Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 25 June 2009 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1805)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I have a range of engagements to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
This week, a damning report on child protection services in Dundee said:

"Inspectors were not confident that all children who were at risk of harm, abuse or neglect, and in need of protection, were identified and received the help and support they needed."

We can hardly be surprised at that, given that 23-month-old Brandon Muir was beaten to death by his mother's boyfriend in that city. His mother was a heroin addict and Brandon's short life was brutal and chaotic. What action has the First Minister taken since that tragedy?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
As Iain Gray knows, Peter Wilson, the former chief constable of Fife Constabulary, is conducting an independent inquiry and has initiated an independently chaired significant case review of the tragic case of Brandon Muir.

On the general position of child protection in the city of Dundee, the Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education report, which was published on 23 June, showed serious deficiencies in child protection in the city. That is not the worst of a number of reports that we have had. On the strenuous and stringent system of inspections that have been carried out in all local authorities in Scotland, we have identified five local authorities, of which Dundee City Council is one, where there are serious deficiencies. That is now being addressed. On 18 June, Fiona Hyslop, as Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning, and Adam Ingram, as the identifiable and responsible minister, met Dundee City Council's child protection leadership, which included the chief executive of the council Alex Stephen, the director of social work, the chief executive of NHS Tayside Professor Tony Wells and the assistant chief constable of Tayside Police. They did so to put in place the substantial remedial action that the council will take to improve the situation and protect the children of Dundee.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
As part of the First Minister's answer indicated, cases such as that of Brandon Muir are not one-off cases that happen in one city or another. We can all remember other examples from the past. We know that 10,000 to 20,000 children in Scotland live with drug-addicted parents and that many more—perhaps up to 100,000—live with parents who are addicted to alcohol. We have heard those same figures from the Scottish Government for two years now. I have been saying for months that we do not need to count those children; we need to find them, and quickly, so that we can protect them. What steps has the First Minister taken in the past two years to find out exactly who those 10,000, 20,000 or 100,000 children are?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
First, there is the in-depth investigation and inquiry into the tragic case of Brandon Muir. We should all await the outcome of Peter Wilson's inquiry before we jump to any assumptions about the precise nature of the case.

Secondly, the reason why we are uncovering the deficiencies in social work and child protection in a variety of areas in Scotland is that we have the most systematic and strenuous inspection system certainly anywhere in these islands and perhaps anywhere in Europe. That has identified that there are deficiencies in five local authorities; 26 authorities are broadly satisfactory or better; and five local authorities—Inverclyde Council, East Renfrewshire Council, Renfrewshire Council, West Lothian Council and Perth and Kinross Council—are very good indeed.

That system was planned by the Parliament in 2005 and has been implemented by this Government to remedy deficiencies when they appear. I hope that Iain Gray will acknowledge that one of the other reports that was published yesterday, on the city of Aberdeen—the follow-up report from an unsatisfactory report six months ago—found substantial progress as a result of the action that has been taken. Therefore, not only in one tragic case where an inquiry is pending but in social work protection for children right across Scotland, this Government applauds—as I hope all in the Parliament applaud—the action that is being taken to make safer the children of Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The inspection regime, which I think my colleague Peter Peacock introduced and which was agreed by the Parliament—as the First Minister indicated—is an important move forward. It has identified deficiencies in five local authority areas. That said, surely those deficiencies and the fact that 20,000 children are at risk because of their parents' addiction indicates a national problem. Overstretched social workers are doing their best, but something needs to change. That is a job for the First Minister. As the minister with the highest office, he should be working for the most vulnerable children in the country. Will the First Minister support my call for a national inquiry to devise a new and better child protection system for Scotland?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
We have a very good child protection system in Scotland, which is identifying deficiencies, authority by authority, and remedying them. The system was introduced by the Parliament and implemented by this Government.

Iain Gray said that social workers are hard pressed. I agree with him. When tragedies have occurred and difficult situations arisen, I have expressed, I hope, the support of the Parliament for the difficult job that social workers do.

