Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister's Question Time

Thursday 27 November 2008 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 13 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

13 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1215)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.

Let me say a word about the atrocity in Mumbai, which we all obviously unite to condemn. There were some indications this morning that employees of Scotland-based companies could have been caught up in the atrocity. I emphasise to members that there has been no confirmation of that. Indeed, at this stage, it may be just that some companies were unable to contact their employees because of the overnight situation.

Officials have been in contact with the Foreign and Commonwealth Office this morning, and there will be ministerial contact this afternoon. However, I know that members will appreciate that, regardless of the nationality of those caught up in the atrocity, there will almost certainly be Scottish families with close connections to the area. Scottish families will be affected, and I know that members will want to express their solidarity with those families, wherever they come from, and will unite to condemn the atrocity.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister knows that he can count on Labour members' solidarity with those who are caught up in and dealing with the atrocity.

Monday's pre-budget report was described in the media as the biggest budget statement since world war two. All eyes were on it. Is that why the Scottish National Party Government chose to publish on Monday its response to the consultation on Mr Salmond's so-called local income tax? Did the First Minister think that no one would notice?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
The consultation exercise was published five hours before the pre-budget report. To be helpful to the Labour Party, we put it as the number 1 item on the Scottish Government website. The people who responded to the consultation were written to individually. However, as the Labour Party, alone among the political parties, did not make a submission to the consultation, it did not get a letter and had to read the website.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister is not normally known for his shyness. He is always happy to turn up to the opening of an envelope or, better still, one of the schools that Labour planned and built. However, when it comes to his Administration's flagship policy, he sneaks it out the back door of Bute house under the cover of darkness and the PBR. Why? Perhaps it is because so many of the organisations that replied to the consultation roundly condemned his tax: the Confederation of British Industry, the Scottish Trades Union Congress, the Institute of Directors, the Scottish Chambers of Commerce, Unison, the Federation of Small Businesses, the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy, and the Law Society of Scotland.

Let us be fair. Some organisations supported the tax, including Dumfries and Galloway Council's SNP group, East Dunbartonshire Council's SNP group and South Lanarkshire Council's SNP group. Not all those organisations were SNP branches—the Association of Scottish Liberal Democrat Councillors was in there, too.

Will the First Minister listen to his own consultation and dump his discredited tax plan now?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Far be it from me to defend the Association of Scottish Liberal Democrat Councillors, but at least it managed to make a submission.

Iain Gray should not be too dismissive of the details of the consultation because they confirm what every single opinion poll on the matter has confirmed: overwhelming support for a local income tax that is based on the ability to pay over the discredited council tax policy of Labour and the Tories.

Was there another reason why Andy Kerr was unable to make a submission to the consultation? Perhaps it had something to do with Iain Gray's interview in The Sunday Times on 5 October:

"‘We don't have our own proposals,' he says candidly. ‘We went into the 2007 election with a proposal to try and make the council tax fairer and it didn't add up. Central to our new manifesto is a properly worked out suggestion for how we make the council tax fairer.'"

The interview also states:

"He is not prepared to give any further details of a putative scheme. ‘I've always resisted being asked to do that immediately on the back of a fag packet,' he says. ‘We made that mistake once before.'"

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
The First Minister really needs to read his opinion polls and consultations more carefully. He well knows that the most recent opinion poll evidence showed that a minority of Scots supported the local income tax proposal. That is almost exactly what his consultation showed: fewer than half the individual respondents were in favour of a local income tax; and only 34 per cent of the group most likely to be in work—34 to 54-year-olds—supported it, which is not surprising, as it is a tax on work.

On Monday, a Labour Chancellor of the Exchequer put £2 billion into the pockets of Scotland's working families. On the same day, the SNP Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth insisted that he would go ahead with his plans to take £1.5 billion in extra income tax out of those self-same Scottish pockets. Labour has taken strong, decisive action to put money into the pockets of hard-working Scottish families and to help us weather the global economic storm.

