To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1398)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 8
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Alex Fergusson 6
The record
21 contributionsLater today, I will meet Opposition leaders who have asked for meetings to discuss taking forward the budget process to completion. The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth has contacted every local authority in Scotland to explain the circumstances that threaten to disrupt their budgeting. Hopefully, that will concentrate the minds of the Parliament on the jobs and services outside the chamber that depend on the decisions that we make inside the chamber.
Yesterday morning, John Swinney said:
"The duty for me is to put forward a budget that convinces Parliament."
I agree. Last night, he acknowledged that he had failed in that duty. He failed because the Scottish National Party approached the serious matter of the Scottish budget with reckless brinkmanship and arrogance. Hubris indeed. It chose to seek narrow political advantage rather than broad, constructive consensus. That approach must not be repeated.
I welcome the First Minister's meetings today, and offer him the opportunity to explain to Scotland how he intends to change his approach to secure support for the resubmitted budget bill.
"The duty for me is to put forward a budget that convinces Parliament."
I agree. Last night, he acknowledged that he had failed in that duty. He failed because the Scottish National Party approached the serious matter of the Scottish budget with reckless brinkmanship and arrogance. Hubris indeed. It chose to seek narrow political advantage rather than broad, constructive consensus. That approach must not be repeated.
I welcome the First Minister's meetings today, and offer him the opportunity to explain to Scotland how he intends to change his approach to secure support for the resubmitted budget bill.
The bill failed because the Labour Party, as the principal Opposition party, decided to put its own narrow interests before employment and jobs for Scotland. That is why we have editorials such as that in today's Scottish Daily Express:
"Labour MSPs should be ashamed of themselves".
There were a number of revealing contributions in yesterday's debate, but none more revealing than that from John Park MSP, who responded to the realisation that the SNP had offered the Labour Party one of its key demands—the apprenticeship guarantee, which I think is vital—with the words:
"Will the cabinet secretary confirm that the Government would have announced that anyway, regardless of the budget process?"—[Official Report, 28 January 2009; c 14452.]
As if an issue as important as apprenticeships should depend on who was making the announcement. That is exactly the problem with the Labour Party when it refuses to face its responsibilities.
"Labour MSPs should be ashamed of themselves".
There were a number of revealing contributions in yesterday's debate, but none more revealing than that from John Park MSP, who responded to the realisation that the SNP had offered the Labour Party one of its key demands—the apprenticeship guarantee, which I think is vital—with the words:
"Will the cabinet secretary confirm that the Government would have announced that anyway, regardless of the budget process?"—[Official Report, 28 January 2009; c 14452.]
As if an issue as important as apprenticeships should depend on who was making the announcement. That is exactly the problem with the Labour Party when it refuses to face its responsibilities.
Einstein defined insanity as doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. There is little sign of the Government having learned any lesson from yesterday. One editorial does not the news coverage make—I suggest that the First Minister reads the editorials in some of the other newspapers—nor does one proposal constitute constructive discussion.
Labour has a series of sincere proposals that we believe will help Scotland through the global economic crisis. A young person in Scotland has less than half the chance of an apprenticeship place that a young person in England has. We want that corrected. Most people would consider that a reasonable and compelling objective. In a budget of £34 billion, no one would believe it to be too much to ask. However, last night the SNP described that constructive dialogue as Labour "playing games". We have heard more of the same today.
Will the First Minister learn the lesson of yesterday, and promise to set aside such language and give an assurance that he will enter into discussions seriously, responsibly and in a spirit of good faith?
Labour has a series of sincere proposals that we believe will help Scotland through the global economic crisis. A young person in Scotland has less than half the chance of an apprenticeship place that a young person in England has. We want that corrected. Most people would consider that a reasonable and compelling objective. In a budget of £34 billion, no one would believe it to be too much to ask. However, last night the SNP described that constructive dialogue as Labour "playing games". We have heard more of the same today.
Will the First Minister learn the lesson of yesterday, and promise to set aside such language and give an assurance that he will enter into discussions seriously, responsibly and in a spirit of good faith?
We have entered into discussions seriously, responsibly and in a spirit of good faith. I agree with Iain Gray. Responding to only one constructive suggestion is not enough, which is why, for example, in response to another of the Labour Party's five demands we announced a town centre regeneration fund of £60 million, when they wanted one for £50 million. I see Labour members pointing at the Conservatives. Because the Conservatives championed that idea, it suddenly becomes invalid. Does that not imply that what Labour wanted out of the budget was not constructive investment for the people of Scotland but to be able to claim for itself ideas that were shared throughout the Parliament? [Applause.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
That is enough applause, thank you.
The First Minister's responses demonstrate exactly the narrow party advantage that he has brought to and seeks from the process. Let us examine his responses.
In his first answer, the First Minister talked about the consequences of last night's vote, although he seems to have learned little about the consequences for his own standing. For some time now, the SNP and its loyal servants in the matter, the Tories, have claimed that £1.8 billion would be lost to Scotland if the Budget (Scotland) (No 2) Bill fell and that there would be no increase in funding next year. In fact, the Tories are claiming today that that has already happened, but it is not true.
I am sure that the First Minister would not wish to allow the Parliament or the people of Scotland to be misled, so let me read from an e-mail from the assistant clerk to the Finance Committee:
"If the Budget Bill for 2009-10 was passed at some point after 1 April and only came into force on, say, 1 June 2009, then the Government would get the full allocation of circa £34 billion".
[Interruption.]
