Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 3 September 2009 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1827)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Later today I have a range of engagements to carry forward the Government's programme for Scotland.

I ask that the chamber gets the opportunity to recognise the tragic news of the deaths of Sergeant Stuart Millar from Inverness and Private Kevin Elliott from Dundee of the Black Watch, 3rd Battalion the Royal Regiment of Scotland. Those men were killed as a result of an explosion while on active service in Helmand province on Monday morning. I know that all colleagues throughout the chamber will wish to join me in sending condolences to the men's families.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister knows that he has the condolences of the Labour Party to pass on, too.

Perhaps members will indulge me in asking them to note that, within the next few minutes, Royal National Lifeboats Institution stations throughout Britain will be paying tribute to the 778 lifesavers lost in the line of duty. Like many others, my constituency, which has stations at Dunbar and North Berwick, owes much to its lifeboat volunteers.

Yesterday, the First Minister and his Government were resoundingly defeated in the Parliament over the most important decision that they have had to take. He personally failed to carry the chamber. All the evidence shows that he has failed to carry Scottish opinion. Most Scots believe that the reputation of Scotland has been damaged. Does the First Minister have any regrets about how his Government has handled this matter?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I have regrets about how the matter was handled in the chamber. In particular, I have regrets that Opposition parties, on what was a matter of principle and justice, chose to whip and dragoon their members into voting against the Government. Iain Gray should understand that choosing to use such a vital issue of justice in an attempt to destabilise a Government is a very foolhardy strategy, particularly given that the Government that he has started to destabilise is his own one in London.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Let us talk about principle and justice. If a single thing characterises what was wrong about how this decision was taken, it is Mr MacAskill's visit to Greenock prison, which compromised the whole process. Every explanation for it has collapsed.

Yesterday, Mr MacAskill said that he did not want a media circus if al-Megrahi stayed in Scotland, so why did he orchestrate one in Greenock? I refer to the Press Association diary from the night before the visit. In between references to the exam helpline and a rehearsal for the tattoo, it states,

"Justice Secretary meets Lockerbie bomber",

and provides a Scottish Government press officer's contact number. If the First Minister cannot explain—he failed to do so yesterday—why Mr MacAskill had to go to Greenock, can he explain why the media had to go, too?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
The note on that was exactly the same as the notes for the Cabinet Secretary for Justice's meetings with the American Government, the Libyan Government, the United Kingdom families, the Lockerbie family and the Spanish family. All the justice secretary's intentions to conduct meetings were announced in public, because it would have been a grave mistake to hold secret meetings as part of a judicial process.

Although we have been over this territory a number of times, I have yet to hear a convincing answer to this point that the justice secretary made: if we were conducting direct meetings with all interested parties in the case, if this was the first prisoner transfer agreement that did not require the consent of the person to be transferred, and if direct meetings were held with all other parties, why would it not have been a breach of natural justice and an open invitation to judicial review if a meeting was not held with a party under discussion? Perhaps Iain Gray will take the opportunity to make an observation on that rather simple point.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
I am happy to do so because those meetings were not all the same. Although the justice secretary was prepared to go to Greenock to meet the bomber face to face, he chose not to cross the Atlantic to afford the American families the same courtesy. We know that he was prepared to cross the Atlantic earlier this year to go to a Burns supper when he should have been right here with knife crime victims. Does the First Minister now accept that he should have insisted that his justice secretary afforded the same respect to the families of the victims as he did al-Megrahi by meeting them face to face? Would that not have been natural justice?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
There were meetings with the families by videolink to the United States. There were direct meetings in person with families in the United Kingdom, the Lockerbie relatives and the Spanish relatives. The justice minister was totally open about the process that he was following and totally punctilious about the prisoner transfer agreement. I remind Iain Gray that the prisoner transfer agreement was not sought by the justice minister or by this governing party but signed between the Governments in Libya and Westminster. However, once it became part of the law of Scotland, a justice minister was duty bound to carry out the issue by due process.

The problem that Iain Gray has on this matter, and the reason why he concentrates unavailingly on process, is that he cannot take on the issue of principle. The heart of this matter is the one that is being consistently addressed by the justice secretary, which is whether we should, in our justice system, be able to offer compassion and mercy to a dying man, even one who has committed a great atrocity. That is the issue of principle that people in Scotland are debating. It is unfortunate that in his desire for party-political advantage, Iain Gray cannot rise to that issue of principle.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The issue of principle here is the balance that is struck between compassion for the prisoner, and compassion for the victims, the length of the sentence remaining, and the courts' view of that sentence. At no stage, either yesterday or last Monday, has that issue of balance been addressed.

At the beginning of the Lockerbie story is an act of terror. I agree that the principles and integrity of our justice system are exactly our greatest bulwarks against terror, but so, too, are our parliamentary democracy and its integrity. Yesterday, the First Minister lost, in the Parliament. He cannot simply, like the Sid James of minority government, carry on governing, as he said last night he would. Will he at least support my suggestion of a Justice Committee inquiry to look further into the Scottish Government's handling of this matter? We can then find out how, for example, the American families feel about the equivalence of treatment they have received in the process.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
The justice minister and I will be delighted to appear at the Justice Committee to account for the Government's actions. I hope that there is the same enthusiasm on the part of ministers at Westminster to appear before their committees to account for the actions of their Government. The contrast between Labour's posturing in Scotland and Labour's silence in London has been glaringly obvious over the past few weeks. It illustrates the great mistake that Iain Gray has made in trying to party politick on the grave issue of justice.

On the question of removing the Government, Iain Gray has his opportunity. It is only two weeks since Labour members were speculating and briefing the press that there would be motions of no confidence and motions of censure. They ran away from that as they run away from every big issue in Scottish politics.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 September 2009 Debate · 1
  2. Influenza A(H1N1) Statement · 22
  3. Scottish Government's Programme Statement · 9
  4. Scottish Government's Programme Debate · 59
  5. VisitScotland Questions · 7
  6. Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 Questions · 6
  7. High-speed Rail Link Questions · 8
  8. Biotechnology Industries (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
  9. Scottish Futures Trust (School Building) Questions · 8
  10. Scottish Clinical Leadership and Excellence Award Scheme Questions · 4
  11. Stromness Ferry Terminal Questions · 4
  12. Draft Children's Hearings (Scotland) Bill Questions · 4
  13. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  14. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  16. Short Sentences (Impact on Reconviction Rates) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  17. Child Protection (Inter-agency information) First Minister’s Questions · 7
  18. Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 First Minister’s Questions · 6
  19. District Courts (Ayrshire) Questions · 7
  20. Police (Funding) Questions · 8
  21. Legal Aid (Eligibility Criteria) Questions · 4
  22. Quasi-judicial Matters (Scrutiny) Questions · 10
  23. Knife Crime (Paisley) Questions · 4
  24. Police Officers (Numbers) Questions · 8
  25. Kafeel Ahmed Questions · 4
  26. Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 (Excess Packaging) Questions · 8
  27. Derelict Land (Urban Areas) Questions · 8
  28. Sheep (Electronic Identification) Questions · 8
  29. Scottish Agricultural Wages Board Questions · 6
  30. National Food and Drink Policy Questions · 4
  31. Prawn Fishing (Western Isles) Questions · 4
  32. Scottish Government's Programme Debate · 99
  33. Decision Time Decision time · 1
  34. Insulin Pump Therapy Members’ business · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.