Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Commission on Scottish Devolution

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE General Questions

Thursday 7 May 2009 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 16 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

16 contributions
George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link
To ask the Scottish Executive for what reason the First Minister has met the chairman of the Independent Commission on Funding and Finance for Wales but not the chairman of the Calman Commission on Scottish Devolution. (S3O-6796)

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
For reasons of open-mindedness. The Holtham commission is looking at a full range of options for funding the Welsh Assembly Government, including tax-varying and borrowing powers. By contrast, the Calman commission cannot examine all the options for the future of Scotland. Nevertheless, if it helps, I will meet Sir Kenneth Calman later this month to explain the work of the Governments national conversation in more detail.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link
The minister is trying to mislead the chamber, just as the First Minister did when on 29 March he pointed out to the BBC that

"the Welsh finance commission was considering independence."

According to the remit of the Holtham commission, which I have here, it is, like the Calman commission, not considering independence. When the First Minister made that comment, was he ignorant or was he lying?

Alex Fergusson The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
I will not have the accusation made in this chamber that anyone is lying. Will you please withdraw that accusation?

Members
link
Withdraw!

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link
I withdraw the accusation. Was the First Minister being ignorant or was he being economical with the truth?

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
I would have thought that a peer who apparently is one of the four wise men considering British intelligence matters might be more careful with his language than he appears to be in this chamber. If anything, such comments reflect badly on him.

I make it entirely clear—and the member should know this if he is a man of intelligence—that the Holtham commission is considering a whole range of options including tax-varying and borrowing powers.

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
I am afraid that Lord Foulkes is just not asking the right question.

The reality is that tax-varying and borrowing powers are being considered by the Holtham commission, a body that the First Minister and I have met. We should remember that the Calman commission has, by diktat of the party of which Lord Foulkes is a member, excluded from consideration all the options that face the people of Scotland.

Kenneth Gibson SNP Cunninghame North
link
Does the minister agree that the Calman commission, whose 15 members include six peers and three knights of the realm, is hardly a representative cross-section of Scottish society; that a commission that specifically excludes the noble aim of Scottish independence has damaged its democratic credentials; and that the national conversation is a more open and inclusive way of addressing Scotlands constitutional future?

Alex Fergusson The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Briefly, minister.

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Culture, External Affairs and the Constitution · South of Scotland
link
I certainly concur. However, I advise the member not to judge all members of the House of Lords by the one from whom we have just heard.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 7 May 2009 Debate · 1
  2. School Discipline Debate · 56
  3. Community Courts Debate · 44
  4. Newly Qualified Teachers Questions · 8
  5. Scottish Qualifications Authority Questions · 4
  6. Commission on Scottish Devolution Questions · 16
  7. Oil Questions · 6
  8. Dumbarton Health Centre (Family Planning and Well Woman Clinic) Questions · 4
  9. Pensioners Parliament Questions · 7
  10. Southern General Hospital (Clyde Fastlink) Questions · 4
  11. Houses in Multiple Occupation Questions · 6
  12. Lottery Funding Questions · 5
  13. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  14. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  16. Economic Support First Minister’s Questions · 7
  17. Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed Al Megrahi First Minister’s Questions · 8
  18. Departmental Expenditure Limit First Minister’s Questions · 20
  19. “The Road to Recovery” Questions · 6
  20. Strathclyde Police Questions · 7
  21. McKenzie Friends Questions · 4
  22. Paid Informants Questions · 5
  23. Antisocial Behaviour (Short-term Holiday Lets) Questions · 6
  24. Drug Addiction Services Questions · 13
  25. National Food Policy (Local Food) Questions · 6
  26. Greener Scotland Objectives Questions · 7
  27. Scotland Rural Development Programme Questions · 6
  28. Energy Generation (Waste) Questions · 6
  29. Flooding (Kinross-shire) Questions · 4
  30. Fish and Shellfish (Promotion) Questions · 5
  31. Incinerators Questions · 4
  32. Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 63
  33. Climate Change (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
  34. Presiding Officers Rulings Procedure · 1
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 66
  36. Royal Mail (Part-privatisation) Members’ business · 47

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.