To ask the First Minister whether the recent opinion from the European Court of Justice on tobacco pricing affects the Scottish Government's plans to introduce a minimum price for alcohol. (S3F-1974)
Official Report · Chamber
Alcohol (Minimum Pricing)
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 3
- Michael Matheson SNP 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
The record
6 contributionsThe directive in the case to which the member refers is specifically about the excise duty on tobacco and has nothing to do with alcohol products. It is, therefore, entirely inappropriate and irrelevant to transfer the comments in the opinion to the introduction of a minimum price for alcohol for public health reasons. However, the European Commission has given an indication of its attitude to minimum pricing. In a written statement to Catherine Stihler MEP, it confirmed that European Union legislation does not prohibit member states from setting minimum retail prices for alcoholic drinks on public health grounds.
The First Minister will be aware that some organisations have questioned whether minimum pricing for alcohol is compatible with EU law. He referred to the statement that the European Commission has already issued. Is he aware that the Commission has also stated that two key criteria must be complied with if minimum pricing on alcohol is to comply with EU trade treaties? First, minimum pricing must apply to all relevant traders within a national territory. Secondly, it must have the same impact on domestic and imported products, if they are discounted. Can the First Minister confirm that the policy that the Scottish Government is pursuing will comply with those two key criteria?
We are aware of all the issues that must be considered to ensure that the arrangements and the specific price that is set are fair and proportionate, to be consistent with European law. They must be non-discriminatory and must exemplify and illustrate a substantial health benefit.
I hope that, before the matter is discussed fully, all members will take the opportunity to look at the University of Sheffield study for Scotland that was published on 28 September. The study identified substantial financial savings in the economy, running to billions of pounds a year, from a minimum price of 40p per unit of alcohol. It demonstrated that a minimum pricing policy would have substantial health benefits and postulated that it could save thousands of lives in Scotland by preventing unnecessary and early deaths.
When we weigh up, as we will, the considerations that lie behind the proposal, we should look at the substantial economic benefit—there is also a crime argument—of redressing Scotland's attitude to alcohol. Let us also remember the public health benefits that the University of Sheffield's report has identified. It is not that often that a Parliament decides on an issue that affects the lives of many thousands of our fellow citizens. I hope that all members will address this issue with the seriousness that it deserves.
I hope that, before the matter is discussed fully, all members will take the opportunity to look at the University of Sheffield study for Scotland that was published on 28 September. The study identified substantial financial savings in the economy, running to billions of pounds a year, from a minimum price of 40p per unit of alcohol. It demonstrated that a minimum pricing policy would have substantial health benefits and postulated that it could save thousands of lives in Scotland by preventing unnecessary and early deaths.
When we weigh up, as we will, the considerations that lie behind the proposal, we should look at the substantial economic benefit—there is also a crime argument—of redressing Scotland's attitude to alcohol. Let us also remember the public health benefits that the University of Sheffield's report has identified. It is not that often that a Parliament decides on an issue that affects the lives of many thousands of our fellow citizens. I hope that all members will address this issue with the seriousness that it deserves.
link
I am aware that the fact and, indeed, the content of legal advice are not published by the Scottish Government. However, the First Minister has acknowledged the concern that exists about the European Court of Justice judgment on tobacco pricing and its potential impact on minimum pricing. Given the seriousness of the issue that Scotland has with alcohol, which the First Minister has set out clearly, will he follow the precedent set by the previous Scottish Executive and share the substance of legal advice with party leaders, which would enable progress to be made on considering minimum pricing?
I understand that we have already had discussions with Cathy Jamieson about how we can try to do that. I hope and believe that such information can be made available to members to enable us to discuss and address the issue in a serious way. I hope that we will be able to pursue with Jackie Baillie the discussions that were held with Cathy Jamieson, to see what can be done to provide members with the maximum amount of information.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Oct 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 October 2009 Debate · 1
- Influenza A(H1N1) Statement · 23
- Elder Abuse Statement · 24
- Marine Scotland Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 26
- Marine (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
- Military Personnel (Support) Questions · 6
- Voluntary Sector (Funding) Questions · 4
- Transport Projects (Ministerial Responsibility) Questions · 9
- Bus Services(Strathclyde Partnership for Transport) Questions · 5
- Ferry Services (Orkney) Questions · 8
- Lloyds TSB Foundation for Scotland Questions · 6
- People's Charter Questions · 9
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Grid Upgrade (Beauly to Denny Power Line) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Influenza A(H1N1) (Health Workers) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Education Spending Questions · 6
- Teacher Employment Working Group Workforce Plan Questions · 6
- Private Finance Initiative (Schools) Questions · 6
- Apprenticeships and Work-based Training Questions · 6
- Student Accommodation(University of Aberdeen) Questions · 6
- Modern Languages Questions · 4
- School Buildings (Dumbarton Academy) Questions · 4
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Scots Language Questions · 4
- Cultural Collections Budget Questions · 5
- Climate Change Questions · 4
- Film Industry Questions · 8
- Youth Music Initiative Questions · 6
- United Kingdom Government (Protocols) Questions · 6
- Brussels (Visits) Questions · 4
- Scottish Economy Debate · 103
- Decision Time Decision time · 37
- Schools (North-east Fife) Members’ business · 18
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.