To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1745)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
11 contributionsToday I was pleased to be in the Borders to open the new Ahlstrom facility at Chirnside. The development has involved investment of around £23 million and takes the total number of jobs at the facility to over 200. It is exactly the sort of investment in modern facilities that we welcome in these tough economic times for the Scottish Borders.
Later today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland, then it will be on to campaigning in the European elections, to which I am sure all of us in the chamber are looking forward enormously.
Later today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland, then it will be on to campaigning in the European elections, to which I am sure all of us in the chamber are looking forward enormously.
Last week at First Minister's questions, the First Minister was asked seven times about absconds from the Scottish open prison estate. In seven long-winded and repetitive replies, not only did he fail to answer any of the questions, but he did not see fit to mention what he already knew—that yet another prisoner had gone on the run. Does the First Minister believe that he was being open and transparent with Parliament?
It is obvious that my answers were not repetitive enough, otherwise the difference between 16 absconds in 2008-09 and 79 absconds in 2006-07 would have got through to Iain Gray. I have heard Opposition leaders struggling to ask questions, but not to even realise that we are now in 2009-10 tends to undermine any substance in Iain Gray's complaints.
The matter has been referred to the panel of former Presiding Officers. I received a letter this morning from Iain Gray welcoming that, and I welcome his welcome. Unfortunately, nowhere in the letter does he say that he will abide by the adjudication of the Presiding Officers. Would he like to make that clear now?
The matter has been referred to the panel of former Presiding Officers. I received a letter this morning from Iain Gray welcoming that, and I welcome his welcome. Unfortunately, nowhere in the letter does he say that he will abide by the adjudication of the Presiding Officers. Would he like to make that clear now?
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Questions are to the First Minister.
I am glad that the First Minister has seen fit to refer himself on the matter to that independent panel of advisers, although I thought that he did so rather gracelessly. His accusation that my complaint was
"publicity-driven rather than procedural"
was not just wrong, but—as is so often the case with the First Minister—it missed the point. My complaint was one of principle: that the First Minister should treat this Parliament with respect.
I am not the only one who is concerned. At least one commentator concluded last week that the First Minister's Government
"bore the hallmarks of an administration that is not up to the job or cares not a jot for its responsibility to protect and inform the public. Or both."
Presiding Officer—[Interruption.] I hear Mr Crawford asking, "Only one?" No, I fear that there is not only one such commentator, but time does not permit me to read them all. Many commentators expressed concern about how straight the First Minister was being with Parliament last week. Will the First Minister give a commitment today to treat this Parliament and the public with respect in the future?
"publicity-driven rather than procedural"
was not just wrong, but—as is so often the case with the First Minister—it missed the point. My complaint was one of principle: that the First Minister should treat this Parliament with respect.
I am not the only one who is concerned. At least one commentator concluded last week that the First Minister's Government
"bore the hallmarks of an administration that is not up to the job or cares not a jot for its responsibility to protect and inform the public. Or both."
Presiding Officer—[Interruption.] I hear Mr Crawford asking, "Only one?" No, I fear that there is not only one such commentator, but time does not permit me to read them all. Many commentators expressed concern about how straight the First Minister was being with Parliament last week. Will the First Minister give a commitment today to treat this Parliament and the public with respect in the future?
If I were Iain Gray, I would not rely too much on commentators. There are plenty of comments in the papers today, including in The Guardian. An Opposition leader who relies on commentators is in a very weak position indeed.
We have seen the statements last week—which should be taken very seriously indeed—from Scottish prison officers warning the Opposition party about undermining the confidence of our staff on the front line of the Scottish Prison Service. We have seen the comments from Tayside Police explaining exactly the procedures that they follow, although Iain Gray still seems to be oblivious to them.
Iain Gray might not know about the comments of Patrick J Shearer, who is the chief constable of Dumfries and Galloway Police and—of course—the president of the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland. He said:
"It would be entirely inappropriate for the First Minister or the Cabinet Secretary for Justice to make any public announcement regarding an abscondee when that operational decision had not yet been made by the Police to release information which was the case this week."
Now that Iain Gray knows and understands that information, will he cease undermining our prison officers and operational police forces and accept the word of the chief constable?
We have seen the statements last week—which should be taken very seriously indeed—from Scottish prison officers warning the Opposition party about undermining the confidence of our staff on the front line of the Scottish Prison Service. We have seen the comments from Tayside Police explaining exactly the procedures that they follow, although Iain Gray still seems to be oblivious to them.
Iain Gray might not know about the comments of Patrick J Shearer, who is the chief constable of Dumfries and Galloway Police and—of course—the president of the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland. He said:
"It would be entirely inappropriate for the First Minister or the Cabinet Secretary for Justice to make any public announcement regarding an abscondee when that operational decision had not yet been made by the Police to release information which was the case this week."
Now that Iain Gray knows and understands that information, will he cease undermining our prison officers and operational police forces and accept the word of the chief constable?
