To ask the First Minister what evidence there is to support the Scottish Government's plans to tackle alcohol misuse. (S3F-1922)
Official Report · Chamber
Alcohol Misuse
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 5
- Michael Matheson SNP 2
- Richard Baker Lab 1
- Robert Brown LD 1
- Bill Aitken Con 1
The record
10 contributions
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
link
On Monday, we published the results of independent research carried out by the University of Sheffield on the potential effects of minimum pricing for alcohol and a ban on irresponsible off-sales promotions. The results show that a 40p per unit minimum price and a ban on irresponsible promotions would be expected, over a 10-year period, to reduce alcohol-related deaths by 19 per cent, to reduce alcohol-related illnesses by 8 per cent, to reduce hospital admissions by nearly 10 per cent, to reduce crime by more than 3,000 offences per year and to provide a financial saving from harm reduction of £950 million over 10 years.
Of course, no single action will bring about the change that is required to rebalance our relationship with alcohol. Working with others from across the chamber, the Government is determined to produce a package of measures that can make a big difference to this massive public health challenge.
Of course, no single action will bring about the change that is required to rebalance our relationship with alcohol. Working with others from across the chamber, the Government is determined to produce a package of measures that can make a big difference to this massive public health challenge.
The Sheffield study, which demonstrates the economic, health and social benefits of introducing minimum pricing, follows on from a gathering body of international evidence that supports such a policy, given the gains that could be derived from it.
I am sure that the Deputy First Minister agrees that although minimum pricing can play an important role in addressing Scotland's unhealthy relationship with alcohol, it is essential that we take every opportunity to inform individuals of the direct health risks that come from consuming too much alcohol and that, as overconsumption of alcohol is one of the main lifestyle risks in relation to breast cancer, the launch of breast cancer awareness month today provides an ideal opportunity to get that message across.
I am sure that the Deputy First Minister agrees that although minimum pricing can play an important role in addressing Scotland's unhealthy relationship with alcohol, it is essential that we take every opportunity to inform individuals of the direct health risks that come from consuming too much alcohol and that, as overconsumption of alcohol is one of the main lifestyle risks in relation to breast cancer, the launch of breast cancer awareness month today provides an ideal opportunity to get that message across.
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
link
Michael Matheson is absolutely correct, and I am sure that there will be much agreement throughout the chamber with what he has just said. There is still a lack of awareness of the full health risks that are associated with alcohol misuse. In the case of breast cancer, more than one in 10 deaths among women in Scotland are estimated to be attributable to alcohol.
The Government is working hard with partners and other parties to highlight the health risks that are associated with alcohol and to encourage people to reflect more carefully on their alcohol consumption. We have rolled out an ambitious programme to help support people whose drinking might be putting them at risk and to persuade them to cut down.
Over time, the wider package of measures that I have already mentioned, which I believe should include action on pricing, will help us to turn the tide on the problem and to rebalance our relationship with alcohol.
The Government is working hard with partners and other parties to highlight the health risks that are associated with alcohol and to encourage people to reflect more carefully on their alcohol consumption. We have rolled out an ambitious programme to help support people whose drinking might be putting them at risk and to persuade them to cut down.
Over time, the wider package of measures that I have already mentioned, which I believe should include action on pricing, will help us to turn the tide on the problem and to rebalance our relationship with alcohol.
Does the Deputy First Minister agree that any new measures to tackle alcohol misuse must be supported through better enforcement of current law, particularly a higher success rate in prosecuting cases of underage drinking—including the prosecution of those who are responsible for selling alcohol to children?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
link
Yes, I strongly agree with that. I believe that the package of measures in the Government's alcohol framework, which we intend to legislate on later this year, will go a great distance towards helping to tackle problems with alcohol. However, I agree strongly that we should not introduce new legislation without enforcing strongly the legislation that is already in place. In the past couple of days, I have discussed that with Cathy Jamieson, who is Labour's health spokesperson. On behalf of the Government, I can say that we are committed to working with other parties in the Parliament to look at ways in which we can ensure that existing legislation works as well as possible and that new legislation will tackle the problem effectively.
