To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1294)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
14 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
I know that the chamber will want to join me in recalling that Sunday 21 December marks the 20th anniversary of the Lockerbie air disaster. The community in Lockerbie will be observing the anniversary with a dignified programme of events to mark the occasion. Our thoughts are with them and with all those whose lives have been affected by the atrocity.
Later today, in a display of Christmas solidarity, all the party leaders and I will be launching the homecoming programme for next year. I know that the whole chamber will want to support that wonderful initiative, which is so important for our country.
Following that, I will be speaking with the directors of Norfolkline, which has today announced the opening of bookings for the first sailings of the new Rosyth to Zeebrugge ferry, which is of enormous importance not only to communities in Fife, but to our whole country.
I know that the chamber will want to join me in recalling that Sunday 21 December marks the 20th anniversary of the Lockerbie air disaster. The community in Lockerbie will be observing the anniversary with a dignified programme of events to mark the occasion. Our thoughts are with them and with all those whose lives have been affected by the atrocity.
Later today, in a display of Christmas solidarity, all the party leaders and I will be launching the homecoming programme for next year. I know that the whole chamber will want to support that wonderful initiative, which is so important for our country.
Following that, I will be speaking with the directors of Norfolkline, which has today announced the opening of bookings for the first sailings of the new Rosyth to Zeebrugge ferry, which is of enormous importance not only to communities in Fife, but to our whole country.
Those of us on this side of the chamber wish to be associated with the First Minister's remarks regarding the people of Lockerbie and that anniversary.
A year ago, on the day on which we rose for the Christmas recess, the First Minister sneaked out his consultation on the Scottish Futures Trust. A year later, the Finance Committee has published its report on capital investment and has said that there is insufficient information to judge whether the SFT will be a mechanism for improved value for money, to judge its role in managing a pipeline of projects, or to comment on the accountability and governance issues relating to the SFT.
A year after the consultation was launched, we still do not know what the SFT is or how it will work. Does the First Minister still believe that it is ever going to build anything? If he does, does he believe in Santa, too?
A year ago, on the day on which we rose for the Christmas recess, the First Minister sneaked out his consultation on the Scottish Futures Trust. A year later, the Finance Committee has published its report on capital investment and has said that there is insufficient information to judge whether the SFT will be a mechanism for improved value for money, to judge its role in managing a pipeline of projects, or to comment on the accountability and governance issues relating to the SFT.
A year after the consultation was launched, we still do not know what the SFT is or how it will work. Does the First Minister still believe that it is ever going to build anything? If he does, does he believe in Santa, too?
I will answer the question about Santa first. I note that Iain Gray told The Big Issue in Scotland that his Christmas wish was
"to get the new style Ray-Bans—as modelled by one Barack Obama."
I cannot promise that I can get him Barack Obama's pair, but I will see what I can do about getting him some sunglasses.
The Scottish Futures Trust promises and offers the people of Scotland better value for money than they have had from the disgraceful excesses of the private finance initiative and public-private partnership models. I have been totalling up the massive capital investments that have been announced or taken forward by the Scottish Government since the Scottish National Party came to office, and it comes to a grand total of more than £8 billion. However, the most satisfying aspect of that is that no less than £2 billion of that sum will be spent on projects under the non-profit distributing model, which is the financial mechanism that is at the heart of the Scottish Futures Trust proposal.
"to get the new style Ray-Bans—as modelled by one Barack Obama."
I cannot promise that I can get him Barack Obama's pair, but I will see what I can do about getting him some sunglasses.
The Scottish Futures Trust promises and offers the people of Scotland better value for money than they have had from the disgraceful excesses of the private finance initiative and public-private partnership models. I have been totalling up the massive capital investments that have been announced or taken forward by the Scottish Government since the Scottish National Party came to office, and it comes to a grand total of more than £8 billion. However, the most satisfying aspect of that is that no less than £2 billion of that sum will be spent on projects under the non-profit distributing model, which is the financial mechanism that is at the heart of the Scottish Futures Trust proposal.
The First Minister's Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth has admitted that the non-profit distributing model is a version of PPP. The difference between PPP and the Scottish Futures Trust is that PPP actually builds schools and hospitals. The First Minister said that the trust would build bullet trains, roads, super ports and a Forth bridge, and that patriotic Scots would buy patriotic bonds for those patriotic projects. Last week, the Scottish Government published its strategic transport priorities for the next 20 years. The document was 3,000 pages long, and the Scottish Futures Trust was not mentioned once. Not one of the 29 projects will be built by the Futures Trust; the Futures Trust is dead. Will the First Minister do Scotland's parents, pupils, passengers and builders a favour, and bury the Futures Trust once and for all?
I remind Iain Gray—and Andy Kerr, who is sitting beside him—of the PFI disasters under the Labour-Liberal Administration. I remind him of the contrast between Hairmyres hospital, for which every single one of us will be paying for the next 20 to 25 years, and the announcements that this Administration has made, for example on the £842 million that will be invested in the new Southern general: public finance in the public health service.
I do not know whether Iain Gray has caught up with the instructions from London, but he might wish to know and understand that as of next April, after a transition period, everything comes on balance sheet: public-private partnerships, PFI, NPD—every capital investment. That is a recognition that PFI was part of the age of irresponsibility of off-balance-sheet funding. Therefore, it is important to get value for money from the capital projects, the efficiencies and the savings that the Scottish Futures Trust will bring forward.
I do not know whether Iain Gray has caught up with the instructions from London, but he might wish to know and understand that as of next April, after a transition period, everything comes on balance sheet: public-private partnerships, PFI, NPD—every capital investment. That is a recognition that PFI was part of the age of irresponsibility of off-balance-sheet funding. Therefore, it is important to get value for money from the capital projects, the efficiencies and the savings that the Scottish Futures Trust will bring forward.
