To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1708)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 2
The record
15 contributionsLater today I will have meetings that take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
The whole Parliament will wish to join me in congratulating all those who work in the national health service, who have worked so hard to meet—for the first time ever—the two-month target to treat urgently referred cancer patients. Figures released this week confirm that 95.4 per cent of urgently referred patients began treatment within two months. The national target was first set in 2001, and it was due to be achieved in 2005. I am proud that it has now been delivered under this Administration.
The whole Parliament will wish to join me in congratulating all those who work in the national health service, who have worked so hard to meet—for the first time ever—the two-month target to treat urgently referred cancer patients. Figures released this week confirm that 95.4 per cent of urgently referred patients began treatment within two months. The national target was first set in 2001, and it was due to be achieved in 2005. I am proud that it has now been delivered under this Administration.
On Monday, convicted gunman Brian Martin got up and walked out of Castle Huntly open prison. He is yet to be recaptured. Why was a man with a long record of violence and of fleeing justice being held in an open prison in the first place?
Open prisons, by their very nature—and since their instigation in the 1950s—are designed for long-term offenders who are approaching the end of their sentences. That is what open prisons are for. Any absconding from an open prison is to be regretted. There have been three absconds from the open prison estate this year. Two people have been apprehended; the search is on for the one who has not.
When he walked out of the open prison on Monday, Brian Martin was just three years into a 10-year sentence for firing a gun during a fight in a house in Fife. His previous offences include a string of armed robberies and threatening police with a sawn-off shotgun. This is a man who was once dubbed "the most dangerous man in Britain". Will the First Minister agree with me that Brian Martin should not have been in an open prison in the first place?
Neither Iain Gray nor I can rule on the criteria for open prisons, but we can look at the figures for open prisons and abscondings over the past generation. After the introduction of the tightened regulations following the case of Robert Foye, which were announced by the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and approved, I think, by the whole Parliament, we can now see from the figures what is actually happening in the open estate. In the last year of Labour control, there were 339 prisoners in the open estate and 79 abscondees. That is an abscond rate, as a percentage of the daily population, of 23 per cent. In the past year, following the reforms that were instigated by the justice secretary, there were 342 prisoners in the open estate, of whom 16 absconded.
In other words, although it is greatly to be regretted for anybody to abscond from the open estate, I do not think that Iain Gray is on particularly firm ground when he complains about abscondees, as the rate under the present justice secretary is one fifth of what it was under the Labour Party.
In other words, although it is greatly to be regretted for anybody to abscond from the open estate, I do not think that Iain Gray is on particularly firm ground when he complains about abscondees, as the rate under the present justice secretary is one fifth of what it was under the Labour Party.
I am not entirely sure about the arithmetic there—
Members
link
Oh!
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Although the figures on the reduction in the number of absconds are welcome, that misses the point. Back in March last year, the justice secretary said:
"every abscond is one too many."
Surely this abscond—Brian Martin— is the one too many.
Two years ago, Robert Foye absconded from Castle Huntly and viciously attacked a young schoolgirl. Following that, Mr MacAskill said that there was now
"a clear presumption against returning a prisoner to the open estate if they have previously absconded."—[Official Report, 26 March 2008; c 7308-9.]
This is not the first time that Brian Martin has gone on the run, is it? He has had previously to be pursued using roadblocks and sniffer dogs, yet he was still housed in an open prison. Is it not the truth that Mr Salmond and Mr MacAskill have not done enough to protect the public since the last such case?
"every abscond is one too many."
Surely this abscond—Brian Martin— is the one too many.
Two years ago, Robert Foye absconded from Castle Huntly and viciously attacked a young schoolgirl. Following that, Mr MacAskill said that there was now
"a clear presumption against returning a prisoner to the open estate if they have previously absconded."—[Official Report, 26 March 2008; c 7308-9.]
This is not the first time that Brian Martin has gone on the run, is it? He has had previously to be pursued using roadblocks and sniffer dogs, yet he was still housed in an open prison. Is it not the truth that Mr Salmond and Mr MacAskill have not done enough to protect the public since the last such case?