In his first answer, the First Minister talked about the consequences of last night's vote, although he seems to have learned little about the consequences for his own standing. For some time now, the SNP and its loyal servants in the matter, the Tories, have claimed that £1.8 billion would be lost to Scotland if the Budget (Scotland) (No 2) Bill fell and that there would be no increase in funding next year. In fact, the Tories are claiming today that that has already happened, but it is not true.
I am sure that the First Minister would not wish to allow the Parliament or the people of Scotland to be misled, so let me read from an e-mail from the assistant clerk to the Finance Committee:
"If the Budget Bill for 2009-10 was passed at some point after 1 April and only came into force on, say, 1 June 2009, then the Government would get the full allocation of circa £34 billion".
[Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Yesterday, the moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland reminded us of Burns's words
"an honest man's the noblest work of God".
Is the First Minister honest enough to admit that the claim that £1.8 billion will be lost is just gratuitous scaremongering?
"an honest man's the noblest work of God".
Is the First Minister honest enough to admit that the claim that £1.8 billion will be lost is just gratuitous scaremongering?
I have heard many questions in my time as First Minister, but that must rate as the most extraordinary of them all. We are now told by Iain Gray that, apparently, it would not cause disruption to Scottish public services if a budget bill did not pass until June. What are the health boards throughout Scotland to do in the meantime? What are the local authorities throughout Scotland to do in the meantime? What is every voluntary organisation in Scotland to do in the meantime? [Applause.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Let us put it in terms of jobs: £1.8 billion is 35,000 jobs. Sooner or later, the Labour Party had better realise, as the first ever Opposition party to vote against a budget at stage 3 in this Parliament, that it is jeopardising 35,000 jobs.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Mr Gray, a brief final question, please.
Mr Swinney made it clear last night that the Government intends to seek consensus and lodge a budget bill that the Parliament can support. That is what the Government requires to do in order to avoid the kind of disruption that has been mentioned. That is its responsibility. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
The process has to be about the SNP Government responding to the scale of the economic challenge that we face. Yesterday's gross domestic product figures simply emphasise the seriousness of the challenge in Scotland. Last night, when Mr Swinney was asked how much of his budget he had changed, he answered, "£82 million." That is one quarter of one per cent.
Members
link
Question!
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. I will decide on the timings in the chamber.
We know that more can be done. We have been saying that since October. Our door is still open to discuss the budget that Scotland needs. Can the First Minister promise the same, and can we believe him?
We are now making progress. We have moved from the context of the previous question, where there was to be no disruption at all and we could have a budget through in June, to an acceptance that there will be serious disruption. If the Labour Party starts to understand the consequences of its vote yesterday, perhaps we will get to the solution.
I have pointed out a number of issues on which the SNP had made agreements with, or at least offers to the Labour Party. I have mentioned two already. One was apparently invalid because we were going to do it anyway, and the second was invalid because the Conservatives were also proposing it. How about the promised increased investment in PACE—partnership action for continuing employment? That is another of Labour's demands that was met, but it is apparently now swept aside because Labour wants to seek some other advantage.
Yes, 35,000 jobs are at stake, as are the apprenticeship places that are going through; the small business bonus scheme; the council tax freeze; the extra police officers; the accelerated capital investment; the help for people who are facing redundancy; the zero waste fund; free personal care; regeneration; capital city costs; the reduction in prescription charges; and the town centre regeneration fund. They are all at risk because of Labour's attitude, and it is high time that Iain Gray started to face up to his responsibilities, not to his back benchers or to Jim Murphy, but to this Parliament and the people of Scotland.
I have pointed out a number of issues on which the SNP had made agreements with, or at least offers to the Labour Party. I have mentioned two already. One was apparently invalid because we were going to do it anyway, and the second was invalid because the Conservatives were also proposing it. How about the promised increased investment in PACE—partnership action for continuing employment? That is another of Labour's demands that was met, but it is apparently now swept aside because Labour wants to seek some other advantage.
Yes, 35,000 jobs are at stake, as are the apprenticeship places that are going through; the small business bonus scheme; the council tax freeze; the extra police officers; the accelerated capital investment; the help for people who are facing redundancy; the zero waste fund; free personal care; regeneration; capital city costs; the reduction in prescription charges; and the town centre regeneration fund. They are all at risk because of Labour's attitude, and it is high time that Iain Gray started to face up to his responsibilities, not to his back benchers or to Jim Murphy, but to this Parliament and the people of Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 January 2009 Debate · 1
- Forestry Debate · 61
- Transport Debate · 65
- Community Prison Facilities (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
- Social Rented Housing Questions · 12
- Schoolchildren (Physical Activity) Questions · 6
- Nuclear Weapons Questions · 6
- Schools (Biometric Technology) Questions · 4
- Fatal Accident Inquiries (Armed Services Personnel) Questions · 4
- HMP Peterhead (Replacement) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 21
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Manufacturing Sector (Recession) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Victims Champion First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Schools (Excluded Children) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Global Economic Downturn (Employment) Questions · 8
- Economic Recovery Programme Questions · 6
- A9 (Dualling) Questions · 6
- Scottish Futures Trust (Chief Executive) Questions · 4
- ScotRail (Ticket Pricing) Questions · 4
- Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Glasgow Crossrail Project Questions · 4
- Sickness Absence (Public Sector) Questions · 6
- Consultants (Expenditure) Questions · 4
- M80 (Stepps to Haggs Project) Questions · 4
- Local Authorities (Extra Funding) Questions · 6
- Economic Growth (South of Scotland) Questions · 6
- Island Air Routes (Service Levels) Questions · 6
- Scottish Futures Trust Questions · 4
- Gaelic Language Plan Debate · 39
- Business Motion Business motions · 3
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 55
- Diabetes UK Members’ business · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.