Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Commission on Scottish Devolution

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Europe, External Affairs and Culture

Thursday 18 June 2009 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 10 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
David Whitton Lab Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link
To ask the Scottish Executive whether it will support the recommendations of the Calman Commission on Scottish Devolution. (S3O-7460)

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
The member will not be surprised to know that we support some of the Calman recommendations, in particular those that we argued for—the member has usually been on the other side in those arguments, so I welcome his conversion—on matters such as air-guns, drink driving and a range of other issues. We have made those arguments for some time, so I am glad that others are now catching up with us.

However, the report as a whole—Professor Calman indicated that the report should not be taken as a whole, but we can take it as a whole, if the member wishes—is a missed opportunity. In contrast, the Government's national conversation provides a genuinely open debate with the people of Scotland about our future. [Interruption.]

As ever, I hear the tinkling laughter of the member for Midlothian. That somewhat annoying noise, which I try not to be annoyed by, tinkles away. However, the member for Midlothian has not attended a national conversation event. I invite her to turn up to such an event to debate with me. Then it will be the audience whose laughter tinkles.

We are intensifying the national conversation. That will lead to a white paper in November that lays out our proposals and a choice for the people in a referendum next year. I am sure that the people of Midlothian will choose wisely and choose independence.

Alex Fergusson The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
I call Alasdair Morgan.

Alex Fergusson The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Sorry. I meant to call David Whitton.

David Whitton Lab Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link
That is all right, Presiding Officer. It would be easy to lose track after that very long answer.

Earlier today, the First Minister said that he saw no reason why some of the Calman commission recommendations could not be implemented now. Laying aside the national conversation, which is really just a nationalist blog, does the minister agree that the process would be aided greatly if the Scottish Government lifted its petty and ludicrous ban on Scottish civil servants co-operating with the continuing work of the Calman commission?

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
Were there such a ban, I would ask for it to be lifted now. As the minister responsible for this area of work, I know the amount of time and effort that the civil servants who work with me have put into answering questions from the Calman commission and working constructively. I attended the launch of the commission's report on Monday, but I do not think that the member was there, so I have better first-hand knowledge of what Ken Calman said than the member does.

I make it clear that we are very keen to see forward movement on these matters. I hope to come to the chamber shortly to talk about how we can take the issues forward without further delay and without the long-grass tactics of which Mr Jim Murphy seems fond. We will move forward. Just as I suggested to Mr Fraser that openness was required on the referendum, I say to the member, let the people of Scotland have the final say. Until he does that, he is no democrat.

Alasdair Morgan SNP The Deputy Presiding Officer · South of Scotland
link
Does the minister agree that, given that the Labour Party has argued for the past 10 years that the current devolution settlement is somehow the immutable will of the Scottish people, the fact that it is now offering extensions to that settlement only gives weight to the arguments for full independence for Scotland?

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
As ever, I find myself in complete agreement with my friend Mr Morgan. I could not put it better myself.

Alex Fergusson The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Question 7 was lodged by Helen Eadie, but I do not think that she is in the chamber, which is unfortunate, shall we say.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 18 June 2009 Debate · 1
  2. Business Motion Business motions · 5
  3. Convention Rights Proceedings (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 35
  4. Review of SPCB Supported Bodies Committee Bill Proposal Bill debate · 19
  5. Nuclear Material (Transportation) Questions · 4
  6. Sports Facilities Questions · 8
  7. Antisocial Behaviour (Holiday Flats) Questions · 6
  8. Hospital Catering (Fruit and Vegetables) Questions · 4
  9. Cycling (2020 Target) Questions · 4
  10. Local Government Concordat (Progress Reports) Questions · 12
  11. Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 5
  12. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  15. Influenza A(H1N1) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  16. Commission on Scottish Devolution First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Prison Sentences First Minister’s Questions · 6
  18. Schools (Glasgow East End) Questions · 10
  19. Apprenticeships Questions · 6
  20. Physical Education Questions · 6
  21. Students (Drop-out Rates) Questions · 5
  22. Primary Schools (Shared Headships) Questions · 4
  23. Schools (Local Food Procurement) Questions · 4
  24. Scottish MEPs Questions · 8
  25. Latin America (Engagement) Questions · 6
  26. Latin America (Opportunities) Questions · 7
  27. Edinburgh Festivals Questions · 4
  28. Commission on Scottish Devolution Questions · 10
  29. Scottish Maritime Museum Questions · 6
  30. Cultural Developments (Borders) Questions · 5
  31. Committee of the Whole Parliament Debate · 1
  32. Convention Rights Proceedings (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 4
  33. Scottish Parliament Debate · 1
  34. Convention Rights Proceedings (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 13
  35. Scotland's Festivals Debate · 33
  36. Point of Order Procedure · 4
  37. Decision Time Decision time · 9
  38. Former Gurkha Soldiers' Rights Members’ business · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.