To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day (S3F-1894)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
13 contributionsLater today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
I know that the whole chamber will wish to take this opportunity to record its appreciation as a national Parliament for the life of Bill Speirs, the former general secretary of the Scottish Trades Union Congress. Bill made a substantial contribution to Scottish life for many years and will be greatly missed by us all. [Applause.]
I know that the whole chamber will wish to take this opportunity to record its appreciation as a national Parliament for the life of Bill Speirs, the former general secretary of the Scottish Trades Union Congress. Bill made a substantial contribution to Scottish life for many years and will be greatly missed by us all. [Applause.]
I thank the First Minister for those words, which I am sure are echoed across the chamber and throughout Scotland.
On 5 September 2007 the First Minister was asked a straight question: would he reduce in this parliamentary session class sizes to 18 in primary 1, 2 and 3? For once, he gave a straight answer; he said, "Yes". But that was not true, was it?
On 5 September 2007 the First Minister was asked a straight question: would he reduce in this parliamentary session class sizes to 18 in primary 1, 2 and 3? For once, he gave a straight answer; he said, "Yes". But that was not true, was it?
The commitments were set out in the concordat with local government, which was published in 2007 and which said that there would be "year on year progress" towards lower class sizes of 18 in primary 1 to 3 in Scotland. Throughout Scotland, there has been year-on-year progress. Class sizes in Scotland are now at a record low, thanks to the actions of this Government and many local authorities around Scotland.
But some local authorities have not been quite so much in favour of a class size reduction policy. Is that not true?
But some local authorities have not been quite so much in favour of a class size reduction policy. Is that not true?
Indeed. Twelve out of 13 Scottish National Party-led councils have failed to make progress and have reduced their teacher numbers. That was certainly not the straight answer.
Last night on television, Fiona Hyslop was asked five times when the class size promise would be delivered. She could not answer. This morning, Fiona Hyslop did not speak, so Keith Brown was asked when the promise would be delivered. He could not answer. Let us try the organ grinder. Will the First Minister tell us when the promise will be delivered?
Last night on television, Fiona Hyslop was asked five times when the class size promise would be delivered. She could not answer. This morning, Fiona Hyslop did not speak, so Keith Brown was asked when the promise would be delivered. He could not answer. Let us try the organ grinder. Will the First Minister tell us when the promise will be delivered?
Under this Administration, there will be year-on-year progress towards that class size target, which is in dramatic contrast to Labour's failure to meet its class size target when it was in government. Not only are we determined to make that year-on-year progress at this hugely difficult economic time, but we are going to have class sizes that are lower than those either under the previous Labour Administration or anywhere else on these islands. That will be the aim of the Scottish Government and our local authorities.
Of course, Iain Gray did not wish to comment on the fact that the largest local authority in Scotland, which is under Labour control, is itself responsible for 20 per cent of the decline in teacher numbers in Scotland. Why on earth should that be? Would anyone on the Labour benches care to comment?
Of course, Iain Gray did not wish to comment on the fact that the largest local authority in Scotland, which is under Labour control, is itself responsible for 20 per cent of the decline in teacher numbers in Scotland. Why on earth should that be? Would anyone on the Labour benches care to comment?
As Benjamin Franklin once said,
"He that is good for making excuses is seldom good for anything else."
The issue is not just about class sizes. A year ago, the First Minister told us that nursery teacher numbers were "substantially increasing". They were not; they were falling. Moreover, in his manifesto, he said that he would
"maintain teacher numbers in the face of falling rolls".
However, he has cut 1,000 teachers out of our schools. The promises on class sizes, nursery teachers and school teachers—not one of them was true, was it?
"He that is good for making excuses is seldom good for anything else."
The issue is not just about class sizes. A year ago, the First Minister told us that nursery teacher numbers were "substantially increasing". They were not; they were falling. Moreover, in his manifesto, he said that he would
"maintain teacher numbers in the face of falling rolls".
However, he has cut 1,000 teachers out of our schools. The promises on class sizes, nursery teachers and school teachers—not one of them was true, was it?
We now know for the first time just how many nursery teachers there are in Scotland: there are 2,590. Unfortunately, that figure cannot be compared to figures in previous years, because the Labour Administration double-counted hundreds of nursery teachers because they worked at several schools. In other words, under the Labour-Liberal Administration, if a nursery teacher worked in two schools, they were counted twice; and if they worked in three schools, they were counted three times. I am not sure that Iain Gray was fully familiar with that double and treble-counting policy, but I am sure that he welcomes the fact that we now have an accurate estimate of nursery teacher numbers in Scotland.
