To ask the First Minister what implications the decision by HM Treasury to refuse the proposed funding package for the new Forth crossing will have for capital spending by the Scottish Government. (S3F-1346)
Official Report · Chamber
Forth Crossing
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 4
- Christina McKelvie SNP 2
- Jim Tolson LD 1
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
The record
8 contributionsThe Scottish Government is prepared to fully provide for the construction costs of the Forth replacement crossing because its immense economic importance to Scotland means that the project has top priority in our capital programme. That view is widely shared in Scotland. However, if no adjustment is made to Scotland's capital budgets from the Treasury, there will be a substantial impact on other capital projects in the period 2013 to 2016, when the crossing will be under construction. We have sought HM Treasury's assistance in reprofiling the capital budget over a number of years to reduce that impact. The initial reply is disappointing, but offers further constructive discussions, which are being arranged and will be conducted in that spirit.
Does the First Minister agree that what that case and the current economic situation show is that it is essential that the anomaly whereby local authorities and Network Rail have borrowing powers but the Scottish Government does not is rectified as soon as possible?
Yes, indeed. That question gets to the very heart of the issue. Previous Governments had the option of using PPP and PFI to get round the lack of borrowing powers but, as the letter from the Chief Secretary to the Treasury indicates, that is no longer an option. Indeed, it is obviously the worst option because if we proposed a Labour-type scheme for PPP, not only would the entire capital cost fall on a single year, which would swallow more than half the capital budget in that year, but we would then have to pay for the next 30 years the on-going borrowing costs of PPP. We would end up paying for the bridge twice—no wonder the Labour Party is thinking of tolling the bridge.
A new Forth crossing is of the utmost importance not only to my constituents in Dunfermline West but to the whole Scottish economy. Given that the Scottish Futures Trust and holding out the begging bowl to Westminster have failed, where is the credibility in the First Minister's assurances that a new crossing will be completed in 2016, when no funding is in place?
The funding is in place. That has been done by traditional public procurement. The advantage of doing it that way has been demonstrated by the substantial savings that have already been made in the cost estimates for the bridge. When, or if, any of the other parties comes forward with a better funding mechanism than the certainty of public procurement under our proposals, of course we will listen. However, we know that we can build a bridge on time and on budget.
link
If the on-going commitment to an additional road bridge puts other projects—such as public transport investment—at risk, it will make the current Government's transport policy even less sustainable. In the light of the Treasury's decision on the matter, is it not time to take the cheapest, quickest and most sensible option and fix the bridge that we already have?
The majority of people in the chamber, and certainly the majority of people in Scotland, do not believe that we can risk the closure of one of the integral links in the Scottish transport system, which would be the inevitable result of anticipating that it would be possible to sort the current bridge without having to close it for a substantial time. I think the decision to have the new Forth crossing carries substantial support.
In terms of the risk to other transport projects, the risk is that there will be delay if we are not allowed to spread the cost of this huge capital project over time. The analogy—I hope that Patrick Harvie will support this aspect—is with the ability that we have in respect of rail improvements, which are substantial across Scotland at present, for Network Rail to borrow. That has allowed us to procure a huge programme of rail facilities across Scotland. That is the mechanism that we need for all transport projects so that such uniquely costly projects can be spread sensibly over time.
In terms of the risk to other transport projects, the risk is that there will be delay if we are not allowed to spread the cost of this huge capital project over time. The analogy—I hope that Patrick Harvie will support this aspect—is with the ability that we have in respect of rail improvements, which are substantial across Scotland at present, for Network Rail to borrow. That has allowed us to procure a huge programme of rail facilities across Scotland. That is the mechanism that we need for all transport projects so that such uniquely costly projects can be spread sensibly over time.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 January 2009 Debate · 1
- Homecoming Scotland 2009 Debate · 35
- Gaza (Humanitarian Disaster) Debate · 27
- Disclosure Scotland Questions · 4
- National Health Service (Patient Transport) Questions · 8
- Strathclyde Police Chief Constable (Meetings) Questions · 4
- A9 Questions · 8
- National Health Service Boards (Meetings) Questions · 4
- NFU Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Energy Companies (Excessive Profits) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 26
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Forth Crossing First Minister’s Questions · 8
- International Development Policy (Gaza) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Economy First Minister’s Questions · 10
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- National Theatre of Scotland (Funding) Questions · 4
- European Ministerial Counterparts (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Creative Scotland Bill Questions · 8
- Scotland's Culture Website Questions · 4
- Young People (Exchanges) Questions · 4
- Scottish Artists Union (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Architecture Questions · 4
- Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games (Cultural Programme) Questions · 4
- Scottish Language Dictionaries (Funding) Questions · 4
- Citizenship Questions · 8
- Secondary Schools (Laurencekirk and Kemnay) Questions · 8
- Class Sizes (Primary 1 to Primary 3) Questions · 6
- School Leavers Questions · 6
- Skills Development Scotland Chief Executive (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Nursery Teachers Questions · 4
- Asylum Seekers (Further and Higher Education) Questions · 6
- Scottish Baccalaureate (Universities and Colleges Admissions Service Tariff Points) Questions · 4
- Offender Management Plan Debate · 82
- Points of Order Procedure · 14
- Decision Time Decision time · 43
- Aberdeen Forensic Science Laboratory Members’ business · 46
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.