I am glad that Iain Gray is not clear about the arithmetic: that applies to every subject that he raises in the chamber. The statistics on the number of abscondees from the open estate are important, and I remind him that they show a dramatic reduction. He says that that is to be welcomed; indeed it is, and I hope that that welcome applies across the Labour benches.
Iain Gray asked me to say that one abscondee is too many. Yes, it is. The three that we have had this year are too many as well, but let us recognise that, because of the firm action taken by the justice secretary, the number of abscondees from the open prison estate in Scotland is at an all-time low. Is not that to be welcomed?
Iain Gray asked me to say that one abscondee is too many. Yes, it is. The three that we have had this year are too many as well, but let us recognise that, because of the firm action taken by the justice secretary, the number of abscondees from the open prison estate in Scotland is at an all-time low. Is not that to be welcomed?
I have already welcomed the improvement shown by the statistics, but the statistics also show that a particularly dangerous violent criminal is on the loose. It would be bad enough if Mr MacAskill let the public down in that way occasionally, but hardly a day goes by without another fiasco: he missed the knife summit to go to a pub in Canada, defied Parliament to cancel community courts and abandoned tough action on antisocial behaviour. We found out this week that hundreds of cases in the High Court are being delayed and that police officers are being trained in the dark at Tulliallan to save on electricity bills. He persists—[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Kenny MacAskill also persists with the madness of ending all six-month sentences. He has failed to protect the public from Brian Martin; will Mr Salmond now protect the public from him and admit that his justice secretary is just not up to the job?
Iain Gray says that police officers are being trained in the dark at Tulliallan. If it had been up to him, they would not be trained at all, because there would be no extra police officers. Under the justice secretary, 16,675 police officers patrol the communities of Scotland and keep them safe.
Iain Gray still does not understand the statistics for abscondees from the open prisons, so I will read out the numbers for the last three or four years of Labour control in Scotland: 71, 63 and 79 abscondees. The figure of 16 for last year is a great deal lower than was the case under any Labour justice minister.
At some point, Iain Gray will have to admit that we had the biggest reduction in crime statistics for a generation and have a record clear-up rate because we have police officers going through Tulliallan day and daily under the current justice secretary.
Iain Gray still does not understand the statistics for abscondees from the open prisons, so I will read out the numbers for the last three or four years of Labour control in Scotland: 71, 63 and 79 abscondees. The figure of 16 for last year is a great deal lower than was the case under any Labour justice minister.
At some point, Iain Gray will have to admit that we had the biggest reduction in crime statistics for a generation and have a record clear-up rate because we have police officers going through Tulliallan day and daily under the current justice secretary.
In this meeting
Everything on 21 May 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 21 May 2009 Debate · 1
- Student Hardship Debate · 71
- Supporting Employment Debate · 51
- National Concessionary Travel Scheme (Extension) Questions · 6
- Compulsory Redundancies (Public Sector) Questions · 7
- Community Courts (Glasgow) Questions · 6
- Pharmacy Applications Questions · 8
- Forth Replacement Crossing (Baseline Indicators) Questions · 5
- Registered Sex Offenders Questions · 4
- Scottish Futures Trust Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Curriculum for Excellence First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Young People not in Education, Employment or Training First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Teachers (Safety) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Broadcast Spectrum Questions · 4
- National Trust for Scotland Questions · 13
- Scottish Screen Questions · 7
- Slovakian Nationals (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Local Newspapers Questions · 9
- Individual Learning Accounts Questions · 6
- Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Bill Questions · 6
- Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning (Meetings) Questions · 4
- The Path is Green Questions · 4
- Children's Hearings System (Reform) Questions · 6
- Bologna Process Questions · 8
- Schools (Refurbishment or Reconstruction) Questions · 4
- Aquaculture Debate · 29
- Coroners and Justice Bill Bill debate · 10
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 13
- Decision Time Decision time · 57
- Strathclyde Police Prolific Offender Programme Members’ business · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.