To ask the Scottish Executive for what reason it has not publicised the fact that it has an extra £880 million in purchasing power available in its 2010-11 budget due to lower rates of inflation. (S3O-8159)
Official Report · Chamber
Budget (Purchasing Power)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Finance and Sustainable Growth
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 2
- John Swinney SNP 2
The record
4 contributions
link
That has not been done because it is not the case. Freeing up an additional £800 million as the member suggests would require us to cut salaries for Scotland's teachers, health staff and police officers, which the Scottish Government is not willing to do. The resources that are available to the Scottish Government will not increase in 2010-11. Even after accounting for the expected lower rate of inflation, the Scottish Government's budget will still fall by 0.9 per cent in real terms between 2009-10 and 2010-11. That is the first real-terms cut since devolution.
The Scottish Government has been entirely open about the scale of the financial pressures that need to be addressed, and our budget calculations clearly reflected the lower inflation forecasts. The member will find that the foreword to the draft budget document contains exactly that point.
The Scottish Government has been entirely open about the scale of the financial pressures that need to be addressed, and our budget calculations clearly reflected the lower inflation forecasts. The member will find that the foreword to the draft budget document contains exactly that point.
I would like to confirm some of the basic facts to find out whether we have any agreement between us.
First, is the cabinet secretary aware that £880 million is not my or my party's figure, but is from the Scottish Parliament information centre? It gave an independent view and suggested that there is additional headroom in the budget. Secondly, does the cabinet secretary agree that the inflation rate will probably be between 1 and 1.5 per cent, whereas the original budget estimates last year were based on an assumption that inflation would be 2.75 per cent? If we can agree on those facts, we can begin to discuss why projects such as the Glasgow airport rail link have been cut although there is further headroom within the budget.
First, is the cabinet secretary aware that £880 million is not my or my party's figure, but is from the Scottish Parliament information centre? It gave an independent view and suggested that there is additional headroom in the budget. Secondly, does the cabinet secretary agree that the inflation rate will probably be between 1 and 1.5 per cent, whereas the original budget estimates last year were based on an assumption that inflation would be 2.75 per cent? If we can agree on those facts, we can begin to discuss why projects such as the Glasgow airport rail link have been cut although there is further headroom within the budget.
link
If Dr Simpson looks at page 15 of the budget document, he will see that the real-terms calculation has been made using an assumed gross domestic product deflator of 1.5 per cent, which is exactly the GDP deflator that has been identified by Her Majesty's Treasury. If I had set the budget figures on the basis of the GDP deflator in the 2007 comprehensive spending review, I would not have identified a 0.9 per cent real-terms reduction in the budget; I would have identified a 2.1 per cent real-terms reduction in the budget. I am normally criticised for not defending Her Majesty's Treasury, but I have purely and simply followed the guidance of Her Majesty's Treasury in applying the appropriate GDP deflator. Those are the basic facts that underpin the budget.
If Dr Simpson looks at page 6 of the draft budget, he will see that I state:
"The Scottish public sector already has an excellent record of setting and meeting challenging efficiency targets. Of course success in the past means progressively greater difficulty in achieving further reductions in future. However, sharply lower general inflation rates since budgets were first proposed in 2007 will provide some help."
That has been stated clearly and openly in the budget document.
Dr Simpson also asked for an explanation of why projects such as GARL have had to be cancelled. I will give him a simple explanation. In 2010-11, the reduction in the Scottish Government's capital budget applied by Her Majesty's Treasury will be £129 million. That is a consequential impact of a decision to reduce the Department of Health baseline figure in the United Kingdom budget by about £2 billion. I decided not to apply any of that reduction to the health service in Scotland, so I have used end-year flexibility to cushion the impact of that. I can do that only once, however, in 2010-11. In 2011-12, we will face a further, additional £129 million cut in the budget. I must ensure that the capital budget remains sustainable not just in 2010-11, but into 2011-12 and 2012-13, when we know that capital budgets will be under significant pressure.
I hope that that explains the matter to Dr Simpson. I apologise for the length of that answer, Presiding Officer, but those are important facts to put on the record concerning the difficult decisions that the Government has had to make.
If Dr Simpson looks at page 6 of the draft budget, he will see that I state:
"The Scottish public sector already has an excellent record of setting and meeting challenging efficiency targets. Of course success in the past means progressively greater difficulty in achieving further reductions in future. However, sharply lower general inflation rates since budgets were first proposed in 2007 will provide some help."
That has been stated clearly and openly in the budget document.
Dr Simpson also asked for an explanation of why projects such as GARL have had to be cancelled. I will give him a simple explanation. In 2010-11, the reduction in the Scottish Government's capital budget applied by Her Majesty's Treasury will be £129 million. That is a consequential impact of a decision to reduce the Department of Health baseline figure in the United Kingdom budget by about £2 billion. I decided not to apply any of that reduction to the health service in Scotland, so I have used end-year flexibility to cushion the impact of that. I can do that only once, however, in 2010-11. In 2011-12, we will face a further, additional £129 million cut in the budget. I must ensure that the capital budget remains sustainable not just in 2010-11, but into 2011-12 and 2012-13, when we know that capital budgets will be under significant pressure.
I hope that that explains the matter to Dr Simpson. I apologise for the length of that answer, Presiding Officer, but those are important facts to put on the record concerning the difficult decisions that the Government has had to make.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Oct 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 October 2009 Debate · 1
- School Buildings Debate · 90
- Volunteering Debate · 32
- Alcohol Awareness Questions · 10
- Schools Questions · 6
- Genetic Modification (Contamination) Questions · 4
- Recycling Questions · 6
- School Estate Strategy (Barrhead High School) Questions · 4
- Health Services (Highland Perthshire) Questions · 4
- Unmarried Mothers (Supervised Homes) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Drugs First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Students (Financial Support) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Prisons (Human Rights Cases) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Active Travel (Funding) Questions · 8
- Glasgow Airport Rail Link Questions · 6
- PFI/PPP Payments Questions · 6
- Budget (Purchasing Power) Questions · 4
- Single Outcome Agreements (Zero Waste) Questions · 4
- Enterprise Budget (Economic Recovery) Questions · 12
- Non-domestic Rates Questions · 6
- Marine and Fisheries Budget Questions · 4
- Dalmarnock Station (Commonwealth Games) Questions · 4
- Scottish Enterprise (Restructuring) Questions · 4
- Borders Railway Questions · 5
- New Railway Stations Questions · 6
- Scottish Futures Trust (Consultants) Questions · 4
- Civil Justice Debate · 45
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 44
- Dementia Members’ business · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.