To ask the Scottish Executive how much it estimates that the recent fuel price increases will cost (a) the Scottish economy, (b) local government, (c) the national health service and (d) the remaining areas over which the Scottish Government has responsibility, in 2008-09 if such prices remain at current levels. (S3O-3701)
John SwinneySNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth · North Tayside
Escalating fuel costs are having wide-reaching impacts across both the Scottish economy and the public sector in Scotland.
All parts of the Scottish public sector will be affected, including local authorities and the national health service. These effects are complex and in part depend on future movements in fuel prices over the remainder of the financial year, on relative fuel dependency and on the way that different parts of the public sector pay for their fuel. Unless additional funding is made available from the United Kingdom Treasury, the impact of rising fuel costs will be similar to a budget cut for the Scottish public sector.
High oil prices mean a big revenue gain for the UK Treasury, but they also mean a great deal of pain for families, households and businesses across Scotland. That is why we need a new approach, with Scotland getting a fair share of the windfall oil wealth.
While speaking to the chief executive of North Ayrshire Council on Tuesday, I was advised that its bill will increase by at least £1 million. That local authority area represents only one fortieth of Scotland's population.
Does the cabinet secretary agree that it is absolutely shameful for the UK Government to deny Scotland a modest share of the more than £4.5 billion that it will gain in increased revenue this year as a result of rising fuel prices? Further, does he also agree that the silence of the unionist parties in this Parliament—in terms of defending Scottish interests and seeking a reasonable portion of what is rightfully ours—has been deafening?
John SwinneySNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth · North Tayside
As always, Mr Gibson makes some fair points. If oil prices are sustained at the level that they have been at, on average, since the start of the financial year, the Treasury will receive in excess of £4.5 billion in additional revenue. Quite clearly, that is a windfall gain to the Treasury. The Scottish Government's position is that, at a time when various public sector organisations—including North Ayrshire Council, to which Mr Gibson referred—are wrestling with increased costs, the Treasury is making a tremendous windfall gain. Obviously, the Government is making strong representations to ensure that we have access to some of the oil wealth that is generated within Scottish territorial waters.
Alasdair MorganSNPThe Deputy Presiding Officer · South of Scotland
I say to Jamie McGrigor that it is quite intolerable that members are not present in time for their question. That is the second time it has happened in this meeting. Members well know what time question time is and they should be here throughout it.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.