For 10 years, PPP not only built schools and hospitals, but created tens of thousands of jobs for Scottish workers. The Futures Trust debacle is costing Scotland jobs. The construction industry says that 25,000 jobs have gone already and 100,000 more are at risk, and yet the Government still plays politics with infrastructure.
In last weekend's B-movie, John Swinney played a poor man's Jimmy Cagney, reduced to threatening that schools and hospitals will "get it" unless funds are forthcoming for his Forth crossing. That might have been a potent threat if anyone in Scotland believed that the Government was ever going to build any schools or hospitals in the first place.
The Futures Trust—[Interruption.] I can wait all day.
In last weekend's B-movie, John Swinney played a poor man's Jimmy Cagney, reduced to threatening that schools and hospitals will "get it" unless funds are forthcoming for his Forth crossing. That might have been a potent threat if anyone in Scotland believed that the Government was ever going to build any schools or hospitals in the first place.
The Futures Trust—[Interruption.] I can wait all day.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. The First Minister will get plenty of time to answer—Mr Gray is allowed to ask a question.
The Futures Trust—with no future—has £23 million against it, which could build new homes for almost 300 families. Will the First Minister take that money away from the Futures Trust now and use it to create some of the construction jobs that Scotland so badly needs?
The Scottish Futures Trust offers savings of £150 million a year in the capital programme. I repeat to Iain Gray the figure of £8,000 million of capital projects that have already been announced during this Government's term.
In between the long pauses in Iain Gray's questions, I did not quite get the references to Jimmy Cagney, but I note that—apart from his wish for sunglasses—Iain Gray's new year's resolution is to get a Johnny Seven gun. I might manage the sunglasses, but even Jimmy Cagney cannae manage the gun.
In between the long pauses in Iain Gray's questions, I did not quite get the references to Jimmy Cagney, but I note that—apart from his wish for sunglasses—Iain Gray's new year's resolution is to get a Johnny Seven gun. I might manage the sunglasses, but even Jimmy Cagney cannae manage the gun.
We have all seen the First Minister's I M Jolly, but really he should be starring in "Only an Excuse?" It is not just his Futures Trust that is dead in the water; it is his local income tax, which no one wants, and his concordat, which councils want to renegotiate. It is also his energy policy, which even his economic advisers say is wrong. It is a response to the economic crisis that will culminate tomorrow in his launching a commemorative shortbread tin—nice, but not nearly enough. As Scots face the challenges of 2009 and circumstances change faster than ever before, the First Minister must raise his game, because he looks more and more like a rabbit caught in the headlights, paralysed by policies that do not work but that he will not drop.
Members
link
Question.
I will come to the question—the answer will be much longer coming.
The Government has run out of ideas and is fast running out of excuses. Will the First Minister admit that after only 19 months he has run out of steam?
The Government has run out of ideas and is fast running out of excuses. Will the First Minister admit that after only 19 months he has run out of steam?
I do not know about I M Jolly, but I think that Iain Gray badly needs a new script writer. I M Jolly is a character whose role is to be depressed and scunnered—Iain Gray plays that character every week.
Since we are on the subject of finance, Iain Gray has had three weeks in which to work out whether the £500 million of Labour cuts are actually £500 million. Three weeks ago he told us that
"it may well be less than that, as we know".—[Official Report, 27 November 2008; c 12865.]
The Finance Committee has received Professor David Bell's estimate of Labour Party cuts, which is more than £500 million. As he thinks about the new year, how can Iain Gray ask a single question about finance, given that we are looking forward to £1 billion being slashed from the Scottish budget over two years by Alistair Darling, Gordon Brown and Jim Murphy? It may not be entirely surprising that Iain Gray is totally at the mercy of decisions made in London—after all, they even run his constituency party.
Since we are on the subject of finance, Iain Gray has had three weeks in which to work out whether the £500 million of Labour cuts are actually £500 million. Three weeks ago he told us that
"it may well be less than that, as we know".—[Official Report, 27 November 2008; c 12865.]
The Finance Committee has received Professor David Bell's estimate of Labour Party cuts, which is more than £500 million. As he thinks about the new year, how can Iain Gray ask a single question about finance, given that we are looking forward to £1 billion being slashed from the Scottish budget over two years by Alistair Darling, Gordon Brown and Jim Murphy? It may not be entirely surprising that Iain Gray is totally at the mercy of decisions made in London—after all, they even run his constituency party.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Dec 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 18 December 2008 Debate · 1
- Drink Driving Debate · 115
- Antisocial Behaviour Strategy (Review) Questions · 6
- Affordable Housing (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
- Food Safety (Imports) Questions · 8
- Consultants Distinction Awards Questions · 4
- Vulnerable People (Argyll and Bute) Questions · 7
- People with Mental Health Problems (Carers) Questions · 4
- Universities (Competitiveness) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Methadone Prescribing (Research Report) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Construction Industry (Jobs) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Energy Efficiency (Action Plan) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Dignity for Palestinians Members’ business · 24
- Railway Stations Questions · 8
- Scottish Water (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Institute of Asian Professionals (Meetings) Questions · 12
- Local Government Finance Settlement Questions · 4
- Road Works (Impact on Small Businesses) Questions · 4
- Public Transport (Local Authorities) Questions · 4
- Construction Industry Questions · 8
- Transport Projects (Fife) Questions · 4
- Waverley Railway Questions · 6
- Transport Links (Highlands) Questions · 4
- Scottish Futures Trust (Investment Models) Questions · 11
- Economy (Scottish Borders) Questions · 4
- Non-profit-distributing Model Questions · 6
- Organ Donation Debate · 57
- Decision Time Decision time · 30
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.