Iain Gray asked about my involvement in the issue. It is enough to know exactly what the profession itself is saying about the position in Scotland at the moment. Figures were published yesterday that show a record number of social workers in Scotland: we have 5,072 social workers, up 126 on the position in 2006. They also show that we have a record number of social workers in children's services—2,349, up 59 on the position in 2006—and that vacancy rates for social workers have dropped this year to a six-year low. In the publication Community Care, Ruth Stark, the British Association of Social Workers professional officer for Scotland, stressed that the level of political support for social work in Scotland explained why the vacancy level in Scotland is so dramatically lower than vacancy levels across the United Kingdom.

What I say next is for not only Iain Gray but the entire chamber. When professional social workers, given the difficult job that they do, express appreciation for the cross-party political support that they are receiving, all members must, for goodness' sake, rise to the compliment and keep up our cross-party support to protect the children of Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister simply misses the point. I do not criticise social workers. I believe that they try—overstretched as they are—to implement the system that we have put in place. The First Minister defends the system with the figures that he cited. My argument is that the system has to change. I will explain.

We are about to embark on our summer recess. Scotland's schools are also about to go on summer holiday. Summer is a time for children—as we remember from our childhoods—but not for children such as Brandon Muir. The times in which those children live are brutal, chaotic and joyless—summer or winter. We need to change the balance in terms of leaving those children with their families or keeping them safe. The time has come to challenge and change the orthodoxy that underpins our system and to be quicker to remove and protect. Doing that needs a national debate and leadership to start it. Does the First Minister agree? If not, why not?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
We have appointed Peter Wilson to conduct an independent inquiry. When lessons are learned and recommendations are made that are specific either to the local or national area, they will be implemented. I will not accept from Iain Gray any suggestion that the system that the Parliament put in place and which is now being enforced is doing anything other than improving protection for the children of Scotland.

The key relevant findings are not just that we have more social workers and a dramatically lower level of vacancies than that south of the border, but that systematically, council by council, mistakes and deficiencies are being identified and, above all, rectified. Does Iain Gray not understand the significance of the fact that not only have deficiencies in the city of Dundee been identified, but, as a result of the identification of problems in the city of Aberdeen, action has been taken that will protect the children of that city, and such action is being taken by the vast majority of councils across Scotland?

Given that we as a Parliament introduced the systematic inspection process, all of us should take pride in the fact that it is working and improving the safety of children in this country. Of course we will take forward the independent inquiry's recommendations, but we will probably wait to see what its recommendations are before we jump to any conclusions.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 25 June 2009 Debate · 1
  2. Commission on Scottish Devolution (Report) Debate · 143
  3. “Hybrid Bills” Debate · 15
  4. Rail Services (Carrick, Cumnock and Doon Valley) Questions · 9
  5. Enterprise Finance Guarantee Questions · 4
  6. Knives Questions · 6
  7. Government Advertising (Newspapers) Questions · 6
  8. A83 Questions · 4
  9. Kintore Railway Station Questions · 6
  10. Transport Summit (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  11. School Closures Questions · 6
  12. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  15. Alcohol Summit First Minister’s Questions · 8
  16. Anti-sectarianism Strategy First Minister’s Questions · 4
  17. Digital Switchover First Minister’s Questions · 6
  18. Mary's Meals Members’ business · 13
  19. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  20. Tobacco and Primary Medical Services (Scotland) Bill (Childhood Smoking) Questions · 6
  21. National Health Service Volunteer Drivers Questions · 6
  22. Multiple Sclerosis (National Health Service Support) Questions · 5
  23. In Vitro Fertilisation Questions · 7
  24. NHS Grampian (Public Engagement) Questions · 4
  25. NHS Dumfries and Galloway (Consultation) Questions · 4
  26. Pharmacies Questions · 4
  27. Delayed Discharges Questions · 9
  28. Affordable Housing (Consequential Funding) Questions · 6
  29. Local Employment Partnerships Questions · 4
  30. Affordable Housing (Single Regional Developers) Questions · 6
  31. Mental Health Questions · 4
  32. Food Content and Labelling Powers Questions · 4
  33. Affordable Housing (Borders) Questions · 8
  34. National Health Service Dentists (Aberdeen South) Questions · 4
  35. End-year Flexibility Statement · 25
  36. Arbitration (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 15
  37. Holocaust (Return of Cultural Objects) Bill Bill debate · 4
  38. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 7
  39. Decision Time Decision time · 30

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.