To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Government, in liaison with the United Kingdom Government, has plans to redefine the role of the Lord Advocate. (S3F-1147)
Official Report · Chamber
Lord Advocate
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bill Aitken Con 2
- Alex Salmond SNP 2
The record
6 contributionsWe have had no discussions with the UK Government on redefining the role of the Lord Advocate. Our national conversation—to which I know Bill Aitken is on the cusp of submitting a contribution—is considering all aspects of our constitutional arrangements, but we have no immediate plans to change the role of the Lord Advocate.
The First Minister should never anticipate my actions, but he will be aware of the problems caused by the volume of appeals on so-called devolution issues. Many may be spurious, but a great many are related to the currently defined role of the Lord Advocate in relation to convention rights legislation. Is there not a case for seeking, through the UK Government, an amendment to the Scotland Act 1998 to exclude the acts of the Lord Advocate from section 57(2) or to redefine the Lord Advocate's role between the prosecution function and that of the Government's legal adviser, which would seem to be one way of obviating what is becoming an increasing problem?
I do not anticipate what Bill Aitken is going to do but, when we came to office and one of our first actions was to agree that the Lord Advocate and Solicitor General would no longer routinely attend the cabinet, emphasising the separation of the political and judicial, I am pretty certain that Bill Aitken welcomed that move.
Bill Aitken should also be aware that the Lord Advocate has indicated on several occasions that she is open to the constructive consideration of the future of the role. For example, in the KPMG annual law lecture last February, she said:
"I think it is perfectly valid and proper for people to debate the proper role of Law Officers. I also believe it is important, though, for that debate to be informed not only by history but, crucially, by the needs of a modern 21st Century … Scotland."
With that in mind, Bill Aitken invites me to consider amendments to the Scotland Act 1998. I must confess that I am considering amendments to the Scotland Act 1998, although the amendments that I have in mind may be more all-encompassing than those that Bill Aitken has in mind. However, there is a degree of consideration and flexibility, and if we pursue that in good faith and while acting jointly, I am sure that Bill and I will come to the right conclusions.
Bill Aitken should also be aware that the Lord Advocate has indicated on several occasions that she is open to the constructive consideration of the future of the role. For example, in the KPMG annual law lecture last February, she said:
"I think it is perfectly valid and proper for people to debate the proper role of Law Officers. I also believe it is important, though, for that debate to be informed not only by history but, crucially, by the needs of a modern 21st Century … Scotland."
With that in mind, Bill Aitken invites me to consider amendments to the Scotland Act 1998. I must confess that I am considering amendments to the Scotland Act 1998, although the amendments that I have in mind may be more all-encompassing than those that Bill Aitken has in mind. However, there is a degree of consideration and flexibility, and if we pursue that in good faith and while acting jointly, I am sure that Bill and I will come to the right conclusions.
Meeting suspended until 14:15.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Nov 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 6 November 2008 Debate · 1
- Scrutiny Improvement Statement · 22
- Patients' Rights Bill Bill debate · 37
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- A76 Questions · 6
- Animal Welfare (Transportation) Questions · 4
- Economic Growth Questions · 6
- Scottish Qualifications Authority Exam Reforms Questions · 4
- Television Questions · 6
- A90 (Laurencekirk Junction) Questions · 12
- Charities Legislation Questions · 10
- Homecoming Scotland 2009 (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Icelandic Banks (Asset Recovery) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Repossessions First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Lord Advocate First Minister’s Questions · 6
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- British Dental Association (Meetings) Questions · 7
- National Health Service Dentists Questions · 6
- Social Rented Housing Questions · 6
- National Health Service Boards (Meetings) Questions · 10
- National Health Service Board Elections (Ayrshire and Arran) Questions · 6
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 4
- National Health Service Dentists (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 7
- Wheelchair and Seating Services Modernisation Draft Action Plan Questions · 6
- Secure Forensic Mental Health Services (Young People) Questions · 7
- Media and Communication Services (Hospitals) Questions · 4
- United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child Debate · 61
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
- Community Service Volunteers Members’ business · 23
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.