source. After Damian McBride and the Leaky Chanter, the Labour Party should not pretend that it has not had serious involvement in such things. As a Parliament, can we not agree to deprecate such conduct?
I condemn absolutely attack blogs from whichever part of the political spectrum they come. I want the matter to be cleared up properly, so I ask: will the First Minister release any documents or e-mails that relate to Mr MacLachlan that any ministerial office or any of his special advisers holds? When did the First Minister, Kevin Pringle and any of the First Minister's other special advisers know about Mr MacLachlan's blog? Just for today, will the First Minister say when he or Kevin Pringle first had sight of the e-mails that were published in The Herald today?
I knew about Mr MacLachlan's resignation when Mr Russell informed me that his former employee was no longer working for him because he did not judge Mr MacLachlan to be a suitable person to work for him.
The question for Iain Gray is whether he knows the difference between an allegation and a revelation. I have a remarkable statement from him this morning in which he talks about "revelations" in The Herald today, which is a dangerous course of action to take. It is only a few days since the same journalist who writes in The Herald today said on the front page of the Sunday Herald:
"Labour leader Iain Gray in new donations ‘sleaze' row".
That referred, of course, to what has become known as the burgergate scandal in East Lothian. My point is that that is an allegation, not a revelation. A statement is a revelation only if it is established. If Iain Gray bandies about allegations as revelations, he should not be surprised if he has to answer the allegations about his constituency.
It is extraordinary that Iain Gray comes to the chamber to bandy about comments on process and personalities, to ignore the big issues that face Scotland, to be totally unaware of the feet of clay in his constituency, to recycle smears and not to accept a minister's clear statement that he—like me and, I hope, every member of Parliament—deprecates the smears and attack blogs that have been prevalent throughout the political system.
The question for Iain Gray is whether he knows the difference between an allegation and a revelation. I have a remarkable statement from him this morning in which he talks about "revelations" in The Herald today, which is a dangerous course of action to take. It is only a few days since the same journalist who writes in The Herald today said on the front page of the Sunday Herald:
"Labour leader Iain Gray in new donations ‘sleaze' row".
That referred, of course, to what has become known as the burgergate scandal in East Lothian. My point is that that is an allegation, not a revelation. A statement is a revelation only if it is established. If Iain Gray bandies about allegations as revelations, he should not be surprised if he has to answer the allegations about his constituency.
It is extraordinary that Iain Gray comes to the chamber to bandy about comments on process and personalities, to ignore the big issues that face Scotland, to be totally unaware of the feet of clay in his constituency, to recycle smears and not to accept a minister's clear statement that he—like me and, I hope, every member of Parliament—deprecates the smears and attack blogs that have been prevalent throughout the political system.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Dec 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 17 December 2009 Debate · 1
- Budget Process 2010-11 Debate · 114
- Dementia Services (Fife) Questions · 8
- HM Prison Noranside (Christmas Closure) Questions · 4
- Fife Constabulary (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Computer Games Industry (Dundee) Questions · 8
- Scottish Police Services Authority (VAT) Questions · 13
- Dietary Food Standard (In-patients) Questions · 4
- Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Bill Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- National Health Service Boards (Front-line Services) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Teacher Induction Scheme Employment Survey 2008-09 First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Emissions Targets (Nuclear Power) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Allotments, Community Gardens and Grow-your-own Projects Members’ business · 18
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- “Report on scrutiny of theDraft Budget 2010-11” Questions · 8
- Senior Public Sector Staff (Pay Cap) Questions · 10
- British Geological Survey(Gilmerton Core Store) Questions · 4
- RAF West Freugh (Satellite Ground Station) Questions · 4
- Network Rail (Payments for Rail Projects) Questions · 4
- Textiles Industry (Scottish Borders) Questions · 6
- Front-line Services(Health and Local Government) Questions · 8
- Public Information Notices (Advertising) Questions · 4
- Alternative Business Models (City of Edinburgh Council) Questions · 4
- Rail Freight (Longannet) Questions · 6
- Local Authority Funding Questions · 4
- Barclays Partner Finance (Relocation) Questions · 4
- Pre-budget Report Questions · 4
- CO2 Emissions (Hunterston) Questions · 8
- Home Owner and Debtor Protection (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 38
- Home Owner and Debtor Protection (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.