The First Minister talked about a mistake that I said we had made. Alistair Darling made a mistake too on Monday—a mistake on whisky duty—but he fixed it in 48 hours. The First Minister is making a far more damaging mistake with his local income tax. Will he fix his mistake and drop the policy now?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Alistair Darling's somersaults on the whisky tax do not give us much confidence that the pre-budget report was carefully worked out. I welcome the about-turn on the whisky tax, because it might forecast about-turns on other aspects of policy. Iain Gray had better get used to the figure of £500 million. That is the cut—the Labour cut—that is coming to Scottish councils, the Scottish Government and the Scottish people. We are not talking about efficiency savings that councils get to retain for the first time or which health boards can reinvest in front-line services; we are talking about direct cuts in spending coming down the line from the Labour Party. He and his team had better get used to that figure—the £500 million bombshell—because it will haunt each and every Labour MSP from now until the general election.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
That £500 million—it may well be less than that, as we know—

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
—follows naturally from the belt tightening that will happen throughout the United Kingdom, and Scotland must take its share of that. However, the First Minister's local income tax proposals would take £900 million out of the budget in Scotland for no reason whatever.

The First Minister told us his engagements for the rest of the day. We read that his finance secretary will meet the big six business organisations of Scotland this afternoon. They will tell him that no one wants the local income tax. They will plead with him not to make Scotland the highest-taxed part of the United Kingdom.

This is a seminal moment for the First Minister. Will he step in, overrule his finance secretary and do what is right for Scotland's economy and working families, or will he continue to put his own party interests before the national interest? Is he First Minister for Scotland, or First Minister for the SNP alone?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I will tell Iain Gray who wants a system that is based on the ability to pay: the people of Scotland.

Iain Gray says that he is not quite sure whether the figure is £500 million or not, so I will make a deal with him. I will tell him why we believe that it is £500 million: the Barnett consequentials of the cut in expenditure by Darling, Brown and Murphy are £380 million; and the latest jiggery-pokery with the health budget adds another £129 million. I understand that those figures have been confirmed by David Bell, the adviser to the Finance Committee. That is the £0.5 billion cut that is coming from the Labour Party. Perhaps when Iain Gray gets the time to think about it, he can consult further with Andy Kerr and tell us what he thinks the figure is next week.

There is a tax giveaway next year, followed by spending cuts in 2010. That is a move from John Maynard Keynes to Milton Friedman, with no intervening period whatsoever. It is new Labour to hard labour, and Iain Gray had better get used to it, because it will undermine and hole below the waterline his entire political attack. In a phrase, "You're sunk."

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 27 November 2008 Debate · 1
  2. A Framework for Science Statement · 23
  3. Sea Fisheries Debate · 51
  4. Licensed Premises (Drunkenness) Questions · 4
  5. Strathclyde Police (Meetings) Questions · 6
  6. Rail Services (Fife) Questions · 11
  7. Leven to Thornton Rail Link Questions · 6
  8. National Concessionary Fares Scheme Questions · 6
  9. Health Provision (Perthshire) Questions · 4
  10. Economic Development (Southern Ayrshire) Questions · 6
  11. Aviation Growth (Greenhouse Gas Emissions) Questions · 4
  12. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
  13. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  14. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  15. Anti-poverty Agenda First Minister’s Questions · 10
  16. Child Protection First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Forestry First Minister’s Questions · 10
  18. Science Education Questions · 7
  19. Small Businesses (Staff Training) Questions · 6
  20. Scottish Borders Council (Children's Services) Questions · 4
  21. Bullying (Schools) Questions · 6
  22. Early Years Education Questions · 15
  23. UHI Millennium Institute (University Title) Questions · 6
  24. Dumfries and Galloway Council (Education Budget) Questions · 5
  25. Biometric Fingerprinting (Schools) Questions · 4
  26. International Development (Budget) Questions · 4
  27. Scottish Mining Museum Questions · 6
  28. Department for International Development (Headquarters) Questions · 6
  29. Local Newspapers Questions · 8
  30. Europe and External Affairs (Priorities) Questions · 8
  31. Scotland and Malawi (Community Partnerships) Questions · 6
  32. Culture (Priorities) Questions · 10
  33. St Andrew's Day Debate · 69
  34. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 16
  35. Decision Time Decision time · 43
  36. World AIDS Day 2008 Members’ business · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.