To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-817)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 8
- Wendy Alexander Lab 5
- Alex Fergusson 3
- George Foulkes Lab 1
The record
18 contributionsLater today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
Yesterday, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning failed five times on radio to provide a cost for reducing class sizes to 18 in primary 1 to 3. Perhaps the First Minister can tell us. How much will it cost and when will it happen?
Very fortunately, this Government has put substantial resources into local authorities and education above and beyond what the previous Administration planned. As Wendy Alexander well knows, page 5, paragraph 1 of the historic concordat with local government in Scotland makes it clear that
"Local government will be expected to show year on year progress toward delivery of the class size reduction policy."
That point, of course, was confirmed only yesterday by the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in evidence to a parliamentary committee.
"Local government will be expected to show year on year progress toward delivery of the class size reduction policy."
That point, of course, was confirmed only yesterday by the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in evidence to a parliamentary committee.
I am still looking for clarity on the timetable and the cost. In September, the First Minister was asked in the chamber to confirm that his class size pledge would be delivered in the lifetime of this parliamentary session. He replied, "Yes, I can"—no ifs, buts or qualifications: delivery by 2011. The price tag, according to the Scottish National Party manifesto, was to be £210 million. Yesterday, Scotland's education directors said that the cost would be £420 million—double the original SNP estimate. Are Scotland's education directors wrong?
Scotland's education directors, like the rest of local government in Scotland, are now working for the first time in full co-operation with central Government through the concordat. Wendy Alexander should acknowledge that last year, even before the comprehensive spending review increased local government's share of spending over its course for the first time in a generation, extra resources were put into both capital building and teacher numbers in Scotland. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. There is too much noise.
I hope that Wendy Alexander will now concede that the concordat's intention to deliver this commitment is the way forward for class sizes in Scotland. Perhaps, even now, she will have the humility to accept that the Labour-Liberal Administration failed to deliver on every class size reduction target that it set in eight years.
Last year, the First Minister was willing to provide both the timetable and the price tag for the class size promise. It is the First Minister's promise and the First Minister's responsibility. He really cannot hide behind the concordat, not least when COSLA, the SNP education convener of COSLA, Scotland's education directors and headteachers across the country all say that the money is not there. So let me try again: how much will it cost?
Wendy Alexander publicly doubted whether class size reduction was an effective policy. I welcome her conversion to the SNP initiative on class size reduction. Page 5 of the concordat states that local government will show progress year on year—
Members
link
Answer the question!
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. I think that the First Minister knows what the question is.
You must not stop me teasing them in full stream, Presiding Officer.
Local government will show year-on-year progress on the delivery of the class size reduction policy. The Labour members should listen to the dominie and start behaving like parliamentarians.
Local government will show year-on-year progress on the delivery of the class size reduction policy. The Labour members should listen to the dominie and start behaving like parliamentarians.
The First Minister might know what the question is, but we have certainly not had an answer. Week in, week out, we get no straight answers. First Minister's question time has become entirely predictable. When it comes to respect for the Parliament, it is unacceptable that week in, week out, no figures are given.
Last week, I charged the SNP Government with legal incompetence and financial illiteracy, which is becoming the hallmark of the Government. The evidence keeps mounting. The Scottish futures trust was uncosted. The local income tax was uncosted. Dumping student debt was uncosted. The reduction in class size to 18 was uncosted. Every one of the SNP's flagship policies is foundering in a sea of financial incompetence.
In four weeks' time, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning will give evidence to the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee. Will the First Minister ensure that she finally produces an answer on the price tag on and timetable for implementation of his class size promise?
Last week, I charged the SNP Government with legal incompetence and financial illiteracy, which is becoming the hallmark of the Government. The evidence keeps mounting. The Scottish futures trust was uncosted. The local income tax was uncosted. Dumping student debt was uncosted. The reduction in class size to 18 was uncosted. Every one of the SNP's flagship policies is foundering in a sea of financial incompetence.
In four weeks' time, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning will give evidence to the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee. Will the First Minister ensure that she finally produces an answer on the price tag on and timetable for implementation of his class size promise?
I will tell Wendy Alexander what is costed: the £800 million a year that the people of Scotland will be paying for Labour's private finance initiative disasters. As she has raised the subject, last week, when I was giving her straight answers, she claimed that the non-profit-distributing model was a Labour invention—
Answer the question!
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
That is enough. We do not need any more sedentary interventions.
I have a statement from Councillor David Alexander, the leader of Falkirk Council who pioneered the NPD model, who says:
"Falkirk Council, under the SNP, developed a model that was less costly to local taxpayers than the equivalent PFI model yet the Labour/Liberal Executive blocked this. Even when our amended delivery model did meet with reluctant acceptance from the previous Holyrood Administration we were faced with constant delays and indecision on the part of the then Labour/Liberal Executive."
Will Wendy Alexander accept that the model that is being brought forward to finance schools, hospitals and infrastructure in Scotland is not a Labour invention but a practical policy that was developed, pioneered and pursued by the SNP, with the support of the people of Scotland?
"Falkirk Council, under the SNP, developed a model that was less costly to local taxpayers than the equivalent PFI model yet the Labour/Liberal Executive blocked this. Even when our amended delivery model did meet with reluctant acceptance from the previous Holyrood Administration we were faced with constant delays and indecision on the part of the then Labour/Liberal Executive."
Will Wendy Alexander accept that the model that is being brought forward to finance schools, hospitals and infrastructure in Scotland is not a Labour invention but a practical policy that was developed, pioneered and pursued by the SNP, with the support of the people of Scotland?
In this meeting
Everything on 29 May 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 May 2008 Debate · 1
- Drugs Strategy Statement · 32
- Common Agricultural Policy Debate · 73
- Crofting Inquiry Report (Consultation) Questions · 8
- Edinburgh Trams Questions · 6
- Financial Services Sector (Support) Questions · 4
- Outdoor Education Questions · 12
- Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Coeval Building Questions · 4
- Fuel Costs (South of Scotland) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Fuel Costs First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Common Fisheries Policy First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Financial Services Sector (Support) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Homeless People (Services) Questions · 6
- Blood Donation Questions · 8
- Deep Vein Thrombosis Questions · 6
- Betting Shop Workers Questions · 4
- Population Health Trends (West Dunbartonshire) Questions · 6
- Health Services (Lanarkshire) Questions · 6
- Respite Care (Brora) Questions · 8
- Hospital Meals (Assistance) Questions · 6
- Below Tolerable Standard Housing (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Elder-care Homes (Argyll and Bute) Questions · 4
- Cardiovascular Disease Questions · 6
- Alcohol Misuse (Services) Questions · 4
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill Questions · 5
- Homeless People Questions · 4
- Moving Scotland Forward Debate · 115
- Point of Order Procedure · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 42
- “‘No Recourse' No Safety” Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.