Can the Deputy First Minister tell me why the study used rather old figures, from 2003, rather than the 2008 figures that are now available? Will she comment on the fact that the study estimates that a minimum price of 40p per unit of alcohol will result in an increase of £90 million per annum to private retailers and a drop of £4 million a year to public revenues? Can she tell me why that is a good thing?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
link
A good thing about the research that was published the other day is that it demonstrates that a policy of minimum pricing, on its own or in combination with a ban on irresponsible promotions, would cut consumption of alcohol. The key objective is to reduce the consumption of alcohol. The benefits that are laid out in the University of Sheffield study are that, by reducing consumption, the policy could cut the number of alcohol-related deaths, illnesses and incidents of crime. I appreciate and concede that we have still to win the argument on minimum pricing among sections of the Parliament, but I encourage all members to read the study. It lays bare the great benefits that could result if the Parliament is prepared—as it was on the ban on smoking in public places—to be bold and to lead from the front by taking action that is about improving the long-term health of our country.
The Deputy First Minister will no doubt agree that there are individuals who are problem drinkers and that there are drinks that can be identified as problematical. Does she agree that a more targeted approach might be to work with the Westminster Government to look at ways in which excise duty can be used to target problematical drinks, to make them less accessible to the more vulnerable sections of our society who abuse them?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Glasgow Govan
link
Bill Aitken and I might have a slight disagreement, in that he thinks that alcohol misuse is only a marginal problem whereas I think it is a wider problem that affects more people in the population. Notwithstanding that disagreement, I think that he has a point about the need to ensure that, as well as cutting consumption across the population, we target the problem of hazardous drinkers.
I am happy to co-operate with anybody who will co-operate with us in tackling the problem. We are currently trying to persuade the Westminster Government to take action on the advertising of alcohol. So far, the Westminster Government has not proved too willing to do that, but we will continue to seek to persuade it.
I recommend that Bill Aitken read the University of Sheffield study, if he has not already done so. It suggests that minimum pricing and a ban on irresponsible promotions be a targeted policy. For example, the cost impact will be felt by those who drink hazardous levels rather than by moderate, responsible drinkers. I submit that that is exactly the type of policy that we should look to implement.
I am happy to co-operate with anybody who will co-operate with us in tackling the problem. We are currently trying to persuade the Westminster Government to take action on the advertising of alcohol. So far, the Westminster Government has not proved too willing to do that, but we will continue to seek to persuade it.
I recommend that Bill Aitken read the University of Sheffield study, if he has not already done so. It suggests that minimum pricing and a ban on irresponsible promotions be a targeted policy. For example, the cost impact will be felt by those who drink hazardous levels rather than by moderate, responsible drinkers. I submit that that is exactly the type of policy that we should look to implement.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Oct 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 1 October 2009 Debate · 1
- “Equal Pay in Local Government” Debate · 55
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Public Access to Science (Kilmarnock and Loudon) Questions · 4
- Strategic Transport Projects Review Questions · 13
- National Health Service Physiotherapy (Waiting Lists) Questions · 6
- Abnormal Loads Questions · 6
- Voluntary Organisations (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Scottish-Islamic Foundation (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Alcohol Misuse First Minister’s Questions · 10
- School Building Programme (Scottish Futures Trust) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Home Insulation Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Power Stations (Environmental Impact) Questions · 4
- Flooding (Moray) Questions · 9
- Food and Drink Industry (New Markets) Questions · 6
- Rural Development (Support) Questions · 8
- Fisheries (European Union Talks) Questions · 8
- Animal Welfare Groups (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Meat Inspection System (Food Standards Agency) Questions · 7
- Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act 2009 (Implementation) Questions · 6
- Assisted Suicide Questions · 4
- Title Conditions (Scotland) Act 2003 (Land Maintenance Companies) Questions · 4
- Extradition (United States of America) Questions · 4
- Knife Crime (Glasgow) Questions · 6
- Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 Questions · 4
- Rural Policing Priorities (Lothian and Borders) Questions · 5
- Illegal Encampments (Montrose and Bridge of Dun) Questions · 4
- Colleges (Economic Recovery) Debate · 71
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 12
- World Pipe Band Championships Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.