It is not the word of the chief constable that I have difficulty accepting sometimes.
Tayside Police released the news of last week's absconded prisoner a few hours after my exchanges with the First Minister—a day after Tayside Police and ministers knew that the prisoner had failed to return. The ministerial code states plainly that
"Ministers should be as open as possible with the Parliament and the public."
The First Minister must surely have known that he would be asked about open prisons last week. Did he ask Tayside Police whether it had any objections to his informing Parliament, at First Minister's question time at 12 noon, of the abscondment?
Tayside Police released the news of last week's absconded prisoner a few hours after my exchanges with the First Minister—a day after Tayside Police and ministers knew that the prisoner had failed to return. The ministerial code states plainly that
"Ministers should be as open as possible with the Parliament and the public."
The First Minister must surely have known that he would be asked about open prisons last week. Did he ask Tayside Police whether it had any objections to his informing Parliament, at First Minister's question time at 12 noon, of the abscondment?
I am not certain that Iain Gray understands the concept of operational independence, which is to leave the police service to decide when to release information. I would be able to understand that he does not if trusting our police with operational independence were a new concept that had been introduced by Kenny MacAskill or Alex Salmond. If it is not a new concept that was introduced or dreamt up by the SNP, and if, in the term of office of the Labour Party, it was normal to release such information to the Parliament, why is it that although there were 79 absconds in the last year of the Labour Administration, not once did Cathy Jamieson make an announcement to Parliament on an abscondee? Operational independence means that we trust our police force to look after public safety. I do that. When will Iain Gray do it?
Is operational independence the reason why it took Mr MacAskill from the Monday, when Brian Martin absconded, until the Thursday to try to find out what had gone wrong? That is yet another question to which the First Minister has failed for two weeks now to give an answer.
Let us return to the real issue, which is trust. Last week, representing us at the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, the First Minister said:
"Trust is an essential quality and once lost it is not easy to rebuild. … trust is the lifeblood of a decent society and a true currency in a democracy."
However, trust is not just a matter of claims for food, home cinemas, moats or duck islands. Does not the First Minister understand that every time he is less than straight with Parliament, he demeans his office, and that every time he defies the will of the chamber, he undermines Parliament? Above all, does he not understand that every time he breaks another promise in the chamber he shows that he just cannot be trusted?
Let us return to the real issue, which is trust. Last week, representing us at the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, the First Minister said:
"Trust is an essential quality and once lost it is not easy to rebuild. … trust is the lifeblood of a decent society and a true currency in a democracy."
However, trust is not just a matter of claims for food, home cinemas, moats or duck islands. Does not the First Minister understand that every time he is less than straight with Parliament, he demeans his office, and that every time he defies the will of the chamber, he undermines Parliament? Above all, does he not understand that every time he breaks another promise in the chamber he shows that he just cannot be trusted?
Usually when people give us reprises or repeat performances, it is of their best performance, but this Opposition leader repeats his worst performances. I note that during this question time there is no call for the resignation of any United Kingdom Government minister. I wonder why. I say to Iain Gray that in order for there to be total disclosure to Parliament, I have made arrangements to be informed if there are any more resignations from Westminster over the next few minutes. The reality is this: the Cabinet Secretary for Justice is staying in office, but the Home Secretary has gone; the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning is staying in office, but the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government has gone; the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth is staying in office, but I would put no bets on the fate of the Chancellor of the Exchequer. This First Minister is staying in office. I do not know the fate of the Prime Minister.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Jun 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Wednesday 3 June 2009 Debate · 1
- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Community Health Nurses Questions · 4
- Submarines (Emergency Planning) Questions · 4
- National Health Service (Distinction Awards) Questions · 6
- Edinburgh's Festivals (Support) Questions · 7
- Agenda for Change Questions · 6
- Glasgow (Training and Skills Development) Questions · 6
- Kessock Bridge (Congestion) Questions · 6
- Southern General Hospital (Parking Charge Exemptions) Questions · 4
- Project Scotland Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Teenagers (Alcohol Addiction) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Local Government Concordat (Education) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Drug Addiction (Targets) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Animal Welfare Questions · 6
- Sheep and Cattle (South of Scotland) Questions · 9
- Plastic Bags (Recycling) Questions · 5
- Food and Drink Industry (New Markets) Questions · 6
- Recycled Waste (Commercial Exploitation) Questions · 6
- Waste Management Questions · 6
- Peatland Restoration Questions · 6
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Fine Defaulters (Jail Sentences) Questions · 9
- Domestic Abuse Questions · 6
- Antisocial Behaviour Questions · 8
- Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2003 (Rehabilitation) Questions · 4
- Community Sentences (Lanarkshire) Questions · 4
- Cabinet Secretary for Justice (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Offences (Aggravation by Prejudice) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 24
- Business Motions Business motions · 51
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
- Unpaid Carers Members’ business · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.