Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Independence Referendum

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 3 December 2009 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Party Spokesperson on Culture · Glasgow Kelvin
link
To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Government considers that £12 million spent on a referendum is the best use of taxpayers' money in a recession. (S3F-2071)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
The moneys to be spent on a referendum will be indicated in the referendum bill that will come before the Parliament. If Scotland chooses, in a national referendum, to increase the powers of the Parliament and to become independent, the many benefits that I can see accruing include this Parliament and this nation not having to contribute £9 million for the House of Lords every year, £32 million for our share of the House of Commons every year or £8 million for the Secretary of State for Scotland every year. That is money that we should invest every year in making Scotland more successful, and it far outweighs the cost of a one-off referendum.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Party Spokesperson on Culture · Glasgow Kelvin
link
Does the First Minister acknowledge that today's MORI poll puts support for independence at just 20 per cent, and that support for independence is falling? Could that be due the fact that, after two and a half years of a Scottish National Party Administration, the people of Scotland have got a glimpse of the SNP's vision for their country and are rejecting it?

If Alex Salmond, the new member in charge of the referendum bill, cannot persuade respected nationalists such as Jim Sillars and Gordon Wilson about his doomed referendum bill, has he considered the possibility that he might just be wrong? Where will Alex Salmond succeed where Mike Russell has failed?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I thank agent Pauline McNeill for allowing me to talk about today's MORI poll. The real figures published by MORI, as opposed to the fake figures in a Labour Party press release, show that the Scottish National Party is ahead not just in Holyrood voting intentions but in Westminster voting intentions.

On the subject of a referendum, I was generous enough to congratulate Carwyn Jones, who is to be First Minister of Wales, on his election. Pauline McNeill will have heard that Carwyn Jones is an enthusiast for a referendum on Wales's constitutional future. Perhaps that point should be considered. Perhaps the SNP is moving ahead, as shown in today's MORI poll, because the people of Scotland are wondering why the Labour Party wants an alternative transferable vote referendum in England and a constitutional referendum in Wales but is trying to deprive the people of Scotland of the right to have a say on their own constitutional future.

Aileen Campbell SNP South of Scotland
link
Will the First Minister confirm that it is still the Scottish Government's intention to find a way to allow 16 and 17-year-olds to vote in the referendum on Scotland's future, unlike that of the Opposition parties, which are refusing to let any voter in Scotland have a democratic say on the constitution?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Of course, a surge in support for the SNP among 16 and 17-year-olds cannot be the reason for our moving ahead in the MORI poll, since they were not counted in MORI's sample.

I hope that the Parliament will decide that 16-year-olds should be entitled to vote on things that affect their future, as will happen in relation to elections to health boards. For the referendum bill, we will have to use the current franchise that is available to people. Nonetheless, I am sure that Aileen Campbell, on behalf of the young people of Scotland, will continue to put forward her argument. From this First Minister at least she will get receptive concern and answers.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link
Does the First Minister now regret not taking up my offer some 18 months ago, before the global economic downturn, of parliamentary support for an early referendum?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I am not certain that this is Wendy Alexander's strongest suit. There is a hopeful aspect to the Wendy Alexander initiative last year, which at the time was loyally supported by Iain Gray. We might come to the conclusion that, if the Labour Party can change its mind twice—as it has done already in this parliamentary session, given that it now opposes a referendum—a third change of mind next year is not beyond the bounds of possibility. I am sure that Wendy Alexander will encourage her colleagues to allow the people of Scotland to have that say on this nation's future.

Jeremy Purvis LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link
At the meeting of the Finance Committee on 9 November, I asked the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth whether there was provision in the 2010-11 budget for the referendum. He said that there was not. I responded that he would therefore have to find the money

"by cutting something that is in the budget".

The cabinet secretary responded:

"I would have to make a choice in order to provide for a referendum bill—yes."—[Official Report, Finance Committee, 9 November 2009; c 1654.]

Education, housing, transport and health budgets are protected. From what line in the 2010-11 budget would the referendum costs come?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
The cost of the referendum will be in the referendum bill, but if it were to be £9 million, that would be 0.03 per cent of total Scottish Government expenditure.

I have been teasing the Labour Party about its support for a referendum elsewhere. I remind Jeremy Purvis that the Liberals seem to be enthusiasts for a referendum on whether we should be in or out of Europe. Incidentally, they enthusiastically back the new Welsh First Minister in his call for an early referendum in Wales. Why on earth does the Liberal party want to consult the people on everything except the constitutional future of this nation?

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link
Can the First Minister tell us how many of the contributors to the national conversation online discussion are in fact cybernats who are working for SNP parliamentarians at taxpayers' expense?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
There were 500,000 hits on the national conversation website. That reflects a substantial amount of interest. If we consider the relative sizes of the national conversation and the Conservative party, I do not think that the Conservatives made a substantial contribution to the national conversation.

The national conversation engaged the people of Scotland at public meetings the length and breadth of the country. If Murdo Fraser wants to put it to the test, as I understand that Conservatives, including his old friend and sponsor Mr Michael Forsyth, do on a range of issues, perhaps they will join Wendy Alexander in supporting the right of the people of Scotland to have a say on expanding the powers of the Parliament, so that we can tackle all the issues and achieve what all of us would like to achieve for the people of this nation.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 December 2009 Debate · 1
  2. Minister Debate · 17
  3. Education Debate · 124
  4. Glasgow Airport Rail Link Questions · 8
  5. Glasgow Airport Rail Link Questions · 8
  6. Schools (Financial Education) Questions · 4
  7. Education Questions · 6
  8. Carbon Emissions Questions · 4
  9. Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 4
  10. Carbon Capture and Storage Questions · 7
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  12. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  14. Throat Cancer (University of Milan Study) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Independence Referendum First Minister’s Questions · 12
  16. Education (National Debate) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Housing (Priorities) Questions · 6
  18. Health Spending (2010-11 Draft Budget) Questions · 6
  19. NHS Aroma Cafe Pilot (Evaluation) Questions · 6
  20. Mental Health Services (Voluntary Sector Providers) Questions · 8
  21. Attendance Allowance (Older Disabled People) Questions · 7
  22. Mental Health Services (International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights) Questions · 4
  23. Children with Epilepsy (West Lothian) Questions · 4
  24. Patient Transport Service (Remote and Rural Areas) Questions · 10
  25. Community Care Services (Guidance) Questions · 4
  26. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde(Meetings with Chief Executive) Questions · 4
  27. Football Questions · 4
  28. Administration of Medicines in Schools Questions · 4
  29. Alcohol Treatment (Disulfiram) Questions · 4
  30. Getting it Right for Every Child Debate · 42
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 30
  32. Licensed Premises(Access for Disabled People) Members’ business · 24

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.