To ask the Scottish Executive what discussions it has had with the staff of Forestry Commission Scotland and their trade unions over the future of Scotland's forests. (S3O-5561)
Official Report · Chamber
Forestry
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Rural Affairs and the Environment
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael Russell SNP 3
- Bill Butler Lab 2
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 1
The record
7 contributionsI met representatives of Forestry Commission trade unions on 4 November 2008, when we published a consultation paper on the forestry provisions in the Climate Change (Scotland) Bill. I have met union members since then at a number of consultation events. To help all staff consider the possible implications of those provisions, senior officials in Forestry Commission Scotland have organised staff meetings in Edinburgh, Stirling, Inverness, Perth, Aviemore, Oban, Dumfries and Stranraer. I have also met staff at other meetings.
The minister will be aware that his Government's proposals for the future of Scotland's forests have caused deep unease in Parliament and, more important, they have caused great anxiety among Forestry Commission staff. I have just come from a meeting with staff who are in the trade unions, at which I heard their concerns at first hand. Is the minister aware that the Forestry Commission trade unions have offered an alternative to meeting the Scottish Government's climate change commitments that does not require the handing over of more than 25 per cent of Scotland's national forest estate to the private sector in a 75-year lease—which is, in effect, back-door privatisation? Will he give a commitment today to respond positively to the unions' proposals, in order to ensure that the jobs remain firmly in the public sector?
No—I will not give that commitment, and I will tell Bill Butler why. I have not seen the proposals, and it would be very foolish of me to commit to proposals that I have not seen. However, I have said repeatedly to everybody involved in the consultation—particularly to those who are willing to listen and debate, which includes a number of people in the forestry sector but very few from the Labour or Liberal seats in Parliament—that I am entirely open to other ideas. Indeed, I have said repeatedly that a monopoly of wisdom on the issue does not lie in any one place and that the proposals can be improved.
I stress again that there is no threat to jobs and that there is a triple jobs guarantee, which I gave at the meeting on 4 November 2008 and have given at every discussion since. I have also made it as clear as I can that the prospect of spending up to £200 million on forestry-related activity in Scotland will produce more jobs, not fewer. Perhaps Mr Butler would like to reflect on the salient fact that more than 1,000 Forestry Commission jobs were lost in the past 10 years, which is of course when Mr Butler's party and the Liberal Democrats—who have been active in the campaign but appear nowhere today—were the parties in power. They cost Scotland 1,000 Forestry Commission jobs. I want to increase the number of forestry jobs in rural Scotland.
I stress again that there is no threat to jobs and that there is a triple jobs guarantee, which I gave at the meeting on 4 November 2008 and have given at every discussion since. I have also made it as clear as I can that the prospect of spending up to £200 million on forestry-related activity in Scotland will produce more jobs, not fewer. Perhaps Mr Butler would like to reflect on the salient fact that more than 1,000 Forestry Commission jobs were lost in the past 10 years, which is of course when Mr Butler's party and the Liberal Democrats—who have been active in the campaign but appear nowhere today—were the parties in power. They cost Scotland 1,000 Forestry Commission jobs. I want to increase the number of forestry jobs in rural Scotland.
The minister may be aware that I am broadly supportive of his proposals to lease part of the forestry land in order to raise resources, but can he tell me what other efforts have been made to explore alternative funding streams that may release the same resources? In particular, is there an option to look at carbon trading mechanisms, which could bring resources into Scottish forestry to be used to expand the planting rate?
There are a number of possible options. However, one of the great difficulties that the Scottish Government and the Scottish Parliament have is that—bizarrely, in the world of democracy—the Government cannot borrow. It is also a Government that does not have full tax powers at its command. The classic means by which we could increase the amount of planting in Scotland, which would include tax incentives and mechanisms to support the price of timber—which might include borrowing to undertake activity such as we are talking about, given that it is an early investment in tackling climate change—are not available to this Government. We must therefore be inventive about how we increase the planting rate. We must raise the rate—which is at about 4,000 hectares a year—to 10,000 hectares a year, and we should try to take it higher than that. I am trying to find a way to do that and am open to any and all suggestions.
If the suggestion of carbon trading were to be brought forward during the consultation period, I would look at it seriously. However, I must stress to members across the chamber that doing nothing is not an option, and that the worst option of all is to create anxiety through the scaremongering that we have seen, rather than addressing the issue honestly. There are members in the chamber whose behaviour has been disgraceful.
If the suggestion of carbon trading were to be brought forward during the consultation period, I would look at it seriously. However, I must stress to members across the chamber that doing nothing is not an option, and that the worst option of all is to create anxiety through the scaremongering that we have seen, rather than addressing the issue honestly. There are members in the chamber whose behaviour has been disgraceful.
Question 4 was not lodged.
In this meeting
Everything on 22 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 22 January 2009 Debate · 1
- Scottish Parliamentary Pensions Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 8
- “First Annual Report of the Scottish Council of Economic Advisers: December 2008” (Scottish Government Response) Debate · 67
- Oil and Gas Industry Questions · 8
- Business (Government Support) Questions · 4
- Strategic Transport Projects Review Questions · 10
- Small Businesses (Cash Flow) Questions · 6
- National Concessionary Travel Scheme Questions · 4
- Care Commission (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Scottish Federation of Housing Associations Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Jury Trials First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Creative Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Water First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Landfill Waste Reduction Questions · 7
- Forestry Questions · 7
- Climate Challenge Fund Questions · 9
- LEADER Programme (Aberdeenshire) Questions · 4
- Eco-schools Questions · 6
- Agricultural Pay and Conditions Questions · 9
- Direct Measures Questions · 8
- Serious Fraud Investigations Questions · 6
- Residency and Contact Orders Questions · 8
- Proceeds of Crime (Reinvestment) Questions · 8
- Low Moss Prison Questions · 9
- Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 47
- Flood Risk Management (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 31
- Cuiken Primary School Playing Field Members’ business · 22
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.