Would it not be wonderful if every council in Scotland shared the enthusiasm of this Government for lower class sizes? Would it not be wonderful if our largest local authority was not engaged in the practice of cutting teacher numbers, increasing class sizes and closing primary schools, despite receiving more per head than any other local authority in this country?
Would it not be wonderful if every council in Scotland shared the enthusiasm of this Government for lower class sizes? Would it not be wonderful if our largest local authority was not engaged in the practice of cutting teacher numbers, increasing class sizes and closing primary schools, despite receiving more per head than any other local authority in this country?
I am delighted that we have accurate figures for full-time equivalent nursery teachers in pre-school education. What those figures show is that last year there were 34 fewer nursery teachers and the year before that there were 14 fewer. The numbers are not going up; they are going down.
The First Minister was elected on a false prospectus. In a tight election, he made cynical promises to children, parents, teachers and students—promises that he never intended to keep.
Here is how one of those teachers feels:
"Think I will send Hyslop a calculator—she obviously does not have one … and if I could—her P45." [Interruption.]
The First Minister was elected on a false prospectus. In a tight election, he made cynical promises to children, parents, teachers and students—promises that he never intended to keep.
Here is how one of those teachers feels:
"Think I will send Hyslop a calculator—she obviously does not have one … and if I could—her P45." [Interruption.]
SNP members can laugh. The teacher continued:
"I can just photocopy mine and change the names."
The education secretary is making Alex Salmond look like a fool. Will the First Minister make that teacher's day and give Fiona Hyslop her P45?
"I can just photocopy mine and change the names."
The education secretary is making Alex Salmond look like a fool. Will the First Minister make that teacher's day and give Fiona Hyslop her P45?
If Iain Gray had attended the education debate, he would have heard that story being told. I am concerned about the future of teachers and post-probationers in Scotland. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order, Mr McAveety.
I think that a serious employment situation is facing all teachers in Scotland. That is why the Government is taking action to address those circumstances.
I agree that it is no consolation for any individual teacher that teacher unemployment is lower in Scotland than in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, but Labour members should reflect for a second on why unemployment among teachers is higher elsewhere in these islands. Might that be something to do with the public expenditure profile that is being set by the Treasury in London, or does the Labour Government in London deliberately make teachers unemployed?
I am interested in individual teachers, such as Alice Thompson, the probationer of the year, who was employed by Glasgow City Council only after it was shamed by publicity into offering record probationer employment, and following the scheme that was introduced by the education secretary to help the implementation of the curriculum for excellence, which employs 100 extra teachers in Scotland—real action by the education secretary, not more cries of, "We was robbed in the last election" by Iain Gray.
I agree that it is no consolation for any individual teacher that teacher unemployment is lower in Scotland than in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, but Labour members should reflect for a second on why unemployment among teachers is higher elsewhere in these islands. Might that be something to do with the public expenditure profile that is being set by the Treasury in London, or does the Labour Government in London deliberately make teachers unemployed?
I am interested in individual teachers, such as Alice Thompson, the probationer of the year, who was employed by Glasgow City Council only after it was shamed by publicity into offering record probationer employment, and following the scheme that was introduced by the education secretary to help the implementation of the curriculum for excellence, which employs 100 extra teachers in Scotland—real action by the education secretary, not more cries of, "We was robbed in the last election" by Iain Gray.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Sep 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 24 September 2009 Debate · 1
- Teachers Debate · 101
- Child Protection Debate · 36
- Energy Options Assessment (Publication) Questions · 7
- Justice of the Peace Courts (South Strathclyde, Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 4
- Teaching Hours (Early Years Education) Questions · 9
- Marches and Parades (Glasgow) Questions · 10
- Bluetongue (Vaccination Rules) Questions · 4
- Government Economic Strategy Questions · 4
- Budget 2010-11 Questions · 8
- Local Government Grant Distribution Review Questions · 3
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Inquiry into Future Fisheries Management First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Glasgow Airport Rail Link (Cancellation) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Curriculum for Excellence First Minister’s Questions · 15
- National Health Service (Consultations) Questions · 8
- Adults with Incapacity (Scotland) Act 2000 (Consultation) Questions · 6
- Disability Organisations (Meetings) Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Funding) Questions · 4
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Personal Care Services) Questions · 7
- In Vitro Fertilisation Treatment (Waiting Time Guarantee) Questions · 8
- NHS Fife (General Practitioner Practices) Questions · 9
- Private Rented Housing (Regulation) Questions · 4
- National Health Service (Older and Disabled People) Questions · 4
- Proposed National Centre for Asbestos-related Diseases Questions · 4
- Audiology Modernisation Programme Questions · 6
- Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 59
- Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill: Financial Memorandum Bill debate · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 52
- Blood Donation Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.